I'd like some examples of this scrutiny that the researchers here claim to be under. Publishing a paper that a few people might read sometime, and maybe - just maybe - might even check some of the working, is not really scrutiny.
It doesn't matter if you can't think of anything better (and there are better things, but you have to step away from academia to get them), it's still not right to claim to be 'scientific' when all you've got is poorly defined peer review with no demonstratable quality assurances, and replication that doesn't happen.
I mean, really, to claim that academic research has the most " rigorous analysis of any field that I'm aware of, and held to standards that would be considered insane" only shows that you're not aware of any other fields.
What is this rigour and where exactly is it applied? What are these standards and how are they enforced?
Peer review does not even check that research was done. Who checks that the data you include in your publications are the data you measured? Does this happen? No. Does anyone check that you ran the experiment you claim to have run? Not normally, no. Does anyone check that the data processing code does what you think it does? Not normally, no. So you have to rely on the experimenters honesty that the experiment was even carried out. No scrutiny.
As for fraud, the numbers given here are not of fraud, but of detected fraud - as you've said yourselves. To now claim you have a detailed precise idea of how much fraud occurs is rubbish; you have no idea how much fraud actually occurs, because you have no scrutiny.
And yes there's punishment for being caught (sometimes....) but there are also lots of incentives to 'adjust' things just a bit to give a publishable result, to bolster an existing view, and so on.
I expect, as do most consumers now, some degree of assurance with the products I use. Most industries have either willingly or unwillingly adopted such rigour, standards and scrutiny - I don't have to accumulate vast amounts of expertise to poke around at an aircraft or a bridge or a pizza to see if it's safe to use, for example - but academia still seems to be in the dark ages. It doesn't even realise that it might be a good idea for itself, let alone for the people who pay for it.
Please, please stop using the word 'science' to describe a process that has not been scientifically tested - something that is essentially gossip. "Science" doesn't discover fraud; people who are researchers discover it, sometimes, eventually; they are after all the people with the time, the money and the equipment. Just because some people who call themselves 'scientists' have found some fraud does *not* mean anything is 'working'.