WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

What tests did they want to do? When you looked for a lab, did you not look for a lab that could replicate the Bentham tests?



It is about replicating tests others have done, and trying to answer Harrit´s question about a proposed "prosaic substance". Also testing Kminek gray layer hypothesis for iron spheres.



It does seem a little strange that he would not do this since he was heating them to nearly ignition temperature anyway.

JTL,

Obviously, as I said, I did not ask them to replicate the bentham test. I asked them to determine if there was thermitic material in red-grey chips from the WTC dust. If so, what would they do to make this determination? Often they would say, we have this machine or that machine so we'll try that. I don't remember what tests they offered, they were just off the mark. I know because I would ask other labs if that were a good idea and they would say no that is not the protocol. Many labs blew me off entirely.

How can you ask someone to replicate the Bentham paper without showing them the paper? Why is it strange that Millette did not want to destroy the chips he was analyzing by igniting them? And BTW I am hoping Millette does complete his paper (he says he wants to) and that he looks at the iron microspheres and pssibkle sources.
 
JTL,

Obviously, as I said, I did not ask them to replicate the bentham test. I asked them to determine if there was thermitic material in red-grey chips from the WTC dust. If so, what would they do to make this determination? Often they would say, we have this machine or that machine so we'll try that. I don't remember what tests they offered, they were just off the mark. I know because I would ask other labs if that were a good idea and they would say no that is not the protocol. Many labs blew me off entirely.
There's a connection between the two highlighted portions.

Asking labs to examine an unknown substance that could potentially be a dangerous material such as thermite will result in a negative response. Why would any lab bring potentially dangerous material into their business? As soon as WTC dust or 9/11 is mentioned then you are automatically a nutter and to be given a very wide berth. Think about it from the lab's perspective;

They are dealing with a nutter who wants them to confirm or not that he has a dangerous substance.

We talked about this at the time.

If you want a lab to investigate then they will do so using the techniques that they think will solve the problem based upon their vast professional experience and the equipment available. Truthers automatically ignore the experience, the definitive analytical techniques that actually tell you exactly what the material is and instead shift the point to irrelevance by moaning about certain pointless and irrelevant tests not being done.


How can you ask someone to replicate the Bentham paper without showing them the paper? Why is it strange that Millette did not want to destroy the chips he was analyzing by igniting them? And BTW I am hoping Millette does complete his paper (he says he wants to) and that he looks at the iron microspheres and pssibkle sources.
If you show the Betham paper to a lab they will just laugh at you behind your back and you will be classed as a fruitloop. The paper is worthless. If you want professional opinions on that paper then mail it to a number of materials science academics politely requesting them to read it and give you feedback. Remember this 9/11 conspiracy stuff is not normal - the whole idea is nonsense from top to bottom. It's a minor miracle that you were able to get anything done especially as you had no samples to start with.

It doesn't matter what Millette does or whether he completes his paper and has it published - his results will be ignored by truthers.

For example take the reason why Millette used an ashing technique to remove the organic material so he could then perform TEM analysis on the particles that remained. The truthers are equating this with DSC and are complaining about the temperature he did the ashing at. It's been explained to them dozens of times why Millette did this. Millette's been quoted time after time after time saying exactly why he did this; the words are there in black and white in the progress report, yet the truthers just ignore it and moan about DSC.

This is why I never put a penny toward Millette's study - it wasn't required, it gives credence to Harrit et al and truthers, it will be ignored and lastly we know that the material is red paint adhered to rust because that's what the data tells us.
 
Last edited:
Mohr: How can you ask someone to replicate the Bentham paper without showing them the paper?

What are you talking about? That someone has to read the paper. But if you are going to outsource the DSC test to someone else, make sure that lab does blind tests.

Why is it strange that Millette did not want to destroy the chips he was analyzing by igniting them?

???Millette is the only one that destroyed samples with his "ashing" at 400 instead of trying to ignite them going up to 450. The ignition tests are required not the ashing, and the ignition tests do not prevent analysis because that is done before ignition.

And BTW I am hoping Millette does complete his paper (he says he wants to) and that he looks at the iron microspheres and pssibkle sources.

You do not sound very certain that he will complete the paper.

Do you know why it is important that those spheres are iron while the chips had iron oxide before ignition?

Sunstealer: If you show the Betham paper to a lab they will just laugh at you behind your back and you will be classed as a fruitloop. The paper is worthless.

One more thing Mohr, as has been noted many times, this kind of bloated farting and hand-waving displayed by some of your buddies here has nothing to do with science. I used to ignore the Bentham paper but someone pestered me for so long that when I had an opportunity to see a lecture by Harrit I did see his university lecture in a hall full of chemists and professors. The paper was taken seriously and you should try some time to see what real scientific discussions are about, instead of the hogwash seen on this forum. The paper is sound but it can still be proven wrong with more research. That will not be done by ignoring the most important result in the paper, the evidence for reduction after ignition.
 
Last edited:
What are you talking about? That someone has to read the paper. But if you are going to outsource the DSC test to someone else, make sure that lab does blind tests.

And what do you compare them too. You know Harrit et al "forgot" to identify what chips they put in the DSC.

Why don't you get Jones to release all the data they neglected to include before you start talking about doing a duplicate study. OK?
 
... One more thing Mohr, as has been noted many times, this kind of bloated farting and hand-waving displayed by some of your buddies here has nothing to do with science. I used to ignore the Bentham paper but someone pestered me for so long that when I had an opportunity to see a lecture by Harrit I did see his university lecture in a hall full of chemists and professors. The paper was taken seriously and you should try some time to see what real scientific discussions are about, instead of the hogwash seen on this forum. The paper is sound but it can still be proven wrong with more research. That will not be done by ignoring the most important result in the paper, the evidence for reduction after ignition.
Harrit is nuts, he did not fool anyone. Fellow chemist and professors are very nice and polite. They know Harrit is nuts. How many tons of thermite did Harrit use in his fantasy? Hiding behind science to fool a few dolts in 911 truth is standard for this kind of fraud.

Jones' paper is fraud. Thermite was not used on 911. The paper proves it was not thermite. The DSC shows thermite is not a match to the chips. I guess a few people might fall for the lies of Jones and Harrit, and they have no clue what the purpose of DSC is. 911 truth and thermite believers are gullible.

The iron rich spheres are the sign of woo. I can make them from many means and material. Anyone who thinks iron rich spheres mean thermite have failed, never took chemistry and can't think outside the box of 911 truth, a lock box full of woo.

What a waste; no thermite evidence on any steel. Harrit's conclusion is nonsense. When 911 truth denies that fact, it reflects great ignorance in chemistry, a failure and lack of critical thinking skills.

Millette should save his time and let his paper die, Gage could use the help to keep his gravy-train flowing. What silly waste. 911 truth is too easy to fool. Jones shows DSC traces that don't match thermite, calls it thermite and 911 truth accepts the lie. Got to have DSC. And they have no clue what DSC is. 911 truth only takes on the fertile ground of ignorance.
 
It's still not an answer, you're asking a question in return.
Which exact chips did they put in the DSC? Which exact chips produced spheres?
again, which ones DID NOT? did they say one or two or three chips did not produce iron and silicon microspheres? NOPE....that means they all did.
 
If they did not specify, how do you know which did, and which did not?

thats the point. all of them did.

from the paper:
"In the post-DSC residue, charred-porous material and
numerous microspheres and spheroids were observed."



can ole millette say the same about his chips?
 
What are you talking about? That someone has to read the paper. But if you are going to outsource the DSC test to someone else, make sure that lab does blind tests.



???Millette is the only one that destroyed samples with his "ashing" at 400 instead of trying to ignite them going up to 450. The ignition tests are required not the ashing, and the ignition tests do not prevent analysis because that is done before ignition.



You do not sound very certain that he will complete the paper.

Do you know why it is important that those spheres are iron while the chips had iron oxide before ignition?



One more thing Mohr, as has been noted many times, this kind of bloated farting and hand-waving displayed by some of your buddies here has nothing to do with science. I used to ignore the Bentham paper but someone pestered me for so long that when I had an opportunity to see a lecture by Harrit I did see his university lecture in a hall full of chemists and professors. The paper was taken seriously and you should try some time to see what real scientific discussions are about, instead of the hogwash seen on this forum. The paper is sound but it can still be proven wrong with more research. That will not be done by ignoring the most important result in the paper, the evidence for reduction after ignition.

Now here is a post from someone who is getting very upset about Millette's work.
Yet another truther who can't understand why Jones & Co have not given any scientific response to Millette's work.

Why do you keep begging for Millette to replicate the Bentham paper, why not beg Jones for some sort of response.

You are making yourself look a fool with your bloated farting and hand waving.

Give us a reason why your request should be taken seriously.
 
@Oystein

Either it is contamination from concrete (flyash)

Or they used flyash as a filler in paint as they did in concrete back then and still do.

Google flyash (pictures), I can't give a link yet.

Flyash consists of varius elements, and Harrit et al has found them all.
 
Fig. (27). Spheres extracted from WTC dust.

This sphere is from the dust (not the chips)

And that is flyash, no doubt about it.

Fig. (25). Spheres formed during ignition of red/gray chip in DSC, with corresponding typical XEDS spectrum (although spheres with predominately iron and some oxygen are also seen in the post-ignition residue).

This picture is not from burned chips, it is from concrete dust.

Fig. (23). Silvery-gray spheroids (left) are seen after the ignition test of red/gray chip from sample 1; some of the porous red material remains; both can be seen in the corresponding SEM image (right).

If you burn with a torch, anything will melt.

Fig. (24). Spheres formed during ignition of commercial thermite, with corresponding typical XEDS spectrum.

Why is there other elements than Al, Fe and O?
Besides the Na-peak can be Zn.
 
In paint can be found many substances: Eg. in Kaolin, which is extracted from Kaolinite, it is such. in Georgia in a big way.
Al2O3
SiO2
Fe2O3 (added to coverage / color)
TiO2 (also known as Titaniumwhiteninger)
CaO
MgO (in very small quantities)
Na2O (in fact, a pollution)
And many other substances but in very small quantities (Uranium, Thorium, Lead, Chromium, Potassium) (possibly from fly ash, which can also be mixed into the paint)
Pure Al powder (pigments) (ie elemental Al) is widely used in paints. Available at drugstore for exactly this, if you want to mix yourself.

The paint must be so tied together:

It may be cellulose, turpentine, but it can also be a mixture of 5-10% of the resin / rest turpentine, turpentine which evaporates in a short time.
The resin is returned, and it can only? dissolved by alcohol.
But not in a MEK solution, so far as I know.
Turpentine-based oil paints are not miscible with cellulose based paints, I do not know why.
But they burn well, even after they have dried up, with the vigorous development of black smoke.
 
Carsten,

we sure have noticed the similarity of those spheres with stuff found in flyash - but also with particles in other and generic ashes. What makes you so sure it has to be flyash? Do you have relevant professional and/or academic expertise in such analysis, or any references to cite?

Also, I think we should be careful to commit to a very specific conclusion as long as other possibilities aren't ruled out. That is, after all, the main error Jones and his fanboys commit when they argue that there had to be thermite because it's the "only" thing that creates "iron spheres".


Your allegation that Fig 25 (larger version of BSE image) "is not from burned chips, it is from concrete dust" is pretty strong, it almost amounts to alleging scientific fraud (the only alternative being serious confusion). So far I have argued from a base assumption that all there data really is what it is and is basically good. I have argued that their data can't be doctored because it really refutes their own conclusions. Had they attempted to fake or manipulate data such that it actually supported their conclusions, then why doesn't it? (Actually, I have doubted that Fig 17 is what they claim it is)

So, Carsten, can you substantiate that claim further? What do you see in that image that is typical for concrete dust, but isn't for burned paint with stuff attached to it?
 
Last edited:
In paint can be found many substances: Eg. in Kaolin, which is extracted from Kaolinite, it is such. in Georgia in a big way.
Al2O3
SiO2
Fe2O3 (added to coverage / color)
TiO2 (also known as Titaniumwhiteninger)
CaO
MgO (in very small quantities)
Na2O (in fact, a pollution)
And many other substances but in very small quantities (Uranium, Thorium, Lead, Chromium, Potassium) (possibly from fly ash, which can also be mixed into the paint)
Pure Al powder (pigments) (ie elemental Al) is widely used in paints. Available at drugstore for exactly this, if you want to mix yourself.

The paint must be so tied together:

It may be cellulose, turpentine, but it can also be a mixture of 5-10% of the resin / rest turpentine, turpentine which evaporates in a short time.
The resin is returned, and it can only? dissolved by alcohol.
But not in a MEK solution, so far as I know.
Turpentine-based oil paints are not miscible with cellulose based paints, I do not know why.
But they burn well, even after they have dried up, with the vigorous development of black smoke.

Carsten:
You mentioned "cellulose paints", which could be used as other kind of paints in WTC, but I should refine this stuff and perhaps I should add first some general remarks as for solubility of linear (not cross-linked) polymers.

Like for other substances, the solubility of polymers keeps the old rule "similia similibus solvuntur". We can divide polymers roughly into three categories, according to their "polarity", which is manifested e.g. by their dielectric constants.

- Non-polar polymers like polystyrene, polyolefines, did not contain any organic polar groups like hydroxyls, acyls, amides, esters, carbonyls, etc. They contain only aliphatic and aromatic non-polar moieties. Therefore they are best dissolved in non-polar solvents like toluene, fluorinated alkanes (polyolefines), but also in tetrahydrofuran (THF), which is just slightly polar solvent etc.

- Polymers with moderate polarity like polymethylmethacrylate, polyvinylacetate or esters of cellulose, with moderately polar groups like esters, carbonyls. Hence they dissolve best in moderately polar solvents like e.g. acetone, MEK, chloroform, tetrahydrofuran, but also they are sometiimes soluble in polar aprotic solvents like dimethylformamide (DMF) of dimethylsulfoxide (DMS).

- Polymers with high polarity like polyvinylalcohol, polyacryclic acid, polyacrylic acid sodium salt, or e.g. linear cellulose, bearing highly polar e.g. hydroxyl groups, acyl groups or their salts. They are best soluble in highly polar solvents like alcohols, acetonitrile, in polar aprotic DMF, DMS, but even in water sometimes (and in tetrahydrofuran).

I emphasize: all this deals with the solubility of linear polymers. Densely crosslinked polymers like epoxy in Laclede WTC primer can not be dissolved in any solvent, no matter how proper is this solvent as regards its polarity.(There are also other causes of polymer insolubility, like too strong interaction of aromatic groups in rather "exotic" conjugated polymers and "highly aromatic" polymers ("pi-stacking"), but this is out of the scope here).
Also, I can add one practical remark (after I have dissolved thousands of various polymers by myself;): by far the most universal, almost miraculous solvent for polymers is tetrahydrofuran: it dissolves many non-polar polymers as well as polar ones, including e.g. polyvinylchloride, which is otherwise soluble only in cyclohexanone.


And now back to cellulose. In paints, not cellulose itsef is usually employed, but its esters are used: nitrates of cellulose (nitrocellulose) or acetates (butyrates) of cellulose. The solubility of these stuffs depends on the degree of esterification ("concentration" of nitrate or acetate groups). With this degree increasing, the solubility in highly polar alcohol(s) decreases, whereas solubility in moderately polar solvents like acetone or MEK increases. E.g., nitrocellulose is frequently dissolved not in alcohol itself, but in the mixture of ether and alcohol (this mixture is less polar), forming viscous solution called collodion.
So we can not simply say: cellulose paint binders are soluble in alcohol(s) but not e.g. in acetone, the matter is much more complicated in fact:cool:
 
Last edited:
...one correction, nitrates of cellulose had not been frequently used in paints, they are indeed highly flammable, but they had been massively employed as films of e.g. Celluloid in movie industry. But I've tried basically to compare solubilities of these esters of cellulose, not speaking about actual applications. Nitrates of cellulose are too dangerous as paint binders:cool:
 
@Oystein

I am a Plummer/water/heat/sanitet as well as engineer in buildingconstruction* and insulator and firefighter. I also worked as carpenter(not educated though).
*I believe it is called Bachelor in structurel engineering.

The xeds spectra contain all the elements you would find in flyash.

Flyash comes from burning coal (slightly contaminated with varius things)

To make cement you start with:

65-75% CaO

20-25% SiO2

3-6% Al2O3

2-5% Fe2O3

Then is added flyash, in Denmark we startet in 1978 way behind USA. In flyash there is many toxid elements/metals like Cr,Cd,Uranium and others besides S, Na, K, Zn.

So when I read the article 3 years ago, I said to my self, they found concrete.

However all these elements is also used in paint, maybe with the exception of flyash.

But do we know, that they didn't use flyash as a filler in paint, it was a cheap filler in cement back then, still is.

If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck....... then it is a CD... to quote Niels Harrit.

"Your allegation that Fig 25 (larger version of BSE image) "is not from burned chips, it is from concrete dust" is pretty strong, it almost amounts to alleging scientific fraud."

I have googled lots of flyash/cement/concrete SEM images and the corresponding xeds spectra and in my opinion, they look as figur 25, 27 and perhaps 21.

Figur 27 is 100% flyash.

In figur 23 and 26 there are not perpectly shaped spheres.

But in figur 25 they are perfect.

Figur 24 (commercial thermite) It must have been very contaminated to start with. ( see xeds)




@Ivan

In Denmark we do use red cellulose paint as primer on steel. When I in my young days welded on a car, we used that primer. It burns very well with black smoke.

As a finishing coat on a car we also used a cellulose paint. Don't inhale, that is not healthy.

You can still buy it, but today most use waterbased paints, but they do used it on heavy steelconstructions.
 
Fig. (20). Photomicrographs of residues from red/gray chips ignited in the DSC. Notice the shiny-metallic spheres and also the translucent
spheres. Each blue scale-marker represents 50 microns.

Well spheres are here, but I mean that they were there in the first place. Now they are not covered by the carbon matrix.
And the spheres size adds up with flyash, which they don't in fig 23, 26.

Fig. (24). Spheres formed during ignition of commercial thermite, with corresponding typical XEDS spectrum.
Size is about ½ mm. It comes from fireworks or "stjernekaster" (danish word)
 
Last edited:
@Oystein

I am a Plummer/water/heat/sanitet as well as engineer in buildingconstruction* and insulator and firefighter. I also worked as carpenter(not educated though).
*I believe it is called Bachelor in structurel engineering.

The xeds spectra contain all the elements you would find in flyash.
...
So when I read the article 3 years ago, I said to my self, they found concrete.
You find the same elements simply everywhere in an urban environment, in many types of ashes, and other mixed materials where minerals and organics come together. Flyash is a possibilty, but far from the only.

However all these elements is also used in paint, maybe with the exception of flyash.

But do we know, that they didn't use flyash as a filler in paint, it was a cheap filler in cement back then, still is.
The paints we are mostly looking at here, the WTC steel primers from Tnemec and LaClede, don't have flyash specified as filler, and also no provision for unspecified filler, so I'd say it's rather unlikely they did contain flyash.

As for other paints that may end up as magnetically attracted red-gray chips, I don't know.

If it looks like a duck and walks like a duck....... then it is a CD... to quote Niels Harrit.
Yes, and he is wrong, as you know, so be careful not to jump to conclusions the same way and be wrong, too!

"Your allegation that Fig 25 (larger version of BSE image) "is not from burned chips, it is from concrete dust" is pretty strong, it almost amounts to alleging scientific fraud."

I have googled lots of flyash/cement/concrete SEM images and the corresponding xeds spectra and in my opinion, they look as figur 25, 27 and perhaps 21.

Figur 27 is 100% flyash.
Again, lots of ashes can have particles and spectra like that. Don't think that googling will give you 100% certainty!

In figur 23 and 26 there are not perpectly shaped spheres.
You realize that these two images show the same chip specimen?

But in figur 25 they are perfect.
Again, such spheres can form in many combustion events. You find them in ash from burning household waste. Those spheres in Figure 25 probably have more silicate than iron oxide (judging from their relatively dark gray shade); such spheres can form in quite ordinary temperatures.

Figur 24 (commercial thermite) It must have been very contaminated to start with. ( see xeds)
Yeah, that's one strange, implausible "thermite".
 
"… I emailed millette and told him i would provide the money for another muffle furnace test at 450C but have had no reply.

I think the guys here on the forum and Millette are afraid to go to the 430Cish temp.
"
"It does seem a little strange that he would not do this since he was heating them to nearly ignition temperature anyway."
"How can you ask someone to replicate the Bentham paper without showing them the paper? Why is it strange that Millette did not want to destroy the chips he was analyzing by igniting them? And BTW I am hoping Millette does complete his paper (he says he wants to) and that he looks at the iron microspheres and pssibkle sources."

You originally lead us to believe that Dr. Millette would attempt a replication of the most salient tests performed by the Bentham Paper scientists.

And then you pretended to be just as fooled as the rest of us, when days before his research presentation, Dr. Millette made it clear he had absolutely no intention of performing DSC testing.

This is particularly strange Chris when considering your claim of having discussed the ability to do DSC testing with dozens of other labs.

Dr. Millette had the same access to the Bentham Paper as anyone with a decent Internet connection. Just the fact that he did not attempt any Resistivity Testing or Heat testing above 400C on the red layers points to his clear lack of interest in following the Paper.

Dr. Millette did not have to completely destroy the chips. He could have divided chips and only performed destructive testing (heated above 430C) on half, leaving the remaining halves for comparison.

Again, such an approach was obvious, but Dr. Millette risked making a discovery which would not be particularly good for his business relationship with the U.S. Government.

Hoping that Dr. Millette will do the right thing now would seem to be little more than trash talk.

I suspect that given his easy access to WTC dust samples, the ease in which he could isolate chips of interest with Resistivity testing, and the fact that he could easily set his oven to +430C and observe the ignition residue, that he has already done some of this testing and knows what a Pandora's Box it is.

MM
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom