Merged Pearl Harbor: "Revisionists" vs. "Traditionalists"

There was only one warmonger back then and he was a Charlie Chaplin lookalike.

Lets not forget Mr. Mussolini when labelling warmongers nor the Japanese military clique...and considering Stalins actions in 39 and 40 him too

On December 6th 1941 who had invaded other countries in the last ten years?

US - none
Germany - Poland, Denmark, Netherlands, Luxembourg, France, Belgium, Yugoslavia and Greece, assisted Franco in Spain
Italy - France, Yugoslavia, Albania, Greece and Egypt (under British protection) and of course Ethiopia, assisted Franco in Spain
Japan - China, and had taken over the French colonies
Soviet - Poland, Baltic states, Finland

I probably forgot a country or two
 
Last edited:
They didn't pass the details along for a while, but "Tora, tora, tora" was relayed immediately. They didn't want to make too long a transmission because it would give the US more time to locate them. We still got a bearing of 357 degrees from aircraft calling back to the carriers with reports, but the reciprocal of 177 was considered more likely given the suspected IJN carrier group south of T. H.


It's a damn good thing they told Halsey 177 instead of 357.
 
Lets not forget Mr. Mussolini when labelling warmongers nor the Japanese military clique...and considering Stalins actions in 39 and 40 him too

On December 6th 1941 who had invaded other countries in the last ten years?

US - none
Germany - Poland, Denmark, Netherlands, Luxembourg, France, Belgium, Yugoslavia and Greece, assisted Franco in Spain
Italy - France, Yugoslavia, Albania, Greece and Egypt (under British protection) and of course Ethiopia, assisted Franco in Spain
Japan - China, and had taken over the French colonies
Soviet - Poland, Baltic states, Finland

I probably forgot a country or two

Japan invaded Thailand on Dec. 8th, 1941, Tokyo time.
 
Just a bit over the time period and I remember now the one I forgot, Czechoslovakia - I've give a pass on Austria
 
I've read all the posts in this thread but have not seen anyone claim whether the Kido Butai did or did not transmit. :duck:

But seriously...

It was proved earlier in this thread that with a single receiver and a single transmitter, both moving relatively slowly, you could possibly get direction but definitely not a distance. BTF has not brought this crap up lately even though he never admitted that he was wrong.

Can we assume that since he hasn't mentioned this after his last few fringe resets that he finally got the point?

No.

So Gallop is the new Oracle. Thanks for explaining that. Over 60% of the public wanted war with Germany.
And I thought this was a skeptic’s forum.

Appeal to Incredulity, Appeal to Ridicule.
 
To correct MaGZ's little bit of misdirection I'd like to point that that over 60% of the US public knew we'd have to fight Germany sooner or later, but that ~83% of the US citizens polled said they'd rather not have to fight at all if possible. Very sensible, rational people don't want to get into war. (And the Nasties started the war, which proves something as well.)
 
It was proved earlier in this thread that with a single receiver and a single transmitter, both moving relatively slowly, you could possibly get direction but definitely not a distance.


I would say it was disproved in this situation when compared to what Grogan claimed and the fact his supporters did not use the proper chart projection when discussing the bearings. You always get direction, e.g. a bearing when DFing. The greater the difference in bearings received the better the accuracy of the estimated distance but that will only happen when the tracking ship is traveling much faster than the target ship and they are a lot closer than half the Pacific Ocean apart.


BTF has not brought this crap up lately even though he never admitted that he was wrong.


He dismissed Jacobsen's critique simply by claiming "northwest by west" is the same as "northwest", despite being shown pictures of compass roses that clearly show "northwest by west" as a distinct compass bearing.

Can we assume that since he hasn't mentioned this after his last few fringe resets that he finally got the point?


Never assume a CT gets the point.
 
It was proved earlier in this thread that with a single receiver and a single transmitter, both moving relatively slowly, you could possibly get direction but definitely not a distance.

I would say it was disproved in this situation when compared to what Grogan claimed and the fact his supporters did not use the proper chart projection when discussing the bearings. You always get direction, e.g. a bearing when DFing. The greater the difference in bearings received the better the accuracy of the estimated distance but that will only happen when the tracking ship is traveling much faster than the target ship and they are a lot closer than half the Pacific Ocean apart.


If the transmitter is stationary and the DF receiver is moving, you can get distance and direction, because by DFing from two locations, you are effectively triangulating. The further apart the DF readings are taken from, the more accurately you can determine the transmitter's position.

If the transmitter is moving, and you don't know how fast or in what direction, it is not possible to to determine either distance or direction.

If the tranmitter is moving, and you have a reasonable idea of how fast and in what direction, you can still roughly determine distance and direction.

Also, the frequency and time of day could be important. Assuming that we are dealing with HF DF, a very rough estimate can be made (close or far away) if you can determine the incident angle of the received transmission to determine whether what you are receiving is a ground wave, an ionospheric "E layer" propagated sky wave or an F1/F2 layer ionospheric propagated sky wave. An expert radio operator can tell you the difference between them and can even estimate how many "hops" an ionospheric sky wave has taken. A ground wave would put the transmitter closer.


Of course, there actually has to be a transmission in the first place, and it is clear that any such transmission was very unlikely to have been made.
 
If the transmitter is moving, and you don't know how fast or in what direction, it is not possible to to determine either distance or direction.


I need to expand on this one sentence even though for all practical real-world scenarios it is correct. Except for ambiguous cases (transmitting and tracking vessel on apparent parallel courses and at the same apparent speed) it is possible to determine the target 's course, speed, and distance if you have extremely accurate bearings, like within 0.1°, and environmental conditions are unrealistically favorable (ocean current, wind and waves are negligible or exactly the same for both vessels). For every large pattern of bearings plotted from the tracking ship there is one unique solution to the target's course, speed, and distance. That said, no mariner experienced in tracking ships would put much stock in this method. The most accurate bearings are obtained visually, i.e. you can see the guy and measure his bearing with a gyrocompass repeater like an alidade or periscope, and those are accurate to about a quarter of a degree for practical purposes. Next comes radar, then sonar, and coming in dead last would be shipborne RDF.
 
I need to expand on this one sentence even though for all practical real-world scenarios it is correct. Except for ambiguous cases (transmitting and tracking vessel on apparent parallel courses and at the same apparent speed) it is possible to determine the target 's course, speed, and distance if you have extremely accurate bearings, like within 0.1°, and environmental conditions are unrealistically favorable (ocean current, wind and waves are negligible or exactly the same for both vessels). For every large pattern of bearings plotted from the tracking ship there is one unique solution to the target's course, speed, and distance. That said, no mariner experienced in tracking ships would put much stock in this method. The most accurate bearings are obtained visually, i.e. you can see the guy and measure his bearing with a gyrocompass repeater like an alidade or periscope, and those are accurate to about a quarter of a degree for practical purposes. Next comes radar, then sonar, and coming in dead last would be shipborne RDF.


I agree.

The problem will be, of course, how are you going to get bearings accurate to 0.1°? This might be possible at VHF/UHF, where multi-element Yagi arrays with very sharp lobes are possible, or even dishes could be used. In the HF bands this has insurmountable practical difficulties. At HF it might even be possible to get somewhere near that accuracy with something like a cubical quad* or a four-element yagi, if you were receiving the ground wave, but if you are receiving multi-hop, or even single hop ionospheric propagation, you would be lucky to get within 2 or 3 degrees. Its is known that the Japanese aircraft used Hawaiian radio stations as RDF, but that is definitely a direct wave.


* Back the the 1980's I used to work American HAM radio operators in the 10m band from my home in Christchurch, using a cubical quad. A quick look at my log book shows...

Hawaii 34°
San Francisco 48°
Los Angeles 51°
Phoenix 54°

It was relatively easy to determine the difference in signal strength as I swung the beam around between Hawaii, and the other three, but picking any change between L.A. S.F. and Phoenix was very difficult, if not impossible.
 
The 64 meter Deep Space Network dishes have a worst case pointing accuracy of .025°. How hard would it be to mount one on a cruise liner?
 
The 64 meter Deep Space Network dishes have a worst case pointing accuracy of .025°. How hard would it be to mount one on a cruise liner?


Pointing accuracy does not equal ability to take accurate bearings. I could point my cubical quad to within 1°, but that doesn't mean I could take a bearing on a radio transmission anywhere near to that accuracy.

Also, the DSN dishes operate in S-Band (2 - 4 GHz), X-Band (8 - 11.2 GHz) and Ka-band (26.5 - 40GHz), that is radio wavelengths of approx 10cm, 3cm and 1cm)

During WW2, most navies operated in the HF bands at around 3 to 20 MHz (wavelengths of 100 down to 15 METERS. A functional dish with any sort of gain needs to be at least 20 wavelengths in diameter; so at 20 MHz it will be 980 feet across, at 3 MHZ, it will be 6,500 feet across, nearly a mile and a quarter in diamater.

This is what I meant earlier when I said "insurmountable practical difficulties"
 
He dismissed Jacobsen's critique simply by claiming "northwest by west" is the same as "northwest", despite being shown pictures of compass roses that clearly show "northwest by west" as a distinct compass bearing.

I dismissed Jacobsen's critique on this point because Grogan made it crystal clear that he was using "northwest by west" as "northwest of Hawaii." Grogan specified this usage twice, yet Jacobsen dishonestly ignored Grogan's specification and used the literal meaning of "northwest by west" to accuse Grogan of being off by 18 and 44 degrees.

People sometimes use technical terms in ways that are incorrect. However, when they go out of their way to make clear how they are using the term, it is dishonest to ignore their specification and then to insist on a literal meaning of the term.

As I said in an earlier reply, I once heard a debate where one of the participants was clearly using the term "mirror image" to mean the exact opposite of what it means. He was using it to mean "complete opposite," whereas, of course, the term means identical, carbon copy, etc. At one point, one of the debate participants asked him if he was using "mirror image" as "exact opposite." He replied that he was.

Now, someone analyzing the debate could dishonestly twist the man's words to say the opposite of what he intended them to say. A dishonest commentator could argue "He argued that the religion was the 'mirror image' of his own, and so he refuted his own position."

Jacobsen did not want to tell his readers about Grogan's explanation of his usage of "northwest by west" because then he wouldn't have been able to falsely claim that Grogan's bearings were off by 18 and 44 degrees. If he had acknowledged Grogan's usage specification, he would have had to deal with the fact that Grogan located the ships he was hearing in the same area where the task force traveled. Rather than be honest and face this evidence head-on, Jacobsen ignored Grogan's own avowed meaning of "northwest by west" and twisted his words to mean something very different from what Grogan plainly said he intended them to mean.
 
I dismissed Jacobsen's critique on this point because Grogan made it crystal clear that he was using "northwest by west" as "northwest of Hawaii." Grogan specified this usage twice, yet Jacobsen dishonestly ignored Grogan's specification and used the literal meaning of "northwest by west" to accuse Grogan of being off by 18 and 44 degrees.

People sometimes use technical terms in ways that are incorrect. However, when they go out of their way to make clear how they are using the term, it is dishonest to ignore their specification and then to insist on a literal meaning of the term.

As I said in an earlier reply, I once heard a debate where one of the participants was clearly using the term "mirror image" to mean the exact opposite of what it means. He was using it to mean "complete opposite," whereas, of course, the term means identical, carbon copy, etc. At one point, one of the debate participants asked him if he was using "mirror image" as "exact opposite." He replied that he was.

Now, someone analyzing the debate could dishonestly twist the man's words to say the opposite of what he intended them to say. A dishonest commentator could argue "He argued that the religion was the 'mirror image' of his own, and so he refuted his own position."

Jacobsen did not want to tell his readers about Grogan's explanation of his usage of "northwest by west" because then he wouldn't have been able to falsely claim that Grogan's bearings were off by 18 and 44 degrees. If he had acknowledged Grogan's usage specification, he would have had to deal with the fact that Grogan located the ships he was hearing in the same area where the task force traveled. Rather than be honest and face this evidence head-on, Jacobsen ignored Grogan's own avowed meaning of "northwest by west" and twisted his words to mean something very different from what Grogan plainly said he intended them to mean.

Which would doubtless be fascinating if you had one shred of evidence the Kido Butai made any transmissions to be detected in the first place. :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom