Yes, I know about different ways of doing DF. I didn't assert that all DF equipment was too big to be on a ship. My post was a response to your comment that beam antennas work for tracking radio-tagged game. They do. But the comment showed that you don't understand how radio works, or you would never have brought it up.
Firstly, let me apologise for my earlier sarcastic statement.
I was at work and being tried from all ends.
Secondly, the reason I brought up the animal tracking was to refute the idea that you cannot triangulate using only one transmitter and one receiver.
As far as my understanding of how a radio works, radiowaves travel radially from the source in straight lines, unless reflected by some medium.
So, triangulation is possible at any frequency.
Sure, a hand held HF tracking setup is far from practical.
As far as ship borne HF/DF sets were concerned they used either Adcock, loop, fixed frame or rotating frame antennas which are relatively compact.
I was not asserting that ships used HF yagi antennas, that was your interpretation of my game tracking statement.
When I studied at King Radio in Olathe Kansas, thay had a directional HF yagi antenna on the factory roof so I know the physical size of a HF yagi.
As far as the SS Lurline is concerned, this was a top of the range luxury liner. It is not unreasonable to expect a ship of this calibre to utilise a RDF seeing as they had been in use for some 20 years before the war.
The SS Lurline was christened on 12 July 1932.
The next issue regarding the SS Lurliner is the fact that this ship was not trying to intercept the source of transmission, just noting from which general direction the transmission came from.
Had they been trying to intercept they would have kept altering course to intercept and refining their heading with further triangulation.
It is gross speculation for Grogan to determine the source to have been the Japanese fleet. The source could have been a decoy or land based transmissions. ( I thought I made this clear in an earlier post).
So, whatever argument is used to refute this conspiracy theory, the intricacies of HF/DF is not going to cut the mustard.
