WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

You miss the details and cannot see the big picture. The DSC alone does not identify thermite, it is used along with XEDS to confirm the thermite reaction aka the iron reduction: This is the actual test to verify presence of thermite, and no competent researcher can ignore it. Maybe you will "get it" one of those days, I doubt it, but I still leave this comment for the benefit of others.

If Millette cannot repeat the igniton tests to check out the composition of the molten spheres, his paper is useless. If he is not going to do this I think Mohr should inform people of that, and maybe start to think about refunding money to those he had told Millette would replicate the Bentham tests.

Lol jtl

Isn't it about time you revealed your true identity and your scientific qualifications.

Oh that's right, you have seen a lecture by Harrit of which he starts by saying We believe. But then again he believed that before he started looking and Jones believed the same by looking at the towers :D

And all of this because he believes that building 7 was hidden from the public :D

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SC3Se86IBAw&feature=youtube

The above is pretty long an boring as you would expect but what I find interesting is that Harrit does not actually mention that the paper was published in Benthan Science.

The last 30 mins is more about thermite although Harrit is very careful not to go into detail.
 
You miss the details and cannot see the big picture. The DSC alone does not identify thermite,
Harrit et al. don't actually use the DSC-results to support their argument. Everything about the actual DSC-results, the curve and the specific energy derived from it, is actually a big problem for them.

They just abuse the DSC as an expensive way to simply burn the chips. You can do the same with a lighter. Or the way Basile did.

it is used along with XEDS to confirm the thermite reaction aka the iron reduction: This is the actual test to verify presence of thermite, and no competent researcher can ignore it.
Can you please name and cite one (1) competent researcher who has ever done research on any kind of thermite, who has ever used that method to confirm the thermite reaction? Thanks.

You might, perhaps, consult the reference Harrit et al. provide in the context of this DSC test, which apparantly they found to be competent precedent:

[28] Tillotson TM, Gash AE, Simpson RL, Hrubesh LW, Satcher JH, Jr, Poco JF. Nanostructured energetic materials using sol-gel methodologies. J Non-
Cryst Sol 2001; 285: 338-345. [Accessed February 7, 2009]. Available from:
http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc...serid=10&md5=96168ef14a007c2cc1dee1667b0d1b2f

Can you quote from this paper the passage that explains which method these authors use to confirm the thermite reaction? Is it "DSC along with XEDS"? Did they look for spheres in the residue? Thanks.
 
Well, "songs remain the same"...
Shortly after publishing of Millette's preliminary report, it was clear that those microspheres remain the "weapons of the last resorts" for nano-truthers, no matter that Millette determined only kaolinite as a source of Al signals in XEDS spectra.

It would be simply good to heat some of the red/gray chips with proven kaolinite in the red layer in some oven up to 700 degrees C and look at the ash with some good microscope.
If some microspheres are formed from the gray layer (or at least some rounded objects), this would be very nice end of our story, even without detailed XEDS and without DSC or other calorimetry:cool:

Jtl still thinks that reduction of iron oxide is possible only by thermitic reaction, which is of course a childish nonsense, but even without any exact explanation, such a finding (microspheres are created) would be simply great.

I can perform such simple experiments (heating and microscopy) in my institute, but this would require some samples from Jim Millette with proven kaolinite.

(As a kind of reminder, here is a microphotograph of my Laclede paint imitation after heating up to 700 degrees C (the whole picture measures around 200 micrometers):

picture.php


Even in that epoxy "paint" (containing iron oxide and aluminosilicate in the same proportion as in Laclede primer) without any gray layer, some rounded and shiny objects are perhaps visible, after heating up to 700 degrees under air... but magnification/resolution was not good enough, since I used the ordinary optical microscope easily available in the lab of my friend here.)
 
Last edited:
...
(As a kind of reminder, here is a microphotograph of my Laclede paint imitation after heating up to 700 degrees C (the whole picture measures around 200 micrometers):

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=854&pictureid=7411[/qimg]

Even in that epoxy "paint" (containing iron oxide and aluminosilicate in the same proportion as in Laclede primer) without any gray layer, some rounded and shiny objects are perhaps visible, after heating up to 700 degrees under air... but magnification/resolution was not good enough, since I used the ordinary optical microscope easily available in the lab of my friend here.)

Ivan,

1. Image is 200 µm across - and 800 px. So that is ca. px/µm, right? A sphere of 2 µm would be 8x8 px, a 10 µm sphere 40x40 px. I think we'd see that.
2. Anyway, we all think it is more likely that Harrit's spheres came from the gray layer. So I don't even expect to find any when you burn just paint.
3. Can you do the same thing with some steel scale? I could send you some weathered and rusted steel wire if you can't find anything like that yourself :p Heat some without paint, and some with; look at both samples before and after heating
 
Oystein: I am well aware that Bentham microspheres were probably formed from the gray layers (at least mostly);) I posted my micrograph of my Laclede imitation ash basically to demonstrate how "treacherous" is the "microworld" for us and how easily can be some rounded shiny objects seen in some ash or so...

Last several weeks (basically after the jtl "intrusion" here), I have thought several times: well, why not to prepare some other Laclede primer imitation, now casted as a thin layer on some steel with grayish (not red) rust? As regards sources of such rust, we in Prague have available at least the same amount of rusted steel as you in Germany (e.g. in the yard of my institute), so no need to send me samples so far;)
Heating of the paint imitation on rust scales would be trivial, as well as some optical microscopy (with a better microscope than that used for micrograph above), so I would not spend much of time on it.
I'm just skeptical in advance that I would be so very lucky man and even in my not really close imitation of Bentham chips, microspheres would be really formed after heating...
But let me suppose that microspheres are really formed in such samples. Would it really convince any single truther (except those few who basically understand the stuff, like ScootleRoyale or Poseidon)? In other words: does it make any real sense to perform such simple experiments?
 
Last edited:
...
But let me suppose that microspheres are really formed in such samples. Would it really convince any single truther (expect those few who basically understand the stuff, like ScootleRoyale of Poseidon)? In other words: does it make any real sense to perform such simple experiments?

It sure would make sense to me - we have proposed several mechanisms by which roundish shapes may appear in iron oxide, even reduced iron, but we have no actual evidence that any of those really do happen in such paint-on-steel-scale flakes. As you say, that is "their" last resort, to say "but you can't explain those microspheres!"

When you can create such spheres from paint on scale without any Al, then this is a result we can always point to. Jones has asked more than once "do you do experiments?" When we do, we can say "yes", and when we find spheres, we can point to them.

Even if you can't do XEDS (and XRD and whatever it takes to really ID them), it still would be a great lead with which we can go for example to Mark Basile and say "look, can you reproduce this?"
We can go to Millette and say "hey, can you do the same?"
 
Oystein: In principle, there is no problem in my institute to perform even XEDS and XRD measurements, we have several machines in house, but it would indeed require some more or less official request or grant or so.

If you think that such basic experiments on Laclede imitation would make some sense at least for us, I will look for some suitable rusted steel next days. And you could basically do the similar in Germany.
Just buy some ordinary epoxy resin, powdered red iron oxide (hematite) and kaolinite, weigh them on some portable scale (this one frequently used for weighing of e.g. cannabis would suffice:rolleyes:) look for some suitable rusted steel, cast the epoxy composite on the rust... etc. Later, I could heat your samples together with my samples...
 
Last edited:
But... I'm still very skeptical, Oystein.
We should not forget (provided that Bentham chips heated in DSC were Laclede chips) that Laclede primer was applied by electrophoresis (electrocoating), therefore the surface steel layer was exposed to very specific conditions during paint job and perhaps it is oxidized/chemically transformed into some specific, perhaps "passivating" form of "rust" (as has been pointed here e.g. by BasqueArch)...

Then, only really suitable "rust" would be this one which was exposed to electrocoating as well.
 
Ivan, I really have no access at all to any instrument; best I could do is find a simple microscope, probably even without camera attached. Also, I have two left hands and would get very aggressive trying and failing to work such tiny specimens :p

If you don't want to do it, I'll respect that - and of course you are right that it would take quite a bit more to make an argument that convinces even truthers. If truthers were ever convinced by merely "good" arguments, they wouldn't be truthers.
 
Since I am having fun today with XEDS simulations, here some more.

This is about Steven Jones's claim that the 'chips of interest' contain lead (chemical symbol: Pb), and that Millette is looking at the wrong chips when he doesn't find any lead.

He made such a claim here:
http://911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses
ProfJones said:
...
6. Jeff notes that in his TEM analyses he observed “very small (nanometer-scale) Pb particles in the TEM samples” as well as strontium and chromium in small amounts. (Much of the TEM analysis was performed at higher magnification than used in the SEM analysis done in the paper.) Thus, red/gray chips which match ours will show these same elements under TEM analysis.
I (Dr. Jones) have searched Millette's plots and see no indication of strontium (Sr) or lead (Pb) in his samples, but he does report titanium (Ti) which we do not see. Thus, his samples do not appear to be the same material as what we reported on.

So Jones implies and claims that Pb is typical for ALL "thermitic" chips they studied in the Bentham paper.

Of course he can't know this:
  • They haven't done TEM analysis on the MEK-soaked chip
  • They definitely haven't done TEM-analysis on the chips they burned in the DSC
  • It is not known that Jeff Farrer still had chips a-d to study in the TEM, so we at least don't know that he found Pb in any of those
  • I am pretty sure he doesn't know Farrer's TEM data and has no idea in which chips Pb is found, how much, how often...

In fact, they must have thought that all these chips did NOT contain lead, for otherwise, why would they stress (on page 28) that "We have observed that some chips have additional elements such as potassium, lead, barium and copper". "Additional" means: The other chips don't have lead.
In that context, they point out one chip which also looks very different for very obvious reasons:
Harrit et al said:
An example is shown in Fig. (31) which shows significant Pb along with C, O, Fe, and Al and displays multiple red and gray layers.
Since they didn't do any TEM for the Bentham study, they must have identified the Pb in that multilayer chip with SEM-XEDS. And figured that this chip was different in that regard.


Now how much Pb is "significant" - how much (or how little) can be detected by SEM-XEDS? That's what I simulated next.

First for LaClede paint (71.5% epoxy, of the rest, 55% is iron oxide, 41% Al-silicate, 4% strontium chromate). Here is an XEDS of clean LaCkede at the standard 20 keV:

LaClede-MCsimulationofbulk20kV_zps9720787e.png


The M-alpha-Level of Pb would be just under 2.4 keV. Let's add 0.1 wt% Pb to the LaClede formula:

LaClede01Pb-MCsimulationofbulk20kV_zpsb033047e.png


That's a region of high noise ("Bremsstrahlung") where the Pb (M-alpha) would show. Difficult to tell here.


How about 0.2 wt% Pb?

LaClede02Pb-MCsimulationofbulk20kV_zps73bc2bef.png


Yes! Now it's clearly visible!


At 0.5% the Pb-peak grows in prominence (link)


Now, the LaClede paint has little in the way of detecting Pb near 2.4 kV. I tried the same with my Tnemec formula with 11% gypsum and some potassium. Comparing that Tnemec with and without an additional 0.2% Pb:

Tnemec3Cont2vsTnemec3Cont202Pb_zps42f5735d.png


The sulfur-peak (K-alpha level) at 2.3 keV sits almost on top of the Pb-signal, and it's a bit difficult to see the difference, but it's there, and I think the EDS software that comes with the lab equipment should have no trouble sorting it out.


So all the chips that Harrit et al. studied with SEM-EDS for the Bentham paper must have had Pb-levels under 0.2 wt% - except for that exception which they did NOT use for their conclusions. As Pb is a very heavy atom and most usefull Pb-compounds are very much dominated by the weight of it (64% in lead chromate, for example), this means that these chips also had less than 0.4% lead compounds. This has to be contamination and not a feature of "nano-thermite".
 
@ Chris Mohr:

Sorry for posting lots of large images. I am on a roll! :D

Here is a possible suggestion to Millette (or any researcher interested in analysing the chips):

Remember we think that many chips with a clean Al-Si-Fe-Signal may be LaClede paint - which ALSO contains strontium chromate, but this latter compound has so far been pretty elusive for Millette? At least as far as I know.

One problem is always that Strontium is difficult to detect with SEM-EDS: It has only one peak under 10 keV, and that sits smack under the silicon-peak, where it hides perfectly from view.
It has two more peaks near 14.2 keV and 15.8 keV, but those are so far out on the graph, and these energies so high, that SEM-EDS at the "standard" beam energy of 20 keV generates very little signal out there, which tends to get lost in the noise.

I am a layman, and I feel almost stupid to make such a proposal to Millette, but - couldn't he try to scan chips at higher beam energies? Again, at 20 keV, it produces practically a flat line beyond 10 keV.

But at 40 keV, Strontium should be unmissable at the 0.5% level that I'd expect it to be there. See:

LINK

Even more prominent if the same data is shown on a logarithmic scale:

LaClede-MCsimulationofbulk40kV-Logarithmicresized_zps087de0ed.png
 
Oystein: As regards Pb, I think it is not necessary to analyze in detail inconsistent "rumours" reported by Jones in some blog (and in Bentham paper as well).

But, your suggestion that Jim Millette could use a higher bombarding energy, when looking for strontium chromate, sounds interesting:cool:
 
Last edited:
Oystein: As regards Pb, I think it is not necessary to analyze in detail inconsistent "rumours" reported by Jones in some blog (and in Bentham paper as well).
...

I had promised Chris to tell him all the "reason" Jones invented to reject Millette's findings, and this is one of them. So the long explanation is mainly for Chris to understand why this "we found Pb (lead), Millette did not" is humbug:

- Pb-compounds aren't that hard to find, as long as there is >0.2% Pb in the mix
- They did not find any Pb in all of the "important" chips in their study, and have thus not establiched that they all do contain Pb
- Finding Pb was hence not a selection criterion
- And Jones most likely doesn't know, though he implies, that Farrer finds Pb vie TEM in all of the chips

Dang, we need to talk to Farrer...
 
Oystein:
Your quote of Jones is quite interesting (I will delete irrelevant parts):

"6. Jeff notes that in his TEM analyses he observed... strontium and chromium in small amounts....
I (Dr. Jones) have searched Millette's plots and see no indication of strontium (Sr) or lead (Pb) in his samples..."

Funny. Whereas truther Jeff Farrer very probably found some strontium chromate, for which we are looking for, "our" scientist Jim Millette found nothing:confused:

I really would like to see those Farrer's data indicating Sr and Cr...
 
Oystein you're much less of a layman than I am! Good work. It's a very interesting puzzle and you are providing some useful pieces to it all.

In the meantime I have received no useful reponses to my open questions on two chemistry blogs asking for a chemist to objectively read and respond to the Bentham Paper and the Millette Preliminary Report. So JTL's suggestion that I seek someone out I can sit down with personally may be the best solution. Finding people to talk to about this is tough though, as I have said. By the time I had talked with 14 physicists, I had also talked with dozens of others who had refused to talk with me at all. I expect the same rejection rate from chemists. Also, to give a fair reading to both papers will take several hours. It's not like just asking a physicist how much more dynamic load the falling 12-foot floor of a building has over its static load, for example.
 
Last edited:
Kminek: Well, "songs remain the same"...
Shortly after publishing of Millette's preliminary report, it was clear that those microspheres remain the "weapons of the last resorts" for nano-truthers,

Misrepresenting the Bentham paper and the truther perspective is not a scientific way to debunk them. Anyone able to understand the Bentham paper can see that the main point is to demonstrate that a thermite reaction takes place, and the culmination is the presence of molten iron spheres after ignition. Calling this the "weapon of last resort" is not fitting for someone with your credentials Kminek.

no matter that Millette determined only kaolinite as a source of Al signals in XEDS spectra.

Harrit et al found chips in which the MEK treatment leaves behind unbound aluminum in still hard chips, while Millette has chips that become soft with MEK and without any unbound aluminum. Why?
Millette has not replicated the ignition tests and scrutinized the composition of the spheres reported by Harrit et al, which means there is no challenge to their results.
If Millette´s paper makes it through peer-review this way, Harrit et al will be able to debunk it with one page letter. If given the opportunity, they might even publish this discussion letter in same issue at the same time as Millette´s paper.

Jtl still thinks that reduction of iron oxide is possible only by thermitic reaction, which is of course a childish nonsense,

This comment of yours is childish nonsense for the same reason as your "the song remains the same" comment above. You know perfectly well that I know there are other possibilities of reduction. Those options however, are not really relevant to the conditions presented in Bentham paper as has been discussed here previously. Amnesia seems to be a common problem on this forum.

One of the sobering realizations I have made, coming to this forum, is that none of you have ever made any experiments to back up your claims. I am still hoping it is possible to get those spheres "normally" with the DSC, but as I told you before, talk won´t do it no more.


but even without any exact explanation, such a finding (microspheres are created) would be simply great.

It is truly amazing that the Bentham paper was published almost four years ago, and that this "it´s paint" debunking explanation has existed the whole time without anyone having done any experiment to show that it is possible to get those spheres from burning paint.

But after getting to know the hogwash routine and amnesia problems on this forum, it is looking less and less amazing. It is also quite disturbing to see that you all have actively tried to discredit and avoid the ignition tests.
 
Misrepresenting the Bentham paper and the truther perspective is not a scientific way to debunk them. Anyone able to understand the Bentham paper can see that the main point is to demonstrate that a thermite reaction takes place, and the culmination is the presence of molten iron spheres after ignition. Calling this the "weapon of last resort" is not fitting for someone with your credentials Kminek.



Harrit et al found chips in which the MEK treatment leaves behind unbound aluminum in still hard chips, while Millette has chips that become soft with MEK and without any unbound aluminum. Why?
Millette has not replicated the ignition tests and scrutinized the composition of the spheres reported by Harrit et al, which means there is no challenge to their results.
If Millette´s paper makes it through peer-review this way, Harrit et al will be able to debunk it with one page letter. If given the opportunity, they might even publish this discussion letter in same issue at the same time as Millette´s paper.



This comment of yours is childish nonsense for the same reason as your "the song remains the same" comment above. You know perfectly well that I know there are other possibilities of reduction. Those options however, are not really relevant to the conditions presented in Bentham paper as has been discussed here previously. Amnesia seems to be a common problem on this forum.

One of the sobering realizations I have made, coming to this forum, is that none of you have ever made any experiments to back up your claims. I am still hoping it is possible to get those spheres "normally" with the DSC, but as I told you before, talk won´t do it no more.




It is truly amazing that the Bentham paper was published almost four years ago, and that this "it´s paint" debunking explanation has existed the whole time without anyone having done any experiment to show that it is possible to get those spheres from burning paint.

But after getting to know the hogwash routine and amnesia problems on this forum, it is looking less and less amazing. It is also quite disturbing to see that you all have actively tried to discredit and avoid the ignition tests.

Yep the " The song remains the same "

What I find interesting is that jtl claims that Harrit will be able to debunk Millette with a one page letter ? Which leaves the question of, why is jtl still here "singing the same old song" :D

Jtl is not sounding to confident to me.

LMFAO what a hogwash truther routine
 
Misrepresenting the Bentham paper and the truther perspective is not a scientific way to debunk them. Anyone able to understand the Bentham paper can see that the main point is to demonstrate that a thermite reaction takes place, and the culmination is the presence of molten iron spheres after ignition. Calling this the "weapon of last resort" is not fitting for someone with your credentials Kminek.



Harrit et al found chips in which the MEK treatment leaves behind unbound aluminum in still hard chips, while Millette has chips that become soft with MEK and without any unbound aluminum. Why?
Millette has not replicated the ignition tests and scrutinized the composition of the spheres reported by Harrit et al, which means there is no challenge to their results.
If Millette´s paper makes it through peer-review this way, Harrit et al will be able to debunk it with one page letter. If given the opportunity, they might even publish this discussion letter in same issue at the same time as Millette´s paper.



This comment of yours is childish nonsense for the same reason as your "the song remains the same" comment above. You know perfectly well that I know there are other possibilities of reduction. Those options however, are not really relevant to the conditions presented in Bentham paper as has been discussed here previously. Amnesia seems to be a common problem on this forum.

One of the sobering realizations I have made, coming to this forum, is that none of you have ever made any experiments to back up your claims. I am still hoping it is possible to get those spheres "normally" with the DSC, but as I told you before, talk won´t do it no more.




It is truly amazing that the Bentham paper was published almost four years ago, and that this "it´s paint" debunking explanation has existed the whole time without anyone having done any experiment to show that it is possible to get those spheres from burning paint.

But after getting to know the hogwash routine and amnesia problems on this forum, it is looking less and less amazing. It is also quite disturbing to see that you all have actively tried to discredit and avoid the ignition tests.
Hmmm... I hired Jim Millette to do a bunch of experiments, and along the way, several others have done smaller experiments to demonstrate a particular point. On the 9/11 Truth side, there are certainly a few experimenters: the Harrit/Jones team, Basile, Cole, to some extent David Chandler. Not all that many people on either side have experimented much, to be honest. JTL what experiments have you done to back up your claims? It seems to me that many claims here at JREF are actually backed up in some way (not all, to be sure, but more than you seem to be willing to give them credit for). I think it's time you acknowledge that your global assertion, "none of you have ever made any experiments to back up your claims" is simply false. Please acknowledge this inaccuracy.
 
Stick to the point.

"Harrit et al found chips in which the MEK treatment leaves behind unbound aluminum in still hard chips, while Millette has chips that become soft with MEK and without any unbound aluminum. Why?
Millette has not replicated the ignition tests and scrutinized the composition of the spheres reported by Harrit et al, which means there is no challenge to their results."

How much clearer could questions of anomalies in the tests BE? Yet Chris Mohr answers "Hmmm... I hired Jim Millette to do a bunch of experiments, and along the way, several others have done smaller experiments to demonstrate a particular point."

So what. The point is, Millette is being called on not doing ignition test replication and that his chips didn't react the same way in MEK! Which serves notice on the entire Millette conclusion. Those are the specific questions you are being tasked to address.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom