Oystein
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 9, 2009
- Messages
- 18,948
jtl, the FAIL-density in your post #1482 is astounding! Almost every single claim is FALSE, almost every singel question based on a FALSE premise.
Only the very first question is a good one:
But the argument remains: Whether or not "Na" should be "Zn" instead: The low or non-existing level of Zn is simply due to Jones focusing on an "apple" (a region rich in Fe in that case; no one claims that there is a compound in that chip that has both Fe and Zn. "Fe"-compound is the apple, "Zn"-compound (chromate, by the way) would be a banana, and you don't see much of the banana because you focus on the apple)
That's why Sunstealer was smart not to answer it.
Can you demonstrate how you used the available data to arrive at this conclusion?
Millette did NOT rule out Tnemec for chips whose XEDS spectra resemble that of Tnemec or the MEK chip.
He only ruled out Tnemec for the chips that have XEDS spectra similar to chips a-d. This was entirely expected, in fact we knew all along that those chips are not Tnemec. Instead, we strongly suspect they are LaClede.
Millette wasn't aware of LaClede paint at the time he wrote the preliminary report, which was in February.
He is now, and actively pursuing sampled of actual LaClede paint (without success, so far).
Again, there is no Al in Fig 16 - this doesn't mean the Al is gone!
http://ae911truth.org/downloads/documents/primer_paint_Niels_Harrit.pdf
Harrit writes:
"In one experiment the chips were to be soaked in methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) and could not – for good reasons – be broken before. The resulting XEDS of this chip (Figure 6, below) displays tiny blips indicating the presence of chromium and zinc. They disappeared after the chips had been soaked/rinsed with the organic solvent. Therefore, they are believed to derive from surface contamination, which very well could have been from the primer paint(!).
Magnesium was never observed, which is another element characteristic of the primer paint (Table 1)."
Harrit's claims are FALSE and MISLEADING.
First of all, there IS a peak for magnesium in Fig 6, which is Fig. 14 of the Bentham paper - they just chose to not label it. It's the peak between Zn and Al.
Secondly, Harrit presents no data that supports the assertion that Zn, Cr and Mg were gone. Same "fruit basket" issue. (Fig 17 has a bit Mg, by the way)
Thirdly, the "tiny blips" for Zn and Cr are consistent with 1.8% and 0.5% by weight of these elements, while the blip for Al is consistent with 0.6%. So the total amount of Al would be as insignificant as that of Cr.
Fouthly, the speculation that Zn and Cr derived from contamination with paint is laughable for several (well, at least two) reasons, and not supported by any evidence at all.
The Harrit letter suffers from another stupid mistake, by which Harrit overestimated the content in Tnemec of the various minerals (metals) by a factor of 3-4.
It does contain valuable data though: It's Figure 5b shows elements in chip a that they did not document in the Bentham paper, most interestingly Strontium and Chromium, thus corroborating nicely our hypothesis that chips a-d are LaClede paint, which contains 1% strontium chromate.
Millette did not rule out Tnemec for all chips, he just ruled out Tnemec for chips a-d, which we already knew to not be Tnemec.
Harrit also can only rule out Tnemec for chips a-d. He says he rules out Tnemec for the MEK chip, but he misrepresents the data. His claimn is thus unsupported and not compelling.
Harrit's letter wasn't thus published.
And the Bentham paper, likewise, cannot be considered a proper scientific journal.
But anyway, an argument is right or wrong regardless of who makes it and where.
Only the very first question is a good one:
When I said or implied that Fig 18 does not show Zn, I didn't consider the possibility that a peak could be mislabeled due to edge energies of two elements being almost the same. Sunstealer is correct in pointing out that Na (K-alpha) at 1.04 keV and Zn (L-alpha) at 1.01 can be easily mixed up, and that it is possible the peak labeled "Na" is actually Zn. I disagree with Sunstealer when he asserts this as a certainty. In the same graph, P and Cl pop up even though they are not seen in Fig 14, and their edge energies (2.01 keV and 2.62 keV, respectively) have no plausible nearby neighbors that could cause a similar mix-up. So seeing Na pop up didn't seem outlandish.So Sunstealer, you say the Zn is still there mislabeled but Oystein says it is not there because Jones focused on a spot without Zn. Which one is it?
But the argument remains: Whether or not "Na" should be "Zn" instead: The low or non-existing level of Zn is simply due to Jones focusing on an "apple" (a region rich in Fe in that case; no one claims that there is a compound in that chip that has both Fe and Zn. "Fe"-compound is the apple, "Zn"-compound (chromate, by the way) would be a banana, and you don't see much of the banana because you focus on the apple)
The premise of this question is UNSUPPORTED. We don't know if there is less, more, or the same proportion of Zn. They only show some selected fruit, not the whole basket, after the MEK soak.Given you are right and there is still some Zn there, why is there less of it after MEK wash?
That's why Sunstealer was smart not to answer it.
The premise of this question is UNSUPPORTED. You don't know if there is less, more, or the same proportion of Zn.Why did fig14 not have the same amount of Zn as the known sample(from Jones) of Tnemec you yourself used for comparison?
Can you demonstrate how you used the available data to arrive at this conclusion?
The premise of this question is FALSE.And you said fig14 was a match for this Tnemec from Jones and also a match to some Millette chips, so why did Millette rule out Tnemec?
Millette did NOT rule out Tnemec for chips whose XEDS spectra resemble that of Tnemec or the MEK chip.
He only ruled out Tnemec for the chips that have XEDS spectra similar to chips a-d. This was entirely expected, in fact we knew all along that those chips are not Tnemec. Instead, we strongly suspect they are LaClede.
Millette wasn't aware of LaClede paint at the time he wrote the preliminary report, which was in February.
He is now, and actively pursuing sampled of actual LaClede paint (without success, so far).
You say this because you get all your facts wrong AND don't understand XEDS.Your Tnemec hypothesis has some holes in it so big you could drive a truck through it.
This FALSE, or at least UNSUPPORTED. You have no evidence that the elements actually disappeared. Insufficient data.Actually I was talking about the fact that all those elements disappeared after washing in figures 16 to 18.
Could still be there.You say the Zn is still there but what happened to the other stuff?
Again, there is no Al in Fig 16 - this doesn't mean the Al is gone!
This disagreement between me and Sunstealer is pretty insignificant. And no, it is not cherry-picking, it comes from a straight interpretation of ALL the available data. There is some room for variety, in my opinion, with just the Ca and S peaks being higher than expected (IMO), but the "Tnemec" fingerprint is too peculiar to be missed.Do you agree with Oystein that you can cherry pick the Zn as part of the chip while dismissing the rest, or at least the Ca and S, as contamination?
Why should we? Truthers misrepresent, quote-mine and otherwise rape our technical points, because they are all as clueless or dishonest as you are. It would actually be your job to find good arguments, as you are the truther here.I said before that you guys should show me some references to what truthers have to say about your technical points, but you don´t.
I believe you are talking about this letter?I did a quick search for "Harrit paint" and found a paper he wrote about the chips vs Tnemec paint. This essay clearly says the Zn disappeared after washing chip from fig14, and it also points out lack of Magnesium.
http://ae911truth.org/downloads/documents/primer_paint_Niels_Harrit.pdf
Harrit writes:
"In one experiment the chips were to be soaked in methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) and could not – for good reasons – be broken before. The resulting XEDS of this chip (Figure 6, below) displays tiny blips indicating the presence of chromium and zinc. They disappeared after the chips had been soaked/rinsed with the organic solvent. Therefore, they are believed to derive from surface contamination, which very well could have been from the primer paint(!).
Magnesium was never observed, which is another element characteristic of the primer paint (Table 1)."
Harrit's claims are FALSE and MISLEADING.
First of all, there IS a peak for magnesium in Fig 6, which is Fig. 14 of the Bentham paper - they just chose to not label it. It's the peak between Zn and Al.
Secondly, Harrit presents no data that supports the assertion that Zn, Cr and Mg were gone. Same "fruit basket" issue. (Fig 17 has a bit Mg, by the way)
Thirdly, the "tiny blips" for Zn and Cr are consistent with 1.8% and 0.5% by weight of these elements, while the blip for Al is consistent with 0.6%. So the total amount of Al would be as insignificant as that of Cr.
Fouthly, the speculation that Zn and Cr derived from contamination with paint is laughable for several (well, at least two) reasons, and not supported by any evidence at all.
The Harrit letter suffers from another stupid mistake, by which Harrit overestimated the content in Tnemec of the various minerals (metals) by a factor of 3-4.
It does contain valuable data though: It's Figure 5b shows elements in chip a that they did not document in the Bentham paper, most interestingly Strontium and Chromium, thus corroborating nicely our hypothesis that chips a-d are LaClede paint, which contains 1% strontium chromate.
This is FALSE.Both Harrit and Millette rule out Tnemec.
Millette did not rule out Tnemec for all chips, he just ruled out Tnemec for chips a-d, which we already knew to not be Tnemec.
Harrit also can only rule out Tnemec for chips a-d. He says he rules out Tnemec for the MEK chip, but he misrepresents the data. His claimn is thus unsupported and not compelling.
The question why he does not publish properly in a scientific journal is a distraction, and hand-wave.You ignored this question Sunstealer, and given the information above it seems obvious why.
Harrit's letter wasn't thus published.
And the Bentham paper, likewise, cannot be considered a proper scientific journal.
But anyway, an argument is right or wrong regardless of who makes it and where.
