science fraud is common place

How rare is medical research?

I am referring to the vast majority of physicians who merely practice medicine. When you consult with a gastroenterologist or urologist, he is not doing science.
Medical research is done by the minority of researching doctors usually associated with universities and the research side of institutions like the Mayo Clinic. Of course, drug companies also use scientific principles in developing new drugs, but unless they are involved in some fundamental breakthrough, they are only marginally doing science in developing, say, some new anti-hypertension drug. This kind of research is more like doing engineering than physics.
 
Last edited:
I am referring to the vast majority of physicians who merely practice medicine. When you consult with a gastroenterologist or urologist, he is not doing science.
Medical research is done by the minority of researching doctors usually associated with universities and the research side of institutions like the Mayo Clinic. Of course, drug companies also use scientific principles in developing new drugs, but unless they are involved in some fundamental breakthrough, they are only marginally doing science in developing, say, some new anti-hypertension drug. This kind of research is more like doing engineering than physics.

To my experience this a simple ignorance of how the practical and daily expression/application of scientific training and education are realized. Science is a process of how one thinks and processes information, it isn't a matter of whether someone is performing novel research or performing routine tasks.
 
In a conversation about fraud in scientific publications, however, the difference is vital.

Context is your friend.
 
I am referring to the vast majority of physicians who merely practice medicine. When you consult with a gastroenterologist or urologist, he is not doing science.
Medical research is done by the minority of researching doctors usually associated with universities and the research side of institutions like the Mayo Clinic. Of course, drug companies also use scientific principles in developing new drugs, but unless they are involved in some fundamental breakthrough, they are only marginally doing science in developing, say, some new anti-hypertension drug. This kind of research is more like doing engineering than physics.


You've given me something think about, but it seems like there could be a lot of overlap and grey areas.

I'll agree that medicine is not exactly the hardest (i.e. the most mathematical) of the sciences. Is diagnostics not considered science?
 
You've given me something think about, but it seems like there could be a lot of overlap and grey areas.

I'll agree that medicine is not exactly the hardest (i.e. the most mathematical) of the sciences. Is diagnostics not considered science?

Maybe a definition of science might be useful here.

Science definition:
1. the intellectual and practical activity encompassing the systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment.

2. from wiki:

"Science (from Latin scientia, meaning "knowledge" is a systematic enterprise that builds and organizes knowledge in the form of testable explanations and predictions about the universe. In an older and closely related meaning, "science" also refers to a body of knowledge itself, of the type that can be rationally explained and reliably applied. A practitioner of science is known as a scientist."
 
I'll agree that medicine is not exactly the hardest (i.e. the most mathematical) of the sciences. Is diagnostics not considered science?

Not really. It's more an application of principles. In terms of thought process, there's little difference between a doctor diagnosing a medical problem and a mechanic diagnosing an engine problem. This is not to belittle the doctors--obviously the practice is very different--I'm just saying that the same thought process is going on, most of the time (diagnosing an unknown disease is obviously different).

I think for the purposes of this discussion, limiting ourselves to publications would be appropriate. We can assume for now that fraud rates in publications are representative of fraud rates in other areas of science. The reason for this is that papers are easier to work with. Once we've done that, we can expand our scope. Since at this point I can't even convince the opposition to work with the papers, I think this is a pretty generous offer.
 
In a conversation about fraud in scientific publications, however, the difference is vital.

Context is your friend.

Agreed, context.

from the post I am responding to with my comments

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9720666&postcount=441
I am referring to the vast majority of physicians who merely practice medicine. When you consult with a gastroenterologist or urologist, he is not doing science.
Medical research is done by the minority of researching doctors usually associated with universities and the research side of institutions like the Mayo Clinic. Of course, drug companies also use scientific principles in developing new drugs, but unless they are involved in some fundamental breakthrough, they are only marginally doing science in developing, say, some new anti-hypertension drug. This kind of research is more like doing engineering than physics.

From the OP:
Most of what occurs in the practice of science goes on behind closed doors, beyond the prying eye of the public. Nevertheless science and the scientists who conduct its research seem to enjoy an almost religious-like reverence, having been granted a virtual hands-off policy by the public at large to advance and mold the future.
Against this backdrop however, science is increasingly accused of fraud in the pursuit of useful research findings, applications and profits. Scientists like the rest of us try to cut corners, get the papers published, have their ideas for research funded, compete with co-professionals, and vie for glory. It is alleged by many that science fraud is commonplace in a society driven by money and ambition. To be sure science is not a career for the faint of heart. On the contrary science is an aggressive, ruthless business.Still the practitioners and institutions of science are accused of going beyond mere ambition in the eternal quest for knowledge. Our researchers pressured by the need to produce are venturing beyond the boundaries of honest science into the forbidden territory of science fraud. Despite this revered social standing, scientists are now more than ever motivated toward the falsification of research in pursuit of hefty corporate grants or public recognition. The scientific process has changed greatly over the years. For the scientist the pressure of obtaining funding, which often is tied to professional advancement, is coming both internally from the employer and externally from the grant giving bodies.
Modern science is a large-scale enterprise heavily funded and highly directed. Its dominant players are large corporations and the US government, both of whom have definite stakes in the outcome of any given research. In the mainstream media of today, tales of science fraud abound. Further complicating these financial challenges, season-scientists find themselves competing for finite funds in a glutted field, going up against much younger comparatively inexperienced practitioners. This competition for grants, status, position and money makes the temptation to veer away from the straight and narrow almost irresistible.
Source: science fraud: the price for fame and fortune
See documentary:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lKbdzGTM5cM

So, do not just trust on science, but think for yourself.

In the documentary they show you that Isaac Newton intentionally scewed data to make the work of a rival appear less important. He was a fraud...
(highlighting added to demonstrate contextual relevance)

My posting is contextually relevant to both the post to which I was responding, and the thread OP.
 
To my experience this a simple ignorance of how the practical and daily expression/application of scientific training and education are realized. Science is a process of how one thinks and processes information, it isn't a matter of whether someone is performing novel research or performing routine tasks.

You've given me something think about, but it seems like there could be a lot of overlap and grey areas.

I'll agree that medicine is not exactly the hardest (i.e. the most mathematical) of the sciences. Is diagnostics not considered science?

I suppose the word "science" and scientist in the context of this thread requires further clarification. I do not regard a practicing cardiologist or an electrical engineer designing cell phone circuitry as scientists. If a physician purposefully prescribes some therapy that he knows is fraudulent or if an engineer purposefully makes his designs more convoluted to extend his project for personal gain, I would not regard these two perpetrators as committing science fraud. I would regard these as plain old business fraud.
If the developer of a drug falsifies data presented to the FDA in order to temporarily increase the value of the stock of his biotech firm, again, I would see this as business fraud -- as long as no new scientific principle or mechanism is being claimed. (Clearly, this last example falls in a grey area.)
In the above examples, scientifically based disciplines are being abused for personal gain, but I would not define these as science fraud.
In the context of this thread, I would narrow the definition of a scientist to a person who is engaged in discovery, not one who uses established science to practice some discipline.
Dinwar
I think for the purposes of this discussion, limiting ourselves to publications would be appropriate. We can assume for now that fraud rates in publications are representative of fraud rates in other areas of science. The reason for this is that papers are easier to work with. Once we've done that, we can expand our scope. Since at this point I can't even convince the opposition to work with the papers, I think this is a pretty generous offer.
This makes good sense to me.
 
In the context of this thread, I would narrow the definition of a scientist to a person who is engaged in discovery, not one who uses established science to practice some discipline.

In general, it is the OP which defines the thread, not people who in the course of discussing the thread find that their previous statements are invalid and wish to redefine the thread to give themselves more wiggle room. That said, if some wish to narrow the discussion to journal published papers, I hope they realize that this dramatically reduces the incidence of "science fraud" and easily disproves the thread's title ("Science fraud is common place").
 
I suppose the word "science" and scientist in the context of this thread requires further clarification. I do not regard a practicing cardiologist or an electrical engineer designing cell phone circuitry as scientists. If a physician purposefully prescribes some therapy that he knows is fraudulent or if an engineer purposefully makes his designs more convoluted to extend his project for personal gain, I would not regard these two perpetrators as committing science fraud. I would regard these as plain old business fraud.
If the developer of a drug falsifies data presented to the FDA in order to temporarily increase the value of the stock of his biotech firm, again, I would see this as business fraud -- as long as no new scientific principle or mechanism is being claimed. (Clearly, this last example falls in a grey area.)
In the above examples, scientifically based disciplines are being abused for personal gain, but I would not define these as science fraud.
In the context of this thread, I would narrow the definition of a scientist to a person who is engaged in discovery, not one who uses established science to practice some discipline.

This makes good sense to me.


So if some researcher is investigating chlorinated hydrocarbon levels in pasteurized milk in the USA using established methods of analytical chemistry, s/he is not doing science? I have a real problem with this definition.
 
Maybe a definition of science might be useful here.

Justintime, your tedious style of argumentum ad dictionarium has never impressed anyone, as far as I can tell. You've been busted on this too many times.

I certainly don't need lay persons like yourself telling me what the word 'science' means.

ETA: Besides all that, you're notorious for presenting arguments that are flat-out lies. Please understand that I am not attacking you as a person. I am merely pointing out that you have a history of presenting flat-out lies as fact. HTH!

You have a nice day.
 
Last edited:
My posting is contextually relevant to both the post to which I was responding, and the thread OP.

True. However, it missed about seven or eight ages between the two.

John Jones: my point wasn't to define science as such; we don't need to. We are discussing fraud in science, which is very different. So long as we can find a valid metric, we're good. Since the primary means of communicating science is the publication of papers, that's a valid area to focus on. Once we have gathered and analyzed that data, the low hanging fruit, we can expand our search. It's SOP in research, really. Do a test run to determine if the more difficult tasks are worth doing.
 
So if some researcher is investigating chlorinated hydrocarbon levels in pasteurized milk in the USA using established methods of analytical chemistry, s/he is not doing science? I have a real problem with this definition.

Good point! I agree that it would be a stretch to say that such people would not be doing science. It provides more weight to Dinwar's suggestion concerning published papers. It would include the researchers in your example since they would be likely to publish their findings, while both some engineer working on cell phone towers and a cardiologist diagnosing some patient would not be likely to publish anything about their more ordinary activities.
 
I do not regard a practicing cardiologist or an electrical engineer designing cell phone circuitry as scientists.

Do you suggest that designing a cell phone with a new combination of components, even those argued to have the same effect as older ones, has no discovery aspect?

Do you argue that the cardiologist must not discover if the patient has v-tach or primary block?
 
True. However, it missed about seven or eight ages between the two.

John Jones: my point wasn't to define science as such; we don't need to. We are discussing fraud in science, which is very different. So long as we can find a valid metric, we're good. Since the primary means of communicating science is the publication of papers, that's a valid area to focus on. Once we have gathered and analyzed that data, the low hanging fruit, we can expand our search. It's SOP in research, really. Do a test run to determine if the more difficult tasks are worth doing.

Save it for The Perpetual Student. I know what I'm doing is science. I've been doing it almost as long as I've been alive.
 
Think of where we were just two hundred years ago. We had no electrical grids. We had no idea what caused disease. Infant mortality was high and women regularly died during childbirth. We had horses to rely on for transportation over land and sailing ships for the seas.

Now we have spaceships destined for the stars. We have eradicated smallpox and made polio a distant memory in most nations. Babies now are expected to survive as are their mothers. We not only have electrical grids but a vast new communications medium that makes more information readily available than ever before.

If science is rife with fraud then it is rife with fraud that works.
 
Do you suggest that designing a cell phone with a new combination of components, even those argued to have the same effect as older ones, has no discovery aspect?

Do you argue that the cardiologist must not discover if the patient has v-tach or primary block?

Do you think that, when an auto mechanic must discover that some exhaust valve is not operating, he is doing science?
 
Save it for The Perpetual Student. I know what I'm doing is science. I've been doing it almost as long as I've been alive.

The issue isn't "What is science?" I'm in the same boat--I dig up fossils, which isn't exactly deep theoretical work. The issue is "How do we measure rates of fraud?" We don't need to have a working definition of science as such in order to estimate that.

But if pointing that obvious (and repeatedly explained) fact out makes you upset, I'll leave it alone. You obviously want to have a different and largely irrelevant discussion.

Travis said:
Then perhaps you should pay closer attention to the context in which my response was made.
:rolleyes: Whatever.

justintime said:
"The success of Darwinism was accompanied by a decline in scientific integrity."
The use of the term "Darwinism" is, outside of a VERY small period of time, proof that the speaker or writer is misrepresenting science.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom