Are the Markets all Manipulated or not?

The Central Scrutinizer said:
Really? So explain Warren Buffett. Charlie Munger. Ben Graham. John Bogle. Bill Miller.

This should be entertaining.

are we supposed to assume from this then, that these people are living gods and their word is irrefutable economic law?

lets assume for a moment that is true.

"High frequency trading is legalized front-running.. ..it's basically evil.."

"You can't trust bankers.. ..to control themselves.. ..they're like heroin addicts.."

Charlie Munger 03 May 2013
 
Thanks for your PMs and the links. As I mentioned in my reply, that was a very good call that you made. But as I said, one good call doesn't impress me, and as you don't make online predictions other than that one, there's no easy way to verify your claims of beating the market consistently.

So I remain skeptical, but good luck. :)

ok, but would details of the information you have seen, tend to back up or disprove claims of achieving the result by understanding regular manipulation of some sort?


Neither. It was a single recommendation to go long on a particular stock.
 
CBC National - The Monarchs of Money

a pretty good overview of the chief manipulators tragic role.

"has anybody ever tried to explain that to the broad American public, there's this 'club' that met secretly in Switzerland and does all kinds of interesting things that affect their lives, but we're not going to tell you about it because it's too complicated."



"Trust us, ..but bear in mind, central bankers are bound by their own mandate to say whatever they think is necessary to retain stability"

( lie ) Carney in particular just looks like he's lying whatever comes out of his mouth.
 
JPM & BOA perfect trading quarters

Bank of America "perfect" 100% trading quarter.

After the "humiliating" performance in Q4 2012, when Bank of America had a whopping 2 trading loss days out of 61, in has managed to redeem itself in the first quarter of 2012, when not only did it record seven trading days when it generated revenue of over $100 million daily, but more importantly it had zero days (of 60 total) with any net trading losses

SEC filing

JPM has 100% first quarter too

SEC filing

Moments ago, Jamie Dimon's firm filed a 10-Q in which, among other things, it announced than in the quarter ended March 31, it was profitable on 63 out of 63 trading days and had one day in which it gained more than $200 million, or said simply another case of trading perfection unmatched anywhere in the known universe except perhaps by sellers of newsletters on Twitter.

nothing to see here, the new normal makes it entirely possible to have 100% perfect trading quarters. move along..
 
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/earth/en...household-goods-prices-as-well-as-petrol.html

Oil price manipulation 'could have driven up food and household goods prices' as well as petrol - Families could have been paying too much for food and everyday household goods if companies are found to have fixed the oil price, the Government has indicated.

Officials admitted the impact of oil-price fixing could go be much wider than driving up petrol prices, after the European officials raided companies suspected of “colluding” to distort the market. Fears are growing that a fresh financial scandal has hit consumers’ pockets, after the European Commission revealed this week it is conducting an inquiry into allegations of fuel price-fixing.

BP and Shell, along with a Norwegian oil giant, Statoil, are suspected of having “colluded in reporting distorted prices to manipulate the published prices for a number of oil and biofuel products”.

High oil prices also feeds through to bigger bills for food, clothes and other essentials because it pushes up the cost of transport and manufacturing.

A high oil price will also fuel inflation, [if your preferred inflation methodology chooses to include affected products, obviously] which erodes the value of people's savings, and can stifle economic growth, by pushing up businesses' costs

BPwiki
BP plc[2][4][5] is a British multinational oil and gas company headquartered in London, England, United Kingdom. It is the third-largest energy company and fifth-largest company in the world measured by 2012 revenues and is one of the six oil and gas "supermajors".[6][7] It is vertically integrated and operates in all areas of the oil and gas industry, including exploration and production, refining, distribution and marketing, petrochemicals, power generation and trading. It also has renewable energy activities in biofuels and wind power.

As of December 2012, BP had operations in over 80 countries, produced around 3.3 million barrels per day of oil equivalent,[2]:67, 81 had total proven commercial reserves of 17 billion barrels of oil equivalent[2] and had around 20,700 service stations.[8][9] Its largest division is BP America, which is the second-largest producer of oil and gas in the United States.[10]

Shellwiki
Royal Dutch Shell plc (LSE: RDSA, RDSB), commonly known as Shell, is an Anglo–Dutch multinational oil and gas company headquartered in The Hague, Netherlands and with its registered office in London, United Kingdom.[2] It is the second largest company in the world in terms of revenue[1] and one of the six oil and gas "supermajors". Shell is also one of the world's most valuable companies.[3] As of January, 2013 the largest shareholder is Capital Research Global Investors with 9.85% ahead of BlackRock in second with 6.89%.[4] Shell topped the Fortune 500 list of largest companies in the world.[5] Royal Dutch Shell revenue was equal to 84% of the Netherlands's $555.8 billion GDP at the time.[6]

Shell is vertically integrated and is active in every area of the oil and gas industry, including exploration and production, refining, distribution and marketing, petrochemicals, power generation and trading. It also has major renewable energy activities, including in biofuels.[7] It has operations in over 90 countries, produces around 3.1 million barrels of oil equivalent per day and has 44,000 service stations worldwide.[8] Shell Oil Company, its subsidiary in the United States, is one of its largest businesses.[9]

so the original "all markets are manipulated" isn't looking so far off is it?
 
Last edited:
EU has a hammer and is looking for massive fines revenue nails

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-05-23/oil-manipulation-inquiry-shows-eu-s-hammer-after-libor.html

Almunia has made policing financial benchmarks a priority. He has opened investigations into Goldman Sachs Group Inc., JPMorgan Chase & Co. and other investment banks over Libor, and he’s examining possible collusion among banks and brokers to manipulate benchmark lending rates in Swiss francs, the yen and the euro.
The EU has treated collusion on benchmark lending rates as a price-fixing cartel that can be punished under its antitrust rules. Fines can be as much as 10 percent of a company’s yearly global revenue and are based on its annual sales in the market where it tried to fix prices.
 
hahaha, so back to the very OP

I've been going to start this thread for a while now, but this article seems like a perfect intro. my premise is that the largest 10 Forex banks control 70% of the $4 trillion per day FX markets and via that, can push pretty much everything about.

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...rig-currency-rates-to-profit-off-clients.html

Traders at some of the world’s biggest banks manipulated benchmark foreign-exchange rates used to set the value of trillions of dollars of investments, according to five dealers with knowledge of the practice.

Employees have been front-running client orders and rigging WM/Reuters rates by pushing through trades before and during the 60-second windows when the benchmarks are set, said the current and former traders, who requested anonymity because the practice is controversial. Dealers colluded with counterparts to boost chances of moving the rates, said two of the people, who worked in the industry for a total of more than 20 years.

It may be difficult to prosecute traders for market manipulation, as spot foreign exchange, the trading of one currency with another at the current price for delivery within two days, isn’t classified as a financial instrument by regulators, said Arun Srivastava. "

The behavior occurred daily in the spot foreign-exchange market and has been going on for at least a decade, affecting the value of funds and derivatives, the two traders said. The Financial Conduct Authority, Britain’s markets supervisor, is considering opening a probe into potential manipulation of the rates, according to a person briefed on the matter.

“The FX market is like the Wild West,” said James McGeehan, who spent 12 years at banks before co-founding Framingham, Massachusetts-based FX Transparency LLC, which advises companies on foreign-exchange trading, in 2009. “It’s buyer beware.”

The $4.7-trillion-a-day currency market, the biggest in the financial system, is one of the least regulated. The inherent conflict banks face between executing client orders and profiting from their own trades is exacerbated because most currency trading takes place away from exchanges.

how the marketmakers (professional or smart money) trade

One trader with more than a decade of experience said that if he received an order at 3:30 p.m. to sell 1 billion euros ($1.3 billion) in exchange for Swiss francs at the 4 p.m. fix, he would have two objectives: to sell his own euros at the highest price and also to move the rate lower so that at 4 p.m. he could buy the currency from his client at a lower price.

:D nice work if you can get it, huh?

 
Last edited:
hahaha, so back to the very OP



http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...rig-currency-rates-to-profit-off-clients.html



how the marketmakers (professional or smart money) trade



:D nice work if you can get it, huh?

Yeah, I read this article yesterday. Doesn't come as a surprise to me.

However, here's the original claim:
If true, that would leave us living in an era of undisguised, real-world conspiracy, in which the prices of currencies, commodities like gold and silver, even interest rates and the value of money itself, can be and may already have been dictated from above. And those who are doing it can get away with it. Forget the Illuminati – this is the real thing, and it's no secret. You can stare right at it, anytime you want.

I think what we're seeing here is traders ripping off their clients by frontrunning their trades. A dishonest and greedy practice to be sure. But I don't think it's quite the same as "dictating prices from above" is it? What they want to do is make money of course, whether prices go up or down. They may have inside information about where the price is going to go, and they may use that inside information to their advantage, but that's not quite the same as controlling where the price is going to go.

If I had a crystal ball that could see the future I could make a lot money trading. I wouldn't have to control the future, I could just buy whatever is going to go up in price tomorrow and sell whatever is going to go down.
 
I think what we're seeing here is traders ripping off their clients by frontrunning their trades. A dishonest and greedy practice to be sure. But I don't think it's quite the same as "dictating prices from above" is it? What they want to do is make money of course, whether prices go up or down. They may have inside information about where the price is going to go, and they may use that inside information to their advantage, but that's not quite the same as controlling where the price is going to go.


Wasn't the Libor scandal an example of controlling/dictating prices?

The scandal arose when it was discovered that banks were falsely inflating or deflating their rates so as to profit from trades, or to give the impression that they were more creditworthy than they were.[3
 
Yeah, I read this article yesterday. Doesn't come as a surprise to me.

and it definitely doesn't come as a surprise to me, it is pretty common knowledge throughout my trading clan, and is, as I have stated before, the entire basis of our many different trading systems.

I can point you to multiple examples of it on any currency and timeframe you like.

However, here's the original claim:

actually that wasnt my original claim, just a perfectly timed topical article with which to open conversation and back up my premise.

No I don't think FX prices are dictated from above, but they are certainly shoved around hard at times. (hint, dont trade until you have seen it ;) )

PuppyCow said:
I think what we're seeing here is traders ripping off their clients by frontrunning their trades. A dishonest and greedy practice to be sure. But I don't think it's quite the same as "dictating prices from above" is it? What they want to do is make money of course, whether prices go up or down. They may have inside information about where the price is going to go, and they may use that inside information to their advantage, but that's not quite the same as controlling where the price is going to go.

In fact, this article is still talking about carbon based traders and the majority of the big stuff is done by silicon based black box traders nowadays anyway, and these marketmaker systems can very much push prices around automatically to benefit themselves.

they have to deal with continual client order flow, and can choose which to route first from their incoming client buy/sells, thus driving the market to benefit themselves in the meantime, before reversing to the ultimate direction by now processing all the other side.

the plain fact is (IMO) that daily manipulation in Forex is a fact of life, and unless you can learn to recognize and work around it, you have almost zero chance of keeping your money. literally. zero.

PuppyCow said:
Oh, yeah. Well there's that.

ok, well I know Im banned from citing ZH, but being as they were writing that Libor was rigged in 2009, perhaps their thoughts are admissible on this one subject? :)

http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-06-12/summarizing-known-rigged-markets

Following last night's revelation that FX trading is the latest addition to the "rigged" column, here is a summary of the known market manipulation scandals (because it can be problematic keeping track of all by now):

Libor - interest rates (link)
ISDAfix - swaps (link)
Platts - oil prices (link)
WM/Reuters - FX (link)
High-Frequency Trading - equities (link)

We also know that the Fed and world central banks are engaged in a full blown (and unprecedented) Treasury curve modeling exercise courtesy of both ZIRP (short-end) and QE (long-end), and that courtesy of some $12 trillion in extra liquidity in the past 5 years, stocks are at an artificial "wealth effect" sugar high.

We can therefore deduce that, following the process of elimination, gold and silver are the only markets that are unmanipulated and where transparent price discovery is allowed to take place without intervention from key players.
 
Last edited:
http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/fed38a0a-d4d5-11e2-b4d7-00144feab7de.html#axzz2WTYONg3r

The sprawling global rate-rigging probe expanded dramatically on Friday as authorities in Singapore disciplined 20 banks and revealed that 133 traders tried to manipulate three interest rate and foreign exchange benchmarks.

“The large number of banks involved suggests that there might be several more fines yet arising out of Libor manipulation, so the bad news for banks will keep on coming,” said Owen Watkins, a barrister with Lewis Silkin.

The other institutions sanctioned by the MAS include Barclays, Crédit Agricole, Credit Suisse, DBS, Deutsche Bank, Standard Chartered, United Overseas Bank, Australia and New Zealand Banking Group, Citibank, JPMorgan Chase Bank, Macquarie, Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, HSBC and Commerzbank.
 
Where was ZH writing that Libor was rigged in 2009?
(Or maybe I should start a new thread about economics sources/writings/journalism.)
 
Where was ZH writing that Libor was rigged in 2009?
(Or maybe I should start a new thread about economics sources/writings/journalism.)

on the very first blogspot blog no less

http://zerohedge.blogspot.com/2009/01/this-makes-no-sense-libor-by-bank.html

THURSDAY, JANUARY 22, 2009

This Makes No Sense: LIBOR By Bank

Posted by Tyler Durden at 9:07 PM

Everyone knows there is something very screwy about LIBOR, with opinion ranging from it's way too high to the opposite. We also have been quite vocal in our opinion of the TED Spread but that's irrelevant for the time being. Lately we have been looking at the most recent BBA data for the 3 month LIBOR submission by bank and while the average is 1.122%, the range is quite wide: 1.04% at the tight end to 1.204% at the wide. What confuses us is that the banks that submitted the lowest rates are the ones that have the most governmental independence, notably BofA and JPM, while the other end of the range is represented by pseudo nationalized banks such as RBS, in which the UK government recently acquired a 70% stake, and UBS, which had all of its bad assets swept by the Swiss National Bank in exchange for a loan (read more about the Swiss model here).

The implication is that with more governmental involvement or even virtual nationalization, the cost to lend to another bank creeps higher, when compared to entities such as BofA and JPM which still, at least theoretically, carry all their bad assets on their books. This intuitively is very confusing as the cheapest LIBOR should come from the nationalized entities, that have a full governmental backstop.

http://zerohedge.blogspot.com/2009/06/on-uselessness-of-libor.html
 
An though it pains me to say this, zerohedge were right.

That said, it reminds me of a quote from another thread

A Conspiracy Theorist is like a guard dog that barks at every shadow. It thinks its doing a great job when actually it is worse than useless.

zerohedge do an awful lot of barking but to be fair, they are sometimes right.
 
"Something is screwy" is a pretty far cry from "is rigged".
 
"Something is screwy" is a pretty far cry from "is rigged".

when all you know for certain is that something isn't right, that's all you can say, is it not? you will note that they absolutely nailed the "what" and "why" ie the govt guaranteed "safe banks" were higher than the non-govt guaranteed "less safe" banks.

and as that was their very first post on the matter, one of approaching 1000 odd on the subject, as shown here perhaps they can be forgiven for not spelling out all the gory details 4 years before anyone else took it seriously?
 
when all you know for certain is that something isn't right, that's all you can say, is it not? you will note that they absolutely nailed the "what" and "why" ie the govt guaranteed "safe banks" were higher than the non-govt guaranteed "less safe" banks.

and as that was their very first post on the matter, one of approaching 1000 odd on the subject, as shown here perhaps they can be forgiven for not spelling out all the gory details 4 years before anyone else took it seriously?

Fair enough, Kev. But do you understand why ZH is considered "not a reliable/good source", and considered kind of on par with infowars.com?

Do you see why someone like me (I'm not really an economics expert, but I've spent 30 minutes or so a day for about 6 years trying to figure out economics) might write them off? I mean, they don't seem to even have an internally coherent working theory of economics. They just publish any and every idea that seems extreme and extremely alarming.

What do you make of Taibbi's economic journalism, or NakedCapitalism?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom