WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

The test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, eh, MM? :D
Gosh, you're setting yourself up for yet another whooping! :D

So tell, me, MM, which "chips of interest" did they in fact "identify" with those electrical resistivity measurements?
  1. Did they identify chip a with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  2. Did they identify chip b with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  3. Did they identify chip c with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  4. Did they identify chip d with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  5. Did they identify the MEK-soaked chip with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  6. Did they identify the first chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, MacKinlay 1, blue line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  7. Did they identify the second chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, MacKinlay 2, red line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  8. Did they identify the third chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, Intermont, black line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  9. Did they identify the fourth chip they tested in the DSC (Fig. 19, White, green line) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  10. Did they identify the multilayered chip (Fig. 31) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
  11. Did they identify the chip with the carbon layer (Fig. 32+33) with the help of electrical resistivity measurements as a "chip of interest"?
MM, that's 11 separate "chips of interest", 11 separate questions, I expect 11 separate answers. And I expect you to answer all 11 of them with "I don't know".

So much ignorance, MM!

But here is an easy one for you:

On how many chips did they do any electrical resistivity measurements? Here, I'll give you a clue:

I'll give you another clue:

They thusly tested 2 (two) chips!

So then, of the above-mentioned 11 chips, how many did they NOT select via electrical resistivity measurements?

Here is a clue for you:

11-9 = ???




So final question, MM:


Is "electrical resistivity measurements" the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, and made it easy to eliminate the many paint chips, MM? Yes, or no?


Here is a final clue for you:


No!



Gosh, that was fun :D

Maybe you should talk to Gamolon?

You do know what a probe is don't you?

MM
 
Bentham paper :We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A mul- timeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the formula:
Specific resistivity = RA / L
where R = resistance (ohms); A = cross-sectional area (m2); L
= thickness (m).
Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of ap- proximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typi- cally over 1010 ohm-m [31].
Another test, described above, involved subjection of red chips to methyl ethyl ketone solvent for tens of hours, with agitation. The red material did swell but did not dissolve, and a hard silicon-rich matrix remained after this procedure. On the other hand, paint samples in the same exposure to MEK solvent became limp and showed significant dissolution, as expected since MEK is a paint

It can't of been easy using the probes on such A small chip.

Rough approximate readings :rolleyes: not sounding very exact.

Not sure if the 10 MEK soak is of use to chris
 
Last edited:
Maybe you should talk to Gamolon?

You do know what a probe is don't you?

MM

Maybe you should read the Harrit's paper again because what you state here:
Or have you forgotten the test that helped them to identify the chips of interest, and made it easy to eliminate the many paint chips?

Is not what they wrote in their paper:
Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5
mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude
less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 10
10
ohm-m [31]

They tested one chip according to their paper, not chips.
 
Nowhere has Dr. Jones et al indicated that the Resistivity test was only used once.

Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?

He certainly expected Dr. Millette to.

Dr. Jones said:
"Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material."
bolding is mine

MM
 
Nowhere has Dr. Jones et al indicated that the Resistivity test was only used once.

Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?

He certainly expected Dr. Millette to.


bolding is mine

MM

It was written in the paper.
Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5
mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude
less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 10
10 ohm-m [31].

Everywhere else AROUND that statement in the paper refers to "chips", plural.

Another test, described above, involved subjection of red
chips to methyl ethyl ketone solvent for tens of hours, with
agitation

Further, we have shown that the red material contains
both elemental aluminum and iron oxide, the ingredients of
thermite, in interesting configuration and intimate mixing in
the surviving chips
 
Let's not be too quick to go after MM here, he is quoting Jones and of course MM can't answer every question about what Jones did. Seems to me that Jones is the one who should be challenged, if indeed he tested only two out of 11 chips or whatever. I have been trying to write to Jones, so far with marginal success. MM and Oystein, what would you like to know from Jones about this matter? Two things I want to avoid: asking dozens of questions and being insulting. Jones won't respond to either of these I'm certain.
 
jtl: What is called superthermite can be a mixture that is only partially feo-al thermite, and also other stuff not normally found in thermite. The result will obviously not perform like std thermite. Straight hermite does not release gas pressure and is not explosive but superthermite can because it can be mixed with organic components.
Sunstealer: A nano-thermite simply refers to a thermite that has particles with sizes under 100nm. What jtl is actually talking about is a nano-thermite composite. Seeing the quote it's interesting to note that he says superthermite can contain other metals and other metal oxides. but fails to realise that Harrit et al only claim that Fe2O3 and Al are present.

I actually said they can be mixed with "other stuff" and specified organic components, not metals. Harrit:
Thus, there is a highly energetic form of thermite known as an energetic nanocomposite or “super-thermite,” composed of aluminum and iron oxide with at least one component being approximately 100 nm or less, often along with silicon and carbon [19-28].

Similarly here we have the idea that the epoxy in the paint is somehow engineered to produce gas (which then has to do work) then the "thermite" is ignited. You can plainly see that this is not the case in Basile's heated element experiment.

This is a fact, there are variations of superthermite that have organic material for gas output as Harrit does point out and even wikipedia article has this information. I am not sure just how clearly basile experiment shows gas output but Kminek has explained that the reason is the slow heating:
Kminek: (But, this comparison is not really correct, since typical extremely rapid thermitic reaction must be triggered by some thermal/energetic shock, like in the linked video, which is not the case of slow DSC heating indeed)

Tests by Harrit using torch instead of DSC does indicate that the chips burn differently when heated quickly:
Harrit: After a few seconds of heating, the high-speed ejection of a hot particle was observed under the hand of the
person holding the torch (Fig. 22). The intense light and
bright orange color of the particle attest to its high tempera-
ture
 
MM did quote Steven Jones and Jones's claim that they did more to separate out the chips than Millette did. Thank for bringing it to my attention MM. Perhaps a summary of Jones's objections to Millette's study would be a good thing for me to have and pass on to Millette, if only as an FYI.
Jones may claim all he wants. If they used more techniques to separate their chips then they should have put the methodology used in the paper. Secondly you would expect the paper to make specific mention of exactly what the materials were that were separated by a magnet, but later ruled out for further tests due to failing these undocumented separation criteria and methods. This is a severe failure.

Fig 31 is a classic example - this chip is radically different from all the others, yet is claimed to be thermite just like all the others. Why does this chip pass the undocumented and unknown additional separation criteria? What other samples or materials were separated by a magnet but failed other separation criteria? There is zero mention of this.

Moving on..

Millette doesn't need to perform an electrical conductivity test because he uses the EDX spectra from samples a-d as criteria in matching red/gray chips separated by a magnet.

The electrical conductivity test is a red-herring and a completely silly test to perform because these red/gray chips have two layers; one red and one gray which are completely different materials, have radically different electrical properties and are found in differing proportions from sample to sample.

An electrical conductivity test cannot tell you anything meaningful about the sample for this reason. Truthers and the authors also love to claim that paint didn't exhibit the same electrical conductivity as the chips, but they fail to realise that paint is one material, one layer and not two, so any comparison is moot.

The resistivity test is not mentioned in the relevent section regarding isolation of the relevant material. Here is the full text

2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination

For clarification, the dust samples collected and sent to the authors by Ms. Janette MacKinlay will be sample 1; the sample collected by Mr. Frank Delassio, or the Delassio/ Breidenbach sample, will be sample 2; the sample collected by Mr. Jody Intermont will be sample 3; and the sample
collected by Mr. Stephen White will be sample 4. The red/gray chips are attracted by a magnet, which facilitates collection and separation of the chips from the bulk of the dust. A small permanent magnet in its own plastic bag was used to attract and collect the chips from dust samples. The chips are typically small but readily discernible by eye due to their distinctive color. They are of variable size with major dimensions of roughly 0.2 to 3 mm. Thicknesses vary from roughly 10 to 100 microns for each layer (red and gray). Samples of WTC dust from these and other collectors have been sent directly from collectors to various scientists (including some not on this research team) who have also found such red/gray chips in the dust from the World Trade Center destruction.
An FEI XL30-SFEG scanning electron microscope (SEM) was used to perform secondary-electron (SE) imaging and backscattered electron (BSE) imaging. The SE imaging was used to look at the surface topography and porosity
of the red/gray chips, while the BSE imaging was used to distinguish variations in average atomic number, Z. The microscope was also equipped with an EDAX X-ray energy dispersive spectrometry (XEDS) system. The XEDS system uses a silicon detector (SiLi) with resolution better than 135 eV. The spectrum resolution was set to 10 eV per channel. Operating conditions for the acquired XEDS spectra were 20 keV beam energy (unless otherwise specified) and 40-120 second acquisition time (livetime). XEDS maps were acquired using the same system at a beam energy of 10 keV. For general surface analysis in the SEM, dust samples were mounted to carbon conductive tabs. The samples were left unwashed and uncoated unless otherwise specified. In order to more closely observe the characteristics of the red and gray layers, and to eliminate the possibility of surface contamination from other dust particles, several red/gray chips from each of the four WTC dust samples were fractured. The clean, cross-section surfaces were then studied by BSE imaging and XEDS.


Some samples were also tested in a differential scanning calorimeter (Netzsch DSC 404C) to measure heat flow into or out of the red/gray chips. The DSC tests were conducted with a linear heating rate of 10 °C per minute up to a temperature of 700 °C. During heating, the samples were contained in alumina pans and air was allowed to flow at 55 milliliters per minute during the heating. The plots were generated by acquiring data points at a rate of 20 points per °C or 200 points per minute. The equipment was calibrated to
display the data in watts per gram. The plots were set to display positive heat flow out of the sample such that exothermic behavior of the sample would yield a peak and endothermic behavior a trough.

The dust samples were also examined by visible-light microscopy (VLM) through a Nikon Epiphot 200 stereomicroscope, an Olympus BX60 stereomicroscope and a Nikon Labophot microscope and camera.

I see no mention of an electrical test.

I have been trying to figure out which specific chips Dr Millette used in his FTIR tests so I can match them to their EDX spectrum. The progress report states that specimens

9119-4795L1560-red-atr_0001.spc
9119-4808L1616-red-atr_0001.spc
9119_5230m3451-red-atr_0001.spc
9119x0135-red-atr_0001.spc

were subject to FTIR

now this obviously relates to the 4 dust samples however, I can't see how it relates to the individual EDX for the specimens.

For example sample L1560 has 7 red chips with 7 corresponding EDX spectra labelled (1), (2) etc but it's not explicit which chip is in the FTIR graph.

L1616 only has 4 red chips but again I don't know which specific chip is shown in the FTIR trace.

I'm assuming that they must correlate to chips that conform to spectra that match samples a-d in Harrit et al. It would be nice to know the specifics.
 
Last edited:
"Jones may claim all he wants. If they used more techniques to separate their chips then they should have put the methodology used in the paper. ...Moving on..

Millette doesn't need to perform an electrical conductivity test because he uses the EDX spectra from samples a-d as criteria in matching red/gray chips separated by a magnet.

The electrical conductivity test is a red-herring and a completely silly test to perform because these red/gray chips have two layers; one red and one gray which are completely different materials, have radically different electrical properties and are found in differing proportions from sample to sample.

An electrical conductivity test cannot tell you anything meaningful about the sample for this reason. Truthers and the authors also love to claim that paint didn't exhibit the same electrical conductivity as the chips, but they fail to realise that paint is one material, one layer and not two, so any comparison is moot.

The resistivity test is not mentioned in the relevent section regarding isolation of the relevant material. Here is the full text

I see no mention of an electrical test. …
"

Page 27 of the Bentham Paper;

Harrit et al said:
"7. Could the Red Chip Material be Ordinary Paint?

We measured the resistivity of the red material (with very little gray adhering to one side) using a Fluke 8842A mul- timeter in order to compare with ordinary paints, using the formula:

Specific resistivity = RA / L

where R = resistance (ohms); A = cross-sectional area (m2); L
= thickness (m).

Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 1010 ohm-m [31]...."

I wish Dr. Millette had taken the time to thoroughly read the paper he was so busy debunking.

MM
 
Last edited:
Nowhere has Dr. Jones et al indicated that the Resistivity test was only used once.

Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?

He certainly expected Dr. Millette to.


bolding is mine

MM

Ok, I have a question. In the paper it states:
All of the chips used in the study had a gray layer and a
red layer and were attracted by a magnet.

Am I correct in saying that the only criteria for determining which chips to be tested was:

1. The chips had to have a red and gray layer
2. They were attracted to a magnet.

Using the criteria above, did some of the red/gray paint chips (non-super-thermite) have the chemical composition of just paint and other red/gray super-thermite chips had the chemical composition of the paint PLUS those that make up super-thermite?

So according to MM, they took that group gathered by the above method and further separated them into red/gray paint chips and red/gray super-thermite chips.
 
Why would he be so interested in how useful it was in sorting-out all the paint chips if he never used it?

Sorting out the paint chips from which group MM?

According to the paper, the criteria for the test group of chips was:
1. They had to have a red and gray layer
and
2. They had to be attracted to a magnet

So as I stated in my above post, you are telling me that they FURTHER separated that test group determined by the criteria above into:

Group A
Red/gray chips that were paint

Group B
Red/gray chips that were super-thermite

Is that correct?
 
Page 27 of the Bentham Paper;



I wish Dr. Millette had taken the time to thoroughly read the paper he was so busy debunking.

MM
I am very well aware that page 27 contains a brief mention of a resistivity test, however, my point still stands. The relevant section, namely 2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination. I have highlighted the word "isolation" for you again. Oystein has already given you the dictionary definition of the word yet you continue to fail to understand what that word means.

The resistivity test is not part of the isolation criteria - it says so in the paper, in the relevant section. that's why I quoted the relevant section in it's entirety. If you had bothered to read my post you will understand that a by-layered chip with 2 wildly different materials cannot be compared to paints using resistivity as a measure Why do you ignore this?

It's your ****** irrelevant points that derail the thread.
 
Last edited:
I wish Dr. Millette had taken the time to thoroughly read the paper he was so busy debunking.

MM

Why would someone write a paper and on page 9 include a section of how the chips were segregated and then on page 27 include a supposedly crucial segregation process. :confused:
 
Originally Posted by Harrit et al
"Given the small size of the red chip, about 0.5 mm x 0.5 mm, we used two probes and obtained a rough value of approximately 10 ohm-m. This is several orders of magnitude less than paint coatings we found tabulated which are typically over 100,000,000,000 ohm-m [31]."
The above quote was taken from post 1618 by MM

Does anyone notice anything unusual about it ?
 
... , hiding behind their fake names, and I am fed up with it. Their answer to everything seems to be declaring themselves experts and calling the actual scientists that have done the research and the papers incompetent fools and other names like that.
...
Are you the one who will be using thermite in your rockets? What fake names? The hiding behind names crap is standard paranoid conspiracy theorists rant; you sound like Balsamo. You are too easy to distract; what is your goal? Purpose?

Why can't you answer questions about 911 on thermite.
Do you understand no thermite/super themite was used on 911?

Where is your list of improvements for Millette's paper?

How do you improve on a paper which finds no thermite, unless you prove there is no thermite using the same data, from the same paper. What is wrong with the conclusion, the big picture?

The Harrit paper shows no thermite, they say it implies thermite and a few fringe people were fooled. Like your friend.
 
Last edited:
Mohr: But when all is said and done, if there is room for improvement in the ongoing Millette study, I want to tell Jim about it. If there is scientific validity to their complaints, that needs to be openly stated (and perhaps corrected in the final paper).

One example: many 9/11 Truth people have told me that Millette should have exactly duplicated the protocol set out by Jones et al in the Bentham paper. Clearly he chose not to do a DSC test (because he considered it useless, not because DSC equipment wasn't in his lab, BTW). Originally, I came to him with a question: can you find samples of the same kind of red-grey chips the Jones et al folks claimed were thermitic and determine if these chips have thermitic materials in them? I did NOT hire him to replicate every element of the Bentham study.

when a scientific paper is beinmg published to test the findings of a prior study, is it expected that every aspect of the original protocol be followed to the letter, even if parts of the original study are believed to have been poorly carried out?

"Test the findings", you can´t cherry pick tests for Millette and still call the paper a replication of Harrit´s paper. Your buddies here like to pose as big experts and basically declare that Harrit along the others are incompetent fools and all their tests meaningless, but this is just typical behavior of anonymous forum trolls.

You have identified a two part question to Millette:

1. Can he identify the same chips as Harrit? But this part is already being disputed because Millette has not done all the same tests and some results even suggest they are not the same chips. They become soft in MEK and have titanium while that is not true for Harrit´s chips just to mention some of the problems. Your buddies seem sure there are many different chips in the dust and Basile says some red chips are paint while one type is NOT, so you can´t ignore this problem. If you do and identify one type of paint chip in the dust, like Millette now claims, you only possibly prove you have found one type of paint chip in dust, but everyone agrees there are paint chips in the dust. The problem is identifying the other type of chips that Harrit and Basile claim is different from the others, and not paint.

2. Can he identify thermitic chips? Millette cannot do this without the ignition tests. Here you come to the same problem as Harrit, even though you have some superthermite ingredients like Harrit chips do have(fe, al, si, c and polymers are all mentioned in the superthermite papers he refers to), you have to show that the chips work like active thermitic material. You cant do this without ignition tests. Harrit first uses DSC test to show that it is energetic because he replicates procedure by people that developed superthermite, so saying this is a useless test is absolute garbage. Harrit then says the energetic exotherm is due to thermite reaction because he compares the residue to the original ingredients, i.e he says he had iron oxide before burn and molten iron after burn, again basically replicating procedure by the developers.

Maybe Millette can prove that Harrit results are not conclusive or flawed. He does not compare the DSC results with paint results so he doe not really prove you can´t get similar results with paint, does not prove there is al oxide in the residue etc. But Millette cannot ignore the DSC tests or not do them.

It is very easy to see room for improvement. It is obvious that you won´t get the feedback you need from this forum, but I think Kminek could help you to go over this in private communications. You can forget about the rest of the people here.
 
Last edited:
"Test the findings", you can´t cherry pick tests for Millette and still call the paper a replication of Harrit´s paper. Your buddies here like to pose as big experts and basically declare that Harrit along the others are incompetent fools and all their tests meaningless, but this is just typical behavior of anonymous forum trolls.

You have identified a two part question to Millette:

1. Can he identify the same chips as Harrit? But this part is already being disputed because Millette has not done all the same tests and some results even suggest they are not the same chips. They become soft in MEK and have titanium while that is not true for Harrit´s chips just to mention some of the problems. Your buddies seem sure there are many different chips in the dust and Basile says some red chips are paint while one type is NOT, so you can´t ignore this problem. If you do you only prove you have found paint chips in dust, but everyone agrees there are paint chips in the dust. The problem is identifying the other type of chips that Harrit and Basile claim is different from the others, and not paint.

2. Can he identify thermitic chips? Millette cannot do this without the ignition tests. Here you come to the same problem as Harrit, even though you have some superthermite ingredients like Harrit chips do have(fe, al, si, c and polymers are all mentioned in the superthermite papers he refers to), you have to show that the chips work like active thermitic material. You cant do this without ignition tests. Harrit first uses DSC test to show that it is energetic because he replicates procedure by people that developed superthermite, so saying this is a useless test is absolute garbage. Harrit then says the energetic exotherm is due to thermite reaction because he compares the residue to the original ingredients, i.e he says he had iron oxide before burn and molten iron after burn, again basically replicating procedure by the developers.

Maybe Millette can prove that Harrit results are not conclusive or flawed. He does not compare the DSC results with paint results so he doe not really prove you can´t get similar results with paint, does not prove there is al oxide in the residue etc. But Millette cannot ignore the DSC tests or not do them.

It is very easy to see room for improvement. It is obvious that you won´t get the feedback you need from this forum, but I think Kminek could help you to go over this in private communications. You can forget about the rest of the people here.

To simplify your question.....

Ask Millette to do DSC tests ?
 
"...

2. Can he identify thermitic chips? Millette cannot do this without the ignition tests. ...
Big BS. Where do you get this from, 911 truther chemistry book of woo?
Wrong. There was no thermite. Millette found no thermite.
Please get some help from a chemical engineer or a chemistry teacher.

You don't know what DSC is used for. The DSC test done my Harrit shows the dust was not super-thermite.

Why don't you know there was no thermite used on 911? Got Chemistry?
 
Last edited:
So here is my question and anyone on either side is welcome to answer: when a scientific paper is beinmg published to test the findings of a prior study, is it expected that every aspect of the original protocol be followed to the letter, even if parts of the original study are believed to have been poorly carried out? Or is it more standard to ask the same question and then replicate only the relevant parts, and also filling in the missing parts of the original study (which is what Millette did)?

I don't want just the standard debunker answer, I'd like to know what the tradition is in scientific circles when publishing a paper that follows up on a prior published work.
Firstly I think this question should be posted in the scientific part of the forum as a general question. You are far more likely to get a more in depth response from a far greater number of posters who are engaged in a wide variety of disciplines.

I've never read a metallurgical paper that specifically aims to solely replicate previous work. Usually there is a necessary part of replication which confirms the previous authors findings and will be referenced as such (eg: we did this and this correlates with "such and such et al", who did the same thing), but additional experimentation is carried out to further the work, which ultimately builds upon the original (and other works - which are cited in the reference section of the paper).

Research is an exploration of the new or unknown, so purely replicating a peer-reviewed paper, without any addition, is somewhat pointless. The only time I can see this as a valid route to take is when there is a ground breaking discovery and such a discovery must be confirmed. Usually that will mean that multiple (teams of) independent researchers will look to confirm such findings. Even then, original research is encouraged because this additional work strengthens or challenges the previous findings.

Over time a bulk of work is built up and subsequently forms a literature, which can then be referenced.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom