...
Have you not noticed that the basic argument your buddies have against Harrit paper is that the MEK chip and the ignited chips were somehow the wrong chips, and not the same as chips a to d?
Did you notice the part where Harrit et al say their chips remain hard in MEK while paint chips become soft, and that Millette´s chips become soft?
Did they test any of chips a-d with MEK? What was the result?
Which of the chips they did test with MEK had the same elemental composition, as per XEDS, as chips a-d?
Which of the chips they did test with MEK was observed to contain those peculiar hexagonal platelets?
Citation and data, please.
Thanks.
After you fail to provide these citations an data, please comment on the evidence that exists that the MEK-chip (Fig. 12-18) is the same material as chips a-d (Fig 5-11). Also, comment on the evidence that exists that they were
different.
Thanks.
I already went over this, the point was showing fast energy release comparable to a known superthermite.
How fast was the energy release?
Was it "fast"?
Did they, or did the not, compare their DSC results with that of Tillotson and Gash (Reference [28])?
What do Tillotson and Gash (Reference [28]) say about DSC and its ability to measure how "fast energy release" is of nano-thermite? They make an explicit statement on this!
The ignition temperature and total energy output are not important as they will vary for different ratios of components and different compositions(different superthermites!). Even with all the same ingredients in the same ratios, just changing the size of the particles will change ignition temp.
Why then did they show the shape of one of their DSC curves along with that of Tillotson and Gash (Reference [28])? When you answer this, keep in mind that the draft of their paper originally had many more Figures, but that they eliminated many on advide of the peer-reviewer, so they would have kept only important Figures, or not?
Why then do they keep stressing the ignition temperature, if it's "not important"?
Why does the paper even mention the total energy output, if it's "not important"?
Would you say that they drew no conclusion from the energy output?
And if you read the paper where that compared superthermite peak comes from, you realize that the authors explain that it did not release as much energy as expected because of some faults with the sample, so that small 1.5 energy release is certainly not typical.
How much did they expect, and what is the basis for that expectation? There must be some base numbers, and calculations, that one can do to come up with such an expectation, right?
Applying the same method to Harrit's chips, what should they expect in terms of energy release?