Sunstealer
Illuminator
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2007
- Messages
- 3,128
Henryco - I've looked at the spectra in your link. In my opinion what you have there is Tnemec Red primer paint with the carbon removed due to burning.There was no genuine gray layer on my chips except one but there was gray deposits which appeared to be already made of many small spheres, as if the chips had already reacted before.
http://www.darksideofgravity.com/redreds.pdf
When i heated those chips , one of them even released a small sphere, which would seem to confort Sunstealer idea except that,
- This is very different from what i can see on jones photos.
- if i had obtained their photos (huge appearing microspheres , i mean not much smaller than the chip they originated from) i would have concluded as they did because i'm afraid there is no way how their such big microspheres could have been hidden in the gray layer , which in Jones photos never include spheres at all (at the contratry to my gray deposits)
The reason there are no microspheres with iron content is because the chips you examined had no gray layer. The gray layer (in samples a-d) is oxidised steel. Jones and Harrit etc didn't know what the gray layer in samples a-d was.
In addition, the gray-layer material demands further study. What is its purpose? Sometimes the gray material appears in multiple layers, as seen in Fig. (32).
If they had they would have said so categorically in the paper. I've shown that the gray layer in samples a-d) is oxidised steel.
Infact it actually shows their sloppy thinking. The gray layer is the substrate, not part of the red layer. They seem to think the gray layer is part of the nano-thermite. That's the reason why some gray layers are different materials. It's self evident that this is the case as shown by comparing Fig 6 and Fig 33. The gray layer in Fig 33 is probably some sort of filler. You know that stuff that you can use to fill in car body repairs or seal gaps in your house, something like that. To think that this represents something sinister is laughable.
The top EDX is from the FEMA Appendix C Limited Metallurgical Examination. Locations 2 and 3 of Fig C13. Those two locations are in the oxide scale.
http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/metallurgy/WTC_apndxC.htm (Sorry I had to link there but Firefox is not behaving with PDF and Adobe for me at the moment)
---------------
To Remo - Do you now see that you don't need to do any experiments when the data is readily available? Jones and Harrit did the experiment, but they still didn't know that the gray layer is oxidised steel. I showed that over 3 years ago using the data in the paper. I can do that because I have the required knowledge and experience by profession.
Dr Millette comes to the same conclusion. I've been backed up by experiment, but I didn't need to do the experiment myself. Harrit et al consistently misinterpret their own data.
---------------
Henryco - Is it possible that your red/red chips, sometimes found with high iron content spheres had previously been heated? Is that why they had no gray layer, but did have spheres embedded in the red layer? Were you simply heating them again?
If you look at Fig 20 - Photomicrographs of residues from red/gray chips ignited in the DSC.
Where is the gray layer? Where is the oxidised steel? It's not there. The gray layer is what forms the bulk of the spheres.
The likely explanation is reduction of the iron oxide by carbon and hydrogen (possibly silicon plays a role too) combined with an annealing effect.
Now lets ask another question. Why is this post DSC material still red? Everyone can see that we have a reddy/orange material with silver globules attached in the above photo.
If the red layer is thermite then we would not expect to see any evidence of a red layer post heating because that red layer would have reacted almost entirely. If this nanothermite reacts at 430°C and produces temperatures high enough to melt steel (Fe MP = 1536°) then why do we still see unreacted nanothermite?
Fig 20 alone is proof that no thermite is present.
The reason why the red layer is red is due to rhombohedral Fe2O3 pigment which is clearly shown in the SEM photos. If the post DSC residue is red then it is confirmation that a significant proportion of the Fe2O3 rhombohedral particles have not undergone the thermite reaction.
Fe2O3 + Al --> Fe + Al2O3
They have not been reduced. It's unreacted. Not a very efficient thermite is it if the bulk of the Fe2O3doesn't react, is it?
If you look at Fig 21, the SEM photo of post DSC residue you can clearly see unreacted hexagonal platelets and iron oxide particles. Look how close the claimed reacted particles are. They are still "intimately mixed".
Page 25 of the HArrit et al paper.
The red layer of the red/gray chips is most interesting in that it contains aluminum, iron and oxygen components which are intimately mixed at a scale of approximately 100 nanometers (nm) or less.
Now compare the distance between the hexagonal platelets and iron oxide particles in Fig 21 and Fig 8 and 9. Why are particles that are in such close proximity unreacted? Perhaps they are not what the authors claim.
Harrit et al claim that there is bulk aluminium in those platelets yet upon heating to 700°C (and a thermite reaction producing temperatures higher than 1500°C) those platelets have been unaffected - no shape change nothing. What's the melting point of Al?
Again Fig 21 debunks their own paper. The claims are wrong. See Remo, you don't need to do the experiment when you have the data and the knowledge and thinking skills to do a proper analysis.
I'll leave it there for the time being.