mikegriffith1
Muse
- Joined
- Sep 25, 2012
- Messages
- 805
Back to the radio silence myth again. The main "evidence" for the claim of radio silence is Japanese testimony. But the Japanese lied about all kinds of things after the war.
The Japanese solemnly swore that they had no spies on Hawaii. But years later this was proven false when Takeo Yoshikawa, Tokyo's official spy at the Hawaiian consulate, went public with his story.
The Japanese said that the Hawaiian consulate never sent Tokyo any information on the Pearl Harbor fleet. But this tale was later debunked.
The Japanese said that no Kido Butai documents survived the war. But this turned out to be another falsehood.
Some members of the task force said the weather was calm and clear for the entire trip. But at least one other KB member refuted this, and we know from weather reports that there was severe storm activity in the North Pacific for several days shortly before the attack.
And all this is not to mention that we have hard evidence that the task force broke radio silence. For example, we know that one of the submarines assigned to the Kido Butai sent a radio message advising that there were no American warships at the Lahaina anchorage. At the time Lahaina was an alternative anchorage to Pearl Harbor. We know that the Japanese had hoped that some ships would be at Lahaina; they believed that the anchorage was so deep that sunken ships would be unrecoverable.
Plus, there is a mass of credible anecdotal evidence that American, British, and Dutch intelligence units intercepted messages from or about the task force and were aware of its location.
I've discussed and documented other evidence against radio silence in previous replies.
The Japanese solemnly swore that they had no spies on Hawaii. But years later this was proven false when Takeo Yoshikawa, Tokyo's official spy at the Hawaiian consulate, went public with his story.
The Japanese said that the Hawaiian consulate never sent Tokyo any information on the Pearl Harbor fleet. But this tale was later debunked.
The Japanese said that no Kido Butai documents survived the war. But this turned out to be another falsehood.
Some members of the task force said the weather was calm and clear for the entire trip. But at least one other KB member refuted this, and we know from weather reports that there was severe storm activity in the North Pacific for several days shortly before the attack.
And all this is not to mention that we have hard evidence that the task force broke radio silence. For example, we know that one of the submarines assigned to the Kido Butai sent a radio message advising that there were no American warships at the Lahaina anchorage. At the time Lahaina was an alternative anchorage to Pearl Harbor. We know that the Japanese had hoped that some ships would be at Lahaina; they believed that the anchorage was so deep that sunken ships would be unrecoverable.
Plus, there is a mass of credible anecdotal evidence that American, British, and Dutch intelligence units intercepted messages from or about the task force and were aware of its location.
I've discussed and documented other evidence against radio silence in previous replies.