Are we (The Markets anyway) all slaves to central bankers?

So the Central banks are the primary movers of markets. Why is that a surprise to anyone ?

well apparently it is to most here.

When markets are weak and in recession we expect the Fed to drop short term rates, to improve access to money. It was how Bush2 managed the dot.com bust circa 2001 (an oft forgotten example). Of course the current setback is more severe.

I havent forgotten, it was the "management" of the .com bust that set in motion the housing bubble

But I think the problem with markets not strengthening in response is related to several factors. Despite the Fed, banks are reluctant to loan at these historically low rates. The news is filled with stories of stable businesses unable to borrow except at high rates, and sources of venture funding have nearly vanished. Individual consumers are the biggest drivers of the US economy, and with high unemployment, weak business growth, high uncertainly about how the current anti-business climate will impact the long term, and the obvious unsustainability of social and retirement programs - the consumer has insufficient confidence to buy.

The Keynesian approach of replacing low private sector spending with government spending seems to not be working well (but we can't evaluate the alternative outcomes fairly). It's unclear if Keynes would be a supported of the current crop of "more is needed' when consumer spending is such a large fraction of the economy. What now seems obvious is that government spending is less effective at stimulating production than imagined, and the debt created by the stimulation acts to frighten the already wary consumer, actually harming any hopes of a private sector recovery

We may well have been better off not nationalizing/federalizing the problem and letting the markets crash.

yes, because like trying to hold back the tides or put off death, it will come anyway.

The short term rates are near zero, operation twist is still effective but boosts business borrowing costs, and the Fed is buying a majority of US bond sales. Seems unsustainable.

welcome to "the new normal" :D

No, the system needs a reset, and we can't get the consumer back at the trough until they have some confidence in their futures. I believe that means we have to substantially revise the social benefit programs, retirement programs and certainly the US mil spending - they are obviously untenable. We voted to give everyone massive benefits, but neglected to create a practical way to pay for it all; that failure needs to be discounted, instead we are adding to the failure with more spending and underfunded programs.. Maybe we can inflate our way out of some of this (a soft default) - but the government overhang has a large fraction of payments due that are already indexed to inflation - TIPS bonds, SS and MediC payments, retirements plans, ... So these are resistant to an inflation solution.

yes, if they reported it accurately, and I cant see any motive not to, here, can you?
 
Last edited:
The Keynesian approach of replacing low private sector spending with government spending seems to not be working well (but we can't evaluate the alternative outcomes fairly). It's unclear if Keynes would be a supported of the current crop of "more is needed' when consumer spending is such a large fraction of the economy. What now seems obvious is that government spending is less effective at stimulating production than imagined, and the debt created by the stimulation acts to frighten the already wary consumer, actually harming any hopes of a private sector recovery.
If this was just about government spending then this thread would be an academic discussion about whether living standards would change if we changed the size of government.

However, it is the incessant government borrowing that is causing confidence to plummet. In spite of attempts by many to suggest that governments borrowing money is different to individuals borrowing money, it seems that international creditors are no more forgiving than the domestic variety.
 
If this was just about government spending then this thread would be an academic discussion about whether living standards would change if we changed the size of government.

However, it is the incessant government borrowing that is causing confidence to plummet. In spite of attempts by many to suggest that governments borrowing money is different to individuals borrowing money, it seems that international creditors are no more forgiving than the domestic variety.

Fortunately for governments, most "international creditors" are simply foreign central banks with unlimited (fiat) lines of credit, obtained by stealing the savings of their respective citizens, and debasing their salaries, and fixed incomes.
 
Fortunately for governments, most "international creditors" are simply foreign central banks with unlimited (fiat) lines of credit, obtained by stealing the savings of their respective citizens, and debasing their salaries, and fixed incomes.
Stiffing foreign central banks is probably as practicable as invading their countries and taking the gold out of their vaults.
 
Stiffing foreign central banks is probably as practicable as invading their countries and taking the gold out of their vaults.

er.. Libya?

"Libyan rebels form new Central Bank"

of course this idea was entirely their own, and the Libyan gold had nothing to do with the sustained and suspicious selling pressure without regard for attaining the best price seen in Nov/Dec 11.

I keep telling myself this, because otherwise I would be a crazy-ass manipulation Ct-ist, wouldnt I, and we all know that cant happen.
 
It seems to me that we and the bankers have forgotten that their job is simply to keep score. For some time now they have managed to convince the world that they're actually running the game.
 
If so, I thank my masters. I am up nearly 40% for the year. If it keeps, I will buy myself something really nice (a car probably).
 
Last edited:
Stiffing foreign central banks is probably as practicable as invading their countries and taking the gold out of their vaults.

If we're talking about what is "practicable" versus what is necessary, then we've already lost the war. We have to decide as a society whether we will be ruled by banksters and unlimited money and debt, or not. There are a million trojan horse solutions between here and there.
 
We have to decide as a society whether we will be ruled by banksters and unlimited money and debt, or not.
In that case the answer is to stop electing fiscally irresponsible politicians. The answer is for governments to stop borrowing money. The answer is to realize that you can not maintain a high standard of living indefinitely by "charging it".

The answer is not to say that government debt doesn't matter because it is only owed to money printers.
 
In that case the answer is to stop electing fiscally irresponsible politicians. The answer is for governments to stop borrowing money. The answer is to realize that you can not maintain a high standard of living indefinitely by "charging it".

No, of course I disagree. The answer is sound money, money that cannot be infinitely debased. The problem is not too much debt, it's too much credit. The former depends entirely on the latter. Strike the root.

Ban government borrowing, I support it. But if you ban institutional counterfeiting, you will automatically set a limit on the amount that greedy politicians can borrow, a limit imposed by real, willing savers in the market. Any solution other than sound money is a trojan horse. Even some solutions that include sound money are trojan horses as well, making things even more complicated.

The answer is not to say that government debt doesn't matter because it is only owed to money printers.

I certainly didn't say that, or imply anything near that. But if you abolish the central bank and the seigniorage tax/theft, the point becomes moot.
 
But if you ban institutional counterfeiting, you will automatically set a limit on the amount that greedy politicians can borrow, a limit imposed by real, willing savers in the market.
I dunno. Greece didn't have the option of counterfeiting its own money but that didn't stop its government borrowing its way to third world status.
 
I dunno. Greece didn't have the option of counterfeiting its own money but that didn't stop its government borrowing its way to third world status.

That's irrelevant, it borrowed money from private banks who had virtually unlimited lines of credit with the ECB, but who seem to have empty pockets when it comes to bailing out the Greek taxpayer. I'm not arguing that government borrowing isn't problematic, I'm arguing that unlimited money for insiders is the bigger problem. If you ban government borrowing and still allow central banking to exist, you will still have the business cycle, illicit financial asset speculation, and enormous wealth condensation.
 
If you ban government borrowing and still allow central banking to exist, you will still have the business cycle, illicit financial asset speculation, and enormous wealth condensation.
I would have thought those problems were features of fractional reserve banking.

Central banks are mainly reacting to counterbalance problems caused by government borrowing. Take that away and the central banks don't have that much to do.
 
I would have thought those problems were features of fractional reserve banking.

You would have been mostly wrong. Fractional reserve banking only ensures that the aggregate money supply is a multiple of the fiat base money supply, not a perpetually growing money supply which is the cause of the problems I listed in the above post. Only lowering the reserve requirement ratio would result in a higher money multiplier, and this is typically not done (although it was done by the Bank of China, recently).

I thought you were already aware of all of this.

Central banks are mainly reacting to counterbalance problems caused by government borrowing. Take that away and the central banks don't have that much to do.

I still don't think you grasp the fundamental problem, which is kind of sad considering that you know a lot more than most on the subject. Where does that leave everyone else? Josiah Stamp, former director of the Bank of England said it best:

Josiah Stamp said:
"Banking was conceived in iniquity and was born in sin. The bankers own the earth. Take it away from them, but leave them the power to create money, and with the flick of the pen they will create enough deposits to buy it back again. However, take away from them the power to create money and all the great fortunes like mine will disappear and they ought to disappear, for this would be a happier and better world to live in. But, if you wish to remain the slaves of bankers and pay the cost of your own slavery, let them continue to create money."

I don't much care that governments borrow, I care that an elite few have a license to steal. Not coincidentially, it is they who do the lion's share of lending to governments. It lends a certain air of legitimacy to it all. And serves to misdirect people like you away from the root of the problem.
 
Last edited:
I still don't think you grasp the fundamental problem, which is kind of sad considering that you know a lot more than most on the subject. Where does that leave everyone else? Josiah Stamp, former director of the Bank of England said it best:
If you are suggesting that Josiah Stamp was referring to the complicity of central banks and governments then maybe it's you that doesn't grasp the fundamental problem.

Of course, you know better. Josiah Stamp was referring to the dangers of a privately owned money supply - which is substantially what you get under fractional reserve banking - regardless of the monetary base. This is the reason why a gold standard was unable to prevent the booms, busts and bank runs of the 19th century.

Fix the money supply and you stop governments from borrowing. Alternatively, stop the government from borrowing and there is no need to expand the money supply. Either way, it is the government borrowing that needs to be stopped.

I don't much care that governments borrow, I care that an elite few have a license to steal.
These elite few can steal only because governments borrow money.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom