WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

So lets knock another claim down.

For general surface analysis in the SEM, dust samples were mounted to carbon conductive tabs. The samples were left unwashed and uncoated unless otherwise specified. In order to more closely observe the characteristics of the red and gray layers, and to eliminate the possibility of surface contamination from other dust particles, several red/gray chips from each of the four WTC dust samples were fractured.
The clean, cross-section surfaces were then studied by
BSE imaging and XEDS.
Page 9 from Harrit et al.

and

Prior to soaking the chip in MEK an XEDS spectrum was acquired from an area of the red-layer surface. The resulting spectrum, shown in Fig. (14), produced the expected peaks for Fe, Si, Al, O, and C. Other peaks included calcium, sulfur, zinc, chromium and potassium. The occurrence of these elements could be attributed to surface contamination due to the fact that the analysis was performed on the as-collected surface of the red layer. The large Ca and S peaks may be
due to contamination with gypsum from the pulverized wallboard
material in the buildings.
So they don't break the chip in half and perform EDX on the fresh red surface.

In the Harrit et al paper Fig 14 says

picture.php


again re-iterating that they think contamination is present.

Truthers have been arguing that the chip soaked in MEK was contaminated and that's the reason why it has a different EDX spectrum for the red layer than samples a-d.

So lets read Millette.

Methods

In order to confirm that the samples chosen had the characteristics of WTC dust, the samples were examined by stereomicroscope and by polarized light microscopy (PLM) according to the procedures described in Turner et al., 20054 (Figures 2 and 3). The analytical procedures used to characterize the red/gray chips were based on the criteria for the particles of interest in accordance with the recommended guidelines for forensic identification of explosives5 and the ASTM standard guide for forensic paint analysis and comparison.6 The criteria for the particles of interest as described by Harrit et al.1 are: small red/gray chips attracted by a magnet and showing an elemental composition primarily of aluminum, silicon and iron as determined by scanning electron microscopy and x-ray energy dispersive spectroscopy (SEM-EDS) (Figure 4). The spectrum may also contain small peaks related to other elements. To that end, the following protocol was performed on each of the four WTC dust samples.

1. The dust sample particles contained in a plastic bag were drawn across a magnet and those attracted to the magnet were collected (Figure 5).


2. Using a stereomicroscope, particle chips showing the characteristic red/gray were removed and washed in clean water.
3. The particles were dried and mounted on a carbon adhesive film on an SEM stub and photographed (Figure 6).

4. Analysis of the surfaces of the chips was done by SEM-EDS at 20 kV without any added conductive coating (Figures 7 and 8).

So there we have it - Millette washed all of his red/gray chips that he separated using the same method as Harrit et al. Therefore, the chips would be free from contamination when EDX of the red layer is performed. Therefore, if contaminants have been removed then we would not expect to see any EDX spectra of the red layers matching Fig 14 in Harrit et al because the Ca and S would be washed away. We would also have spectra that would more readily match samples a-d rather than Fig 14.

So lets have a look at some of Millette's red layer EDX spectra and see if any match Fig 14 in Harrit et al.

picture.php


Yep, loads do and that's just the ones that have Zn in the spectrum. N.B. Many of Millette's samples show Na and sometimes Na and Zn for the same peak. This is the EDX programme labelling these peaks. They will be Zn in reality.

So there you have it - they same separation method used, chips cleaned, but the same spectrum comes up time and time again that matches Fig 14. We can therefore conclude that Fig 14 is not contaminated to any significance.

That therefore means that Fig 14 material is not the same as a-d yet Harrit, Jones and the truthers maintain that it's the same material and it's thermite. This is impossible.

I won't wait for MM to comment. lol.
 
"Here, I can agree with you. Millette can do this simple experiment. Only I doubt that he can really explain expected microspheres in the "ash" in detail (which processes exactly took place), but I can be wrong:cool: This is just my opinion.
Just a question (to be sure): do you believe that chips would do exactly the same things when heated in DSC device and in ordinary oven, respectively (considering the same/very similar heating rate)?"
"With the DSC, the scientists reported using a "rising temperature method of ignition", but they also tested with flame-ignition."
"And heating to 3000°C+ is indeed the ultimate proof that a thermite reaction was started at 430°C. :rolleyes:"

I mentioned the flame test in response to Ivan Kminek's query about whether another method of heating heating ("ordinary oven") would produce similar results.

In that test, the scientists applied a small small oxyacetylene flame for a few seconds before obtaining the expected reaction which produced debris containing melted iron-rich semi-spherical shapes. But they acknowledge that more definitive results were obtained by the DSC because it accurately revealed a temperature around 430C at which ignition consistently occurred producing iron-rich microspheres and iron-rich semi-spherical shapes in the resulting debris.

MM
 
Dr. Ferrer said:
"After igniting these chips in the DSC, we found micro-spheres that were very shiny in appearance. Some of them were almost glassy, a little translucent and we found that these micro-spheres had the identical or very similar composition as the spheres that Steve [Dr. Jones] was finding in the dust samples. They were also very similar to spheres found in commercial thermite. Once you ignite commercial thermite you also get micro-spheres and the composition was very very similar. And that lead to the conclusion of the paper which was, we've got some form of thermite in these red/gray chips. And I think it is a very strong conclusion."

Look for yourself.

fig24andfig25r1.png



The top XEDS spectrum (Fig. (24) is for ignited commercial thermite.
The bottom XEDS spectrum (Fig. (25) is for an ignited red/gray chip.

MM
 
As quoted by Sunstealer;

Harrit et al said:
"…to eliminate the possibility of surface contamination from other dust particles, several red/gray chips from each of the four WTC dust samples were fractured. The clean, cross-section surfaces were then studied by BSE imaging and XEDS."

The actual quote in its full context;

Harrit et al said:
"For general surface analysis in the SEM, dust samples were mounted to carbon conductive tabs. The samples were left unwashed and uncoated unless otherwise specified. In order to more closely observe the characteristics of the red and gray layers, and to eliminate the possibility of surface contamination from other dust particles, several red/graychips from each of the four WTC dust samples were fractured. The clean, cross-section surfaces were then studied byBSE imaging and XEDS."
"…So there we have it - Millette washed all of his red/gray chips that he separated using the same method as Harrit et al. Therefore, the chips would be free from contamination when EDX of the red layer is performed. Therefore, if contaminants have been removed then we would not expect to see any EDX spectra of the red layers matching Fig 14 in Harrit et al because the Ca and S would be washed away. We would also have spectra that would more readily match samples a-d rather than Fig 14."
bolding is mine

So there you have what?

I see a deliberate attempt to misrepresent the truth.

Interesting how you deliberately left out the part about Dr. Harrit et al, NOT washing the chips?

And you believe that because Dr. Millette's chips were; "washed in clean water", that they were now free from surface contamination?

Only the physical removal of the surface layer (as performed by Dr. Harrit et al) could be expected to remove most of the embedded surface contaminants.

MM
 
MM - go back and read my post because your reading comprehension as usual is poor. In post http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8928923&postcount=1402

I clearly quote Harrit et al on page 9.

For general surface analysis in the SEM, dust samples were mounted to carbon conductive tabs. The samples were left unwashed and uncoated unless otherwise specified. In order to more closely observe the characteristics of the red and gray layers, and to eliminate the possibility of surface contamination from other dust particles, several red/gray chips from each of the four WTC dust samples were fractured.
The clean, cross-section surfaces were then studied by BSE imaging and XEDS.
So why are you trying to divert the thread? I'll ask the mods to remove your post because it adds nothing. And yes washing in water will remove the surface contaminant - if you had worked in a metallurgical or forensic lab you'd know this was the case.

You are doing your usual tactics of trying to nit pick rather than address the point which is that Millette and Harrit had the same paint samples which I have proven by analysis of the data in both papers. Everyone can see that you will do everything in your power to never address the argument.
 
Last edited:
Look for yourself.

[qimg]http://img600.imageshack.us/img600/5075/fig24andfig25r1.png[/qimg]


The top XEDS spectrum (Fig. (24) is for ignited commercial thermite.
The bottom XEDS spectrum (Fig. (25) is for an ignited red/gray chip.

MM
What are we supposed to be looking at? These two are not the same. :confused:
 
Please someone correct me if I am wrong.

What MM is now kinda claiming, the reason Millete did not find thermite is because he washed the chips ?

Well in my reckoning, that is saying the chips are not thermite and it was a residue on the chips :D
 
Sunstealer: The data before MEK soaking is an EDX spectrum of the red layer. The data after soaking is an EDX mapping of the sample for individual elements. These are chalk and cheese and cannot be considered the same thing.

I don´t agree about chalk and cheese. Both maps show which elements go together, but the paper does not show spectra of clean surface of that chip before MEK and that is a weakness because it is harder to make sure it is the same as the other chips.

What Harrit et al are observing in their MEK test is the migration of aluminates in the sample. This has been discussed in some depth before.
That's a tell tale sign for an aluminosilicate in this case kaolin. Laclade paint contains kaolin but Tnemec red doesn't. When we look at the MEK chip red layer EDX we don't see this characteristic, the Si peak is higher.

Your charts say both paints have aluminates, but are they not the same? Why do you say only LaClede has kaolin? Can one or both aluminates separate with MEK and leave al?


We know Millette has Tnemec and most likely Laclade

You do not seem sure about the LaClede, why? Millette does not seem to agree with you about Tnemec:

According to the MSDS currently listed on the Tnemec website,17 55 out of the 177 different Tnemec coating products contain one or two of the three major components in the red layer: epoxy resin, iron oxide and/or kaolin (aluminum silicate) pigments. However, none of the 177 different coatings are a match for the red layer coating found in this study.

This seems like a definite weakness, no positive id. How many paints were used and why the focus on these two brands?

Yep, loads do and that's just the ones that have Zn in the spectrum. N.B. Many of Millette's samples show Na and sometimes Na and Zn for the same peak. This is the EDX programme labelling these peaks. They will be Zn in reality.

So there you have it - they same separation method used, chips cleaned, but the same spectrum comes up time and time again that matches Fig 14. We can therefore conclude that Fig 14 is not contaminated to any significance.

There are some major flaws here. You use washed Millette chips to show similarity to one Harrit chip that is supposed to be contaminated, this is not a very strong argument. If the Zn in fig 14 in not contamination why does it disappear after MEK? Fig 16, 17, 18, no Zn, so again not a very strong argument. No Zn no Tnemec?
 
Africanus: This doesn't contradict Millette's results. Millette's Chip remained hard, too as neither the kaolin nor the epoxy was dissolved

What? There is definitely a contradiction because Millette notes his chips soften. Harrit says his chips remain hard but the compared paint samples soften.
 
What? There is definitely a contradiction because Millette notes his chips soften. Harrit says his chips remain hard but the compared paint samples soften.

Please can you quote your reference to chips staying hard.
 
pgimeno: You are applying different standards to compare. The shapes of several of the pictures I posted are essentially the same: a large peak after a slower increment. You should be aware by now that the expected total energy release of thermite is much less than that observed in the DSC traces of the chips, therefore what the DSC trace shows can not materially be thermite. It is a physical impossibility. On what basis do you dare to compare the DSC traces if it is self-evident they do not show the same material burning to start with? What significance does it have that the width matches, if the height, the shape, the peak temperature and the endothermic areas don't?

You can´t call your peak "large" without having the same Y-axis, as it might as well be a tiny blimp that would hardly register on the Harrit graph. The point of the comparison seems quite clear also, to show that Harrit chips have similarly narrow peak as known superthermite and I think everyone agrees that no one has actually compared paint. Maybe this DSC method to compare is not very accurate so this seems like an easy chance for Millette to debunk Harrit.

The other factors are probably not important, because there are so many variations of superthermite with different compositions and then you have the additional organic elements to consider. The ignition temperatures, total output and endothermic peaks should vary accordingly. But maybe it is possible to find faults with some of those factors with careful research. Another possibility for Millette.

But they fell short of doing this, therefore they didn't really show that a thermite reaction occurred

They do show molten iron and they do compare directly to known thermite residue. This kind of nit pick seems weak without Millette ignition results.

On what basis do you dare to compare

Really?
 
Spanx: Please can you quote your reference to chips staying hard.

Already quoted Harrit yesterday, in this post.

Thats Harrit page 27

It would also be helpful if you all would give me links to truther arguments against your points, especially technical stuff.
 
I don´t agree about chalk and cheese. Both maps show which elements go together, but the paper does not show spectra of clean surface of that chip before MEK and that is a weakness because it is harder to make sure it is the same as the other chips.
That's the point. A map taking in the entire area of the chip is not the same as a spot. Methinks you need to look up information on what a SEM is, it's operation and the additional tools that accompany the machine.

It isn't the same as the other chips period. There is no way it can be. Resolution of the SEM will easily pick out particles of contaminant so you'd never select an area or spot with contamination in to perform EDX (unless you were specifically interested in the contaminant particle). Basic stuff there.

Remember that there are people on this forum who have worked with SEM and other scientific tools. JREF forum member "The Animus" has extensive experience and has commented numerous times.

If you go to the origin of paint thread you'll see he even produces a EDX spectrum of what Laclade paint should look like using standard industry software based on the composition in the given specification. They match very well.


Your charts say both paints have aluminates, but are they not the same?
No they don't. Don't know how you are getting that info. Aluminosilicate is not an aluminate.

Why do you say only LaClede has kaolin?
Because the specification for Tnemec red does not contain kaolin or any other aluminosilicate. Laclade doesn't contain any aluminates.

Can one or both aluminates separate with MEK and leave al?
It's possible that particles of aluminate will separate from other particles due to density differences. They aren't picking up pure Al but Al from an aluminate - the O in the spectrum gives it away. Again there has also been debate regarding a false positive for Al due to the SEM stub being made of Aluminium and most of the Al is seen near the sample edge.


You do not seem sure about the LaClede, why? :
I'm perfectly sure it's Laclade and I'd bet everything I own on it. I was right about kaolin being present days after the pape was released - Millette confirms this. I was right about the rhombohedral Fe2O3 before Harrit et al even though I used the data in their paper - they needed TEM to confirm it. I was right about the matrix being epoxy days after the paper came out and Millette confirms this. I was right about the gray layer being oxidised steel before Harrit et al knew what it was, even though I was using the same data as them, Millette confirms this.

I've been right all along, why would I not be sure about Laclade? The only reason I don't say it is, is because I'm 99.5% sure it's Laclade, but data from Millette cannot confirm this 100%. However, if you look at the Laclade paint specification we observe all the components bar Strontium Chromate.


Millette does not seem to agree with you about Tnemec:
How could he?

Thought experiment.

In front of you is a bowl of fruit containing Apples, pears, oranges and bananas.

Pick out all the apples and put them in another bowl. Throw the other bowl away. Now examine the apples in detail. Are they apples? Now answer this - do you have any bananas?

If you can reason that out then you will know why Millette will rule out Tnemec.

Millette had a criteria, a specification to stick to. He had to separate chips by magnet. He had to then look at all the chips through a microscope and remove only red chips. He then had to look at the EDX for each red layer and discard all the red chips that didn't match EDX spectra from samples a-d in Harrit et al. He then analysed these chips further.

This is very simple to understand why the samples he further analysed were not Tnemec.

If Millette had been given the criteria to match EDX spectra to Fig 14 instead then he wouldn't find any Laclade. Guess what he would find? Yep, Tnemec. He can only comment on what he has analysed that match the criteria. Tnemec didn't match the criteria. That's why I have used Fig 14 as the criteria and matched half a dozen EDX spectra from Millette's chips that match.

Harrit et al separated both Laclade and Tnemec. So did Millette. That's not surprising because they both used the same method!


This seems like a definite weakness, no positive id.
You sound like a truther. Remember the apples above? Does it matter whether the apples are granny smiths or golden delicious or cooking apples? No, they are all apples and not pears.

Same with the paint, doesn't matter whether you can find a perfect match or not, even though we have got an exceptionally good match to two known paints that were used on the WTCs, what matters is the samples are paint and not thermite. The data says the chips are paint adhered to oxidised steel.

Focus on what Millette says when he concludes it's paint. Paint, paint, paint. He doesn't say anything else. If he concludes it's paint then why is there any weakness? It's paint, get over it.



How many paints were used and why the focus on these two brands?
No one knows how many paints were used. We don't focus on any brands. What we have done is come to the conclusions that the data points us to.

We know of only two paints used in the WTC from the NIST report. They are Laclade and Tnemec red. Why would we focus on Duluxe egg shell blue gloss when the data points us in the direction of the two paints known to have been used?

There are some major flaws here. You use washed Millette chips to show similarity to one Harrit chip that is supposed to be contaminated, this is not a very strong argument.
No, there are no major flaws at all.

The point is that truthers claim the MEK chip is contaminated. I have shown that some of Millette's chips are exactly the same material as this MEK chip even after they have been washed. This means that there is no contamination on the MEK chip and therefore it is significantly different from chips a-d. a-d = Laclade. MEK chip = Tnemec.


If the Zn in fig 14 in not contamination why does it disappear after MEK? Fig 16, 17, 18, no Zn, so again not a very strong argument. No Zn no Tnemec?
Oh, the Zn is there. Definitely there in Fig 18. You can't see it because you don't know what you are looking at. I can see it and I suspect that Oystein will too as will anyone else who's educated themselves in SEM EDX. You see this is where amateurs just get completely stuck because they don't have the specialist knowledge. Can you work out why it's there but you can't see it?

Just because there is a label on a peak it doesn't mean that the peak is labelled correctly. ;)

The peak at 1KeV is labelled as Na. This is wrong. It should be Zn. In fact most EDX packages will label this peak both Na and Zn, because these two elements k-alpha and k-beta lines fall in the same place namely at 1 KeV and the software cannot separate them. You can see this on Millette's EDX spectra.

This is a handy site for comparing x-ray energies for SEM EDX http://csrri.iit.edu/periodic-table.html)


 
The initial objective was to compare the behav- ior of the red layer with paint when soaked in a strong or- ganic solvent known to soften and dissolve paint. Red/gray chips were soaked in methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) for 55 hours with frequent agitation and subsequently dried in air over several days. The chips showed significant swelling of the red layer, but with no apparent dissolution. In marked contrast, paint chips softened and partly dissolved when similarly soaked in MEK. It was discovered in this process that a significant migration and segregation of aluminum had occurred in the red-chip material. This allowed us to assess whether some of the aluminum was in elemental form.

To clarify, you are talking about the 10 hour MEK soak test and not the 55 hr soak?
 
Last edited:
... They do show molten iron and they do compare directly to known thermite residue. This kind of nit pick seems weak without Millette ignition results.

Really?
The old iron sphere scam? Did you fall for that one?

Melted iron? Where? The stuff they had was never hot enough to melt iron. Iron spheres are not proof of thermite, they are proof Harrit and Jones lie about things.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jZ9wSD4Hcys

Millette found no thermite, Harrit and Jones make up delusions about 911.
What is a delusion, thinking Harrit's paper is a factor on 911. There was no thermite evidence on any WTC steel. Makes the paper a lie when you understand Harrit claims tons of thermite was used to destroy the WTC. Is Harrit a liar? Don't need Millette paper to understand there was not thermite.
 
Sunstealer: It's possible that particles of aluminate will separate from other particles due to density differences. They aren't picking up pure Al but Al from an aluminate - the O in the spectrum gives it away. Again there has also been debate regarding a false positive for Al due to the SEM stub being made of Aluminium and most of the Al is seen near the sample edge.

So this could perhaps explain the MEK chip but I don´t think the part about the "o in the spectrum" is right. Harrit says there is always some al oxidized along with pure al in superthermite and that they calculated the ratios to show there must be some pure al. Could the MEK somehow purify some of the al?

I remember the debate about the aluminum stub but I also remember getting a beating for it because the authors rule it out. There was some debate somewhere where Harrit argues with some other scientist who brought it up, can´t remember the name right now.

I am pretty sure there is some pure al in there but why is that a big deal? Could you really not find it in paint?

No, there are no major flaws at all.

Common, you can´t use washed Millette chips to compare to the Harrit dirty chip before MEK. You have to compare clean Harrit chip to clean Millette chip.
And the argument falls apart when the signals start disappearing after MEK. Your statement is not true:
there is no contamination on the MEK chip

Oh, the Zn is there. Definitely there in Fig 18. You can't see it because you don't know what you are looking at. I can see it and I suspect that Oystein will too as will anyone else who's educated themselves in SEM EDX. You see this is where amateurs just get completely stuck because they don't have the specialist knowledge. Can you work out why it's there but you can't see it?

You are way to sure about yourself. You compared dirty chip fig14 to some Millette chip and also known Tnemec chip from Jones. To begin there is an obvious problem because the Tnemec chip has much bigger Zn peak than fig14 and Millette chip, so that alone casts doubt on Zn in chip = Tnemec.
But the real problem starts when the Zn starts to disappear after MEK. You may think you can see some Zn traces there but it is obvious that there is no longer as much Zn there. This seems a lot more consistent with the Zn being surface contamination than it being part of the chip. But the real point is that if you think those figures show same level of Zn before and after MEK, you should publish or give the info to Millette and let him do it.

jtl: Millette does not seem to agree with you about Tnemec:
Sunstealer: How could he?

You sometimes appear as someone very scientifically minded but other times you just make authoritative statements. Tone it down a bit. You should not claim to know for sure that Milletta has Tnemec when he rules it out it seems.

No one knows how many paints were used. We don't focus on any brands. What we have done is come to the conclusions that the data points us to.

We know of only two paints used in the WTC from the NIST report. They are Laclade and Tnemec red.

These are very conflictive statements and not at all in line with Millette and Harrit who both focus on Tnemec.
 
What? There is definitely a contradiction because Millette notes his chips soften. Harrit says his chips remain hard but the compared paint samples soften.

1. No, Harrit doesn't say that his chips remained hard. Futhermore I'd like to know how aluminum should be set free from the platelets, if you are not able to remove the organic matrix. Harrit's result contradicts his claim of the successful separation and migration of aluminum.

2. The paint sample is not specified in the paper, so the comparison is just nonsense.

3. You are focussing on one side effect instead of the important thing: Neither Harrit nor Millette were able to remove the organic matrix.

I don´t agree about chalk and cheese. Both maps show which elements go together, but the paper does not show spectra of clean surface of that chip before MEK and that is a weakness because it is harder to make sure it is the same as the other chips.

As I stated before, the two maps in Harrit's paper show chips from different samples.

Your charts say both paints have aluminates, but are they not the same? Why do you say only LaClede has kaolin? Can one or both aluminates separate with MEK and leave al?

Sunstealer says this, because he knows the composition of the Tnemec and the LaClede primer. If you want to know them, take a look in the NIST report:

Tnemec Primer: NCSTAR1-3C, Table D1, p. 438

LaClede Primer: NCSTAR1-6B, Appendix B

There are some major flaws here. You use washed Millette chips to show similarity to one Harrit chip that is supposed to be contaminated, this is not a very strong argument. If the Zn in fig 14 in not contamination why does it disappear after MEK? Fig 16, 17, 18, no Zn, so again not a very strong argument. No Zn no Tnemec?

Sorry, but what source tells you that the Zinc disappeared ofter soaking in MEK?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom