Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

On the other hand, what's the typical range at which an animal transmitter is being tracked? I suspect it's from a lot closer than radio messages from a task force at sea in an ocean with thousands of square miles of open water. Also, how many animals move at anywhere from 15 to 30 miles per hour for twenty-four hours a day?

the limitation in animal tracking is the size of the equipment in relation to the power output.

All you need is a receivable signal, ascertain the direction the peak in signal strength occurs.

Draw a long line on your chart with the relative bearing.

Repeat a fair distance and time away from your first point and draw the corresponding long line on the chart.

Where they intersect indicates the "probable position" of the source over the amount of time spent locating.

It's not rocket science.
 
Last edited:
the limitation in animal tracking is the size of the equipment in relation to the power output.

All you need is a receivable signal,ascertain the direction the peak in signal strength occurs.

Draw a long line on your chart with the relative bearing.

Repeat a fair distance and time away from your first point and draw the corresponding long line on the chart.

Where they intersect indicates the "probable position" of the source over the amount of time spent locating.

It's not rocket science.

Ok, now what if you are a ship moving at x knots on bearing y, and the target is another ship (ships? Land transmitter?) Moving at ??? Knots on ??? Bearing and possibly performing course and speed corrections? And what if your own vessel is also changing course and speed? Now, how accurate would your location estimate be?
 
* Some of the replies about my comments regarding DFing in relation to signal strength and signal characteristics assume arguments I have not made. I did not say Grogan used DFing to determine that the signals he was hearing were low power. I'm guessing that the folks who are making these arguments still have not read Hill and Wilford's article on the Lurline DF bearings.

It does not really matter what some people write. I know what is and was technically possible. I have worked with radio for half a century, and I know what level was achievable in 1941. Ships of the era used shortwave radio (apart from sattelite links they still do, btw). The precision of a DF antenna depends on its size in relation to the wavelenght; it should be at least as large as one wavelength, preferably far larger, and you must be able to rotate it. Since shortwaves come in wavelengths from 10meters to 100 meters, it follows that even a large ship could not have an efficient DF array. In fact, it still can't, as this is basic physics and has little to do with technological advances..

* Regarding the repeated challenge that I produce a map showing how Grogan's bearings would have been triangulated, is that really necessary? Is it so hard to understand that multiple bearings taken over the space of several days on a huge, slow-moving target would essentially, roughly enable triangulation?

There are two problems:

1) There is no reason to belive that the Japanese did not largely maintain radio silence. They would have been complete fools not to.

2) A DF plot of a shortwave signal is at best possible within 10-20 degrees. That is fine for finding the whereabouts of a land vehicle a few miles away (as you have been doing in the army) but triangulating over a thousands miles of ocean, it is close to useless.

Hans
 
Ok, now what if you are a ship moving at x knots on bearing y, and the target is another ship (ships? Land transmitter?) Moving at ??? Knots on ??? Bearing and possibly performing course and speed corrections? And what if your own vessel is also changing course and speed? Now, how accurate would your location estimate be?

As long as you know your own position and time when you recorded the respective signal relative bearings, you have the required data.

Locating the general position and direction of an unknown source does not equate to identifying the source.

The source could have been a decoy. You wouldn't know until you had visual confirmation or additional intel.

I am not asserting anything other than the DF possibilities are reasonable.

Any further arguments with respect to the Japanese, Americans and Pearl Harbour should be taken up with bobtaftfan.

He is the source of assertions regarding motives and the USA.
 
the limitation in animal tracking is the size of the equipment in relation to the power output.

All you need is a receivable signal, ascertain the direction the peak in signal strength occurs.

Draw a long line on your chart with the relative bearing.

Repeat a fair distance and time away from your first point and draw the corresponding long line on the chart.

Where they intersect indicates the "probable position" of the source over the amount of time spent locating.

It's not rocket science.

An animal tracking transmitter uses VHF or UHF. With those wavelengths, you can get a good bearing with a hand-held antenna. Ships, during WW2, used HF, 10 to 100 meters. You would need a 30 meter, rotatable multi element antenna to get a comparable result. Obviously, you couldn't place such a thing even on a battleship (not one that would survive ocean conditions), so instead loop antennas were used. However, loop antennas have a serious shortcoming: A multi element antenna (Yagi type) can find a direction at max sensitivity. For the loop antenna you need to use the minimum. Thus, it quickly becomes very inefficient at distance.

Hans
 
Ok, now what if you are a ship moving at x knots on bearing y, and the target is another ship (ships? Land transmitter?) Moving at ??? Knots on ??? Bearing and possibly performing course and speed corrections? And what if your own vessel is also changing course and speed?


Actually, if your own vessel were changing course and speed it would help! But this was a cruise liner on its regularly scheduled route to/from Honolulu and the US west coast. Any deviation from its track would waste fuel.
 
the limitation in animal tracking is the size of the equipment in relation to the power output.

All you need is a receivable signal, ascertain the direction the peak in signal strength occurs.


And how accurate is that? In degrees, please.


Draw a long line on your chart with the relative bearing.


A "relative bearing" is an actual thing in the maritime sciences. It means the bearing in relation to the bow, measured clockwise when looking down. "True bearing" is the correct term.


Repeat a fair distance and time away from your first point


What is a "fair distance"? Remember the amount and direction the task force moved relative to its distance made a very small angle.


and draw the corresponding long line on the chart.


It's so easy! Except when the bearing errors are larger than the bearing spread caused by the movement of the ships involved.
 
As long as you know your own position and time when you recorded the respective signal relative bearings, you have the required data.

Locating the general position and direction of an unknown source does not equate to identifying the source.

The source could have been a decoy. You wouldn't know until you had visual confirmation or additional intel.

I am not asserting anything other than the DF possibilities are reasonable.

Any further arguments with respect to the Japanese, Americans and Pearl Harbour should be taken up with bobtaftfan.

He is the source of assertions regarding motives and the USA.

If I understand this, the problem is that you only know the general direction. You know nothing of the position. You don't know the speed or course of the source.

Assuming that triangulation means the bearing lines will converge and that you only have the direction, the source could be on the far side of the convergence point going in the opposite direction of what it would be if it was on the near side.
 
If I understand this, the problem is that you only know the general direction. You know nothing of the position. You don't know the speed or course of the source.

Assuming that triangulation means the bearing lines will converge and that you only have the direction, the source could be on the far side of the convergence point going in the opposite direction of what it would be if it was on the near side.

Almost as if it's nearly completely useless for determining where something is or how it's traveling under the circumstances in question, just like we've been saying! Wow!

I'd break out Photoshop, but it wouldn't help.
 
Last edited:
While the RF discussion is somewhat interesting, it is ultimately irrelevant in regards to the thread's subject unless some solid evidence is provided that the Japanese task force did actually transmit during its voyage. No such evidence has been provided. Surely the Japanese records on this point would be the most relevant, and those records indicate the task force sailed under strict radio silence. That leaves proponents of the theory to explain why (a) the Japanese accounts lied about the task force transmitting, and (b) what those transmissions which were made were about—why was a fleet engaged on a risky, secret mission making so many radio transmissions?
 
Last edited:
While the RF discussion is somewhat interesting, it is ultimately irrelevant in regards to the thread's subject unless some solid evidence is provided that the Japanese task force did actually transmit during its voyage. No such evidence has been provided. Surely the Japanese records on this point would be the most relevant, and those records indicate the task force sailed under strict radio silence. That leaves proponents of the theory to explain why (a) the Japanese accounts lied about the task force transmitting, and (b) what those transmissions which were made were about—why was a fleet engaged on a risky, secret missing making so many radio transmissions?

Phil Jacobsen has been saying that since the Grogan story came out, IIRC.
 
After laughing at the rest of the post, I came to this part. First, the information was not forwarded to the fleet in that format, so we can be absolutely certain it was not intended for tactical use.

Second, the Japanese planes has "windows". The pilots saw something similar to the pix below. They didn't need a tic-tac-toe board.

[qimg]http://www.history.navy.mil/photos/images/g100000/g182874.jpg[/qimg]

MacArthur's staff didn't think it was funny. They noted that plotting ships on a grid in the way outlined in the bomb plot messages was classic preparation for an aerial attack. And they were by no means the only ones who recognized this.

The Japanese did not request bomb-plot information about any other port--only about Pearl Harbor. Even the JCC majority grudgingly admitted that the bomb-plot messages requested unique information about Pearl Harbor compared to what the Japanese asked for regarding other ports.

Interested readers might want to compare Gawdzilla's dismissal of the importance of the bomb-plot messages with Edward Beach's analysis of them in Scapegoats: A Defense of Kimmel and Short at Pearl Harbor, pp. 35-37. As some might know, Beach was a recognized, award-winning, and authoritative writer on naval history. And, yes, he was the same Edward Beach who wrote the famous novel Run Silent, Run Deep.
 
While the RF discussion is somewhat interesting, it is ultimately irrelevant in regards to the thread's subject unless some solid evidence is provided that the Japanese task force did actually transmit during its voyage. No such evidence has been provided. Surely the Japanese records on this point would be the most relevant, and those records indicate the task force sailed under strict radio silence. That leaves proponents of the theory to explain why (a) the Japanese accounts lied about the task force transmitting, and (b) what those transmissions which were made were about—why was a fleet engaged on a risky, secret missing making so many radio transmissions?

There's also no solid evidence the HF/DF was even used by Mr. Grogan, unless someone caughs up his annotated work (charts, etc) from the time, including credible evidence it was employed at the time stated (witnesses, for example).
 
By the way, regarding Jacobsen's article on Grogan's DF bearings and signal information, Villa and Wilford respond to it in detail in their lengthy article "Signals intelligence and Pearl Harbor: The State of the Question, Intelligence and National Security, 2006, 21:4, pp. 520-556.

Villa and Wilford introduce their long analysis of the radio-silence claim with the following comment about Jacobsen's scholarship:

"Clearly, Jacobsen is unable to advance the traditionalist position with a high degree of academic credibility because he not only relies upon polemics and innuendo, but also often fails to develop coherent arguments. The authors of the books and articles that Jacobsen chooses to criticize tell us more about Pearl Harbor than Jacobsen seems able to. To better understand the nature of signals intelligence and Pearl Harbor, or rather the concept of warning and decision, we need to examine the critical issues and the relevant evidence in an academic manner."

I think Villa and Wilford soundly refute Jacobsen's defense of the radio-silence story. Get their article and read it for yourselves.

I will be posting much more on Grogan's bearings within the next few days.
 
MacArthur's staff didn't think it was funny. They noted that plotting ships on a grid in the way outlined in the bomb plot messages was classic preparation for an aerial attack. And they were by no means the only ones who recognized this.

The Japanese did not request bomb-plot information about any other port--only about Pearl Harbor. Even the JCC majority grudgingly admitted that the bomb-plot messages requested unique information about Pearl Harbor compared to what the Japanese asked for regarding other ports.

Interested readers might want to compare Gawdzilla's dismissal of the importance of the bomb-plot messages with Edward Beach's analysis of them in Scapegoats: A Defense of Kimmel and Short at Pearl Harbor, pp. 35-37. As some might know, Beach was a recognized, award-winning, and authoritative writer on naval history. And, yes, he was the same Edward Beach who wrote the famous novel Run Silent, Run Deep.

The IJN didn't get the information that would make the bomb plot relevant. They only got numbers, not locations. So this idea that the bomb plot was important is stranger than most of the weird CT ideas.
 
I think Villa and Wilford soundly refute Jacobsen's defense of the radio-silence story. Get their article and read it for yourselves.


Questions for you to answer:

  • Why do Japanese sources state that the task force sailed under strict radio silence?
  • If the task force didn't follow radio silence, then why do Japanese accounts lie about this?
  • If the task force did transmit radio messages, what was the content and purpose of such messages?
  • Why would a task force engaged on a secret, risky mission be required to or otherwise choose to transmit radio messages?
How many times must I pose these same questions before getting some sort of reply?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom