Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

I fully agree TA is not really valid for longterm price predictions in these sham markets, but at approaching one year in now of amateur trading I am 100% confident that TA is valid enough for short term trading usage that you can consistently make money from it, to the point that I am aiming to turn part-time pro in 2013.

I tip my hat to you, it's not something I'd dare do.

Good luck.
 
Penultimate bump of the year.....

Silver spot is currently under $32 which means that while there have been significant swings over the course of the year (a low of $26 and a high of $37), it still hasn't returned to the value that prompted this thread to be started in the first place 20 months ago and hasn't yet fulfilled the most optimistic predictions of silver enthusiasts.

To be fair we never got the conditions that would trigger the price spiral that Turk was predicting (closing above $37.50).

On the other hand Kevsta has made a handsome return even with silver not flying away into the stratosphere. His TA methods clearly work. Kevsta, I wish you the best for next year when you go (part-time) pro.


...at least we've not had the hyperinflation so confidently predicted in the OP. Sadly michaelsuede seems to have left the building so there's no chance to berate him for his apocalyptic views.
 
Oooh, I just found another Turk prediction here from back in August 2012:

http://etfdailynews.com/2012/09/04/...coming-to-silver-prices-slv-gld-pslv-agq-zsl/

The latest prediction for a moonshot in the silver market comes from Goldmoney Founder James Turk, who foresees, not only a massive short squeeze coming, but also surmises, at least, momentum also popping the top off the price of the poor-man’s monetary metal.

“I expect to see $68-$70 in 2-to-3 months,” Turk tells King World News (KWN), Monday.

Oops, looks like he didn't get that one right.
 
...at least we've not had the hyperinflation so confidently predicted in the OP. Sadly michaelsuede seems to have left the building so there's no chance to berate him for his apocalyptic views.

I'm sure the predictions were allright, it's reality that is at fault. Manipulation, Goldman Sachs, the Fed, you name it. Or quite possibly, we're in hyperinflation but we just refuse to see it.
 
Kevsta...His TA methods clearly work.


Sometimes.

Curious as to his total return, all in for the year after transaction costs and taxes.

Kevsta, I wish you the best for next year when you go (part-time) pro.

Me, too.

But to paraphrase "A League Of Their Own", "Trading commodities and making money at it is hard. That's the point. If it was easy, then anyone could do it!"

I still question whether one can, in principle, beat the market via any (legal) scheme - still waiting to have it demonstrated by someone honestly and consistently over time.
 
Last edited:
Oooh, I just found another Turk prediction here from back in August 2012:

http://etfdailynews.com/2012/09/04/...coming-to-silver-prices-slv-gld-pslv-agq-zsl/



Oops, looks like he didn't get that one right.

There was always a chance he'd be right.

In that case, we have to be very careful not to be...

fooled-by-randomness.gif


Can anyone look at the price of silver over the course of this thread and NOT see randomness? But we're pattern-seeking animals, so its predictable that some will seek to retro-fit patterns to what is, most likely, a random walk.

Still a fool's game to use any of this stuff to make meaningful predictions about the future.
 
Sometimes.

Curious as to his total return, all in for the year after transaction costs and taxes.

Well it must be considerable because I can't recall him posting about a loss so I can only assume that every single investment has yielded a profit. ;)
 
Well it must be considerable because I can't recall him posting about a loss so I can only assume that every single investment has yielded a profit. ;)

Correct. But the Rothschild's will find a way to steal most of it back.
 
Well it must be considerable because I can't recall him posting about a loss so I can only assume that every single investment has yielded a profit. ;)

hola amigos. lo siento no showup much, very busy with my real job, as well as my next one we are discussing here.

No, it has to be said, in my first year of trading I am not a millionaire yet, and I have made every mistake it is possible to make. However in the last 10 weeks or so I do believe I have turned it around and have been consistently profitable after I stopped doing all the other stupid stuff along the way too and giving it all back again, and more sometimes.

You do need to get whooped a few times at the start to learn enough respect for the market, and I think I have gotten that out of the way now :boxedin:

so next year's part time project is to take a small account, and grow it into a big enough account to trade for a living with. the risk /reward and strategy I'm trading now regularly makes 4% of the account size in a trade for a 1% potential loss per trade, and you can get 3-5 good setups per week on average, (way more sometimes, if I had the capital to risk multiple trades at once) so it should (and has been) compounding fairly fast, as slightly larger account means slightly larger trades (fixed 1% risk)

The reality check (I thought I ought to impose one on myself in the structure of this, rather than blow my savings lol) is that if I can't hit the first target of growing the account enough, then obviously part (b) cannot follow. we shall see.

thanks for your good wishes, and yes I was clearly very wrong on my longterm metals price predictions this year, and in hindsight this negatively affected my trading to start with, much more than it should have.
 
Correct. But the Rothschild's will find a way to steal most of it back.

haha you could ultimately turn out to be nearer to the mark than you think.

And for the record I have nothing against the Rothschilds, and only curiosity about all the things we'll never know.
 
I give you all the props in the world, kevsta, for being capable and willing to aknowledge a mistake and then adjust fire as necessary.

Seriously, that's not seen nearly enough these days. Kudos is yours. :D

#EDIT: You make me want to fool around with my Forex practice account some more.
 
I give you all the props in the world, kevsta, for being capable and willing to aknowledge a mistake and then adjust fire as necessary.

Seriously, that's not seen nearly enough these days. Kudos is yours. :D

#EDIT: You make me want to fool around with my Forex practice account some more.

I tell you what, my xmas gift to you, before you do, go spend a few weeks reading this site and watching their videos. track their daily market reviews and what happens the next day. talk about "aha" moment.

you can rest assured that I have thoroughly pre-screened the entire internet forex training inventory, and suggested to you only the very best.

this video is a good introduction, because knowing the probability of the main trend direction before you start turns out to be somewhat of an edge, and once you know what to look for it is often ridiculously simple.



and actually guys, truth be told, although of course there are charts involved, their method is not actually TA, and they are very specific about why TA in the standard sense cannot and will not work for the 99% of forex traders.
 
I used the site at babypips.com. They had a really good training system in place, and I've been through it twice, though I go back now and then to double check something. I'll check your site out as well, when I'm home from the office.

#EDIT: Usually what I'll do is first look at how the trends are going month-to-month, then check the daily trend, and then go down to the ten minute mark (the time scales I prefer to trade in). Then I'll try to keep up with financial news in order to identify which way things are going to go. When I hop on and things are going in the right direction, I'll put a trailing stop on the order, but before then I'll put a stop loss on just in case I was really wrong.
 
Last edited:
I used the site at babypips.com. They had a really good training system in place, and I've been through it twice, though I go back now and then to double check something. I'll check your site out as well, when I'm home from the office.

#EDIT: Usually what I'll do is first look at how the trends are going month-to-month, then check the daily trend, and then go down to the ten minute mark (the time scales I prefer to trade in). Then I'll try to keep up with financial news in order to identify which way things are going to go. When I hop on and things are going in the right direction, I'll put a trailing stop on the order, but before then I'll put a stop loss on just in case I was really wrong.


ok good, well the more you know, and the more price action you've seen, the bigger the aha moment will be.

and re financial news, my only other tip to you would be turn it all off, and watch the charts alone. this comes back to me trading gold with an innate bias to thinking it should be going up in general. answer, trade something you know nothing about, by the information in front of you alone. this has been a big part of my learning curve.

have fun, let me know how you get on. maybe we should start a forex TA thread so we dont derail the silver topic though :D
 
Actually, that sounds pretty good. So how about this? We open a new forex thread, and I'll make a new forex practice account, since it seems my last one "timed out". And we'll just post in there once in a while with updates on how we're doing and what strategies we're doing.

#EDIT: If you do decide to start a forex thread, please PM me the link. I tend to lurk the main page, and if the article isn't recently edited when I check, I may miss it!
 
Last edited:
Actually, that sounds pretty good. So how about this? We open a new forex thread, and I'll make a new forex practice account, since it seems my last one "timed out". And we'll just post in there once in a while with updates on how we're doing and what strategies we're doing.

#EDIT: If you do decide to start a forex thread, please PM me the link. I tend to lurk the main page, and if the article isn't recently edited when I check, I may miss it!

thing is, its not really skeptic material is it? we'd probably be better off on a forex forum really
 
...and once you know what to look for it is often ridiculously simple.

Leading into a thought experiment...

Let's say predicting a given market is, in fact, ridiculously simple. So simple that a single algorithm or program or method or scheme allows you to trade in a manner where net profit is virtually assured.

It's SO ridiculously simple and obvious that literally everyone starts using it. And literally everyone makes money at it.

If you can sense there's something wrong somewhere in the above thought experiment, you'll start to get a hint as to why I believe any such strategy is ultimately doomed.

More to follow...
 
Last edited:
Leading into a thought experiment...

Let's say predicting a given market is, in fact, ridiculously simple. So simple that a single algorithm or program or method or scheme allows you to trade in a manner where net profit is virtually assured.

It's SO ridiculously simple and obvious that literally everyone starts using it. And literally everyone makes money at it.

If you can sense there's something wrong somewhere in the above thought experiment, you'll start to get a hint as to why I believe any such strategy is ultimately doomed.

More to follow...

I completely agree, however if the strategy is that of the main players - you can call them *smart money*, who have to trade the way they do, because of the size of their trading positions, (50% of volume in a $4 trillion daily market) to induce the 95% permanently losing retail traders to trade with (against) them, then identifying their strategy and tagging along rather than trading against them like they want you to, might have some legs?

edit. and anyway, even shown what to do and told which way its going, many traders still consistently lose when others win, not everybody is going to be able to pull it off, certainly not.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom