Basically, I agree with the posters who said that the world in which conspiracy theories are true would look exactly like the one in which we currently live. Everything, from the way the economy is structured, to the selective nature in which media gets published and plethora of government secrets, is indicative of control by elites rather than a plurality of conventional, competing powers.
It appears from this thread that the reason some people don't believe in the reality of control by elites is because they have an unrealistic, Hollywood-esque conception of what control by elites would actually look like. People suggested all kinds of indications that simply would not be ideal methods of control in a world where conspiracy theories are actually true. The typical skeptic seems to envision that in a world dominated by elites, flagrant censorship is practiced en masse. The population is mostly aware of the conspiracy. The population is also destitute and subject to crushing totalitarianism. None of these features would apply to a successful control by elites. Instead, what we have now is more amenable to such control. People are economically ravaged just so, not excessively, in a way that would decrease productivity too much. Censorship is very real, but doesn't occur in the obvious way imagined by skeptics. The majority of the population is unaware of the existence of a conspiracy. Partisan politics is rigged and exists to create the illusion of choice. In short, everything is as you would expect it to be for there to be control by elites.
The hypothetical indications hazarded in this thread show a misunderstanding of the methods and incentives of people who seek control. All ten of the 'indications of elite control' posted are either happening now or are not optimal methods of control. Mostly the latter.