Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

Why aren't demolition companies routinely using Miracle Nanothermite? No danger of damaging adjoining property, at least in its Hush-A-Boom (TM) mode. If a demolition engineer in China uses nanothermite, will he be assassinated by Mossad agents for revealing the secret to the world?

Most CT tech explanations don't pass the sniff test. Strange that in the decade since 911, no one is using "super-duper nano-thermite" much less "hologram aircraft," "vice sims," dustification rays, etc...?
 
Most CT tech explanations don't pass the sniff test. Strange that in the decade since 911, no one is using "super-duper nano-thermite" much less "hologram aircraft," "vice sims," dustification rays, etc...?

Well according to Dickie Gage it's only made in the most sophisticated labs in the country, unless you're Kevin Ryan. In that case you can make it in your backyard. You would think with their 1600+ "experts" they could get a demo company to demonstrate it.
 
In the houses of shadow everybody lies.

Gee. All of the above not-with-standing, Next you will be telling me you BELIEVE some creatioNIST 'new phenomena' computer algorithm that has a complex 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed government secured High-rise in lower Manhattan suddenly drop into its own plan area in 6.5 seconds, 2.25 seconds at free fall, because of 'ordinary office furnishings fires' on one floor already out at the one column girder seat critical initiation just because you were told it did.
 
Gee. All of the above not-with-standing, Next you will be telling me you BELIEVE some creatioNIST 'new phenomena' computer algorithm that has a complex 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed government secured High-rise in lower Manhattan suddenly drop into its own plan area in 6.5 seconds, 2.25 seconds at free fall, because of 'ordinary office furnishings fires' on one floor already out at the one column girder seat critical initiation just because you were told it did.

Is there such a thing as an "appeal to gullibility" fallacy?

Because I think this may be one.


(interesting paintings though, Roger)
 
Gee. All of the above not-with-standing, Next you will be telling me you BELIEVE some creatioNIST 'new phenomena' computer algorithm that has a complex 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed government secured High-rise in lower Manhattan suddenly drop into its own plan area in 6.5 seconds, 2.25 seconds at free fall, because of 'ordinary office furnishings fires' on one floor already out at the one column girder seat critical initiation just because you were told it did.

No, but you BELIEVE US patent 5505799 looks like manual for 9/11 "explosive" just because you were told it does.
 
No, but you BELIEVE US patent 5505799 looks like manual for 9/11 "explosive" just because you were told it does.



Wow, what a great example of cherry-picking the details out of the patent that they need, while ignoring those that contradict their beliefs!

For instance, the patent clearly shows a maximum layer thickness of 10 000 Angstroms, or 1 micron. Compare that to the scale of the layers shown in their photo of the "red grey chips", where the layers are clearly several hundred microns thick.

Secondly, they hand-wave away that the layers are formed by magnetron sputter deposition:


Referring now to FIG. 2, a three source magnetron sputtering assembly is schematically illustrated, and which comprises a chamber 20 in which is located a rotating copper substrate table 21 provided with a substrate water cooling mechanism 22 having coolant inlet and outlets 23 and 24. Located and fixedly mounted above the rotating table 21 are three DC magnetrons 25, 26 and 27, equally spaced at 120.degree. C., and being electrically negative, as indicated at 28. Each of the magnetrons 25, 26 and 27 is provided with water cooling inlets 29 and outlets 30. Located between each of the magnetrons 25-27 and the rotating table 21 is a cross contamination shield 31. Rotating table 21 is provided with an opening 32 in which is located a substrate 33 on which the thin films of reactive metal, carbon and oxide are deposited as the table 21 is rotated in opposite directions over the substrate 33 as indicated by the dash line and double arrow 34. The chamber 20 may include means, not shown, for providing a desired atmosphere for the sputtering operation, the type of atmosphere depending on the materials being sputtered.


Yeah.... Good luck doing that with massive steel beams, guys.
 
This looks like a big plane crashing into a big building to me

9-11%20attacks.jpg
 
Regardless of what the actual collapse explanation is, thermite is still excluded by virtue of the existent evidence, full stop. There is nothing to debate on this; even if that trutherist construction "The Official StoryTM" were wrong, that doesn't open the door to thermite, nor any sort of incendiary.

Critiques must be based on the substance of the argument being disputed. It makes no good, for example, to dispute evolution and attempt to substitute Lamarckism in its place with superficial arguments about morphology because the basis of modern evolutionary theory is genetic. Any arguments criticising the field must be about that, else they're not even addressing the proper topic.

Similarly, complaints about the NIST model of collapse must be based on an understanding of the material properties of the building components, as well as the cascading failures theorized. Otherwise, the critique is not addressing the substance of the claim.


It's simple. To dispute a theory, you must first dispute that theory. Failing to do so doesn't even get you to the starting line.
 
Next you will be telling me you BELIEVE some creatioNIST 'new phenomena' computer algorithm that has a complex 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed government secured High-rise in lower Manhattan suddenly drop into its own plan area in 6.5 seconds, 2.25 seconds at free fall.....................

Why do you feel the need to lie to support your view of truth? Building 7 was not "government secured" or did if fall in 6.5 seconds.

People see these lies and know you're full of crap. That's why your "movement" is where it is today.
 
Gee. All of the above not-with-standing, Next you will be telling me you BELIEVE some creatioNIST 'new phenomena'

Fire causing steel to lose it's strength is not any kind of new phenomena. Not even close.

computer algorithm that has a complex 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed government secured High-rise in lower Manhattan suddenly drop into its own plan area

Um, you could walk into the lobby of 7WTC, and go to just about any floor you wanted to. So, not sure how you get the idea that it was a "government secured" building.

Also, if you're REALLY claiming it fell into it's footprint, you're delusional.

Here's proof.

414px-Fiterman_hall_damage-1.jpg


Fiterman Hall. 7WTC, when it collapsed, caused this damage. Did they put this building in the footprint of 7WTC?


in 6.5 seconds, 2.25 seconds at free fall,

Wrong again. Forgot the East Mechanical Penthouse.


because of 'ordinary office furnishings fires' on one floor already out at the one column girder seat critical initiation

More than one floor.

just because you were told it did.

No, because of the research that was provided by experts in their relevant field, including fire science professors, fire protection engineers, structural engineers, and dozens of other relevant disciplines.

You've got....Gage. And his card board boxes.
 
Gee. All of the above not-with-standing, Next you will be telling me you BELIEVE some creatioNIST 'new phenomena' :bananalama: (fire weaking steel structures is not a new phenomena) computer algorithm that has a complex 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed government secured :bananalama: (government secured? :sdl:) High-rise in lower Manhattan suddenly drop into its own plan area :bananalama: (lolwut - "own plan area = buildings across the street in 2 different directions?) in 6.5 seconds, :bananalama: (you're not counting the fall of the mechanical penthouse? why is that?) 2.25 seconds at free fall, because of 'ordinary office furnishings fires' on one floor :bananalama: (one floor? what?) already out at the one column girder seat critical initiation just because you were told it did. :bananalama: (yeah, just because I was told it did. Right)

I have noted some of the inaccuracies above with this symbol. :bananalama: Comments in red. Good luck.
 
The post [remo 828] has been merged from its original forum stream discussing the Millette paper[showthread dot php?p=8441831#post8441831] WITHOUT reference to its original post [926] regarding the patent 5,505,799 pertaining Government/LLNL/Nanoengineered explosives.
To understand its origin and intent of this post[828] the reader would need be informed of its first part on the Millette thread[926]

Which was:
MIX
United States Patent 5,505,799


Makowiecki April 9, 1996
Nanoengineered explosives

Primary Examiner: Nelson; Peter A.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Sartorio; Henry P. Carnahan; L. E.

Abstract

A complex modulated structure of reactive elements that have the capability of considerably more heat than organic explosives while generating a working fluid or gas. The explosive and method of fabricating same involves a plurality of very thin, stacked, multilayer structures, each composed of reactive components, such as aluminum, separated from a less reactive element, such as copper oxide, by a separator material, such as carbon. The separator material not only separates the reactive materials, but it reacts therewith when detonated to generate higher temperatures. The various layers of material, thickness of 10 to 10,000 angstroms, can be deposited by magnetron sputter deposition. The explosive detonates and combusts a high velocity generating a gas, such as CO, and high temperatures.

URL details on that page.
 
Last edited:
This post [remo 828] has been merged from its original forum stream discussing the Millette paper[showthread dot php?p=8441831#post8441831] WITHOUT reference to its original post [926] regarding the patent 5,505,799 pertaining Government/LLNL/Nanoengineered explosives.
To understand its origin and intent of this post[828] the reader would need be informed of its first part on the Millette thread[926]

Which was:
MIX
United States Patent 5,505,799


Makowiecki April 9, 1996
Nanoengineered explosives

Primary Examiner: Nelson; Peter A.
Attorney, Agent or Firm: Sartorio; Henry P. Carnahan; L. E.

Abstract

A complex modulated structure of reactive elements that have the capability of considerably more heat than organic explosives while generating a working fluid or gas. The explosive and method of fabricating same involves a plurality of very thin, stacked, multilayer structures, each composed of reactive components, such as aluminum, separated from a less reactive element, such as copper oxide, by a separator material, such as carbon. The separator material not only separates the reactive materials, but it reacts therewith when detonated to generate higher temperatures. The various layers of material, thickness of 10 to 10,000 angstroms, can be deposited by magnetron sputter deposition. The explosive detonates and combusts a high velocity generating a gas, such as CO, and high temperatures.

URL details on that page.

Actually, if you look up through the merged thread, the link to that patent has already been referenced. I would suggest you start with discussing the arguments made against the patent's applicability, rather than simply restating it as if it's supposed to be obvious.
 
MIX

My response to this thread was merged onto another without acknowledgment on this original Millette stream, thus leaving it unaswered here.

Any reader interested in the following reply posted 8th August:

Patent filed Sept.19.1993.
Patent filing Concludes:

"While a particular embodiment of the invention has been illustrated and described, and specific materials, thicknesses, and processing procedures have been set forth to explain the principles of the invention, such are not intended to be limiting. Modifications and changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art, and it is intended that the invention be limited only by the scope of the appended claims."

7 years between patent filed and WTC demolitions.

Those 'skilled in the art' were 'not limited' by the 'principles of this invention'.
You are arguing limitations of this particular patent, as it applies to the energetic material identified by Harrit/Jones, while not the CONCEPT, the complexity, the PROBABILITY of Nanoengineered explosives R&D being able to achieve exactly what we saw happen on 911.
Sputtering was the method in 1993 but those are 'processing procedures [are] not intended to be limiting' and 'limited by the scope of the appended claims' circa 1993.
This patent proves material OF THE KIND identified by Harrit/Jones was known and recorded by Government and LLNL in 1993. That multi-layered highly engineered energetic material 'of the kind' was being developed at the highest levels of secrecy, and that "Modifications and Changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art".
An expression of that continued development became apparent on 911.
 
This patent proves material OF THE KIND identified by Harrit/Jones was known and recorded by Government and LLNL in 1993. That multi-layered highly engineered energetic material 'of the kind' was being developed at the highest levels of secrecy, and that "Modifications and Changes will become apparent to those skilled in the art".
An expression of that continued development became apparent on 911.
It's either the same stuff, or it isn't.
 
To the argument.

pp 21 of the Harrit/Jones paper states 'The evidence for active, highly energetic thermitic material in the WTC dust is compelling'. Reported 'highly energetic reactions, iron-rich sphere formation so that the product must have been molten', 'to be expected from thermitic reactions' and that 'These observations reminded us of nano-thermite fabricated at LLNL and elsewhere.."[pp23]

Patent 5 505 799 pertains to Government/ LLNL nanoengineered explosives., 'reactive elements that have the capability of considerably more heat 'involving a plurality of very thin stacked multilayer structures etc [as above and read the patent] with a clearly stated intention to further refine going forward and not intended to be limiting by its filing . so that we have
. A paper identifying energetic material chips in the DUST 'reminding the the authors of nano-thermite fabricated at LLNL'
. A patent filed 1993 establishing High end development of energetic materials by LLNL that are of the kind identified in 1.

As I struggle with the essentially [creatio]nist HYPOTHESIS; an unproven UNTESTED THEORY morphing the OBSERVABLE 2.25 second FREE FALL of building 7; A complex 81 Vertically columned 47 storied steel framed high-rise suddenly straight down in 6.5 seconds to its own plan area "in the manner of controlled demolition" - all concrete pulverized into thermitic material and iron-rich microsphere riddled DUST., as I struggle with the observable building behaviour deconstructed into 'the result of 'Normal Office furnishings fires", burning around ONE column girder seat [of three at that join] on ONE floor [12] where photograph shows the fire OUT at critical Pinnochio Sunder axial 'thermal expansion' moment,
- where 3/4" shear studs at 22" centers break because of 'differential thermal expansion stresses created in the model by turning heat off the concrete floor slabs sat direct on the beams/girders to achieve differential stresses[NCSTAR1-9:352]
Where thermal expansion data is input on 'unrestrained beams', and where the critical girder shear-studs are excluded from input, and 'unusual' [6%] per volume iron-rich spheres are attributed to 'rust burn' in 'elevator furnaces',
- a THEORY constructed on computer algorithms held in secret
- a declared 'New Phenomenon' in building science never seen before nor since 911 [where are the skeptics when you need them],
- Where eyewitness TESTIMONY of explosive events within the building and of Molten metal 'flowing like a foundry' 'like it was lava, in a volcano' cannot even be given HONOR of official record ,

......as I struggle with that agnotological THEORY being accepted as REAL by any sentient being, the need to argue finer points of chemical chip layering possibles in the face of patent projected variables reminds me fully of the sinister Karl Rove:

" We're an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you're studying that reality.....judiciously, as you will, - we'll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and thats how things will sort out. We're history's actors....and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do"
 
Gee. All of the above not-with-standing, Next you will be telling me you BELIEVE some creatioNIST 'new phenomena' computer algorithm that has a complex 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed government secured High-rise in lower Manhattan suddenly drop into its own plan area in 6.5 seconds, 2.25 seconds at free fall, because of 'ordinary office furnishings fires' on one floor already out at the one column girder seat critical initiation just because you were told it did.

Yes...any other questions you would liked answered? :rolleyes:
 
To the argument.

pp 21 of the Harrit/Jones paper states 'The evidence for active, highly energetic thermitic material in the WTC dust is compelling'. Reported 'highly energetic reactions, iron-rich sphere formation so that the product must have been molten', 'to be expected from thermitic reactions' and that 'These observations reminded us of nano-thermite fabricated at LLNL and elsewhere.."[pp23]

Patent 5 505 799 pertains to Government/ LLNL nanoengineered explosives., 'reactive elements that have the capability of considerably more heat 'involving a plurality of very thin stacked multilayer structures etc [as above and read the patent] with a clearly stated intention to further refine going forward and not intended to be limiting by its filing . so that we have
. A paper identifying energetic material chips in the DUST 'reminding the the authors of nano-thermite fabricated at LLNL'
. A patent filed 1993 establishing High end development of energetic materials by LLNL that are of the kind identified in 1.

As I struggle with the essentially [creatio]nist HYPOTHESIS; an unproven UNTESTED THEORY morphing the OBSERVABLE 2.25 second FREE FALL of building 7; A complex 81 Vertically columned 47 storied steel framed high-rise suddenly straight down in 6.5 seconds to its own plan area "in the manner of controlled demolition" - all concrete pulverized into thermitic material and iron-rich microsphere riddled DUST., as I struggle with the observable building behaviour deconstructed into 'the result of 'Normal Office furnishings fires", burning around ONE column girder seat [of three at that join] on ONE floor [12] where photograph shows the fire OUT at critical Pinnochio Sunder axial 'thermal expansion' moment,
- where 3/4" shear studs at 22" centers break because of 'differential thermal expansion stresses created in the model by turning heat off the concrete floor slabs sat direct on the beams/girders to achieve differential stresses[NCSTAR1-9:352]
Where thermal expansion data is input on 'unrestrained beams', and where the critical girder shear-studs are excluded from input, and 'unusual' [6%] per volume iron-rich spheres are attributed to 'rust burn' in 'elevator furnaces',
- a THEORY constructed on computer algorithms held in secret
- a declared 'New Phenomenon' in building science never seen before nor since 911 [where are the skeptics when you need them],
- Where eyewitness TESTIMONY of explosive events within the building and of Molten metal 'flowing like a foundry' 'like it was lava, in a volcano' cannot even be given HONOR of official record ,

......as I struggle with that agnotological THEORY being accepted as REAL by any sentient being, the need to argue finer points of chemical chip layering possibles in the face of patent projected variables reminds me fully of the sinister Karl Rove:

" We're an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you're studying that reality.....judiciously, as you will, - we'll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and thats how things will sort out. We're history's actors....and you, all of you, will be left to just study what we do"

Just to pick one tidbit from your Gish Gallop: there is no definitive evidence that WTC7 fell AT "Free Fall", due to measurement uncertainties, and there is a very real possibility it fell at ABOVE "Free Fall". This also can be explained by non-Controlled Demolition collapse mechanisms.

In any case, where's your evidence of your explosives? Find any? No one has that I can discern. No clear residue distinguishable from primer paint, no detonators, no suspects on tape or confessing, no paper trail, no financing, no statements, emails or memos, no Thermite bright light, no explosive sounds, and no use of a similar method of Controlled Demolition as you propose, on a steel frame building.

By the way, what kind of material is your patent designed for?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom