Merged Silver Over 40.00 / Real and fake prices

How does the ongoing shortage of silver for industrial use factor into all this? Apple (IIRC) had to delay production on certain products recently due to lack of silver.

and speaking of Apple, boy what a bear market that sucker's in eh? all those AAPL fanbois got slaughtered didn't they. bubbleheads lol :D

minus 39% in a year, that load of twerps are sooooo toast. wonder how low it will go? a rapidly spiking silver price would likely finish off what is left of their fast diminishing margins and Google will buy them out.

theres a sucker born every minute eh

note, this is about how silly I view the "it's over for gold" opinions as. in fact the far fetched scenario above is more likely in my opinion.
 
and so much for Apps eh? ..because of course the fundamentals are all so entirely different now, as opposed to a week last Tuesday :D

I was, of course, theorizing an app that could determine the value of silver at any given time.

Not in the future, which I still hold is unknowable.

Poring back over this thread and the Gold Bull one just confirms that for me.
 
and speaking of Apple, boy what a bear market that sucker's in eh? all those AAPL fanbois got slaughtered didn't they. bubbleheads lol :D

minus 39% in a year...

Way to cherry pick a time frame.

How about someone who bought at $10 about a decade ago and sold a portion recently at $550?

Someone I know very well (;)) did exactly that.

If a 55-bagger is "getting slaughtered", then please slaughter me more often.

To a day-trader, I suppose a one year time frame is ridiculously long. Investors tend to think longer term, is all.
 
Last edited:
Way to cherry pick a time frame.

How about someone who bought at $10 about a decade ago and sold a portion recently at $550?

Someone I know very well (;)) did exactly that.

If a 55-bagger is "getting slaughtered", then please slaughter me more often.

To a day-trader, I suppose a one year time frame is ridiculously long. Investors tend to think longer term, is all.

not at all, and you miss the intended irony in my comments amigo. Apple is a solid business albeit with increasing margin compression problems, but the stock got way ahead of itself. A correction was duly required, it will bottom somewhere, base, and most likely revert to the long term mean trendline.

reversion to the mean at some point is just about the only absolute in markets, as far as I understand it.

with regards cherry-picking, it is a well used tool of the "antigoldnutter brigade", and I wasn't really cherry-picking in this instance, I was intimating that the kind of comments I made about Apple is how CNBC are talking about gold like, as we speak.

Interestingly, they don't talk about Apple like that, which as you can see has actually corrected much more deeply, and so if the commentary was unbiased in anyway, is exactly what we should be hearing from the stock-pumping bubbleheads.

Im sorry if you (or anyone) got personally burnt, but if you got in at $10 you're still laughing and well done. Buying into Apple at $550 and not timing it right is no different from buying into gold at $1650 in Aug 2011 and not timing it right.

Modern markets exist, basically to take money from the herd as efficiently as possible. Get used to it would be my best advice.
 
Is silver up to $20,000 an ounce yet? :dl:

I heard a commercial yesterday for one of those gloom and doom companies predicting that the price of silver would double this year, and to BUY NOW because this is their lowest price ever!

Of course, not mentioned was that this is their "lowest price ever" because silver is at the lowest price ever in the existence of this company because the value is going down.
 
Is silver up to $20,000 an ounce yet? :dl:

I heard a commercial yesterday for one of those gloom and doom companies predicting that the price of silver would double this year, and to BUY NOW because this is their lowest price ever!

Of course, not mentioned was that this is their "lowest price ever" because silver is at the lowest price ever in the existence of this company because the value is going down.

"the value is going down" of course, it is definitely 20% less valuable than last week. at least 20% less uses for it.

20% less demand at the mint :rolleyes:

less valuable to the more easily influenced, maybe.

but who knows, maybe youre right. after all there must be a reason somebody (naked, obviously) short sold the next 100 years production on the Futures in a single day.

gotta know something, huh?
 
Last edited:
I suppose it depends on how the value of an ounce of silver is made up.

- A proportion of the value is the intrinsic value as an industrial metal.
- Part of it is its value as an investment.
- Part of it is the premium (or discount) based on sentiment (hedging)
- Part of it is the premium (or discount) based on speculation

Presumably the fall from $40+ to current levels represents some change to those last three elements although there may also be lower industrial demand. It may just mean that the hedging and speculation premium is smaller (in the same way that 30% froth has been removed from the Apple share price).
 
Apple is a solid business albeit with increasing margin compression problems, but the stock got way ahead of itself. A correction was duly required...

There was a time when Apple first broke $100, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $200, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $300, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $400, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $500, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $600, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $700, and some were saying that then.

Whenever the "inevitable" correction occurred, in hindsight the prognosticators at any given "top" could tell us how overpriced Apple obviously had been prior to the correction, and all the reasons why.

Problem is, last time I looked, prognosticators were supposed to foretell the future, not the past. :p
 
Last edited:
There was a time when Apple first broke $100, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $200, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $300, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $400, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $500, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $600, and some were saying that then.

There was a time when Apple first broke $700, and some were saying that then.

well as of today when it was trading with a 3 handle again, the last 4 lots on your list have been proven right (-43%)

Whenever the "inevitable" correction occurred, in hindsight the prognosticators at any given "top" could tell us how overpriced Apple obviously had been prior to the correction, and all the reasons why.

Problem is, last time I looked, prognosticators were supposed to foretell the future, not the past. :p

ah, now here I have got you. :D for I knew there was Apple trouble coming, not through my own research, but through, well let me introduce you to Reggie. He a bit full of himself, but with his track record, so would I be.

how far back would you have liked to have known it was coming, 2011?

Monday, 14 February 2011 17:00
Apple Gears Up To Combat The Margin Compression That Apparently Only It, Google & Reggie Middleton Sees Coming

2010? a clear 8 quarters ahead?

9th August 2012 ($630) only a week or two to go what kind of timescale notice would suit you?
 
I have a question or two about the cost pf producing gold and silver. In this thread and another thread kevsta linked to claims that the current market prices for gold and silver are very close to the cost of production (mining) the same. Hence, one might think that producers might halt production until prices recover. Obviously no-one in going to do something that is unprofitable for very long. Here are the relevant posts with parts of the quotes reproduced too:
also, the longer the price stays anywhere near these levels, the more extreme the rebound must be, given that the cost of production per Oz is at or higher than market price.

The true cost of mining silver

The first thing silver investors should note is that the true cost to produce an ounce of silver (excluding write-downs) was $23.68 for 2012, which is around a 7% increase in costs over 2011.

The true silver cost of $23.68 is much higher than the reported "cash costs" (under $10 for most miners) and gives silver miners very limited profit at current silver prices ($28-29 per ounce). This gives investors a much better picture that aligns with silver miner share prices and earnings, which have both been dropping. When considering these margin pressures this drop in share prices makes sense.

Not only are silver costs giving silver miners very slim margins, but they are also still rising (7% year-over-year) which makes it an exceptionally tough environment for silver miners. In our opinion, this cost pressure is related to the true inflation rate (much higher than government manufactured CPI) and that is also why we expect cost pressures to continue into 2013. Slim margins should continue into 2013 without a significant rise in the silver price.

Fourth quarter numbers give investors a much better picture of the direction silver costs are headed, because they represent the most recent costs for the industry. At first glance, fourth quarter costs of $23.04 look like the industry is lowering the cost of producing silver from the annual average of $23.68. But after this cursory glance, investors will notice that taxes paid in 4QFY12 was significantly lower than both 4QFY11 and the average amount of taxes paid for 2012, which totaled $210 million (the low fourth quarter taxes was primarily due to a large tax adjustment assessed to SSRI).

When taxes are normalized to $50 million (the quarterly average for the year), production costs rise to $24.70 per ounce which would support our estimates that 2013 will see more rising costs for the silver industry.

we are now below the cost of production, supply will start going offline quickly if this persists, so one would think that cannot last very long in any correctly functioning marketplace? (either that, or we all just learn to do without it instead)

the next thing that happens is the producers start buying up supply that is below their cost base as a straight arb trade.

you are all absolutely certain that this is it now are you? over. bubble burst? and you know this what because Fox or CNBC told you?

perhaps somebody might even explain their reasoning for a change? make some predictions of your own.

how low do you think it can or will go? lower than it costs to produce? for how long? :rolleyes:
At Monday’s closing gold price of US$1,361 an ounce, margins in the industry have become razor-thin for established producers. In fact, some analysts argue that many of them are underwater.

The industry recently introduced an “all-in” cash cost metric to try to capture the rising cost of producing an ounce of gold. It showed the costs for senior producers are between roughly US$950 and US$1,300 an ounce. But critics of the “all-in” approach point out that it does not account for corporate taxes or development capital. If those are included, the real cost of production is significantly higher.

Put simply, by driving up costs and driving down prices, the market is insisting that companies produce less gold.


I told you, we're all going to have to pay you to come take the useless stuff away soon, and the miners can pay for the privilege of mining it too. and lets get the oil producers to sell that for less than it costs to produce too while were at it.

I think you're all just trolling, because there doesn't seem very much coherent thought going on.

However, I question these numbers because only 10 years ago, the prices for each of these metals were well below the alleged current costs of production, even if you discount for inflation. Has it really become that much more expensive to mine gold and silver than it was 5 or 10 years ago. I understand of course that there has been inflation in the meantime (about 25% cumulatively), but the market prices of gold and silver are still up over 300% since 10 years ago. Have the costs of mining gold and silver doubled or tripled or quadrupled in ten years?
 
Have the costs of mining gold and silver doubled or tripled or quadrupled in ten years?

It's quite possible, for the same reason that oil production costs have risen: when the price of the product rises, it becomes economically feasible to start mining/pumping reserves whose production costs were previously deemed too high.
 
I have a question or two about the cost pf producing gold and silver. In this thread and another thread kevsta linked to claims that the current market prices for gold and silver are very close to the cost of production (mining) the same. Hence, one might think that producers might halt production until prices recover. Obviously no-one in going to do something that is unprofitable for very long. Here are the relevant posts with parts of the quotes reproduced too:

However, I question these numbers because only 10 years ago, the prices for each of these metals were well below the alleged current costs of production, even if you discount for inflation. Has it really become that much more expensive to mine gold and silver than it was 5 or 10 years ago. I understand of course that there has been inflation in the meantime (about 25% cumulatively), but the market prices of gold and silver are still up over 300% since 10 years ago. Have the costs of mining gold and silver doubled or tripled or quadrupled in ten years?

yes. its the combination of dramatic (but not counted obviously) commodity inflation as mining is very energy intensive, combined with fast declining ore grades meaning more and more earth needs to be dug, driven out of the basin, pulverized etc to produce the same amount 1 Oz.

http://www.bnamericas.com/news/metals/global-gold-cash-costs-hit-record-in-2012-barclays

Gold production cash costs were the highest on record in 2012, rising by 13.1% to US$673/oz, mainly due to higher costs in South Africa, according to Barclays Capital analyst Christopher Louney.

Marginal cash costs rose by 15.2% y/y to $1,104/oz. "Although cash costs are rising, we do not expect the curve to provide the floor for prices in the near term given that marginal cash costs are also well below gold's spot price," the analyst wrote. "Even after adding in sustaining capital expenditures, which we estimate at more than US$200/oz for the industry, headroom remains, but the mining environment remains challenging."

Barclays is forecasting an average gold price of US$1,646/oz in 2013.
The highest cash costs in the world according to Barclays data are in South Africa (US$1,141/oz), followed by Australia and New Zealand (US$909/oz) and Ghana (US$883/oz).

In South America, Brazil is ranked highest with US$741/oz, Peru is second (US$519/oz) with Argentina coming in third (US$312/oz).
Although the base of gold cash costs is set to rise, the scope for greater upside risk in 2013 is through labor-related supply disruptions, according to the analyst.

The gold cash costs compiled by Barclays comprise production costs per mined ounce of gold, excluding capital expenditure. The bank's database accounts for around 35% of global mine output. The main omission is China due to a lack of reported data.
 
buying spree continues..

According to today's data from the US Mint, a record 63,500 ounces, or a whopping 2 tons, of gold were reported sold on April 17th alone, bringing the total sales for the month to a whopping 147,000 ounces or more than the previous two months combined with just half of the month gone.

the BTFD crew out in force, worldwide
 
Last edited:
It's quite possible, for the same reason that oil production costs have risen: when the price of the product rises, it becomes economically feasible to start mining/pumping reserves whose production costs were previously deemed too high.

yes. its the combination of dramatic (but not counted obviously) commodity inflation as mining is very energy intensive, combined with fast declining ore grades meaning more and more earth needs to be dug, driven out of the basin, pulverized etc to produce the same amount 1 Oz.

http://www.bnamericas.com/news/metals/global-gold-cash-costs-hit-record-in-2012-barclays

buying spree continues..

According to today's data from the US Mint, a record 63,500 ounces, or a whopping 2 tons, of gold were reported sold on April 17th alone, bringing the total sales for the month to a whopping 147,000 ounces or more than the previous two months combined with just half of the month gone.

the BTFD crew out in force, worldwide

Interesting. Thanks.
 
ah, now here I have got you. :D for I knew there was Apple trouble coming, not through my own research, but through, well let me introduce you to Reggie. He a bit full of himself, but with his track record, so would I be.

how far back would you have liked to have known it was coming, 2011?



2010? a clear 8 quarters ahead?
Good call by him.

But do you know who Joe Granville is?

He successfully and famously predicted at least one market top, and people started following him. Yet as the Wikipedia entry states, his overall success rate isn't all that great.

Unless Apple continued to increase to infinity, eventually there had to be a top. And inevitably, of all the analysts out there, some would have called it.

But some would not have.

Then we just have to try to see whether those that got it right did so by chance - with enough analysts making predictions, even if tops are unpredictable some will get it right. Or if the particular analyst has some insight that allowed him to see market influences that others missed.

I'm open to both possibilities. But beware the "hasty generalization" - this guy got this one right, therefore he knows what's going on. Maybe he does, maybe he doesn't.

I assume I got stopped out yesterday on my stop loss at $400. Gives me a chance to rebalance a portfolio that ended up way overweighted in Apple. I still think its a good company and eagerly await the next "insanely great" thing from them. Fun to watch, in any case!
 
Good call by him.

But do you know who Joe Granville is?

He successfully and famously predicted at least one market top, and people started following him. Yet as the Wikipedia entry states, his overall success rate isn't all that great.

Unless Apple continued to increase to infinity, eventually there had to be a top. And inevitably, of all the analysts out there, some would have called it.

But some would not have.

Then we just have to try to see whether those that got it right did so by chance - with enough analysts making predictions, even if tops are unpredictable some will get it right. Or if the particular analyst has some insight that allowed him to see market influences that others missed.

I'm open to both possibilities. But beware the "hasty generalization" - this guy got this one right, therefore he knows what's going on. Maybe he does, maybe he doesn't.

fortunately, what with Reggies almost unbearable bragging, his past record is not hard to find. Reggie in the News

he is in fact extremely good, and virtually always right, because he does almost certainly the most in-depth analysis of the balance sheets and modeling, I've ever seen on the web anywhere.

he is really on the case about the Irish banks at the moment, lets wait and see if it blows up as an issue again imminently.

I assume I got stopped out yesterday on my stop loss at $400. Gives me a chance to rebalance a portfolio that ended up way overweighted in Apple. I still think its a good company and eagerly await the next "insanely great" thing from them. Fun to watch, in any case!

haha I didnt know you had a "bug" thing going on of your own..

here u go, especially for you, brothers in bear markets :D

17852516eeb83ba52f.png
 
Last edited:
interesting.. growing price divergence on physical silver vs futures price

http://www.kitco.com/ind/Hamlin/20130418.html

Ignore COMEX Pricing – Silver Eagles Sold Out at Dealers, $33 on Ebay
Thursday April 18, 2013 09:53

The silver price has taken a beating over the past week, dropping 18% from $28 to $23. Or at least that is what the COMEX is telling us. In reality, the price of silver is nowhere close to $23. Don’t believe me? Try to find silver coins for sale anywhere in the free market at that price.

Most major bullion dealers are once again sold out of silver eagles, including my local dealer and some of the main online dealers that I use. The following is a screenshot from Tulving.com, which often has the lowest premiums over spot price for gold and silver coins. Notice that Tulving is completely sold out of silver eagles, 90% silver half dollars and even generic silver rounds. The only silver coins from this page that are still in stock are 90% junk silver dimes and quarters. Just a few short months ago, they used to sell at or near the spot price, but now sell for a premium of $4.49 per ounce!

But wait, I thought the silver spot price was just $23? Even with a significant premium of 15%, the price should only be $26.45. But APMEX is apparently able to sell them for a 37% premium or nearly $32 due to high demand and tightening supply from mint rationing. Even then, the coins are on backorder and you will have to wait until they become available at some time towards the end of the month.
Selling of paper Comex contracts on Friday, April 12th, and Monday, April 15th, totaled 1 million contracts, exceeding global annual gold production by 12%. The attack succeeded when the technical support in the low $1500’s/oz. easily gave way and led to waves of forced selling. The volume is without precedent and has all the characteristics of a panic liquidation driven by naked short selling.

What I find particularly interesting is that on April 1st of this year, when silver was trading at $28/ounce on the COMEX, silver eagle rolls were selling for just above $650 on Ebay or $32.50 per ounce. Fast forward to today when the silver price has supposedly crashed by over $5 in two days time and a roll of silver eagles is selling for around $640 on Ebay or $32. So the true free market pricing for silver has only dropped about $0.50 per ounce in the past few weeks, not $5.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom