Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

There was no genuine gray layer on my chips except one but there was gray deposits which appeared to be already made of many small spheres, as if the chips had already reacted before.
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf
When i heated those chips , one of them even released a small sphere, which would seem to confort Sunstealer idea except that,

- This is very different from what i can see on jones photos.

- if i had obtained their photos (huge appearing microspheres , i mean not much smaller than the chip they originated from) i would have concluded as they did because i'm afraid there is no way how their such big microspheres could have been hidden in the gray layer , which in Jones photos never include spheres at all (at the contratry to my gray deposits)
Henryco - I've looked at the spectra in your link. In my opinion what you have there is Tnemec Red primer paint with the carbon removed due to burning.

The reason there are no microspheres with iron content is because the chips you examined had no gray layer. The gray layer (in samples a-d) is oxidised steel. Jones and Harrit etc didn't know what the gray layer in samples a-d was.

In addition, the gray-layer material demands further study. What is its purpose? Sometimes the gray material appears in multiple layers, as seen in Fig. (32).

If they had they would have said so categorically in the paper. I've shown that the gray layer in samples a-d) is oxidised steel.

Infact it actually shows their sloppy thinking. The gray layer is the substrate, not part of the red layer. They seem to think the gray layer is part of the nano-thermite. That's the reason why some gray layers are different materials. It's self evident that this is the case as shown by comparing Fig 6 and Fig 33. The gray layer in Fig 33 is probably some sort of filler. You know that stuff that you can use to fill in car body repairs or seal gaps in your house, something like that. To think that this represents something sinister is laughable.


The top EDX is from the FEMA Appendix C Limited Metallurgical Examination. Locations 2 and 3 of Fig C13. Those two locations are in the oxide scale.

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/metallurgy/WTC_apndxC.htm (Sorry I had to link there but Firefox is not behaving with PDF and Adobe for me at the moment)

picture.php


---------------

To Remo - Do you now see that you don't need to do any experiments when the data is readily available? Jones and Harrit did the experiment, but they still didn't know that the gray layer is oxidised steel. I showed that over 3 years ago using the data in the paper. I can do that because I have the required knowledge and experience by profession.

Dr Millette comes to the same conclusion. I've been backed up by experiment, but I didn't need to do the experiment myself. Harrit et al consistently misinterpret their own data.

---------------

Henryco - Is it possible that your red/red chips, sometimes found with high iron content spheres had previously been heated? Is that why they had no gray layer, but did have spheres embedded in the red layer? Were you simply heating them again?

If you look at Fig 20 - Photomicrographs of residues from red/gray chips ignited in the DSC.


picture.php


Where is the gray layer? Where is the oxidised steel? It's not there. The gray layer is what forms the bulk of the spheres.

The likely explanation is reduction of the iron oxide by carbon and hydrogen (possibly silicon plays a role too) combined with an annealing effect.

Now lets ask another question. Why is this post DSC material still red? Everyone can see that we have a reddy/orange material with silver globules attached in the above photo.

If the red layer is thermite then we would not expect to see any evidence of a red layer post heating because that red layer would have reacted almost entirely. If this nanothermite reacts at 430°C and produces temperatures high enough to melt steel (Fe MP = 1536°) then why do we still see unreacted nanothermite?

Fig 20 alone is proof that no thermite is present.


The reason why the red layer is red is due to rhombohedral Fe2O3 pigment which is clearly shown in the SEM photos. If the post DSC residue is red then it is confirmation that a significant proportion of the Fe2O3 rhombohedral particles have not undergone the thermite reaction.

Fe2O3 + Al --> Fe + Al2O3

They have not been reduced. It's unreacted. Not a very efficient thermite is it if the bulk of the Fe2O3doesn't react, is it?

If you look at Fig 21, the SEM photo of post DSC residue you can clearly see unreacted hexagonal platelets and iron oxide particles. Look how close the claimed reacted particles are. They are still "intimately mixed".


picture.php


Page 25 of the HArrit et al paper.

The red layer of the red/gray chips is most interesting in that it contains aluminum, iron and oxygen components which are intimately mixed at a scale of approximately 100 nanometers (nm) or less.

Now compare the distance between the hexagonal platelets and iron oxide particles in Fig 21 and Fig 8 and 9. Why are particles that are in such close proximity unreacted? Perhaps they are not what the authors claim.

Harrit et al claim that there is bulk aluminium in those platelets yet upon heating to 700°C (and a thermite reaction producing temperatures higher than 1500°C) those platelets have been unaffected - no shape change nothing. What's the melting point of Al? ;)

Again Fig 21 debunks their own paper. The claims are wrong. See Remo, you don't need to do the experiment when you have the data and the knowledge and thinking skills to do a proper analysis.

I'll leave it there for the time being.
 
Thanks, Sunstealer:cool:

I'd like to add that some pictures of chips taken by Henryco seem not to differ dramatically from Harrit's chips, including some rounded gray objects visible. Like here:

picture.php


or here:

picture.php


Henryco commented: "Fig 8: Many microspheres ?!" Henryco, these shots were taken before or after heating?

.................................

And now again for Prof. Jones Letter regarding red/gray chip analyses.

Jones wrote: "Later, we mixed up some ultra-fine aluminum and iron-oxide powders thus making a type of nano-thermite (but with no organic matrix). This was run in the DSC at BYU in an inert atmosphere up to 700C – and it did not ignite! We concluded that oxygen may be important to get the reaction initiated."


Aha. Prof. Jones tries to say now, that heating experiments with nanothermites should be done under air, to initiate thermitic reaction! How "elegant" excuse for the idiotic DSC measurements of the red/gray chips under air! (And what about to test your new brave hypothesis with the another DSC run of your nanothermite heating, now under air, to get some experimental evidence, Prof. Jones?)

Prof. Jones, as a top expert on the supersecret nanothermite demolitions, you should know: when you heat thermites (or even nanothermites) slowly, like is usual in DSC devices, they usually do not violently react, no matter what the atmosphere is around;) Thermites need some thermal (or other energetic shock) to be reliably ignited.
Wiki, nanothermite entry: : "Nanoscale composites are easier to ignite than traditional thermites. A nichrome bridgewire can be used in some cases. Other means of ignition can include flame or laser pulse." So, very slow heating in DSC hardly suffices to ignite such a mixture, leading to really violent thermitic reaction:cool:
 
Last edited:
...

To Remo - Do you now see that you don't need to do any experiments when the data is readily available? Jones and Harrit did the experiment, but they still didn't know that the gray layer is oxidised steel. I showed that over 3 years ago using the data in the paper. I can do that because I have the required knowledge and experience by profession.

Dr Millette comes to the same conclusion. I've been backed up by experiment, but I didn't need to do the experiment myself. Harrit et al consistently misinterpret their own data.

---------------
Exactly.
More experimental data will not alleviate that situation, it will aggravate it! Because if new experiments are guided by incorrect interpretation of the old experiments, those will most likely bad experiments.

First you all need to understand the many errors in Harrit e.al.'s interpretation of the experiments that have already been done.

Then we need to look at the experimental data that allegedly already exists in some private files but hasn't been published yet: The FTIR data mentioned in the april 2009 paper, the TEM data by Farrer that Jones and Harrit have been hinting at since summer 2009, and the XRD data that Jones just now admitted exists but yielded no conslusive results. We need those results, even and especially if they are negative or inconclusive!

Only after we have all understood what all the existing data means, and there are significant questions unanswered, should we go on and design further experiments to answer those unknowns.

...
Now lets ask another question. Why is this post DSC material still red?
...
The reason why the red layer is red is due to rhombohedral Fe2O3 pigment which is clearly shown in the SEM photos. If the post DSC residue is red then it is confirmation that a significant proportion of the Fe2O3 rhombohedral particles have not undergone the thermite reaction.

Fe2O3 + Al --> Fe + Al2O3

They have not been reduced. It's unreacted. Not a very efficient thermite is it if the bulk of the Fe2O3doesn't react, is it?
...

Now couple that conclusion with the other data we already have about the red layer which Harrit e.al. claim is the thermitic component:

Fig. 7: http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums...ticMaterial/ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig07.jpg
Fig 14: http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums...ticMaterial/ActiveThermiticMaterial_Fig14.jpg
Basile's Chip #13: http://i1088.photobucket.com/albums...silePresentation/Basile_39_30_Chip13_XEDS.jpg

Start with the last one: Basile used a standard quantification routine (in plain language: a software that simulates spectra to work from peak heights back to mass proportions - which is by the way what I did, too, with Harrit e.al.'s spectra. You scoffed at that - do you also scoff at Basile??)

Basile finds 1.7-2.6% iron in the red layer! If you assume that all the iron is Fe2O3, all the aluminium is elemental, and the carbon and oxygen are part of a hydrocarbon matrix (which adds some undetected hydrogen to the total mass), you will find that under the best of circumstances, Basile's chip contains less than 5% by mass thermite, but >80% by mass organic matrix. For details see here. It can easily be shown that the energy content of such a small proportion of thermite is too small to even affect the organic matrix very much, let alone do destructive work outside the chip.

Same routine for chips a-d shows that the red-layer spectra in Fig 7 are consistent with ca. 11% iron and no more than 2.5% aluminium, but >70% organic matrix. Under the best of circumstances, assuming that all the Al is elemental, this will give you at most 10% thermite by mass - and that ca. 6 of the 11% iron are redundant.
Of course Al is never 100% elemental. So while the thermite content in these chips could theoretically twice that in the Basile chip, in reality it couldn't be much better.

And then the MEK-chip (Fig. 14), with such a tiny Al-peak that there couldn't be more than 0.6% elemental Al in the best of circumstances. It's again possible that the iron-content is 11-12%, but Al is the limiting factor here - there could be no more than 2.5% thermite, but easily >50% organic matrix. Again, the thermite content is too low to even affect the organic matrix much!


So you see, the data by Harrit, Jones Basile is already sufficient to conclude that no more than 3-10% of the red layer could be thermite - under the optimum theoretical conditions.


Now you see that lots of the iron oxide doesn't even react - it stays red!

Even if you suppose that 5% of the mass of the red layer reacts in a thermite reaction, then only about half of that mass would produce elemental iron (for iron is 52% by weight of stoichoimetric thermite), and with iron being the denset material in the mix, its volume proportion would be even less.

But Jones seems to claim, and Basile most certainly does, that a significant proportion of the volume of the ash is iron-rich spheres and blobs! That's impossible if there isn't enough thermite to begin with to even produce 2.5% by mass iron!


The conclusion is, again, inevitable: The iron-rich spheres and blobs must mainly come from the iron-rich gray layer, which could not have undergone a thermite reaction since in all samples there is way too little aluminium for that!
 
Remo: ...and some addendum as for "mysterious" multilayered chip depicted in Fig. 31 (Bentham paper).

picture.php


We know from the Bentham paper that the inner light gray material is very probably some organic polymer, with the lot of oxygen in it, perhaps some adhesive, as suggested by Harrit et al. Gray and red layers are again very probably just layers of rust and some red paint (welll.... red material).

Jones (and your) hypothesis: This chip must be multilayered nanothermite indeed! (Since, we should reluctantly admit, one such thin red layer is hardly good for cutting WTC steel and commiting the worst crime in the history)

My tentative hypothesis: This light gray thing can be a little particle of some polymer accidentally present/sticked on the steel during paint job. Just accidentally, steel was already oxidized in this little area, leading to some "microscaling" of rust; therefore, during painting, a fresh red paint "wrapped" this polymer particle, together with the adjacent scaling rust, leading to such three-layered (quite probably not really multilayered) irregular object. I know, it's just hypothesis. But still it seems to be a way better than your mighty speculation about sputtered nanothermite multilayers:p
 
Last edited:
Thank you.
It is important for me to understand the paradigm. Who is doing the talking. The experienced hands-on Professor/ technician/ laboratory worker physically originating the data, or those contending by computer analysis their presented works ...
Edited by LashL: 
Edited for civility.
when they think they have found something.

You do realize that, in the field of forensic identification of chemical compounds, the word "experienced" excludes the following individuals:

Niels Harritt
Jeffrey Farrer
Steven Jones
Kevin Ryan
Frank Legge
Daniel Farnsworth
Gregg Roberts
James Gourley
Bradley Larsen

I believe, but am not certain, that this would also exclude Mark Basile.

And since Dr. Henry-Couannier is posting here, I can ask him.

Dr. H-C, have you, in your past experience, been called upon to perform forensic identification of chemical compounds from real-world crime scenes?

Before this event, have you ever identified thermite from any such crime scene or incident?

Do you belong to any such professional organization that is accredited to testify in court under these situations (e.g., arson investigation) as "expert witnesses"?

If so, would you please elaborate on that experience.

If not, do you feel that a laboratory that regularly performs such investigations - such as a forensics chemistry lab that is certified to analyze for thermite in arson investigations - would have some experiential advantage over both you and the Harrit, Farrer, Jones, group?

If not, and you feel that my questions are irrelevant, would you elaborate on the reasons for that opinion.

Thank you.


tfk
 
Last edited:
Oystein: Since I don't read German, what do you basically think about Sitting Bull (you met him personally this spring)?

By accident, I found a Sitting Bull's post on gulli.com (as a response to your post). Here is again a complaint that Millette did not really follow/duplicate all procedures used in Bentham paper, specifically, he washed (some of) his chips with water, whereas no chips were washed in this way by Harrit et al (they were either cut or unwashed with anything, except MEK chip).

Sitting Bull's conclusion: "(Therefore...) Millette is a fraud. Mohr is a fraud. And you too, because you defend their delusions."

Hehe, is this guy serious? Or is he just trolling? Does he really believe that in all potential falzifications of Bentham paper, of this Holy Bible of Truther's pseudoscience, even absolutely idiotic experiments like heating of chips under air (in order to prove thermite!) must be inevitably and scrupulously repeated?

What is actually his suspicion in this case? That alleged elemental aluminium in the red layers can react with the cold neutral water used for washing???:D And that in this way, Jim Millette treacherously destroyed this trail of the megacrime?:D;):cool: Or does he thinks that red layer can be damaged/changed by cold water in other way?
(I'm lazy to read long Google translation into English, so I ask you, who knows quite well Sitting Bull's way of thinking:rolleyes:)
 
Last edited:
Oystein: Since I don't read German, what do you basically think about Sitting Bull (you met him personally this spring)?
We had agreed that we would write articles on our respective blogs about our meeting. We both procrastinated for four months, now he published his, and I haven't even started on mine. We had also agreed that we would first send each other a draft before publishing, so that the other could comment first and perhaps have important bits changed - well he went ahead and published pretty much at the same time he sent me an email last saturday. Oh well.

I don't want to go into much detail here and at this time.

By accident, I found a Sitting Bull's post on gulli.com (as a response to your post). Here is again a complaint that Millette did not really follow/duplicate all procedures used in Bentham paper, specifically, he washed (some of) his chips with water, whereas no chips were washed in this way by Harrit et al (they were either cut or unwashed with anything, except MEK chip).
Well, here is what his beloved ProfJones says on that matter:
ProfJones said:
In particular, it is unfortunate that we did not CLEAN the chip that was soaked in MEK, so as to obtain clear and unambiguous detail BEFORE the MEK run, regarding its elemental content. This is one of my regrets in the first paper.
So here, Sitting-Bull can learn that ProfJones now thinks cleaning a chip before XEDS testing or MEK soaking would have been the competent thing to do.
Perhaps I am out on limb here, but that seems to imply that Jones and pals did their test on that chip incompetently, while Millette did his competently.

Now I wonder if ProfJones or Sitting-Bull have any suggestion about how to clean chips, if neither with MEK nor water?


Sitting Bull's conclusion: "(Therefore...) Millette is a fraud. Mohr is a fraud. And you too, because you defend their delusions."

Hehe, is this guy serious? Or is he just trolling? Does he really believe that in all potential falzifications of Bentham paper, of this Holy Bible of Truther's pseudoscience, even absolutely idiotic experiments like heating of chips under air (in order to prove thermite!) must be inevitably and scrupulously repeated?
Yes, the guy is serious. He has deep, unmovable faith in every prophet of "Truth" (I am not allowed to write "twoof" anymore, as per, iirc, zica's demand, so I have to puth "Truth" in quote marks; of course what these people sell as "Truth" is actualle the very opposite of truth). Occasionally he entertains a moment of doubt, until he reads all the evasions and crap that other "Truthers" write, until he finds a straw that he can cling to. I that case, it is a blessing for the faithful disciples of the "Truth" prophets that the "Truth" prophets did so many things incompetently. Just deny it was all done incompetently, and then moan that competent scientists don't replicate the crap, and you're safe!

Of course Sitting-Bull ought to understand now that ProfJones is slowly coming to an understanding that...
- they treated the MEK-chip incompetently
- they aren't sure any longer they did the DSC tests competently

What is actually his suspicion in this case? That alleged elemental aluminium in the red layers can react with the cold neutral water used for washing???:D And that in this way, Jim Millette treacherously destroyed this trail of the megacrime?:D;):cool: Or does he thinks that red layer can be damaged/changed by cold water in other way?
(I'm lazy to read long Google translation into English, so I ask you, who knows quite well Sitting Bull's way of thinking:rolleyes:)
Yes, he is holding on to the believe that contact with water will make the elemental Al react. At gulli.com, he linked to some data sheet with material properties of "phlegmatized" (iirc - not 100% sure I recall the term correcly) Al powder, which has, among its hazards, the potential of reacting violently with water. Now he and a couple of others believed for a few days (and so did I for about a day) that "phlegmatized" might be the same as "passivated", i.e. "covered with a thin oxide layer", but that was false: Phlegmatized Al is Al without the passivation layer - it comes typically mixed with linseed oil that prevents atmospheric O from reaching the Al surface. His fantasy is missing three obvious facts:
a) There is no reason to assume the Al-rich particles in the red-gray chips could have avoided contact with O for 7 years sitting in a bag of dust - they weren't phlegmatized, but were sure as hell passivated. Passivated Al of course does not react violently with water
b) If elemental Al in Millette's chips had reacted with water, then he should have found Al-oxide ot hydroxide. He didn't. He found Al-silicate. More specifically, he found platelets of crystalline Al-silicate as commonly forms in geological processes. So it's not possible that the Al-rich platelets could have formed from a reaction with just Al and water, without Si
c) Harrit e.al. found the same Al-Si-O-rich platelets in their chips a-d without washing the surfaces they looked at with water.

Beyond that, Sitting-Bull refuses to have a concise and complete theory about what happened on 9/11. He is able to hold multiple, mutually exclusive CTs as probable at the same time.
 
Oystein: Aha, here are things completely new for me. Nanoaluminium can really violently react with water, its frozen mixture with water is even used as a rocket propellant called ALICE, as I read e.g. here.

It's written there: " While standard aluminum alloys require a lot of heat to ignite the reaction with water ice—around 2000 degrees C—nano-aluminum has much greater surface area and will begin reacting with water at just more than 700 C, Son says. In fact, you could light nano-aluminum with nothing more high-tech than a cigarette lighter."

While I have no idea so far what is the reactivity of water with already oxidized nanoaluminium at room temperature, I owe some apology to Sitting Bull in this case: his suspicion that such superfine aluminium (at least in some special forms in which passivating layer of alumina is somehow minimized?) can react with water is not baseless.

All your objections are indeed correct, but this is perhaps a point which could be used against the Millette's study when published and reviewed by truthers.
 
Last edited:
Well, here are some quotes from the document NANOALUMINIUM – THE FUTURE OF HYDROGEN POWER!

"Let's consider more detailed some processes of interaction aluminium nanopowder with water. Metal aluminium – is one of the most active metals – in usual conditions it is always covered with a thin, continuous oxidation film which protects it from influence of oxygen, steams of water, dilute solutions. If integrity of oxidation film is broken, for example, at the expense of metal processing by alkalis and acids, aluminium actively interreacts with water. Formally the equation of such reaction, without the notice of possible transformations of aluminium hydrate, looks like:

2Al + 6H2O = 2Al(OH)3 + 3H2↑.

According to stoichiometric calculations, at interaction of 54g of aluminium with water, 67,2l (or 6g) of hydrogen is formed, and 156g of aluminium hydrate. At a room temperature, the speed of reaction is insignificant, as there is always a dissolved oxygen, in water, which partially passivates metal aluminium. But rise of temperature, and also presence of small amounts of alkalis, acids or salts in water increases speed of reaction."

It seems to be clear that any potentially present nanoaluminium in any paint (well... in any layer of some polymer) must be also fully passivated, namely after almost 40 years, so its potential reaction with a cold clean/neutral water is either very slow or does not proceed at all.
 
Last edited:
Ivan! Did someone hack your account?? :D


This is all mightily interesting - or would be, if anyone had actually managed to find any nano-aluminium.
Which no one did.



To recap:
  • The only chip in which anyone found any hint of elemental Al was the MEK-soaked chip: On it, they found a spot with an EDS spectrum (Fig 17) that is consistent with some of the Al therein being elemental. However, the chip has a total Al-content of <1% (as per EDS spectrum Fig. 14), but in all the images of that chip, they didn't show anything "nano" - SEM images badly out if focus, and magnification insufficient to start with (Fig. 12, Fig. 13, Fig. 15)
  • In all the other chips, they failed to identify elemental Al, whether or not any particles therein were below micron-size in any dimension: The plateletes in chips a-d (shown e.g. in Fig. 8) have relative Al-, Si- and O-contents that are perfectly consistent with kaolin, an Al-silicate (Fig. 11a). And as we learned from Prof Jones, they couldn't find elemental Al with TEM or XRD, and since they never published the FTIR data they talk about in the paper, I suppose they also didn't find anything but kaolin with that method.
  • Millette identified the nanp-thin platelets unequivocally as kaolin.
 
Originally Posted by Ivan Kminek
What is actually his suspicion in this case? That alleged elemental aluminium in the red layers can react with the cold neutral water used for washing??? And that in this way, Jim Millette treacherously destroyed this trail of the megacrime? Or does he thinks that red layer can be damaged/changed by cold water in other way?


Yes, he is holding on to the believe that contact with water will make the elemental Al react. At gulli.com, he linked to some data sheet with material properties of "phlegmatized" (iirc - not 100% sure I recall the term correcly) Al powder, which has, among its hazards, the potential of reacting violently with water. Now he and a couple of others believed for a few days (and so did I for about a day) that "phlegmatized" might be the same as "passivated", i.e. "covered with a thin oxide layer", but that was false: Phlegmatized Al is Al without the passivation layer - it comes typically mixed with linseed oil that prevents atmospheric O from reaching the Al surface. His fantasy is missing three obvious facts:
a) There is no reason to assume the Al-rich particles in the red-gray chips could have avoided contact with O for 7 years sitting in a bag of dust - they weren't phlegmatized, but were sure as hell passivated. Passivated Al of course does not react violently with water
b) If elemental Al in Millette's chips had reacted with water, then he should have found Al-oxide ot hydroxide. He didn't. He found Al-silicate. More specifically, he found platelets of crystalline Al-silicate as commonly forms in geological processes. So it's not possible that the Al-rich platelets could have formed from a reaction with just Al and water, without Si
c) Harrit e.al. found the same Al-Si-O-rich platelets in their chips a-d without washing the surfaces they looked at with water.

Beyond that, Sitting-Bull refuses to have a concise and complete theory about what happened on 9/11. He is able to hold multiple, mutually exclusive CTs as probable at the same time.


Maybe he meant "phlogistonized". :) If aluminum reacted with water, the products would be hydrogen gas and aluminum hydroxide, easily visible as gas bubbles or as a gloppy, gel-like substance. This discussion is academic, of course, as all experimental data point to aluminum silicate containing paint.
 
BTW, in my career in industrial chemistry, I had many a piece of aluminum that I cleaned in a solution of about 10% citric acid in water. It will quickly "scrub" the oxide layer off of aluminum, which re-forms instantly once the aluminum is rinsed, dried, and exposed to air. In the citric acid solution, not only is the oxide layer of aluminum removed, but there's plenty of hydrogen ions about (citric acid is stronger than most people realize). Nonetheless, aluminum will not react violently with even a hot citric acid solution. You're in no danger if you boil lemon juice in an aluminum pot.
 
BTW, in my career in industrial chemistry, I had many a piece of aluminum that I cleaned in a solution of about 10% citric acid in water. It will quickly "scrub" the oxide layer off of aluminum, which re-forms instantly once the aluminum is rinsed, dried, and exposed to air. In the citric acid solution, not only is the oxide layer of aluminum removed, but there's plenty of hydrogen ions about (citric acid is stronger than most people realize). Nonetheless, aluminum will not react violently with even a hot citric acid solution. You're in no danger if you boil lemon juice in an aluminum pot.

Keeping in mind that this excursion is academic, as there is no elemental nano-Al found by anyone in that dust:

Fine Al-powder is flammable, even explosively so if you puff it into a dust cloud. Yet your aluminum pot is in no danger of bursting into flames if you put it on a fireplace. ;)
 
Mix.

"....as there is no elemental nano-Al found by anyone in that dust:"

And yet, Elemental Al is specifically - explicitly - referred to on pages 1,15,17,18,19,23,25,26 and 29[parts 1.3.6.9] of the Bentham paper. Including it being Ultra Fine Grain.
Bear this in mind. data isolated from source gives ability to manipulate the infrastructure of the information, and in this case its nadir, the NIST report, has taught us not to trust the production of theory confirming the official account. Physical forensic test gave evidence of steel vaporization and evaporation - intergranular eutectic attack on the steel.That is established forensic FACT. The question therefor is, where did the additional heat to evaporate the steel come from. We know aircraft fuel and office furnishings cannot supply it, so we are left looking at the DUST for evidence. The Bentham paper is explicit in its findings. Nano engineered incendiary material was found in their physical examination of the DUST.


As to FREE FALL. This ridiculous statement of it not occurring on WTC7 has got to be put outside any reasoned debate. The global 'collapse phase' : that is when the ENTIRE 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed structure suddenly became airborne; had it fall AT free fall, without resistance, for 2.25 seconds. Gravitational acceleration was recorded for 2.25 seconds. 108 feet or eight stories. This is beyond contention. NISTs own graph acknowledges this as forensic FACT. The global collapse phase was 6.5 + or - seconds and 2.25 seconds of that WAS AT at free fall.
To extrapolate into the free fall argument the Penthouse destruct time, then dividing that time-line to construct a theoretical mean, is a tactic of diversion.
As it is, the Penthouse sequence, we are informed by demolitions experts, was the core structure of 24 verticals being pulled first and is actually further evidence of a classic controlled demolition, the kink clearly established, but I know you don't want to hear that.
 
"....as there is no elemental nano-Al found by anyone in that dust:"

And yet, Elemental Al is specifically - explicitly - referred to on pages 1,15,17,18,19,23,25,26 and 29[parts 1.3.6.9] of the Bentham paper. Including it being Ultra Fine Grain.
Bear this in mind. data isolated from source gives ability to manipulate the infrastructure of the information, and in this case its nadir, the NIST report, has taught us not to trust the production of theory confirming the official account. Physical forensic test gave evidence of steel vaporization and evaporation - intergranular eutectic attack on the steel.That is established forensic FACT. The question therefor is, where did the additional heat to evaporate the steel come from. We know aircraft fuel and office furnishings cannot supply it, so we are left looking at the DUST for evidence. The Bentham paper is explicit in its findings. Nano engineered incendiary material was found in their physical examination of the DUST.


As to FREE FALL. This ridiculous statement of it not occurring on WTC7 has got to be put outside any reasoned debate. The global 'collapse phase' : that is when the ENTIRE 81 vertically columned 47 storied steel framed structure suddenly became airborne; had it fall AT free fall, without resistance, for 2.25 seconds. Gravitational acceleration was recorded for 2.25 seconds. 108 feet or eight stories. This is beyond contention. NISTs own graph acknowledges this as forensic FACT. The global collapse phase was 6.5 + or - seconds and 2.25 seconds of that WAS AT at free fall.
To extrapolate into the free fall argument the Penthouse destruct time, then dividing that time-line to construct a theoretical mean, is a tactic of diversion.
As it is, the Penthouse sequence, we are informed by demolitions experts, was the core structure of 24 verticals being pulled first and is actually further evidence of a classic controlled demolition, the kink clearly established, but I know you don't want to hear that.

The last two paragraphs are off topic. I refer you to the Chris Mohr video thread and the several WTC7 threads where they have been discussed at length.
 
Last edited:
"... ...is actually further evidence of a classic controlled demolition, the kink clearly established, but I know you don't want to hear that.
It is evidence of fire destroying the strength of steel, and leading to collapse. WTC 7 was unique, many buildings totaled by fire did not collapse, but were never used again. There is no thermite, Jones' paper proves it; your obsession with coming to false conclusions of CD, are not on topic.

The paper would be famous if true. Reading the paper shows they did not find thermite. They made up their conclusions based on their biases. I don't know what it takes to comprehend Jones bias fantasy on thermite. Chemical engineering or chemistry might help. I read the paper, and find the conclusion does not match the material presented. Feel free to team with a newspaper and earn a Pulitzer, Jones and company have been unable to break thought to Prime Time. Can you? No, you have nonsense of thermite, based on the fantasy of CD.

How many experts outside of the failed truth movement support your claims?
 
"....as there is no elemental nano-Al found by anyone in that dust:"

And yet, Elemental Al is specifically - explicitly - referred to on pages 1,15,17,18,19,23,25,26 and 29[parts 1.3.6.9] of the Bentham paper. Including it being Ultra Fine Grain. ...

Let's see which of these 12 specific and explict mentions of "Elemental Al" are actually in reference to specific observations made of dust specimens:

Page 1 (you probably mean page 7 - the first of the PDF?):
[from Abstract] "Separation of components using methyl ethyl ketone demonstrated that elemental aluminum is present."
This refers to the MEK-soaked chip.

Page 15:
There is no mention of elemental Al on page 15.

Page 17:
"This allowed us to assess whether some of the aluminum was in elemental form."
Does not mention an actual observation of elemental Al.

Page 18
"Thus, while some of the aluminum may be oxidized, there is insufficient oxygen present to account for all of the aluminum; some of the aluminum must therefore exist in elemental form in the red material."
This reports an actual observation of elemental Al in the MEK-soaked chip. However there is no observation or mention of whether or not there are "nano-sized" or "ultra fine" Al-rich particles.

Page 19
"The existence of elemental aluminum..."
This refers again to the same observation in the MEK-soaked chip. No mention of anything nano-sized or ultra-fine.

Page 23
"In the sample soaked in MEK, we observed a clear migration and aggregation of the aluminum away from other elements and determined that elemental aluminum and iron oxide must be present."
This refers again to the same observation in the MEK-soaked chip.

"when the ingredients are ultra-fine grain (UFG) and are intimately mixed, this “nano-thermite” reacts very rapidly, even explosively, and is sometimes referred to as “super-thermite” [20, 22]."
Not an observation from the dust, but talking about materials elsewhere

Page 25
There is no mention of any observation of elemental Al in any dust specimen on page 25.

Page 26
There is no mention of any observation of elemental Al in any dust specimen on page 26.

Page 29 part 1:
"It is composed of aluminum, iron, oxygen, silicon and carbon. Lesser amounts of other potentially reactive elements are sometimes present, such as potassium, sulfur, lead, barium and copper."
Mentions neither elemental Al nor anything nano-sized or ultra-fine.

Page 29 part 3:
"On treatment with methyl ethyl ketone solvent, some segregation of components occurred. Elemental aluminum became sufficiently concentrated to be clearly identified in the pre-ignition material."
This refers again to the same observation on the MEK-soaked chip. No mention that anything nano-sized or ultra-fine was observed.

Page 29 part 6:
"From the presence of elemental aluminum and iron oxide in the red material, we conclude that it contains the ingredients of thermite."
No mention that anything nano-sized or ultra-fine was observed.

Page 29 part 9:
There is no mention of any observation of elemental Al in any dust specimen on page 29 part 9.



remo, your reading skills seem to be underdeveloped.
You missed the fact that all the pages you point to together contain only 1 (one) observation of elemental Al, made on one spot on the MEK-soaked chip. Nothing in the entire paper indicates that this 1 observation of the presence of elemental Al was won from a nano-sized or ultra-fine particle.



Hence all your page references taken together support what I claimed initially:

There is no elemental nano-Al found by anyone in that dust


Thanks for playing and helping me make that point.
 
Last edited:
Keeping in mind that this excursion is academic, as there is no elemental nano-Al found by anyone in that dust:

Fine Al-powder is flammable, even explosively so if you puff it into a dust cloud. Yet your aluminum pot is in no danger of bursting into flames if you put it on a fireplace. ;)

I was wondering if someone here could clarify, correct or affirm my following experience. I used to work for years in industrial smithing, and, surface engineering. I've seen very small mixtures go "boosh boom" in my time, mixtures of otherwise not so uncommon chemicals. Way back, I recall seeing aceton chemicals mixed together with plastic and a bit of powdered/fine aluminum (I think it was aluminum) that, under the certain circumstances that were, reacted quite explosively. I mean there was barely a thimble-full of this stuff, where it converged, and it had a massively violent reaction.

As I recollected the above, I was browsing my bookmarks for relevant references and found something else, allthough somewhat relevant yet nonetheless interesting and affirming of my own blue-colour practical experiences:
Whenever two liquids, with widely different temperatures, come into contact, an explosion can result. This is purely a physical phenomenon, but with aluminium there is an additional concern because it is a very reactive element that has a strong chemical attraction for oxygen, as evidenced in its naturally occurring compounds. Just as a large an amount of energy is required in reduction cell electrolysis to break down the aluminium-oxygen bonds of its oxide form to produce metallic aluminium.
This energy is released dramatically if the metal is able to recombine with the oxygen from either water or air. The energy released when 0.5 kg of aluminium fully reacts with oxygen, according to the reaction equation set out below, is equivalent to detonating 1.4 kg of trinitrotoluene (TNT).

For me, this explains alot, but at the same time makes me want to beg for clarifications. Such conconctions of happenstance would, as close as I can tell, be reasonably expected to have occured in the piles. Would I be correct?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom