We have mentioned a number of these operations, but not as yet discussed the "Sierra Sounds," a term for some recordings, and Bigfoot Sounds, an operation that follows the bigfoot convention trail, giving Bigfomericials I mean, talks, and marketing these recordings of purported bigfoot "speech", the first of which was obtained at a hunting camp in the Sierras many years ago. They also have a website.
There is now a spinoff (that's the word they use for new sitcom television shows that are based on a character from a previously successful sitcom series), a person who claimes that these and/or other recordings demonstrate that this "speech" constitutes an actual language.
I have reviewed the original material, and the original assessment by an academic, though not in as great a depth as RayG, who is trying to communicate with the BFFers at the moment on a thread over there.
I don't have the qualifications to speak knowledgeably about Dr. Kirlin's findings, though I did point out he only published them in a bigfoot book and not in any scientific journals.
I do however, feel I have some training and qualifications when it comes to a certain 'crypto-linguist'. See that machine under my name to the left? It's no regular typewriter. That's a
TSEC/KL-7, developed by NSA, codenamed Adonis, and something I used to encode and decode highly classified messages back in the 70's.
I also worked with a number of 'crypto-linguists' during my military career, and was even pressed into service for a few months as a crypto-linguist, probably in part because I had a good aptitude for language.
From the beginning (February 2009 at least), I questioned how a crypto-linguist would know that he's listening to sasquatch language. Crypto-linguists aren't trained to decipher
unknown languages, they're trained to be fluent in one or two
particular languages. They may be intercepting and recording foreign languages, but their language skills are similar to those of my daughter, who is bilingual. I also pointed out the difference between an actual linguist, and a crypto-linguist, but it hasn't made any difference to some people. (And no, a crypto-linguist is NOT a linguist who studies cryptids)
So when a bigfoot website calls a crypto-linguist a "linguistics expert" my skeptical antennae go up. And when people argue that he has the qualifications to determine whether an unknown language is being spoken by sasquatches, I'll call bs, no matter how many times they wave his resume around.
There are three prominent points about this material (besides the obvious ones: no bigfoot, no peer reviewed paper):
And that right there is one of the biggest indications that we aren't dealing with real science. Kirlin never submitted his findings for peer review because he
knew he hadn't actually proven anything. It was all speculation, nothing more than an unconfirmed, untested hypothesis.
Similarly, R. Scott Nelson
knows he has nothing of interest outside of bigfootdom, so there's no way he'd take it to actual linguists for review. That's why he peddles his presentations to bigfooters, hungry for something, anything, that will make bigfoot ~sound~ plausible. (rim-shot)
Now I am sure that these folks who market this material as bigstuff are nice and honest. But I do think they are wrong. So does Ray G, and I would welcome any comments from him or anyone else on the subject.
Thing is, I don't
know if they're wrong, but I'm pretty certain a crypto-linguist isn't qualified to decipher an unknown language. That's exactly why the
Navajo code-talkers were so effective in WWII, because it was unintelligible to anyone without extensive exposure and training in Navajo.
Now if Nelson is able to show that he can converse one-on-one with a sasquatch, then I will concede that I was mistaken, and apologize.
RayG