Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

The accuracy of the handheld VHT yagi is good enough to triangulate the precise location small animals in the bush.


That wasn't the question. But now you need to define "precise".


Surely the same approach can give a half decent triangulation on a fleet of ships using the available marine radio technology.


Sure. If the Lurline had turned towards the source of the signal and followed it until they saw it then circled around it to verify it was the source of the signal.

This of course assumes that the sought after ships were transmitting every now and then.


Which we know they didn't.

As I say, I have no dog in this fight, but this is a sceptics forum and I am sceptical about every anonomous internet arguer from each side of a given debate.


Then please stick around and keep questioning my answers!
 
Triangulating the source of a radio transmitter using a single mobile direction finder is common practice.
Wildlife tracking
Location of radio-tagged animals by triangulation is a widely applied research technique for studying the movement of animals. The technique was first used in the early 1960s, when the technology used in radio transmitters and batteries made them small enough to attach to wild animals, and is now widely deployed for a variety of wildlife studies. Most tracking of wild animals that have been affixed with radio transmitter equipment is done by a field researcher using a handheld radio direction finding device. When the researcher wants to locate a particular animal, the location of the animal can be triangulated by determining the direction to the transmitter from several locations.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direction_finding

And before you say this only started in 1960, this refers to the attachment of radio transmitters to animals.

Yes, if the source is not thousands of miles away and not moving at unknown speeds of up to 30 knots for days on end.

Also, it helps if the radio transmitter is actually transmitting.
 
The Phillipines were seen as a much more likely target. Look at the geography of the Pacific Ocean and tell me you think that Hawaii is an easy target.

It may not have been an easy target but definitely the best target. The only fault with the plan was not enough damage done to infra-structure. Take out the dry dock and you have crippled US naval activity in the Western Pacific
 
* I seriously doubt that Jacobsen's article Grogan's bearings does not "demolish" or "destroy" the evidence that they were obtained from signals from the task force. I will obtained and read Jacobsen's article. To explain away Grogan's bearings, Jacobsen will need to explain the evidence presented by Farago, Hill, Wilford, and Toland. He will need to explain why Japanese fishing ships in Japanese home waters would have been using repeat-back transmissions and how Grogan could have heard those transmissions when he heard them. He will also need to explain the evidence from USN reports, including from Station Hypo, that indicates Grogan was indeed tracking the task force.


And YOU will need to (a) provide a plausible explanation why a Japanese task force engaged on a highly risky, top secret mission would be broadcasting so many radio messages; and (b) provide something from Japanese sources which corroborate the claim that the task force was transmitting so many radio messages.

To date you have absolutely failed to do either.
 
No, but the principle is pretty much the same of combining bearing only information with ship movement in order to get a fix on a target. It would have been to my mind the only technique that Grogan could have employed to get a real location in 1941, and seeing as it was a technique developed in the 50s, not so good a fit.

It's up to our CT theorist to show if there was some other method that Grogan could have employed. Good luck there...

AFAIK, you would not need any dead reckoning charts other than those for the ship you were on.

All you needed was a rotating antenna, receiver and a gonio.

Not all DF systems require a loop aerial.

Sure, the accuracy may be inferior, but an educated and skilled operator would have no problem with this type of triangulation.
 


Here's an image of the Pacific Ocean. Draw some bearing lines on it and then point out the course of the signal source.
 
Yes, if the source is not thousands of miles away and not moving at unknown speeds of up to 30 knots for days on end.

Also, it helps if the radio transmitter is actually transmitting.

Animals are continually on the move.
The transmitters do not have to transmit continuously.

You can reasonably infer distance when plotting 2 or more df bearings onto a local chart, regardless of the received signal strength

My point is, if you wish to refute bobtaftfan's argument, then you should not be using the DF argument, as what he describes wrt DFing is reasonable.
 
Last edited:
What freq were the Japs supposedly using?

3. The issue of the radio silence maintained by the Pearl Harbor Striking Force has been questioned recently by some researchers. Their misperception that the force actually transmitted and gave their position away is caused almost completely by a misunderstanding of the technical aspects of Japanese naval command and control communications and the capabilities of U.S. naval radio monitoring, cryptanalysis, and direction finding capabilities in the Pacific and Washington, D.C. Their errors and speculations notwithstanding, the task force maintained complete radio silence; that is, it did not transmit any radio messages during its passage to Pearl Harbor. The Japanese naval broadcast system supported the task force as it crossed the Pacific. Tokyo transmitted numerous support messages - intelligence updates, weather reports, orders, and morale statements - to the Striking Force (Kido Butai) on several frequencies at multiple times. The broadcast method consisted of one-way communications, or "blind" (UTU) sending. Several ships in the force listened to the broadcast and copied the messages. The messages were then repeated to the other ships in the formation by semaphore flag or signal lamp. The Kido Butai did not reply or acknowledge the receipt of any messages; their orders prohibited it. The only element of the force to transmit during the voyage were two reconnaissance aircraft, one each from the cruisers Tone and Chikuma, sent out on the morning of 7 December to verify the Pacific Fleet's location in Pearl Harbor or at Lahanai anchorage. The planes' reports were sent "in the blind,"

Page 100

that is, the task force did not acknowledge these messages. The aircraft reports verified an earlier report from the Japanese submarine I-72 from the previous evening that the American fleet was not at the Lahanai anchorage. The submarine sent the report to the Commander of the Japanese 6th Fleet (Submarine Force) located on Kwajalein Island. Kwajalein relayed the message to Tokyo, which, in turn, broadcast it to the Striking Force. See SRN 115367, NARA CP, RG 457, Entry 9014.

http://www.nsa.gov/about/_files/cryptologic_heritage/publications/wwii/west_wind_clear.pdf
 
Animals are continually on the move.
The transmitters do not have to transmit continuously.

You can reasonably infer distance when plotting 2 or more df bearings onto a local chart, regardless of the received signal strength


If the animal is moving then where the bearings cross the animal is no longer there.

My point is, if you wish to refute bobtaftfan's argument, then you should not be using the DF argument, as what he describes wrt DFing is reasonable.


bobtaftfan's argument isn't that they are reasonable; he is claiming a high quality match with the Japanese task force.
 
If the animal is moving then where the bearings cross the animal is no longer there.


Then you do it again and make informed decisions.

As I said it works very well and a skilled operator has no problems.
 
That's what I'd like to see too. I'm not an expert in radio DF, but I know some basic physics and geometry. No matter how hard I try, I can't for the life of me figure out how you can triangulate on a moving target, using one receiver that is itself on a moving platform.

While I see somebody beat me too it, it's obvious and easy to use one transmitter and one receiver, both of which can be moving, to determine the location. And I'm not even that smart.

What is surprising is how after the ignorant are shown something they didn't know, they then move the goal posts, and try to say the other team wasn't really even in the game.

Shameful.
 
Then you do it again and make informed decisions.


And you do it again and you are still moving in the same direction and the animal is still moving but you don't know how far away it is or how fast it is moving or in which direction and you got a whole lot of nothing other than "something is in that direction". Throw in that off in the far distance there are identical radio collars transmitting on the exact same frequency and your antenna isn't accurate to differentiate the bearings so you don't know how many other transmitters there are.

As I said it works very well and a skilled operator has no problems.


What are you basing that on? That you thinks it's simple?

It's all academic until we are shown the actual data.
 
Last edited:
And you do it again and you are still moving in the same direction and the animal is still moving but you don't know how far away it is or how fast it is moving or in which direction and you got a whole lot of nothing other than "something is in that direction". Throw in that off in the far distance there are identical radio collars transmitting on the exact same frequency and your antenna isn't accurate to differentiate the bearings so you don't know how many other transmitters there are.




What are you basing that on? That you thinks it's simple?

Brains and mark1 eyeball.

that's what makes it simple

You are not looking for dark matter here.

Dark forces maybe.:D
 
So the radiomen of the day had no idea what they were doing?

Blatant, blatant straw man. Go sit in the corner.

Strange that direction finding using VHF equipment (common frequency range for comms) without the use of a loop aerial is very succesfull in the african bush.

Now, I am not making any statements about what went down in the Pacific, but, the one statement I will make is:

The USA must have been pretty thick if they believed Pearl Harbour was not a serious target for the Japanese.

The world was at war, the Japanese were allies with the Germans and the germans were already attacking the american liberty ships.

Argument from incredulity.

Nothing in war is easy when you are looking to surprise the enemy.

Dodge.

Here is what was available to the Canadians.

I am sure other countries had similar technology. ...
Argument from ignorance again, and dodge.

The accuracy of the handheld VHF yagi is good enough to triangulate the precise location small animals in the bush.

Surely the same approach can give a half decent triangulation on a fleet of ships using the available marine radio technology.
Bobby has been unable and unwilling to demonstrate how to do so, despite making such a claim. Maybe you can do better.

This of course assumes that the sought after ships were transmitting every now and then.
Which is unlikely, for reasons already explained.

As I say, I have no dog in this fight, but this is a sceptics forum and I am sceptical about every anonomous internet arguer from each side of a given debate.
Then why do you keep arguing from ignorance against only one side?
 
Last edited:
Brains and mark1 eyeball.

that's what makes it simple

You are not looking for dark matter here.


On the other hand, what's the typical range at which an animal transmitter is being tracked? I suspect it's from a lot closer than radio messages from a task force at sea in an ocean with thousands of square miles of open water. Also, how many animals move at anywhere from 15 to 30 miles per hour for twenty-four hours a day?
 
Then you do it again and make informed decisions.

As I said it works very well and a skilled operator has no problems.

There's no amount of "informed decisions", or even "reasonable guesses" that'll locate the animal in more than a general area. What Bobby is describing has a ludicrously large margin of error; thousands of miles, I think someone said.

While I see somebody beat me too it, it's obvious and easy to use one transmitter and one receiver, both of which can be moving, to determine the location. And I'm not even that smart.

What is surprising is how after the ignorant are shown something they didn't know, they then move the goal posts, and try to say the other team wasn't really even in the game.

Shameful.

You and others have claimed its easy, yet no demonstrations have occured.

Brains and mark1 eyeball.

that's what makes it simple

You are not looking for dark matter here.

Dark forces maybe.:D

So, you have nothing except Argument from Ignorance. Put on this cap and go sit in the corner.
 
Roosevelt bears responsibility for the outbreak of the war in the Pacific. He sent the Japanese government a war ultimatum. When he found out Republican leader Hamilton Fish was outraged and correctly stated that the US government would not accept a war ultimatum from Japan so why would Japan accept one from the US? Roosevelt made war inevitable by his embargo policy. www.cwporter.com/japanwas.htm A good article on the treachery of FDR at Pearl Harbor. www.whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/pearl/www.geocities.com/Pentagon/6315/pearl.html

It is true that the American positon did not leave Japan with a lot of options, but that was after Japan had occupied half of Asia, and seriously threatened to take the other half as well.

Later presidents have sent the US to war for much less than that.

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom