Are the Markets all Manipulated or not?

I will read the post later but from what I have read is that financial markets are rigged so that the biggest players move their shares first. That means they get the best deal while the smaller players move when the stocks are at their highest.
Which is a good thing.

When the big guys aren't getting in first and coordinating their movements to provide some stability, it leaves the market at the mercy of the little guys. That's the time to worry, because then you truly have chaos, and anything could happen. That might be OK for those gamblers who enjoy playing the stock market or dabbling in commodities, but do we really want the entire financial system to be chaotic?

kevsta said:
I would want my retirement payout to be a bit less fickle than that.
Me too. That's why I'm keeping my funds in a boring term deposit. Low interest, low risk, fixed worth, guaranteed payout. But hey, it's your right to gamble with your future...
 
Allow me to call your bluff.

You haven't been "riding piggyback" on anything, nor has it been "quite profitable" for you.

Why do I know this? Because I know how the market works, and I know this kind of advantage, when it exists, is limited and extremely short-lived. It's the nature of the market.

Your claims are false.

well, my strategy is the same in principle, but "extremely short lived" is incorrect, because the professional money is forced to trade like they do, always have and always will.

now I'm not claiming the 75k is real money, however I am stating that I think a sample set of over 100 trades in 10 weeks would not have produced these results if there wasn't something to it?

if you do indeed know how the market works you will also know what I am saying is true, ie its most unlikely this happened by chance?

and so while I have been learning this, I watch the advanced guys in the Skype room nailing it all day long. if he is one of those guys, then you could well be wrong here.
 
well, my strategy is the same in principle, but "extremely short lived" is incorrect, because the professional money is forced to trade like they do, always have and always will.

now I'm not claiming the 75k is real money, however I am stating that I think a sample set of over 100 trades in 10 weeks would not have produced these results if there wasn't something to it?

if you do indeed know how the market works you will also know what I am saying is true, ie its most unlikely this happened by chance?

and so while I have been learning this, I watch the advanced guys in the Skype room nailing it all day long. if he is one of those guys, then you could well be wrong here.


Sorry for the cliché, but extraordinary claims (and beating the market like has been claimed, "advanced guys" or not, is extraordinary) require extraordinary evidence. Will that be forthcoming?
 
Last edited:
Sorry for the cliché, but extraordinary claims (and beating the market like has been claimed is extraordinary) require extraordinary evidence. Will that be forthcoming?

ok, well we agree on the extraordinary, because it is without doubt extraordinarily difficult to not go backwards all the time.

evidence, from G6000 you mean, or me?
 
ok, well we agree on the extraordinary, because it is without doubt extraordinarily difficult to not go backwards all the time.

evidence, from G6000 you mean, or me?

I don't understand what you mean by your first sentence, sorry.

Anyway, you're both claiming to be able to beat the markets on a fairly consistent basis, right?

I call BS on that. On both of you.
 
I don't understand what you mean by your first sentence, sorry.

what I mean, is that if you open a $100k demo account, it is extraordinarily difficult to make the figure go up, not down, consistently.

and here, you clearly agree with that?

Anyway, you're both claiming to be able to beat the markets on a fairly consistent basis, right?

I call BS on that.

lets get this straight, I'm not claiming to be master guru or anything, I only started approx 16 months ago, but I am a fast learner. however I am claiming that it is indeed *possible* and that the reason for that is the regular manipulation, and trading off it.

evidence, well I was putting the monthly figures up as we went along, the image on the previous page is just Feb, Mar & April all on one long image. but I have been showing the month-by-month live testing figures as already discussed quite a bit in other threads

Feb the funniest thing about this, is February's trading was actually truly awful, technically. the fact it produced +10% in a month aside, probably 50% of those trades I shouldn't have taken at all, and 80% of the other 50% were poorly executed and could have done much better.

you might look at this and think "impossible", "faked", "liar" - or whatever makes you happy, but I'm looking at it thinking this is really poor, it could have been +225% instead of +75%, because I know every single bad trade or execution and wrong move I made.

the point is, EVEN with my poor trading skills, its potentially profitable. this is not down to chance, IMO.

March in March I started getting more selective, you can see, less trades, bigger profit.

April in April the trend continued..

and also from the ECN account trading just currencies, start point 3000Eu, so 392 Eu is +13% on that in the same time period?

I'm in a phase over period now, small live account which has been on pause the last 2 weeks due to other commitments, but I want to continue proving the system to myself on life-size demo account/s as im splitting up trading activity ie different things on different systems for easier analysis of what I should be focusing on.

..and if you do understand markets, you should also notice that the majority of the winning amounts on this account are USA500 (S&P) and they are SELLS. ie, in the period the S&P has gone UP from 1480 to 1580, I have shorted the manipulation daily and potentially removed +75% account size while trading it against the primary trend.

IF I had just gone long at 1480 (like the rest of the world) and walked away for 3 months, I would not be claiming the ability to extract money from obvious manipulation moves, but hopefully you can see there was a little more involved than that?

its not a big secret or anything, this is the site that opened my eyes, (last Sept / Oct) and the realtime figures are above. what other evidence can I give you?

 
Last edited:
Blah blah blah blah blah....demo account....blah blah blah

Translation: play money.

In a related story, I've made billions playing Monopoly!!!!
 
Blah blah blah blah blah....demo account....blah blah blah

:rolleyes: you really dont like evidence do you?
EVIDENCE THAT PROVES A CONCEPT IS POSSIBLE, USING MANIPULATION.
Translation: play money. I dont have the faintest idea what you are talking about, but you are not a billionaire like Big Wazza and goldbugs are stupid jew haters

ftfy

In a related story, I've made billions playing Monopoly!!!!

frankly I find that extremely difficult to believe.
 
Blah blah blah blah blah....demo account....blah blah blah

Translation: play money.

In a related story, I've made billions playing Monopoly!!!!
I was a play money millionaire on Full Tilt Poker before it was shut down, which of course means I'd be a millionaire playing for real money!
 
Oil Market Manipulation

nope, nothing to see here, move along..

Energy pricing: the market is manipulation Nov 2013
As an oil industry whistleblower, I know the energy sector is even more flawed than this week's exposé of gas prices reveals

The Guardian's investigation into the alleged "Libor-like" fixing of UK gas prices was doubly ironic for me. The first irony is that, as director of compliance and market supervision of the International Petroleum Exchange (now ICE Futures Europe) in the 1990s, I was heavily involved in the development and legal architecture of the gas-market contract that has now allegedly been manipulated.

The second painful irony is that in 2000 the Guardian published detailed allegations made by me on very similar micro-manipulation of the International Petroleum Exchange's Brent futures contract-settlement prices. This systemic manipulation was so pervasive that traders referred to the on-exchange profits they made at the expense of the manipulators – who profited "off-exchange" – as "grab a grand".

....

Unfortunately, I described the manipulation as "systematic" – taken to mean that some of the players were routinely manipulating the price most of the time – rather than "systemic", where most of the players manipulate the market some of the time

One thing I have come to realise since my failed attempt at whistleblowing is that the short-term trading exposed this week is only part of the problem. The malaise runs much deeper. If you want to find out who really has an interest in rigging the market, ask who benefits from medium- and long-term high commodity prices: it's the producers, stupid. From De Beers' diamond hoarding to coffee-grower cartels, if the history of commodity markets tells us anything it's that if producers can find leverage to support commodity prices, they will.

The real problem in the energy market lies not with gas, but crude oil – which is suffering perhaps the greatest market manipulation the world has seen. This is due to financialisation of markets which began in crude oil about 12 years ago, but only became significant from around 2005 onwards.

To understand what happened to oil, we just need to look at the Enron scandal. The fundamental scam perpetrated here was based on an ancient financing method known as "prepay". Quite simply, this occurs when producers sell their product at a discount for cash now, with delivery later.

So via intermediary banks such as JP Morgan and Citigroup, Enron were able to opaquely obtain "off-balance sheet" financing disguised as commodity trades
of which Enron's investors and creditors were blithely unaware.Essentially, Enron was borrowing dollars and lending commodities.

The presence in the market of middlemen who have an interest in volatility and opacity means that we have now reached a stage where market manipulation is no longer an aberration: the market is the manipulation

and oh look, classic stuff, Washington just found some brown people to blame :rolleyes:

http://secureenergy.org/create-cont...oil-market-manipulated-resulting-higher-volat

WASHINGTON April 25, 2013 – The global oil market is significantly influenced by un-free forces such as a producers’ cartel and as a result is not a free market, says a new report authored by economists Andrew Morriss and Roger Meiners and published by Securing America’s Future Energy (SAFE). The report, “Competition in Global Oil Markets: A Meta-Analysis and Review,” was released today at an event at the Cato Institute in Washington, DC. To read the report, please click here. For a summary of key highlights, please click here.

The members of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) control the world’s largest and most accessible petroleum resources, and have undertaken a collaborative effort to maximize their collective profits through output restrictions over the past four decades. In this academic analysis, Morriss and Meiners provide an overview of the many market failures which exist in the global oil market, and a comprehensive literature review which presents a consensus: the international market for oil is not free.

Key findings of the paper include:
• OPEC has at times successfully forced oil prices higher than a free market would dictate;
• OPEC’s market manipulation harms the U.S. economy and directly costs Americans money by causing higher gasoline prices;
• The “non-free” nature of the oil market causes increased price volatility, which is particularly problematic for U.S. businesses.
 
I was a play money millionaire on Full Tilt Poker before it was shut down, which of course means I'd be a millionaire playing for real money!

hello strawwildcat. the aspect of this thread you and your donkey are continually harping on about is immaterial. that is only my opinion, backed by evidence, mind of daily manipulation in currencies.

whether or not it is real money is one of the strawiest straw things I have ever seen here, the difference is simply which number I select from the platform login dropdown. if you had 2 accounts, one live and one demo for the same amount, it is impossible to tell between them in useage. identical in every way.

so in my (considerably better informed than the JREF double act) opinion, it does however lean towards one of several likely conclusions.

1. The Markets are not manipulated, and I was just lucky across 3 different accounts, across 10 weeks of consistent trading. If any of the geniuses here can repeat the same within the next 5 years, I would be willing to consider this as more likely.

2. The markets are not manipulated, but if you just treat them as though they are, you can win consistently. This is just a happy cosmic coincidence that nobody else has worked out yet. (except for the xx thousand people trading this system anyway) ..This is what I think is most likely.

3. er..? :rolleyes:

you people can snide comment all you like, what you cannot do is disprove the figures or the concept. you would of course have to understand what you're looking at first anyway lol. ..once again, if any of you think you can do better, please do show me how it is done for a few weeks, just go here, you can be up and running in 5 mins, markets open at 10GMT 5EST.

I cannot wait :rolleyes:

and until anybody has the faintest idea what they are talking about with Forex, lets get back to the actual OP?
 
Last edited:
So is anyone going to discuss the article in the OP or are we content to just post fallacies?

Considering who the author is, it isn't worth reading or discussing. I'm not sure if it is dishonesty or not understanding the subjects he writes about but Taibbi routinely relies on inaccurate claims to support his conspiracy theories.
 
Considering who the author is, it isn't worth reading or discussing. I'm not sure if it is dishonesty or not understanding the subjects he writes about but Taibbi routinely relies on inaccurate claims to support his conspiracy theories.

He's particularly popular with gold bugs and POtards. As a result, this thread should probably be in the CT section.
 
Blah blah blah blah blah....demo account....blah blah blah

Translation: play money.

In a related story, I've made billions playing Monopoly!!!!

Someone uses $100k in fake money to play the market for a year or two and makes 100% profit thanks to a claim of manipulated markets.
Someone else does the exact same thing with $100k in real money placing the exact same bets also based on the same claim of manipulated markets.

Please tell me how one is relevant and the other is not with regards to whether they were successful based on their claim of manipulated markets?

I was a play money millionaire on Full Tilt Poker before it was shut down, which of course means I'd be a millionaire playing for real money!

Same terrible argument.

Of course!!! The evil Big Oil(tm) companies have been colluding with each other for decades. That's why the price of oil keeps going up and up and up, and never comes down.

Oh......wait....

So oil companies haven't been caught colluding numerous times in the last several decades?

Considering who the author is, it isn't worth reading or discussing. I'm not sure if it is dishonesty or not understanding the subjects he writes about but Taibbi routinely relies on inaccurate claims to support his conspiracy theories.

And now you are making the same fallacy that was used in the first few replies to this topic.

The presenter of an idea is not the idea. Even if the presenter is untrustworthy the idea can still have merit. So discuss the ideas being presented in the topic. If you don't want to then why are you here? It's really simple. Not interested in discussion, don't post.

Not one person in here has even attempted to discuss the content and evidence Kevsta has posted. Too busy patting themselves on the back for blatantly mocking people.
 
Someone uses $100k in fake money to play the market for a year or two and makes 100% profit thanks to a claim of manipulated markets.
Someone else does the exact same thing with $100k in real money placing the exact same bets also based on the same claim of manipulated markets.

Please tell me how one is relevant and the other is not with regards to whether they were successful based on their claim of manipulated markets?

Wow. Please tell me this is not a serious question. I didn't see a winking smiley.

So oil companies haven't been caught colluding numerous times in the last several decades?

No, they haven't. Unless you plan on providing an extensive list.
 
And now you are making the same fallacy that was used in the first few replies to this topic.

The presenter of an idea is not the idea. Even if the presenter is untrustworthy the idea can still have merit. So discuss the ideas being presented in the topic. If you don't want to then why are you here? It's really simple. Not interested in discussion, don't post.

Not one person in here has even attempted to discuss the content and evidence Kevsta has posted. Too busy patting themselves on the back for blatantly mocking people.

thanks for noticing that.

Wow. Please tell me this is not a serious question. I didn't see a winking smiley.

yes, it is a serious question, try and answer it seriously with your admittedly limited knowledge. You cannot.

you are by definition also attempting to argue then that backtesting (running automated algos over hundreds or thousands of hours of previous market data to establish win loss ratio) is also not valid, because it isnt done with real money? moronic argument.

the platform is the same, the data feed is the same, the broker is the same, the trades are the same. the only difference is which number you log into.

so please do inform me why these figures over hundreds of hours trading are invalid and disprove my thesis?

would Randi take me up on the million$ challenge do you think? :rolleyes:

be much quicker than trading my way to it lol.

He's particularly popular with gold bugs and POtards. As a result, this thread should probably be in the CT section.

lulz. once again we have a thread full of evidence nobody wants to discuss and the usual pseudo skeptic behaviour in full view.

as a side note, when considering the liklihood or possibility of my actually having learned this, people really ought to think a little more carefully about my other job, (I taught myself) which is manipulation of "adjusting" results from the other side of the fence.

the opponent there is not unlike the market, they have a good few $billion in hardware, software, like 000's of PHDs, and yet..
 
Last edited:
And now you are making the same fallacy that was used in the first few replies to this topic.

The presenter of an idea is not the idea. Even if the presenter is untrustworthy the idea can still have merit. So discuss the ideas being presented in the topic. If you don't want to then why are you here? It's really simple. Not interested in discussion, don't post.

Not one person in here has even attempted to discuss the content and evidence Kevsta has posted. Too busy patting themselves on the back for blatantly mocking people.

I don't have to read Taibbi's article to know that he doesn't use evidence, but like most prominent conspiracy theorists, he is gifted at making it seem like he does to his gullible readers. Let me guess, quote mining coupled with embellishment from Taibbi about what they meant which is almost never accurate and mentions of actual investigations/indictments/convictions coupled with embellishments from Taibbi that make actual crimes or alleged crimes seem like they are much bigger in scope than they actually are, in Taibbi fantasy land if one bank employee anywhere ever commits a crime it is a worldwide conspiracy of epic scope that all bank employees are guilty of. Further, if government investigators do not find evidence of his predetermined conspiracy views it means that they are involved in the conspiracy. Every Taibbi article is the same, once you have read one you have read them all.
 
I don't have to read Taibbi's article to know that he doesn't use evidence, but like most prominent conspiracy theorists, he is gifted at making it seem like he does to his gullible readers. Let me guess, quote mining coupled with embellishment from Taibbi about what they meant which is almost never accurate and mentions of actual investigations/indictments/convictions coupled with embellishments from Taibbi that make actual crimes or alleged crimes seem like they are much bigger in scope than they actually are, in Taibbi fantasy land if one bank employee anywhere ever commits a crime it is a worldwide conspiracy of epic scope that all bank employees are guilty of. Further, if government investigators do not find evidence of his predetermined conspiracy views it means that they are involved in the conspiracy. Every Taibbi article is the same, once you have read one you have read them all.

I'm not really familiar with Taibbi past knowing he popularized "Vampire Squid" for GS and he got that about right.

It will be quite widely read then I assume?

and better scientific minds than us already concluded that the big banks do pretty control the world anyway, didn't they?

http://www.newscientist.com/article...e-capitalist-network-that-runs-the-world.html

When the team further untangled the web of ownership, it found much of it tracked back to a "super-entity" of 147 even more tightly knit companies - all of their ownership was held by other members of the super-entity - that controlled 40 per cent of the total wealth in the network.

"In effect, less than 1 per cent of the companies were able to control 40 per cent of the entire network," says Glattfelder. Most were financial institutions. The top 20 included Barclays Bank, JPMorgan Chase & Co, and The Goldman Sachs Group.

it doesnt necessarily mean anything of course

One thing won't chime with some of the protesters' claims: the super-entity is unlikely to be the intentional result of a conspiracy to rule the world. "Such structures are common in nature," says Sugihara.

but..

So, the super-entity may not result from conspiracy. The real question, says the Zurich team, is whether it can exert concerted political power. Driffill feels 147 is too many to sustain collusion.

Braha suspects they will compete in the market but act together on common interests. Resisting changes to the network structure may be one such common interest.

jus sayin..
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom