Sean Hannity makes the case for NSA under Bush...

Yes, Hannity's partisanship would go just fine with a guy who is so partisan that he thinks any criticism of Obama is due to racism.

You don't understand: since conservatism and Republicans are axiomatically evil, any partisanship on their part is also evil. But partisanship on the half of liberalism or Democrats, well, that's just common sense in Tony's mind.
 
You don't understand: since conservatism and Republicans are axiomatically evil, any partisanship on their part is also evil. But partisanship on the half of liberalism or Democrats, well, that's just common sense in Tony's mind.

Well anyone who has ever disagreed with Obama or Tony is a racist who wants to turn America into a christian theme park after all, you can't fault him for opposing these completely real opponents.
 
Odd concept that we are not supposed to point out moral inconsistency and political expediency. But I'm curious, are we supposed to agree with Hannity under Bush or Hannity under Obama?
if the perceived NSA that Hannity commented on was different than the current there was no hypocrisy. At least not on this issue. I feel that it has changed.
 
if the perceived NSA that Hannity commented on was different than the current there was no hypocrisy. At least not on this issue. I feel that it has changed.
You "feel" it has? Could that be your bias possibly?

The collection of domestic communications was certainly public knowledge during the Bush era.

https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying
http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/news/2006/04/70619
http://www.pbs.org/now/shows/307/spy-scandal.html
http://www.privacysos.org/technologies_of_control/naurus
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A

James Bamford has been writing about the NSA for years. My copy of Body of Secrets is from April 2002. The Shadow Factory was published in 2008, and The Puzzle Palace was published way back in 1982.

He's also written a couple of interesting articles regarding the NSA:

http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2013/06/general-keith-alexander-cyberwar/all/
http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/03/ff_nsadatacenter/

Some of us don't find this this latest whistleblowing all that surprising.

RayG
I don't share your feelings.
 
BTW:

if the perceived NSA that Hannity commented on was different than the current there was no hypocrisy. At least not on this issue. I feel that it has changed.

Had Hannity talked about the past and admitted that the Patriot act and the NSA were potentially harmful things I might be able to accept that perception wise he is not being morally inconsistent. People can change their minds. But it is clear that his views change with the political winds and his outrage is as phony as a $3 bill.

I have made it clear when I've changed my mind. That includes my views of water boarding and my support of GWB for most of the 8 years he was president. Hannity doesn't need to change his ideology but if he's going to attack the current administration for infringing on our liberties he damn well ought to be honest enough to admit his past support of the NSA.
 
Last edited:
Had Hannity talked about the past and admitted that the Patriot act and the NSA were potentially harmful things I might be able to accept that perception wise he is not being morally inconsistent. People can change their minds. But it is clear that his views change with the political winds and his outrage is as phony as a $3 bill.

I have made it clear when I've changed my mind. That includes my views of water boarding and my support of GWB for most of the 8 years he was president. Hannity doesn't need to change his ideology but if he's going to attack the current administration for infringing on our liberties he damn well ought to be honest enough to admit his past support of the NSA.

Is it strange that I'm not entirely sure he's being morally inconsistent? I imagine it's possible that he honestly believes that the NSA programs under Bush were all in our nation's security interests, but under Obama it will be used for partisan purposes. Assuming that that was true he would be naive, at best, but not quite a hypocrite.

While Hannity seems like someone who would be extremely hypocritical between Republican and Democratic administrations, he also seems like someone who would have extreme partisan blinders.
 
Last edited:
Is it strange that I'm not entirely sure he's being morally inconsistent? I imagine it's possible that he honestly believes that the NSA programs under Bush were all in our nation's security interests, but under Obama it will be used for partisan purposes. Assuming that that was true he would be naive, at best, but not quite a hypocrite.

While Hannity seems like someone who would be extremely hypocritical between Republican and Democratic administrations, he also seems like someone who would have extreme partisan blinders.
If there wasn't google I'd buy that. It's not that hard to find the truth anymore. You have to willfully and actively be ignorant and that's something I have a hard time forgiving. And hey, I live in a glass house. I make mistakes but I'm willing to stand up and admit them. Do you think for one moment Hannity will listen to his critics and own up to the facts?

Dream on.
 
If there wasn't google I'd buy that. It's not that hard to find the truth anymore. You have to willfully and actively be ignorant and that's something I have a hard time forgiving. And hey, I live in a glass house. I make mistakes but I'm willing to stand up and admit them. Do you think for one moment Hannity will listen to his critics and own up to the facts?

Dream on.

Oh, no. If he's that blinded by partisan bull no amount of evidence will ever sway him, up to, and including, Bush coming on his show and defending the current NSA program. (I also accept, in principle, that he may not have remembered what he'd said back during the Bush years, but that doesn't really excuse much in this day and age)

I think I like the benefit of the doubt, even to people as clearly of their rocker as Hannity.
 
Last edited:
I'm amazed that anyone finds Sean Hannity worth watching. I mean, if a propaganda station like FOX wants to have someone on to bash the Obama administration, why do they use such a wet blouse of a man like Hannity. He makes Glenn Beck look serious.
 
No it isn't. Do you also not know what ad hominem means?



No it isn't. It is directly stated that he is a hypocrite because of these conflicting views which he has not reconciled by doing the easy thing and saying he was wrong before.



It isn't fallacious at all as long as one doesn't do, as you have, and create straw men. The claim is not that Hannity is wrong to criticize the NSA program because the NSA program is fine and dandy.

Gain say, gain say, and gross misunderstanding of the fallacy.

You seem to be suggesting that the entire purpose of the op was to insult hannity. Seriously? Okay then, let me add an equally important comment:

Derp!
 
You "feel" it has? Could that be your bias possibly?
.
Of course it could be my bias. But I am not alone in my feeling. News outlets of all persuasions appeared shocked when the story broke.
Also I was not really in favor of the programs when they came out.
 
I already cited what was known about this in the Bush era. Compare/contrast to what we know now, and honestly say nothing has changed.
Nothing has changed. We know just as little about NSA activities now as we did back then. You're making a comparison between a Ford and a Chevy in a completely darkened room.

Sorry, we know far more about the scope of NSA data collecting now.
We knew 1% about NSA activities years ago and now we know 1.1% Is that far more.

Yes, yes. I made those values up by farting random numbers. But you get my point.
 
To say that Hannity will criticize something under
President Obama that he justified under president Bush is like saying the sun will come up tomorrow.
Yep. And the same goes for most talking heads no matter where they are on the political spectrum.
 
Of course it could be my bias. But I am not alone in my feeling. News outlets of all persuasions appeared shocked when the story broke.
But you've seen the claims documented that they were spying on Americans in America long before Bush.

Also I was not really in favor of the programs when they came out.
And that's the problem. Hannity was in favor. Very much so.
 
But you've seen the claims documented that they were spying on Americans in America long before Bush.

We know there were Senate Committees investigating the NSA back when Gerald Ford was president. This one was specific to the NSA:
Senate Select Committee to study Governmental Operations with Respect to Intelligence Activities -- The National Security Agency and Fourth Amendment Rights -- October 25 and November 6, 1975​
This next one included:

"The Federal Bureau of Investigation; The Central Intelligence Agency; The National Security Agency; The national intelligence components of the Defense Department (other than NSA); and the National Security Council and its component parts." (page VII of the Preface)
Senate Select Committee Investigation into Federal Domestic Intelligence Activities -- April 26, 1976​
In both cases that's nearly 40 years ago.

Here's a timeline of NSA domestic spying.

And here are some interesting thoughts expressed in Transition 2001, a NSA document published in December 2000:
The volumes and routing of data make finding and processing nuggests of intelligence information more difficult. To perform both its offensive and defensive missions, NSA must "live on the network." -- Transition 2001, page 31

Significant effort and investment are being applied to mastering the global network, both to protect our nation's communications and to exploit those of our targets. This new model for eSIGINT and for information assurance in the Information Age may require a restatement and endorsement of the policies and authorities that empowered the NSA in the Industrial Age...

...Make no mistake, NSA can and will perform its missions consistent with the Fourth Amendment and all applicable laws. But senior leadership must understand that today's and tomorrow's mission will demand a powerful, permanent presence on a global telecommunications network that will host the "protected" communications of Americans as well as the targeted communications of adversaries. -- Transition 2001, page 32​
All this info is freely available online.

RayG
 
Of course it could be my bias. But I am not alone in my feeling. News outlets of all persuasions appeared shocked when the story broke.
Also I was not really in favor of the programs when they came out.
Could you acknowledge that others have already documented that the NSA was spying on Americans long before Obama? That's the problem, now that Obama is in office people are suddenly upset with things that had been going on under Bush.
 
Could you acknowledge that others have already documented that the NSA was spying on Americans long before Obama? That's the problem, now that Obama is in office people are suddenly upset with things that had been going on under Bush.

Could you acknowledge that whether it was going on under Bush is in no way shape or form an excuse for Obama and that Candidate Obama promised to stop it and that the only President who can come clean fix the problem is Obama?

Although the "Obama, just as bad as Bush" does have a certain je ne sais quoi.
 
Could you acknowledge that others have already documented that the NSA was spying on Americans long before Obama? That's the problem, now that Obama is in office people are suddenly upset with things that had been going on under Bush.

This isn't a Bush or Obama issue, it's been going on for the duration of at least the last seven Presidents. Four of them were Republican, three were Democrats. We're talking 38 years folks. This transcends politics.

RayG
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom