View Single Post
Old 6th May 2012, 12:15 PM   #4457
Sunstealer
Illuminator
 
Sunstealer's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 3,128
Originally Posted by Christopher7 View Post
He did not do the critical test of raising the temperature to the ignition point of ~430oC. He did not find a thermitic reaction because he did not look for one. SOS.

If he could heat the chip to 400oC then he could heat it to 430oC and prove or disprove a thermitic reaction. The fact that he could have and did not says it all. You did not get your money's worth. He did not prove anything.
You don't understand why he heated the chip to 400C rather than 430C or 10,000C.

There is a very, very simple and easy to understandable reason why 400C was used in the low temperature ashing process which is designed to burn off the organic component and leave behind the remaining particulate for TEM-SAED analysis.

As we have seen if the sample is heated to 430C then a reaction of some sort occurs and the particles that are required to be analysed are destroyed. So the absolute last thing you want to do is heat them to that temperature if your intent is to analyse the particles in the paint.

Once the particles were shown to be rhombohedral Fe2O3 and kaolin plates absolutely identical to those found in the Harrit et al paper, then there is absolutely no need to do any addition testing (which only adds to cost and time). The material has been identified: case closed.

There is no point in looking for a thermitic reaction if the materials you have characterised and identified are not thermite!


Only deluded truthers who don't understand why DSC is worthless harp on about the test not being performed.

How the hell do you manage to prove or disprove a thermitic reaction in a DSC? Give a defined method in your own words. You won't but we already know that you can't use your own words.

Lastly Millette is continuing with writing up the paper for review and the inconsequential microsphere nonsense will be addressed in that.

Where is the FTIR data that Harrit has but didn't include in the paper? Perhaps you should direct your ire at your heroes for not releasing their data even after a request. What are they hiding?
Sunstealer is offline   Quote this post in a PM   Nominate this post for this month's language award Copy a direct link to this post Back to Top