Occupy Students are suing UC Davis!

Having visited the place where the altercation occurred many times, I feel I must point out that it is not a public sidewalk. This is the quad, a big grassy square at the center of campus, with a paved walk down the center. While there are a few trees there aren't many very close to where the incident occurred. The tents were set up in the middle of the quad, and the campus police had walked down from the street to get them and arrest the people who refused to yield.

I got the impression that what the demonstrators were attempting to do was prevent the officers from driving a car up the walk to take away the people who had been arrested, not preventing them from leaving or threatening them in any way. I don't see why the officers had to do anything but walk away at that point, since the tents had been taken down. But if they wanted to get the car up the walk, they needed to disperse the crowd, and I believe that's when the pepper spray came out.

Remember that just two days before this there had been a similar incident at UC Berkeley, which Davis has lots of ties to, where several people (including faculty members and a Poet Laureate) were beaten with clubs for locking their arms around the tents. In light of that, I think it very likely that Chancellor Katehi would have instructed the campus police chief as she says she did, for there to be no violence or physical confrontation of any kind.
 
They needed to be removed, in order for the police to leave.

Please, if you have a better alternative to accomplish that goal, we're all ears.

Exactly. Haven't seen a better idea mentioned here. What should the police have done once they were surrounded by what appear to be upwards of 75-100 people - and that was just in the immediate circle of students.

I watched the entire video. The police showed great patience and restraint throughout. The video clearly shows that they are surrounded. Or are we to believe that they were only 95% surrounded, and that the one area off camera provided a big escape route that the police just ignored? Anyone arguing the opposite is being dishonest.

The crowd was certainly threatening! Impeding the progress of a police officer - or anyone for that matter - is certainly threatening. But, more importantly, it's illegal. Shouting that they won't "Let them go" unless their friends are released is certainly illegal too. If you wanted to get technical, some serious charges could have resulted. They were, in effect, holding the police hostage.

Again, argue about what they actually did all you want. But then tell us what they should have done, stand there all day? How could they have left without physically removing the students in some way? Does the Chancellor have supreme control over police policy at this point?
 
It certainly does look like they encircled the area where the police hanging out with their arrestees. The police did not appear to actually be moving the suspects towards any location.

They asked the crowd to let them through many, many times.
 
Exactly. Haven't seen a better idea mentioned here. What should the police have done once they were surrounded by what appear to be upwards of 75-100 people - and that was just in the immediate circle of students.

I watched the entire video. The police showed great patience and restraint throughout. The video clearly shows that they are surrounded. Or are we to believe that they were only 95% surrounded, and that the one area off camera provided a big escape route that the police just ignored? Anyone arguing the opposite is being dishonest.

The crowd was certainly threatening! Impeding the progress of a police officer - or anyone for that matter - is certainly threatening. But, more importantly, it's illegal. Shouting that they won't "Let them go" unless their friends are released is certainly illegal too. If you wanted to get technical, some serious charges could have resulted. They were, in effect, holding the police hostage.

Again, argue about what they actually did all you want. But then tell us what they should have done, stand there all day? How could they have left without physically removing the students in some way? Does the Chancellor have supreme control over police policy at this point?
Police policy is set by administrators to comply with court rulings, government regulations, and liability concerns.
A concept called chain of command is in place, and part of that means implementation of policy is conveyed from the top down.
The Supreme Court issues a ruling like Garner, legislative and executive bodies redact existing material, agencies incorporate it into their policies, the top brass signs it, the managers teach it to the supervisors, they all sign it, and the people on the street get it in academy and in-service training, whereupon it goes into their training file, which can be subpoenaed in court proceedings, or used administratively .

Most LEOs will sign a use of force policy acknowledgement more than once a year.

I doubt that you will find US legal cites declaring that such shouting at a protest is 'certainly' illegal and a 'serious charge'. Nothing that is on record from that day rises to the level of unprotected 'hate speech', no matter how emotional the delivery or dramatic the visuals. It would be hard to make the case that officers with guns and other weapons who came and went throughout the event were actual hostages in the criminal sense.

All of which would normally be moot, because police officers enjoy qualified immunity from lawsuits.

They can throw away that qualified immunity, which probably is not going to happen here, or they can have it stripped from them by said top brass hanging them out to dry through the simple process of denying that the actions were authorized by the chain of command, which is a high percentage bet in this case.
 
Last edited:
It would be hard to make the case that officers with guns and other weapons who came and went throughout the event were actual hostages in the criminal sense.

They were not hostages, because they had weapons (like pepper spray) that they could've used to 'break free'?

Why then all the fuss about the police actually, you know, doing that?
 
Can I just mention here how completely idiotic it was for the Occupy movement to choose a form of protest they had to put all their energy and resources into defending? All they've really done is defended their right to have their protests (badly). They'd have been better off getting rid of the camps and spending all that time and energy advocating for what they wanted (which was never communicated very well anyway).

Bingo. OWS has been a movement about having a protest movement more than anything else.
 
Last edited:
Whatever answer I give you will only give you reason to argue nonsensically anyway!

Good job! That's the way to have a productive discussion:

  1. Present a claim.
  2. Present something as supporting evidence.
  3. When asked to tell how the material in 2. supports your claim, ask the perceptive question whether it matters.
  4. If pressed further, throw feces.
 
They were not hostages, because they had weapons (like pepper spray) that they could've used to 'break free'?

Why then all the fuss about the police actually, you know, doing that?
The 'fuss' was the claim that the other students could have been arrested on the 'serious charge' of kidnapping.

The reality is that it would have been laughed out of court, and handed someone a nice fat check for false arrest or malicious prosecution..
 
Sure, but did they actually try?
Force sufficient to break through the crowd would've led to more injuries than the pepper spray, both for the crowd, protestors and police. Even pepper spraying the crowd directly would led to trampling as the crowd tried to get away. Or worse; they turn on the cops.

They held until backup arrived and the outer students moved, then sprayed the human chain directly in their path after warning them, and attempting less forceful methods which failed. This was a minimum force approach.
 
The 'fuss' was the claim that the other students could have been arrested on the 'serious charge' of kidnapping.

The reality is that it would have been laughed out of court, and handed someone a nice fat check for false arrest or malicious prosecution..
Nice attempt to divert.

Did you miss the words "in effect"?

...
The crowd was certainly threatening! Impeding the progress of a police officer - or anyone for that matter - is certainly threatening. But, more importantly, it's illegal. Shouting that they won't "Let them go" unless their friends are released is certainly illegal too. If you wanted to get technical, some serious charges could have resulted. They were, in effect, holding the police hostage.
...
Schplurg does not say or imply they would necessarily face kidnapping charges, or that they were literally holding the cops hostage, but that their actions had a comparable effect. He(?) also says they would face some "serious charges" and what they did was illegal.

This is the part where you complain about semantics.
 
Last edited:
If people were sitting in a circle around me, I'd simply step over them, or jump. If they grab for me, then that would be violence and would justify pepper spray.
 
Nice attempt to divert.

Did you miss the words "in effect"?

Schplurg does not say or imply they would necessarily face kidnapping charges, or that they were literally holding the cops hostage, but that their actions had a comparable effect. He(?) also says they would face some "serious charges" and what they did was illegal.

This is the part where you complain about semantics.
No, this is the part where I have to point out once again that you are are simply out of touch with reality.


Unless there is a medical condition that causes people to read exactly the opposite of what has been written, I'm going with the guess that you are simply feigning being obtuse.
 
If people were sitting in a circle around me, I'd simply step over them, or jump. If they grab for me, then that would be violence and would justify pepper spray.
Okay, now try to carry a bound prisoner over that same line. And through the few dozen angry people on the other side.

Pepper spray is a compliance tool, not just a weapon. It is not necessarily used by police officers in response to violence. In fact, it is usually used to prevent violence by making it easier for officers to subdue suspects.
 
No, this is the part where I have to point out once again that you are are simply out of touch with reality.


Unless there is a medical condition that causes people to read exactly the opposite of what has been written, I'm going with the guess that you are simply feigning being obtuse.
No, I disagree with you.

Schplurg did not say what the "serious charges" were, or that they were literally holding the cops hostage. Moreover, even if they had been, that is not necessarily "kidnapping" in any legal sense. Hostage taking is itself a federal crime.

But please, feel free to insult me instead of openly proving me wrong with a logical argument. I do, in fact, admit my mistakes, and have already done so once this thread.

By the way, the crowd let an individual cop or two through, and then closed up. This is different from letting all or most of the cops out, or letting the cops go with prisoners. I saw one a video which I can't find they let one cop go with a prisoner and promptly corked up. Also, they certainly thought they were obstructing the police.
 
Last edited:
Okay, now try to carry a bound prisoner over that same line. And through the few dozen angry people on the other side.

Why not? Sitting down, the protestors are not much of a barrier. They can be angry as they want, as long as they don't actually, physically attack.

Pepper spray is a compliance tool, not just a weapon. It is not necessarily used by police officers in response to violence. In fact, it is usually used to prevent violence by making it easier for officers to subdue suspects.

It is a weapon. The only time it's not a weapon is when it's used to spice up a sauce. Using pepper spray on people IS VIOLENCE. Your defense would justify police shooting suspects in the thigh with a gun, just to prevent suspects trying to run away.
 
No, I disagree with you.

Schplurg did not say what the "serious charges" were, or that they were literally holding the cops hostage. Moreover, even if they had been, that is not necessarily "kidnapping" in any legal sense. Hostage taking is itself a federal crime.

But please, feel free to insult me instead of openly proving me wrong with a logical argument. I do, in fact, admit my mistakes, and have already done so once this thread.

By the way, the crowd let an individual cop or two through, and then closed up. This is different from letting all or most of the cops out, or letting the cops go with prisoners. I saw one a video which I can't find they let one cop go with a prisoner and promptly corked up. Also, they certainly thought they were obstructing the police.
And how many levels did your avatar go up for that?

Again, you just can't stand to see anyone rationally discuss the facts of an issue that you don't understand, so you pee in the pool with strawmen fallacies and whining challenges when you are called on those fallacies.
 
Why not? Sitting down, the protestors are not much of a barrier. They can be angry as they want, as long as they don't actually, physically attack.

Until one of them punches a cop in the nuts, thinking it is a good idea at the time.

Stepping over protesters is NEVER a good idea. You never know how they are going to react, and which one is the crazy with the knife who just came along because he likes crowds and noise...
 
Until one of them punches a cop in the nuts, thinking it is a good idea at the time.

Stepping over protesters is NEVER a good idea. You never know how they are going to react, and which one is the crazy with the knife who just came along because he likes crowds and noise...
Ahhh but cops are always supposed to know that granny isn't dangerous, or the kids are just having fun, or that white folks belong in this neighborhood, and so forth.

And besides, I'm sure one of our resident 'experts' will be happy to explain how the cops can simply shoot the knife out of the attacker's hand.

:wink:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom