gold bull/bear survey

Where do you think the gold price is going?


  • Total voters
    138
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/178525169998512db5.jpg[/qimg]
That's a great graph, but you got the time frame wrong. First Sell Off and Bear Trap occurred in 2008, and New Paradigm peaked in 2011. We have just passed Return to "Normal", are now entering Fear.

Capitulation will be brutal.
 

Attachments

  • anatomy of a bubble.gif
    anatomy of a bubble.gif
    11.7 KB · Views: 6
Ramjets - please attempt to provide evidence for your otherwise meaningless and incorrect assertions. we have seen 20%+ and over corrections over and over again in the 13 year gold bull run.

the fact that you think that 2008 was a "bear trap" is quite amusing, there I was thinking it was savage liquidation across ALL asset classes on the way towards the end of the financial system itself..

but yes, it was a "gold bubble bear trap" wasnt it :D

perhaps you think the Fed and other global CBs are going to start reducing their balance sheets voluntarily at some point?

or that a 95% correlation is insignificant?

puppycow said:
How about this one:
Gold Falls Most in Five Months as Cyprus to Sell Metal

thats one of the nonsense stories I referred to. 13.9 tonnes of Cypriot gold is such a tiny amount as to be meaningless. and if Cyprus sell their gold it is certain there will be Central Banks worldwide clamoring for it.

Remember Cyprus’s 13.9t of official gold reserves? The recent “correction” in GLD’s holdings has forced it to dump a staggering 169.8t of gold bullion simply to keep GLD shares’ price tracking gold! We are talking about 5.5m ounces of gold here, from this single American ETF! There are only two gold-mining companies in the entire world (Barrick and Newmont) that produce that much gold in a whole year!

http://www.marketoracle.co.uk/Article39924.html

Gold has faced stiff headwinds lately as investors abandon alternative investments to chase record-high stock markets. Probably the most significant has been the major selling hammering the flagship GLD gold ETF. It has suffered such intense differential selling pressure that its custodians have been forced to dump enormous quantities of physical gold. What are the implications of this flood of new supply?

The amount of gold bullion GLD has hemorrhaged recently is amazing. To put it into perspective, earlier this week the rumor that embattled Cyprus may be forced to sell its official gold reserves made news. The Cypriot government owns 13.9 metric tons of gold. But on a single trading day alone in February’s gold capitulation, GLD had to sell 20.8 tonnes! The supply recently added by GLD dwarfs everything else.

dow-gold.png


there was basically no news or events, just a huge sustained (paper) selling attack until the floor finally broke out.
 
Last edited:
"recovery"

so this story about investors believing we are "recovered" lol, most of them probably do.. ..like they did in 2010 (green shoots) and 2011 and 2012..

the facts seem slightly different from the endless hopium parroted throughout MSM.

I dont actually know how any rational person can look at these charts and come to that conclusion

12 WTF charts

8 more WTF divergences

never mind the stunning (to the hopium addict anyway) series of macro data misses in the last month

US Economic Data Plunges Most In 10 Months To 4-Month Lows

Judging by the stock markets the last two weeks have been one of the best periods ever but the reality - hidden behind a smoke-screen of central bank liquidity and jawboning mirrors is dire. The last ten days have seen miss-after-miss in macro economic data - in fact this is the biggest plunge in macro data in 10 months. Despite the stock market's exuberance (at all-time highs), macro data has rolled over dramatically to 4-month lows. Of the major economic data points we have missed 18 of the last 20. With sentiment sagging, GDP revising lower, and earnings season disappointing, we can only imagine the BTFD opportunities that await.

Markit US PMI Miss
ISM Manufacturing Miss
ISM New York Miss
Vehicle Sales Miss
ADP Employment Miss
ISM Services Miss
Challenger Job Cuts Miss
Initial Claims Miss
Trade Balance Beat
Non-Farm Payrolls Miss
Hourly Earnings Miss
NFIB Small Business Miss
Wholesale Inventories Miss
MBA Mortgage Apps Miss
Import Prices Miss
Initial Claims Beat
Retail Sales Miss
PPI Miss
UMich Confidence Miss
Business Inventories Miss

The disconnect yawns ever wider...

yup, all looking Rosy here, just like 2010 (QE2) 2011 (QE2.5 or Op twist), 2012 (QE3 to infinity and beyond) .. :D

herd.png


edit: and speaking of "This Time" and the differences, here's somebody who has studied this quite deeply last week..

http://www.spiegel.de/international...einhart-on-financial-repression-a-893213.html

'The Crisis Isn't Over in the US or Europe'

-Carmen Reinhard - April 10th 2013
 
Last edited:
I'm still somewhat amused at all this.

Charts like these show the past.

Much of what you post is better called "post-dictions".

For someone like me, nearly any explanation of a move after the fact is suspect.

Take this one: "Dow was up strongly yesterday on good job numbers".

Or how about this one: "Dow was up strongly yesterday in spite of weaker than expected job numbers".

Or "Gold plunged yesterday amid Cyprus selling".

Or "Gold spiked yesterday as Cyprus fears lessened."

With rare exeception, these post hoc "explanations" of moves in markets are wild guesses, and probably have nothing to do with the move. Unless the move could have been predicted, its realy unhelpful to assign explanations after the fact.

One can look at tea leaves or I Ching sticks or Tarot cards and find "patterns" and attempt to predict the future. Sometimes those predictions will pan out, sometimes not. We're pattern-seeking animals and are wired to find patterns that may or may not be there.

Any chart you can show me of gold in the past informs me very little of gold going forward. Gold could go to $3,000 or $300 in the next few years. Again, when silver went to $50 originally, "chartists" could look at that run and predict higher highs - which many did. Similarly with the first run of gold to $800.

For predictive validation, show charts that predict the future price of gold and then correlate them with real performance. And don't be tempted to just select from the 50% that called it right - that's the "cherry picking" we always need to be alert for.

Or just make real predictions, as in "Gold will be up tomorrow as Cyprus fears ease" - and then show me a predictive rate that consistently outperforms chance.

In any case, my prediction remains that gold Monday will either be up (reason to be announced after the fact) or down (reason to be announced after the fact) or will be flat (reason to be announced after the fact).

What do the charts tell you?
 
Last edited:
I'm still somewhat amused at all this.

Charts like these show the past.

Much of what you post is better called "post-dictions".

For someone like me, nearly any explanation of a move after the fact is suspect.

Take this one: "Dow was up strongly yesterday on good job numbers".

Or how about this one: "Dow was up strongly yesterday in spite of weaker than expected job numbers".

Or "Gold plunged yesterday amid Cyprus selling".

Or "Gold spiked yesterday as Cyprus fears lessened."

With rare exeception, these post hoc "explanations" of moves in markets are wild guesses, and probably have nothing to do with the move. Unless the move could have been predicted, its realy unhelpful to assign explanations after the fact.

One can look at tea leaves or I Ching sticks or Tarot cards and find "patterns" and attempt to predict the future. Sometimes those predictions will pan out, sometimes not. We're pattern-seeking animals and are wired to find patterns that may or may not be there.

Any chart you can show me of gold in the past informs me very little of gold going forward. Gold could go to $3,000 or $300 in the next few years. Again, when silver went to $50 originally, "chartists" could look at that run and predict higher highs - which many did. Similarly with the first run of gold to $800.

For predictive validation, show charts that predict the future price of gold and then correlate them with real performance. And don't be tempted to just select from the 50% that called it right - that's the "cherry picking" we always need to be alert for.

Or just make real predictions, as in "Gold will be up tomorrow as Cyprus fears ease" - and then show me a predictive rate that consistently outperforms chance.

In any case, my prediction remains that gold Monday will either be up (reason to be announced after the fact) or down (reason to be announced after the fact) or will be flat (reason to be announced after the fact).

What do the charts tell you?

I agree with most of what you've said here, ie the MSM have either no idea, or only what they have been fed, as after the facts reasons for everything.

however I am not looking at charts in this instance as the fundamental reason for owning gold moving forwards, I believe several things that lead me to the conclusion that the same reasons for owning PMs apply now as all the way through the last 10+ years.

1. there is no recovery.

2. negative real interest rates and money printing is bullish for metals

3. this will only change, when there is a real recovery, which cannot happen until the real losses everywhere are recognized.

4. governments will do everything in their power by temporarily re-writing the laws of maths and physics (like they always try) to prevent (3)

5. ultimately it will play out the way it always does.

ie this time is not different.

what happens to "price" in the meantime is anyone's guess.

chart-wise, a good trader I know wrote this yesterday, this is what *should* now happen if you believe in technicals. maybe it will.

Big,classic descending triangles on dailies brokedown finally, this is not a time to be averaging down imo. Momentum players are back in heavy, pirates with knives between their teeth emerging from the waves and hacking away between the scapulas of the once proud metals.

Whats in play is the short side now. I am small short now and will short bounces, I am recalling Armstrong projecting 12-1300 areas and the weakness in the chart confirms that as a possibility, there has been sea change in perception of metal over the last year and many dissappointed investors who do not want to be left holding the bag after a long multi-year climb are understandably pissed off.

The race for the revolving glass exit door has begun and several hapless casualties were already squashed in the turnstiles as the pigmen grunted and squealed on their way out the other side. The game now is about capital preservation and survival pure and simple.

We are in Momentum Land now and the Market in M.Land is cruel and unforgiving. Silver headed to 22 now, triangle break just today. Pull up a monthly chart. Next targets are in the 22-18 zone imo and the pirates will be out in force i think on every bounce and leveraging every down move.

but it doesn't change the underlying fundamentals or supply/demand picture one little bit, and when the shorts have finally had their fill, OR real world events interfere and they wake up to an $80 surge one morning as gold has quite often done in the past just when everybody had thrown in the towel, the shorts buying back into the market will drive it just as violently upwards again.

none of this changes the fundamentals underneath it, and (IMO) if people cannot see that TPTB want to keep the public in their bank accounts and out of the metals for a reason, then they can join the shearing/slaughtering queue with the rest of the flock.

because I am virtually certain that anyone that bought at $1650 and sold at at sub $1500 will have the pleasure of seeing it run again (without them) one day that will clearly show on these charts above.

Bull Markets do their best to throw you off, that's how it works.

After spending many years in Wall Street and after making and losing millions of dollars I want to tell you this: It never was my thinking that made the big money for me. It always was my sitting

The big money is made by the sittin' and the waitin' – not the thinking. "

Jesse Livermore
 
Last edited:
FWIW I think this is much closer to the truth than anything you will ever hear from the MSM.

We shall see.
 
I have a silly question.

Assuming the economy collapses entirely and money becomes worthless, what makes gold bugs think they can actually get their hands on the gold they "own" ? Do you know where the gold is, and how do you think you can take possession of it in a world without laws to back you up ?

I mean, if the economy doesn't collapse, there's always a way to make fiat money work (by fiat), so gold ostensibly is only useful if the whole thing goes down, but in that case... how do you get your gold ?
 
Last edited:
I have a silly question.

Assuming the economy collapses entirely and money becomes worthless, what makes gold bugs think they can actually get their hands on the gold they "own" ? Do you know where the gold is, and how do you think you can take possession of it in a world without laws to back you up ?

I can only speak for myself, I'm not your "Mad Max" type doomer. As bad as I think things will get economically, I think the primary threat to my gold is from Government theft, not roaming gangs of AK47 wielding outlaws.

and legally they currently can't get at it. However as they are prone to rewrite laws to steal stuff as/when required, it would be naive of me to assume that I will definitely escape that if it happens, but forewarned is forearmed.

most proper doomers hold only physical in their own possession, getting at it isn't the issue, but potentially converting it's value back into (whatever) could well be.

I mean, if the economy doesn't collapse, there's always a way to make fiat money work (by fiat), so gold ostensibly is only useful if the whole thing goes down but in that case... how do you get your gold ?

dont agree with the highlighted part, if it doesnt "all go down" people have still done extremely well with contrarian (at the time) investment into it this last decade by understanding fundamentals, its characteristics and history
 
Last edited:
Hum... although I'd think that, in an apocalyptic scenario, lands and guns will be far more useful than gold. ;)

and say you had a few billion in various paper type investments right now, you'd need to buy a LOT of land to store $5billions worth of guns, eh.. :D
 
Big,classic descending triangles on dailies brokedown finally, this is not a time to be averaging down imo. Momentum players are back in heavy, pirates with knives between their teeth emerging from the waves and hacking away between the scapulas of the once proud metals.

Whats in play is the short side now. I am small short now and will short bounces, I am recalling Armstrong projecting 12-1300 areas and the weakness in the chart confirms that as a possibility, there has been sea change in perception of metal over the last year and many dissappointed investors who do not want to be left holding the bag after a long multi-year climb are understandably pissed off.

The race for the revolving glass exit door has begun and several hapless casualties were already squashed in the turnstiles as the pigmen grunted and squealed on their way out the other side. The game now is about capital preservation and survival pure and simple.

We are in Momentum Land now and the Market in M.Land is cruel and unforgiving. Silver headed to 22 now, triangle break just today. Pull up a monthly chart. Next targets are in the 22-18 zone imo and the pirates will be out in force i think on every bounce and leveraging every down move.

I think there's as much meaning in the above as in a horoscope or Tarot reading.

...none of this changes the fundamentals underneath it...

Ummm...

...exactly? ;)
 
I think there's as much meaning in the above as in a horoscope or Tarot reading.

I am hoping so, a monster rebound next week would be pretty funny :D

he is however an ex pro institutional trader, independent for the last 10 years so most likely has more clue about it than I.

Ummm...

...exactly? ;)

haha well I have laid out exactly what I think those are above, but you only seem to want to pick at chartism, not why I bought in the first place nor the (my) macro overview moving forwards?

I just dont see us "growing" out of this and reverting to 2005 style "normality" without encountering some major bumps in the road sinkholes first, ..do you?

edit. some more from Tarot man with slightly less artistic language

Chart reading is the only guide and it is never completely reliable. We has descending triangles on the daily,weekly and monthly charts that have all broken down thru their bases on High volume.

Other people read charts too. Wolves, hyenas,7 ft. SpearMen roaming the plains of the Serengeti, Norse marauders,the 9th SS Panzer Division,BlackBeard and crew,etc. All opportunists have recognized technically what has just happened. Blood is in the water, buckets of it. Soon we will hear from the Fibonacci nerds.

A 50% retrace in Gold to 900 will be parroted along with the 62 and 78% numbers that they worship. In this hyper-tech age when accessibility is widespread, the technology of the trade is all and the speed in which its inevitability can unfold is sometimes surprising.

Hope for the best but prepare for the worst. I think now that all rallies and bounces will be shorted by the bigger players at least until the long descending trendlines in metals are taken out on explosive volume.
 
Last edited:
Basic tenet:

Barring some sort of "inside information"...

EVERY single bit of information you're processing to come to your conclusions, including the charts,is readily available to EVERYONE.

As such, that information is always factored into the current and projected price of anything.

I will stipulate that one may gain a small advantage through intuition or ability to organize the information.

For instance, you may want to play coffee futures. You have found out about a coffee bean disease that has just begun to be a problem. If you found out about it, anyone else could have, and that's already factored into the price. But you may intuit that the problem is greater than stated, and buy futures on that intuition.

But I really don't think you know anything about silver or gold that the market doesn't know as well - which is why the prices are where they are.

It seems to me the bulls are probably right in the long term, but I've been wrong often enough not to ever bet on it. Just gradually accrue and have a hyper-inflation insurance policy just in case.

But That's Just Me! (tm)
 
Last edited:
Basic tenet:

Barring some sort of "inside information"...

EVERY single bit of information you're processing to come to your conclusions is readily available to EVERYONE.

As such, that information is always factored into the current and projected price of anything.

whilst it may be available, it would be just silly to think that everyone has processed it all in time to act as they would like to, in an ideal world, IMO.

because if this were always the case, then nobody (or everybody?) would have made billions shorting subprime and nobody would have been caught in the housing bubble?

the majority of herd never see anything coming (like Bernanke btw, unless he's just a professional liar)

yes, some other interested individuals may have been researching and found the same information, but real world events can drive millions more to do so in a few days, millions who weren't ever even looking outside of their daily grind until said real world events arrive and spur them.

so whilst I understand what you're saying, I do think you give the omnipotent and random market thesis too much credibility, especially given current stresses and distortions by extraordinary CB actions.

the regular winners will carry on winning as they always have, and the rest of the participants with access to all the (public) information in the world they can be bothered to research will carry on losing, as they always have.

markets can be very stupid in the face of the obvious for a long while.

(and if I wake up to £450 gold tomo am, you can count me in on the stupid losing side in the face of the obvious, after a goodish winning streak :) )
 
Last edited:
Chart reading is the only guide...

I call BS.

"Value" investors who go by fundamentals can do quite well and never consult a chart. I would wager that the average "value" investor outperforms the average technical analyst/chartist over time.

...and it is never completely reliable.

Take away the word "completely", and I can pretty much agree!:p
 
I call BS.

"Value" investors who go by fundamentals can do quite well and never consult a chart. I would wager that the average "value" investor outperforms the average technical analyst/chartist over time.

Take away the word "completely", and I can pretty much agree!:p

he is talking to other traders there, not giving public advice in the FT :D

and define average? average investors likely make average gains or average losses along with the mean/median no?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom