science fraud is common place

Just as I figured. It would make a lot more sense if it was written in layman's terms and better appreciated.
You figured that you'd be asked to prove your claim? Well that's good--you should be prepared, then. I suspect we won't have to wait long for you to actually do what you claim can be done.
 
You figured that you'd be asked to prove your claim? Well that's good--you should be prepared, then. I suspect we won't have to wait long for you to actually do what you claim can be done.

Surely there must be some scientist here who can read esoteric high flung dung and translate it for the layman.
 
Many scientists collude with the public’s desire to be over-reassured.
If this is true, why are so many scientists (metaphorically) stomping and screaming at the tops of their voices about climate change?

Why are so many so adamant about keeping up our levels of immunization?


Fact is that sometimes very good submitted manuscripts were first rejected by some high profile journals and, later on, these manuscripts were accepted by another journal.

That tells us enough about the 'objectivity' of the peerreview process.

The objection that papers rejected by one journal are then published later in other journals is again an indication that the objector knows little about scientific communication. Everyone wants fame. And the more read a journal is, the bigger your fame. But journals that are read more also want the bigger discoveries. It is quite normal to try for the best journal you think you can get, then after they reject to search for another to publish your ideas.
It's like a journalist trying to sell a story to CNN, only to get rejected and sell his story to a local news agency. Does that makes the story untrue?
Additionally, papers can be rejected by journals for any number of reasons. A paper might be just different enough from a journal's editorial focus that the editors decide that it doesn't fit. The journal may have recently published another paper on a similar enough topic that the editors think it's time to vary the landscape a little. The editors might think the work outlined in the paper is promising, but want to wait for more information. Getting published in a scientific journal isn't just a matter of "ask and have."


Justintime, you are dishonestly equivocating. You are cleverly trying to imply that 2/3 of ALL "biomedical and life science papers" are fraudulent. The reality is, of the vanishingly small percentage of "biomedical and life science papers" that are, in fact, withdrawn, 2/3 of them (2/3 of that vanishingly small percentage, which was...what...again?) are withdrawn due to fraud. To the intelligent, impartial observer, that resembles a system policing itself. Not the hecatomb purge you try to imply.
Oh, gosh, is that what he's trying to say? I completely missed that. So, unless I'm messing up the statistics too (entirely possible), the actual percentage is 0.00065.


On another note, I have politely asked this question of you several times. I'm sure you must have simply overlooked it, so I will ask again, "mate":

In what area of science does your expertise lie?
Just reiterating because I think it's a question that should be answered.


Here is a sample of scientific high flung dung (esoteric mambo jumbo) which a layman can shrink down to one or two sentences.
And what is your objection to that paragraph? The vocabulary? In that case, all you do is trumpet your own ignorance.
 
Even you a scientist would like it translated. :jaw-dropp

I....what?

I want to see what you can do with it. I'm perfectly capable of reading it as it stands. It's an interesting topic, addressing an area of evolutionary theory particularly relevant to human evolution, and touches (tangentially) on a few issues in paleontological research. It's crystal clear to me as it stands--and I believe that any "translation" of it would only reduce the data. However, I'm willing to be proven wrong. Write it in layman's terms and prove me wrong.
 
You claimed a layman could. So do it.

This is a test for scientists not a layman. But if a layman had to write the same article he/she could do it without all that esoteric high flung dung. So let the scientist demonstrate both comprehension of the article and his communication skills to articulate the same to the general public.
 
I'd like some examples of this scrutiny that the researchers here claim to be under. Publishing a paper that a few people might read sometime, and maybe - just maybe - might even check some of the working, is not really scrutiny.

It doesn't matter if you can't think of anything better (and there are better things, but you have to step away from academia to get them), it's still not right to claim to be 'scientific' when all you've got is poorly defined peer review with no demonstratable quality assurances, and replication that doesn't happen.

I mean, really, to claim that academic research has the most " rigorous analysis of any field that I'm aware of, and held to standards that would be considered insane" only shows that you're not aware of any other fields.

What is this rigour and where exactly is it applied? What are these standards and how are they enforced?

Peer review does not even check that research was done. Who checks that the data you include in your publications are the data you measured? Does this happen? No. Does anyone check that you ran the experiment you claim to have run? Not normally, no. Does anyone check that the data processing code does what you think it does? Not normally, no. So you have to rely on the experimenters honesty that the experiment was even carried out. No scrutiny.

As for fraud, the numbers given here are not of fraud, but of detected fraud - as you've said yourselves. To now claim you have a detailed precise idea of how much fraud occurs is rubbish; you have no idea how much fraud actually occurs, because you have no scrutiny.

And yes there's punishment for being caught (sometimes....) but there are also lots of incentives to 'adjust' things just a bit to give a publishable result, to bolster an existing view, and so on.

I expect, as do most consumers now, some degree of assurance with the products I use. Most industries have either willingly or unwillingly adopted such rigour, standards and scrutiny - I don't have to accumulate vast amounts of expertise to poke around at an aircraft or a bridge or a pizza to see if it's safe to use, for example - but academia still seems to be in the dark ages. It doesn't even realise that it might be a good idea for itself, let alone for the people who pay for it.

Please, please stop using the word 'science' to describe a process that has not been scientifically tested - something that is essentially gossip. "Science" doesn't discover fraud; people who are researchers discover it, sometimes, eventually; they are after all the people with the time, the money and the equipment. Just because some people who call themselves 'scientists' have found some fraud does *not* mean anything is 'working'.
 
Here is a sample of scientific high flung dung (esoteric mambo jumbo) which a layman can shrink down to one or two sentences.

Just as I figured. It would make a lot more sense if it was written in layman's terms and better appreciated.

Even you a scientist would like it translated. :jaw-dropp

Surely there must be some scientist here who can read esoteric high flung dung and translate it for the layman.

What is the sound of one goalpost moving?

You made an unwise claim, that a layman could rewrite the paragraph so that it "made more sense".

What you are missing (or pretending not to see) is that a scientist (or for that matter, and educated layman) does not need the material "translated".

But feel free to present your rewrite--we'll even review it for you. Be sure not to leave out any nuance or detail when you "make it make more sense"...
 
This is a test for scientists not a layman. But if a layman had to write the same article he/she could do it without all that esoteric high flung dung. So let the scientist demonstrate both comprehension of the article and his communication skills to articulate the same to the general public.

You claimed that a layman could rewrite it so that it made more sense.

You have been called on the claim.

Scientists, and educated others, do not need the material "translated"--but feel free to show how your expertise will improve it. Be sure not to leave out any details, or miss any nuances...
 
I....what?

I want to see what you can do with it. I'm perfectly capable of reading it as it stands. It's an interesting topic, addressing an area of evolutionary theory particularly relevant to human evolution, and touches (tangentially) on a few issues in paleontological research. It's crystal clear to me as it stands--and I believe that any "translation" of it would only reduce the data. However, I'm willing to be proven wrong. Write it in layman's terms and prove me wrong.

Actually this is a study of marine life and the affects of environment on early juvenile fish (fry) development. And how adaptation can mitigate some of the environmental influences.
 
Perpetuating fraud is a basic element of human nature. No reason not to expect it as frequently in science as in any other area of life, religion comes to mind. If fraud is endemic to human nature, scientists can't very well argue that it isn't just as likely to be found in science as in any other field of human activity. They might do so but they won't succeed.

We've already addressed this, with data. Feel free to ignore it, though.

MCH said:
I'd like some examples of this scrutiny that the researchers here claim to be under. Publishing a paper that a few people might read sometime, and maybe - just maybe - might even check some of the working, is not really scrutiny.
Type in "EIR/EIS" in Google. Enjoy. Internal review, regulator review, public comment periods, etc.

Or, look at any paper refuting another paper. That's an example of informal review. I've provided one example--Jay Quade's work--already.

Ignoring the fact that your criticisms have been addressed already does nothing to aid your credibility.

Neither, by the way, does the argument "You only look at discovered frauds, therefore you don't know how much fraud is occurring, therefore it's extremely high." A bit of a sensationalized, yes, but not too far off the mark in terms of the implications of your post.

Please, please stop using the word 'science' to describe a process that has not been scientifically tested - something that is essentially gossip. "
This demonstrates that you have no bloody idea what you're talking about. You are arguing that science is gossip--just about the stupidest statement about science that I can imagine. It also deminishes your credibility.

But please, feel free to point to a single example of fraud that was discovered by someone attacking science, rather than scientists. I look forward to it.
 
Actually this is a study of marine life and the affects of environment on early juvenile fish (fry) development. And how adaptation can mitigate some of the environmental influences.

It also deals with how the perpetuation of juvenile traits into adulthood can occur. If you know anything about human and chimp morphology and ontogeny, this sounds all sorts of bells.
 
Actually this is a study of marine life and the affects of environment on early juvenile fish (fry) development. And how adaptation can mitigate some of the environmental influences.

Since you have not explained what the paragraph says, you have not made it "make more sense". You have simply omitted all the information.
 
Here is a sample of scientific high flung dung (esoteric mambo jumbo) which a layman can shrink down to one or two sentences.
Here is another scientific statement written in high "flung dung (esoteric mambo jumbo)."
How would you suggest a layman might "shrink (it) down to one or two sentences."?
 

Attachments

  • dirac.png
    dirac.png
    2.2 KB · Views: 6
It also deals with how the perpetuation of juvenile traits into adulthood can occur. If you know anything about human and chimp morphology and ontogeny, this sounds all sorts of bells.

The author was an ichthyologist. Yes the terms may be common but the specifics are there even in the title which you failed to pickup. You can thank me later.

Read the title again:
"Saltatory Processes and Altricial to Precocial Forms in the Ontogeny of Fishes"
Abstract

SYNOPSIS. Development is not a gradual but a saltatory process. A combination of qualitative changes in form and function—thresholds—creates boundaries between a succession of quantitative intervals—steps. Thresholds can be modified by an altered time of appearance of structures and functions (heterochrony), especially during early ontogeny, to form an operational basis for the prolongation of juvenile characters and adaptability into later ontogeny. Whereas such prolongation enables juvenilization in phylogeny, analogous principles may operate on a much shorter time scale to produce the r-selection-like altricial and the K-selection-like precocial trends in ontogeny. The inherited capacity to adjust constantly to the environment (heterochrony) selects for structural, biochemical and behavioral improvements. The tendency is toward the precocial but the way back to altricial forms is left open. The heterochronous adaptations in early ontogeny can “reverse” the vulnerable specialization, should the environment become less stable and/or the community less competitive. Juvenilization, capable of turning gerontomorphosis into paedomorphosis in evolution, and heterochronous shifts of character anlagen, capable of turning a precocial trend into an altricial trend in ontogeny are both part of the same biological process which operates during early ontogeny.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom