Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

Some of those graphs have a *lot* of lines pointing in all kinds of directions.

lol, they do indeed.

all you really need to know is that prices tend to track trendlines, and either bounce or penetrate, and the moving averages act the same way, ie resistance or support, depending on whether its above or below. you can argue all you like about the validity of this analysis, but you only have to watch the price hit and reverse off them, or fail, try again, fail, try again, and then finally break through for a while before it becomes reasonably clear somethings going on.

at every price decision point, real world forces, (news headlines primarily) can drive price in either direction, it is a 50:50 up/down choice at every instant of every day, however as you can see, the price does track around these points, and from that, larger patterns can be established (theorized)

then its down to back-testing and establishing historical data and extracting probabilities from that.

I think what we can say without fear of contradiction is that the price of Silver will certainly change or stay the same over the next few days/weeks/months

lol yes, but I need a bit more idea than that if possible. :D

if they do shock and awe the markets with QE3+ I think we may still get up somewhere near my silver target this year yet, 3&1/2 months is a long time when silver gets it boogie on.
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, I came across this which is probably equally able to predict silver prices going forward:

Most astrologers use a variety of techniques to "look into the future" of an individual. There are plenty of techniques used to make predictions for—and plan for—the future. Here, we share our preferred techniques—transits, secondary progressions, solar arc directions, solar return charts, and more. Transits, for example, challenge and pressure us to make changes in our lives and in our attitudes toward our lives. They bring us joy and sometimes sorrow—they pull out parts of ourselves and "force" us to face them. Secondary progressions reveal our cycles of maturity and growth, showing us how our personalities unfold.

Transits & Cycles

Our natal chart is very much like a snapshot of the sky at the moment we took our first breath. We carry our natal chart with us through the entire course of our lives, even though the planets and luminaries continue their movement and cycles. However, as the planets and points move ahead, they form special relationships to the planets and points in our individual natal charts.

So, for example, if my Sun in my natal chart is at 25 degrees Virgo, and Saturn is moving towards that same degree of Gemini (25 degrees of Gemini), Saturn is said to be transiting square my natal Sun. Similarly, if Saturn is in 25 degrees Gemini, I can look in my natal chart to see where Saturn would fall in terms of house position. If that degree of Gemini is found in my 3rd house, then I would know that Saturn is transiting through my 3rd house.

It is not our aim here to offer tutorials on the technical aspects of transits. We will assume a basic knowledge of the technique so that we can move ahead to interpretation of transits.


Needless to say, I think the above is a strong buy signal for silver! For me as a Leo, anyway!
 
On the other hand, I came across this which is probably equally able to predict silver prices going forward:

Most astrologers use a variety of techniques to "look into the future" of an individual. There are plenty of techniques used to make predictions for—and plan for—the future. Here, we share our preferred techniques—transits, secondary progressions, solar arc directions, solar return charts, and more. Transits, for example, challenge and pressure us to make changes in our lives and in our attitudes toward our lives. They bring us joy and sometimes sorrow—they pull out parts of ourselves and "force" us to face them. Secondary progressions reveal our cycles of maturity and growth, showing us how our personalities unfold.

Transits & Cycles

Our natal chart is very much like a snapshot of the sky at the moment we took our first breath. We carry our natal chart with us through the entire course of our lives, even though the planets and luminaries continue their movement and cycles. However, as the planets and points move ahead, they form special relationships to the planets and points in our individual natal charts.

So, for example, if my Sun in my natal chart is at 25 degrees Virgo, and Saturn is moving towards that same degree of Gemini (25 degrees of Gemini), Saturn is said to be transiting square my natal Sun. Similarly, if Saturn is in 25 degrees Gemini, I can look in my natal chart to see where Saturn would fall in terms of house position. If that degree of Gemini is found in my 3rd house, then I would know that Saturn is transiting through my 3rd house.

It is not our aim here to offer tutorials on the technical aspects of transits. We will assume a basic knowledge of the technique so that we can move ahead to interpretation of transits.


Needless to say, I think the above is a strong buy signal for silver! For me as a Leo, anyway!

:D :D

you may mock.. http://planetforecaster.blogspot.com
 

I'll stipulate that astrology has the same predictive power as those charts you sometimes link to.

BTW, is this one a joke?

silver-daily-squeeze.png


It seems to show in graphical format what I've been arguing - that charts can be made to show predict any outcome. Then, after the fact, the one correct squiggle is cherry picked to show validity, and the "misses" are rationalized away.
 
Last edited:
I'll stipulate that astrology has the same predictive power as those charts you sometimes link to.

you can stipulate that your opinion is whatever you want it to be.

BTW, is this one a joke?

chart

It seems to show in graphical format what I've been arguing - that charts can be made to show predict any outcome. Then, after the fact, the one correct squiggle is cherry picked to show validity, and the "misses" are rationalized away.

what it seems to show is the 5 most likely probabilities of direction at that point, IMO. A (day) trader is not supposed to have an opinion on which way its going to go, just get on the ride taking cues from price action, however the bigger money is usually made in anticipation of a possible trend change, (longer duration swing trading) exactly as shown above.

what it seemed to show to me at the time, (as stated at the time) was that the most likely direction was up, (there are always other possibilities, of differing probabilities) but that on breaching $29, we would be off to the races and I would be piling in.

one last thing, it also seems to show about $4k profit on that (series of day and swing) trade(s) in my trading account ;)
 
Last edited:
one last thing, it also seems to show about $4k profit on that (series of day and swing) trade(s) in my trading account ;)

Good for you!

Lots and lots of traders are looking for systems that will work for them consistently - I hope you found one and make a fortune!

Really.

I don't think charts of the past inform us of movements in the future, but I'm repeating myself.

But keep us informed of your real returns over time, after transactions costs and and short term capital gains taxes, including all your trades, winners and losers. Too many people crow about their wins and gloss over their losses, skewing their reported success with any given strategy.
 
Last edited:
Good for you!

Lots and lots of traders are looking for systems that will work for them consistently - I hope you found one and make a fortune!

Really.

I'm a long way from that, but I am only 8 and a bit months in, and this is without doubt the most difficult thing I have ever focused on, and that includes teaching myself SEO up to the point I'm in charge of £multi-million sites.

But it is definitely noticeable in this time, and from my trading log, that analysis is not really the problem, discipline, and control are, ie it is much harder to successfully trade, even when you correctly identify what is going to happen, timing usually ensures that trading it (well) is often another matter entirely. I still get plenty wrong too, especially in the day trading (5 and 15min charts)

I don't think charts of the past inform us of movements in the future, but I'm repeating myself.

you could say this about history too, but patterns do tend to repeat.

But keep us informed of your real returns over time, after transactions costs and and short term capital gains taxes, including all your trades, winners and losers.

can I include my physical gold & silver holdings on which I am permanently long? :D

seriously its as much as I can do to write my log up, not being the best at admin) so wasnt really planning on leaving an accounting trail on the web ;)

Too many people crow about their wins and gloss over their losses, skewing their reported success with any given strategy.

tell me about it, trading educators in particular. that's why i decided it had to be a live trading environment I was educated in. If you've ever wondered what a day trader actually does, you might like this video.

http://www.ezeetrader.co.uk/videos/170812.html

this is one of my mentors' weekly live trading educational videos, there is no doubt these guys make money from TA consistently, I am in the private trading room with them, day in, day out.
 
Last edited:
How about a deal...

...I'll keep my mind open to the possibility that technical analysis can be an effective way to make money consistently over time...

...and you'll keep yourself open to the possibility that perhaps all the machinations of the day traders and technical analysts do in fact fail to make meaningful predictions.

Remember, confirmation bias can make it very, very difficult to get to the real truth. For me as well as for you.

BTW, that link requires Flash, and I'm on an iPad right now. I will try to check it ou with an open mind.
 
Last edited:
How about a deal...

...I'll keep my mind open to the possibility that technical analysis can be an effective way to make money consistently over time...

...and you'll keep yourself open to the possibility that perhaps all the machinations of the day traders and technical analysts do in fact fail to make meaningful predictions.

:) deal. and to be fair, as a day trader, it doesnt have to be very meaningful, depending on strategy & trading plan you can be in and out again (up) on a very small move

ie say 1.61918 to 1.61958 and make a hefty profit.

Remember, confirmation bias can make it very, very difficult to get to the real truth. For me as well as for you.

BTW, that link requires Flash, and I'm on an iPad right now. I will try to check it ou with an open mind.

indeed, I came to it with a question "is this actually possible" and no real pre-conceptions except that nearly all traders lose, I would have to say that it is possible, albeit uncommon.

..whether I can do it consistently is another question entirely, but some people definitely can and do.
 
..whether I can do it consistently is another question entirely, but some people definitely can and do.

To be sure.

And on any given day people walk away from roulette wheels as winners, the go back and do it again.

I'm sure I've mentioned this before, but "Fooled By Randomness" should be a must-read to open your eyes a tiny bit more about how our very thought processes can lead us astray.

http://mmoorejones.com/2011/01/16/five-lessons-from-nassim-taleb/
 
To be sure.

And on any given day people walk away from roulette wheels as winners, the go back and do it again.

I'm sure I've mentioned this before, but "Fooled By Randomness" should be a must-read to open your eyes a tiny bit more about how our very thought processes can lead us astray.

http://mmoorejones.com/2011/01/16/five-lessons-from-nassim-taleb/

I will attempt to obtain and read it, as this article was interesting, and I would very much like to see "proof" of this claim

Studies have shown that we feel the effects of negative emotions 2.25 times stronger than we feel the effects of positive emotions.

have they now. lol. pardon my skepticism on measuring "strength" of feelings.

the randomness in markets is very much on short timescales though, over a more significant period of times fundamentals drive trends.
 
the randomness in markets is very much on short timescales though, over a more significant period of times fundamentals drive trends.

I'll stipulate to that possibility.

But the kind of TA your charts are used for all use very short time scales, do they not? What timescale was involved in that $4,000 trade, for example?

"Betting" on possible changes in value over more "significant" time scales sounds a bit more like conventional investing, something I've been known to do myself. Without consulting charts, BTW.
 
Bump !

Silver spot price is currently just under $34 an ounce.

Looks like last month's prediction was right :D

Me said:
I think what we can say without fear of contradiction is that he price of Silver will certainly change or stay the same over the next few days/weeks/months
 
A blast from the past....

yes indeed and there's a beauty of an inverse H & S lining up (and in Gold too at 1800 actually) - we will fairly soon get a live demo of whether TA has any validity at all IMO



and frankly I totally agree with Sprott's latest analysis, central banks are in global splurge mode, it has to go somewhere.

IMO the Dow & S&P would be at least 20% lower if they hadn't been printing a trillion a month since last November

So, was TA valid ?

I see from that graph an indication that prices were going to soar.
 
A blast from the past....

So, was TA valid ?

I see from that graph an indication that prices were going to soar.

:D well, actually I would argue that in that instance, even with my clumsy newbie application, that it was partially valid.

moved on a few days, this is what happened..

17852508b9b98979aa.png


you can see that we did indeed get an upwards push from there which was accelerating until it ran straight into Central Bank shenanigins, one way and another, the infamous March gold and silver "not-for-profit" attack selloff



Did you know that the Fed bought a new building just to house their manipulation and trading schemes. Seems they've run out of space and they are greatly expanding their market interventions through the Plunge Protection Team or PPT as it's known in the trade. When will it all end? We no longer have free markets and we no longer have the rule of law. And not just in the US, but in Europe as well.


I fully agree TA is not really valid for longterm price predictions in these sham markets, but at approaching one year in now of amateur trading I am 100% confident that TA is valid enough for short term trading usage that you can consistently make money from it, to the point that I am aiming to turn part-time pro in 2013.
 
I fully agree TA is not really valid...

Yet again, you should have stopped there!:p

...to the point that I am aiming to turn part-time pro in 2013.

Good luck with that.

Really.

Please report on your "hits" as well as your "misses" and your after-tax rate of return.

Should be edifying if you can pull it off.
 
Last edited:
Did you know that the Fed bought a new building just to house their manipulation and trading schemes. Seems they've run out of space and they are greatly expanding their market interventions through the Plunge Protection Team or PPT as it's known in the trade. When will it all end? We no longer have free markets and we no longer have the rule of law. And not just in the US, but in Europe as well.
The Federal Reserve Bank of New York has been leasing approximately 75% of the space in that building since 1998. It makes sense to simply purchase it. Of course, that doesn't matter to those who don't know WTF they are talking about.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom