Nostradamus on the History Channel tonight

Yeah but WWII was history.. what the hell was Nostradamus ?

A guy who wrote indecipherable quatrains about Armageddon ?
 
Aussie Thinker said:
Yeah but WWII was history.. what the hell was Nostradamus ?

A guy who wrote indecipherable quatrains about Armageddon ?
Not to mention that every single one of his quatrains are general enough (or contain enough symbolic gibberish) that one can make virtually any historical event fit the quatrain... after the fact, of course, as per all "crystal ball" and "biblical prophecy" readings.
 
It was pretty bad. But at least they had Shermer to debunk a few of the predictions. And Penn & Teller. But the skeptical portion was at most ten minutes out of a two hour show.
 
RichardR said:
It was pretty bad. But at least they had Shermer to debunk a few of the predictions. And Penn & Teller. But the skeptical portion was at most ten minutes out of a two hour show.
It was mostly crap. These folks who purport to be experts on the writings come off as somehow being learned, when in fact they interpret VERY freely (often changing their interpretations to suit new developments), they have interpreted the same crap differently over time, and their batting average for predictions is .000.

I always have to have a laugh when the "prediction" about the "New City" at forty-five degrees comes up. The consensus is that NYC is the city in question, although it sits at about 41 degrees north latitude. The city where I live, however, is exactly at 45 degrees north latitude, and it's even newer than New York. If we ever have a catastrophic fire, look for some to say, "Ah! Nostradamus predicted it!"

I also still maintain that my record as a predictor was better than that of Nostradamus, as I made a predictions for the year 2002 (not for any unspecified year, but for a particular year!) in advance, both of which were exactly correct:

The shining sphere in the deep
The eyes of many see in wonder
A perpetrator found asleep
Concealed in the quiet thunder.

The "shining sphere" that was discovered was the very shiny planetoid Quaoar . According to this web site, Quaoar's orbital path was quickly computed, in spite of its distance, because it is "so bright."

The "perpetrator found asleep" was DC sniper John Allen Muhammad, the most significant perpetrator of 2002. "Concealed in the quiet," he and his companion cut down innocents with a thunderous gunshot. He was captured when he was found asleep at a Maryland rest stop.

My point is not that I am a prophet. My point is that anyone can do what people say Nostradamus did, and can do it better.
 
Although my predictions have been pruned from this forum (they are available elsewhere), you can find a brief discussion of them here.
 
Nostrodamus predicted Armageddon?

Big deal. I'd be impressed if he'd actually mentioned that Bruce Willis and Ben Affleck were in it.
:p
 
Brown said:
...

I always have to have a laugh when the "prediction" about the "New City" at forty-five degrees comes up. The consensus is that NYC is the city in question, although it sits at about 41 degrees north latitude. The city where I live, however, is exactly at 45 degrees north latitude, and it's even newer than New York. If we ever have a catastrophic fire, look for some to say, "Ah! Nostradamus predicted it!"

...
Not to mention that Nostradamus lived at within a couple degrees of 45 himself. He probably went to the local surveyor and asked, "hey where are we?" When he was told it was 44°22'18", he decided to round up to the nearest degree in order to preserve the meter of his verse. You see, the mundane explanation is so much more fulfilling, ultimately. :D
 
BTW, Randi himself wrote an excellent book on Nostradamus, The Masks of Nostradamus.

He shows with great clarity how the original quatrains were in reference to events occuring at the time, and how subsequent "interpreters" changed, altered, and misspelled the original texts to make them more in line with the drivel they were putting out.

There was another author they interviewed on NPR a while back who went into researching the stuff as a believer, and ended up of the opinion that it was utter bunk.

Unfortunately, I can't recall his name, and if you search Amazon for Nostradamus, you get like 500 hits...
 
history channel

Does anyone know what's up with the History Channel? Most of their programming is great, high quality programming, but they also have these bizzaro programs that promote the paranormal.

It's as though they had to make some Faustian bargain: You can show high quality history programming, but you can't be too good, you have to include b.s. about UFO's or Bible codes.

That's a story I'd really like to be investigated: who at the history channel is promoting and programming this crap?


David
 
Re: history channel

talldave said:
Does anyone know what's up with the History Channel? Most of their programming is great, high quality programming, but they also have these bizzaro programs that promote the paranormal.

It's as though they had to make some Faustian bargain: You can show high quality history programming, but you can't be too good, you have to include b.s. about UFO's or Bible codes.

That's a story I'd really like to be investigated: who at the history channel is promoting and programming this crap?


David
Maybe it's the inverse-Hefner effect.

Remember when Playboy was under the threat of censorship because it "had no redeeming social value"? Well, Hef, clever lad that he is, solved that problem by including significant political commentary on current issues, usually by including interviews with newsmakers of the day. Poof, there goes the "no redeeming social value" argument. Hef won by this end-run.

So I think your Faustian bargain might have some validity. The History Channel can run good history but they have to include some crappola just to insure that the woo audience will tune in, boost their ratings, and allow them to put the "good stuff" on as much as possible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom