science fraud is common place

DC, sometimes it's good to have an extreme opening post, otherwise you have no discussion at all. I don't have statistics about science fraud, so I honestly have no idea about how common it is. But the title can make some people write here on te forum. I like to be a little bit provocative here on the forum, in order to have a good discussion and to have some fun.

Sometimes we need to hear the other side of the story too.

By the way: I discovered that peerreviewers don't check the data with experiments, described in a submitted manuscript to an editor, in order to publish the manuscript in a journal.

They just publish the paper, without having done the experiments themselves and checking the data. Only when other scientists repeat the experiment in order to falsify the theory in the published paper, then the theory will be faslified.
So, peerreview is not really a good test.

Soooo ...

You are a self-admitted liar.

Thanks much!

I know that you are a liar and I glad that you also know that you are a liar.
 
Maartenn100 said:
They just publish the paper, without having done the experiments themselves and checking the data.
Do you have any idea how stupid such a requirment would be? It would require constructing another Large Hadron Collider for no better purpose than re-running tests, for example. In historical sciences it's even worse--often the data cannot be reproduced in a manner that people like you would find acceptable (reproduce the discovery of a specific fossil, for example!). Reproducibility in those fields is slightly different, and consists of being able to reproduce the general findings, such as ecological trends.

Also, NO editor has time to waste reproducing perfectly good experiments. They're all professional scientists themselves, after all, with their own research.

So, peerreview is not really a good test.
No one ever said it was. What peer review does is ensure that most of the journal articles published are worth discussing. It has nothing to do with whether the paper is right or not.

Your misunderstanding of how science works does not disprove the efficacy of science.

justintime said:
People reject science because science is overrated. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.
So to be clear: You are saying that my research is worthless, that I'm short-sighted, that I'm incapable of coping with immediate problems, and tha tI have little use for long term goals. What, precisely, do you base this off of? I would like specific citations, please.

Their disdain for the general public and an inability to articulate their discipline garbled in esoteric mambo jumbo provides them the protection under the disguise of science.
There is nothing even remotely close to true in this statement. Our "esoteric mambo jumbo" is actually very precise jargon that anyone can learn, if they put in a bit of effort. The fact that most don't have any desire to do so in no way demonstrates that the concepts are incomprehensible. My wife and I have a lot of fun with doctors that try to talk over our heads; both of us have a background in anatomy and physiology (though neither of us is in a medical field), so we can generally figure out what the doctors are talking about. The looks of surprise on the doctors' faces are priceless, and with only one exception the doctors have become much more open and ready to discuss the issues with us.

And we generally don't have disdain for the general public. It varries from scientist to scientist, but many see themselves as working for the good of that general public. I'm ambivalent towards the general public; I honestly don't care about such a nebulous and ill-defined concept. As for non-scientist individuals, I tend to like most people.

Finally, we can ALL articulate our discipline. But again, some effort is required on the part of the listener. And we may get sick of trying to explain the same things over and over to incompetents who wish to have all the benefits of science without any of the costs and who wish to be taken seriously in scientific discussions without bothering to do any research into the topic and who can't even be troubled to learn the basic terminology.

Again, please provide specific citations of my activities that support your point. I am a scientist, therefore you are accusing ME of these things. I think that if you're going to make such accusations, you should be able to back them up.

What corporation would want to be sued for the incompetence of scientists hired to deliver the evidence?
None want to. That said, my company has staked a small part of its reputation on my findings a number of times. They have internal checks and ballances, but in the end they're willing to let me choices that are worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, based on my interpretations of scientific evidence. Oh, and each time it happens there are two or three regulatory bodies (minimum--it can be a LOT more) looking over my work, ready to sue us. You may want to get the facts before you go too far. Some corporations do encourage fraud, but it's hardly universal.
 
Hmmmm so therefore the earth and universe are young, dinosaurs and man walked together, there was a global flood, evolution is a lie, and global warming is false?
 
Also, NO editor has time to waste rep roducing perfectly good experiments. They're all professional scientists themselves, after all, with their own research.

But what criteria do peerreviewers use to in order to check the claimed data, the experimental conditions etc?
How do they decide to publish a claim in a journal or not, when they don't check the claimed evidence?

The reputation of the institure? It's comming from CERN, so it must be true? It's true because NASA scientists wrote the paper.
What citeria do they use, when they do not check the data or evidence claims?
 
Last edited:
While fraud is a problem, it is not that widespread. More of a problem is shoddy science. People do an experiment once and then publish, they ignore each of the replicates where the experiment failed to give a reproducible result, or they lack important controls. Sometimes results just don't work in other labs. Overall, the lack of reproducibility is a huge problem and there are many reports on the topic.

The reproducibly initiative is an interesting potential solution. Basically researchers can have an independent lab reproduce their results and report that along with the publication. Hopefully this type of rigor will become a trend.

https://www.scienceexchange.com/reproducibility
 
But what criteria do peerreviewers use to check the data, the experimental conditions etc?
How do they decide to publish a claim in a journal or not, when they don't check the claimed evidence?

decision is not with the reviewer but the redactor of the journal. reviewers are more like advisers. resently a climate denial paper got published despite the reviewers saying it should not be published in that already revised form, its still crap.
 
But what criteria do peerreviewers use to in order to check the claimed data, the experimental conditions etc?
How do they decide to publish a claim in a journal or not, when they don't check the claimed evidence?

The reputation of the institure? It's comming from CERN, so it must be true? It's true because NASA scientists wrote the paper.
What citeria do they use, when they do not check the data or evidence claims?

Just tell those scientists what a liar you are and that you would like all of the information that they have, and they will gladly turn it over to you.

They will also give you cake, ice cream, your choice of beverage, and a free t-shirt.

:rolleyes:
 
But what criteria do peerreviewers use to in order to check the claimed data, the experimental conditions etc?
How do they decide to publish a claim in a journal or not, when they don't check the claimed evidence?

You are altering the criteria here. Checking the evidence IS NOT limited to re-running the experiment. Every scientist has a background knowledge of the field they work in, and editors ideally have a great deal more background knowledge than the rest. That background knowledge is what's used to verify claims--if it violates some knowledge of the editor's, they will say so in their review and the authors will need to either edit their report or defend it.

Since you appear to know little if anything about the peer review process (seriously, this is the equivalent to asking "How does the gas get to the engine when we put the gas in where the cap is?" and expecting to critique Nascar mechanics), my recommendation for you is to ask questions about the topic, rather than offering criticisms. You need to put some effort into ensuring that your criticisms are valid.

ThunderChunky said:
The reproducibly initiative is an interesting potential solution. Basically researchers can have an independent lab reproduce their results and report that along with the publication. Hopefully this type of rigor will become a trend.
Again, it'll work in physics. But it doesn't have much potential in historical sciences, such as geology, paleontology, archaeology, or astronomy. It's pretty hard to replicate a supernova. Not that I don't think this is a good idea--half the value of my job is in testing hypotheses made by previous researchers that couldn't otherwise get funded--I'm just saying that it's based on a particular view of reproducibility that isn't universal within science as a whole.
 
Originally Posted by justintime
People reject science because science is overrated. The scientific community are made up of short sighted people barely able to cope with the immediate problems and have little use for long term goals that are less sensational.

Dinwar wrote: So to be clear: You are saying that my research is worthless, that I'm short-sighted, that I'm incapable of coping with immediate problems, and tha tI have little use for long term goals. What, precisely, do you base this off of? I would like specific citations, please.

"At the same time, scientific research is under stress, with pressures to change, to turn away from investigation of fundamental scientific problems, and to focus on short-term projects. The aim of this essay is to discuss the reasons for this paradox, and especially for the decline of unfettered research. "
http://www.math.washington.edu/Commentary/science.html


Justintime wrote:
Their disdain for the general public and an inability to articulate their discipline garbled in esoteric mambo jumbo provides them the protection under the disguise of science.

Dinwar wrote: There is nothing even remotely close to true in this statement. Our "esoteric mambo jumbo" is actually very precise jargon that anyone can learn, if they put in a bit of effort. The fact that most don't have any desire to do so in no way demonstrates that the concepts are incomprehensible. My wife and I have a lot of fun with doctors that try to talk over our heads; both of us have a background in anatomy and physiology (though neither of us is in a medical field), so we can generally figure out what the doctors are talking about. The looks of surprise on the doctors' faces are priceless, and with only one exception the doctors have become much more open and ready to discuss the issues with us.

And we generally don't have disdain for the general public. It varries from scientist to scientist, but many see themselves as working for the good of that general public. I'm ambivalent towards the general public; I honestly don't care about such a nebulous and ill-defined concept. As for non-scientist individuals, I tend to like most people.

Finally, we can ALL articulate our discipline. But again, some effort is required on the part of the listener. And we may get sick of trying to explain the same things over and over to incompetents who wish to have all the benefits of science without any of the costs and who wish to be taken seriously in scientific discussions without bothering to do any research into the topic and who can't even be troubled to learn the basic terminology.

Again, please provide specific citations of my activities that support your point. I am a scientist, therefore you are accusing ME of these things. I think that if you're going to make such accusations, you should be able to back them up.

"With some stunning exceptions, the vast majority of scientists are notoriously poor communicators, except when talking to each other. Since scientists are often the only people around who actually understand technical data, this deficiency makes risk communication more difficult than it would otherwise be. This column will discuss some reasons why scientists typically use poor communication techniques when talking with nonscientists."
http://www.psandman.com/col/species.htm


Justintime wrote:
What corporation would want to be sued for the incompetence of scientists hired to deliver the evidence?

Dinwar wrote: None want to. That said, my company has staked a small part of its reputation on my findings a number of times. They have internal checks and ballances, but in the end they're willing to let me choices that are worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, based on my interpretations of scientific evidence. Oh, and each time it happens there are two or three regulatory bodies (minimum--it can be a LOT more) looking over my work, ready to sue us. You may want to get the facts before you go too far. Some corporations do encourage fraud, but it's hardly universal.

Unreliable research Trouble at the lab
http://www.economist.com/news/brief...elf-correcting-alarming-degree-it-not-trouble
 
Dinwar said:
my recommendation for you is to ask questions about the topic, rather than offering criticisms. You need to put some effort into ensuring that your criticisms are valid.

:boggled:Euhm, you answered my question:

Originally Posted by Maartenn100
But what criteria do peerreviewers use to in order to check the claimed data, the experimental conditions etc?
How do they decide to publish a claim in a journal or not, when they don't check the claimed evidence?

So, we can conclude:

These scientific journals publish these papers without checking the evidence for the claims.
So, we, the public, ask ourselves: what do these peers review?
The reputation of the institute?
The reputation of the authors?


Because they don't check the evidence or presented data at all. They don't check the scientific validity of the paper at all. So, what do they actually review?
 
Last edited:
I stopped reading there. Anyone who says this clearly doesn't know the first thing about science, so his opinions are not worth reading.
Exactly.

Hmmmm so therefore the earth and universe are young, dinosaurs and man walked together, there was a global flood, evolution is a lie, and global warming is false?
And humans are from Ganymede. :rolleyes:
 
:boggled:Euhm, you answered my question:



So, we can conclude:

These scientific journals publish these papers without checking the evidence for the claims.
So, we, the public, ask ourselves: what do these peers review?The reputation of the institute?
The reputation of the authors?


Because they don't check the evidence or presented data at all. They don't check the scientific validity of the paper at all. So, what do they actually review?

no we don't , most of us atleast not. the public ask themself more what the judges on American Idol review.
 
Maartenn100 said:
So, we can conclude:

These scientific journals publish these papers without checking the evidence for the claims.
Not honestly. I've already pointed out why this isn't true.
Dinwar said:
You are altering the criteria here. Checking the evidence IS NOT limited to re-running the experiment. Every scientist has a background knowledge of the field they work in, and editors ideally have a great deal more background knowledge than the rest. That background knowledge is what's used to verify claims--if it violates some knowledge of the editor's, they will say so in their review and the authors will need to either edit their report or defend it.
The editors and reviewers DO check the evidence. They do not re-run the experiments, but no rational or honest person demands that they do so.

So, we, the public, ask ourselves: what do these peers review?
The reputation of the institute?
The reputation of the authors?
The fact that you can't answer that is all the evidence we need to dismiss any statement you have about peer review. You can only possibly be right by chance.

Because they don't check the evidence at all.
This is, simply put, a lie. I've already addressed that point, and to continue to act as though I haven't merely furthers the degradation of your reputation here.

justintime: So you're willing to make accusations about me without actually bothering to provide any examples of my work that justify your accusations. Nice. Glad to know you've done your homework before committing what can be termed slander.
 
Dinwar said:
The editors and reviewers DO check the evidence. They do not re-run the experiments, but no rational or honest person demands that they do so.
How do they check the outcome of an experiment (the data) without doing the experiment at all? I don't get it.

Please explain to me: how can you check the validity of an experiment and the results or outcome of it, described by someone, without checking it in experimental conditions?

Strange.

When James Randi wants evidence for the claim of someone who says that he has paranormal capabilities, JR would insist on doing an experiment in order to check this claim. Afterwards he would publish this in a scientific paper.

But you claim that no experiments are needed when someone claims that he has some clairvoyant results with his own experiments and submit his manuscript with the data to a scientific journal?
Strange. Very strange. Not scientific at all.
 
Last edited:
These scientific journals publish these papers without checking the evidence for the claims.
So, we, the public, ask ourselves: what do these peers review?
The reputation of the institute?
The reputation of the authors?

When I reviewed papers, I looked at how likely their results were, and how clearly they were communicated. I will generally assume that they have the data they claim they have, unless they are claiming something entirely outrageous (such as a reaction occurring at a higher rate when sung to, or an external magnetic field causing one enantiomer to be favoured). I will, however, scrutinize their interpretation of the data. Have they missed other possible explanations of what they are observing? Have they given enough information about their procedure that it could be easily reproduced?

For example- I stumbled upon this paper today:
http://www.recentscientific.com/sites/default/files/Download_638.pdf

This was published in an online "journal' with no review process, and it shows. They have no characterization of their copper compounds, and thus have not shown that the substances they are testing are even remotely resembling the formulas they have given. Their stuff may very well be useful pesticides, but they have no business claiming that they have these formulas (for one thing, they've suggested a formulation which includes a copper(+3) ion, even though they are calling it copper(+2), since copper almost never forms a +3 ion).
 
Maartenn100 View Post said:
How do they check the outcome of an experiment (the data) without doing the experiment at all? I don't get it.
The highlighted part is the only honest statement you've made in this thread.

First: What is an experiment? Please define what you mean by that word. This is important, because I feel that much of your problem lies in a false view of that word.

But you claim that no experiments are needed when someone claims that he has some clairvoyant results with his own experiments?
I've said nothing of the sort and would thank you for allowing me to speak for myself. I've said that if someone runs an experiment and reports the results it is not necessarily necessary for someone else to run that exact experiment to prove the experiment's validity, particularly not when the someone in question is an expert in the field. If you are incapable of comprehending that statement, please point to specific areas that confuse you.
 
The problem is, that when you do not repeat the experiment, you can be biased.
And it's a selffulfilling process:

First you accept a paper A because it seems reasonable.
Then you accept paper B because it is in line with the data of paper A.
But you do not accept paper C because it is 'outrageous' (not at all in line with the data of paper A and paper B)

In all these cases you haven't checked the data at all by repeating the described experiments. You just use previous accepted manuscripts about the same subject to judge the next manuscripts with it. But you didn't check any of the data, presented by any of these manuscripts.

This is how scientific publication works. I learned something new today.
 
Last edited:
Maartenn100 said:
The problem is, that when you do not repeat the experiment, you can be biased.
How? Why? How do you know?

And most important: What is an "experiment"?

And it's a selffulfilling process:

First you accept a paper A because it seems reasonable.
Then you accept paper B because it is in line with the data of paper A.
No. First you run your own experiments. Lots of them. Decades worth of them. Then someone recommends you to be editor. Then you read a huge number of other papers, and continue doing your own experiments. Then someone presents Paper A for publication. Using your knowledge, and perhaps testing some implications against known data, you determine if it makes sense or not. Then you accept or reject it. Paper B, if it is an implication of Paper A, is put through a similar process with the acknowledgement of the issues found in Paper A.

In all these cases you haven't checked the data at all by repeating the experiments. You just use previous accepted manuscripts to judge the next manuscripts with it. But you didn't check any of the data, presented in any of these manuscripts.
Good gods below, they don't pick editors out off the street! Editors are scientists in their own rights, and experts in their fields.

Also: What do you mean by "experiment"? I'm asking for a reason.
 
This is how scientific publication works. I learned something new today.

You've learned nothing--because the description of the peer review process you've presented directly contradicts what two scientists--one published and one reviewer--have told you. You are making crap up. That's not knowledge; it's a re-statement of your assumptions based on nothing.
 
Ok, Dinwar, I don't say that the peerreview is not good. I only say that there is the possibility for being biased. That's very human.
I hope you can live with this notion, that there is 'subjectivity' involved.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom