science fraud is common place

There are no independent panels or third party data verification process in place to investigate scientific fraud.

False. Every researcher functions as an independent third party reviewer. Science was specifically built such that it is impossible to avoid third-party review.

You continue to be unable to provide a single case of any scientific fraud discovered by non-scientists. Forget the self-serving excuses; in order to demonstrate that science is ineffective you need to prove that the overwhelming number of cases of fraud were discovered by some other method and you cannot present even ONE such case. EVERY legitimate case of scientific fraud (as defined in this thread, and as opposed to nonsense like defining all of paleontology as fraudulent) that has thus far been raised in this thread was discovered by scientists.

Provide ONE case of scientific fraud that was discovered by non-scientists and we MIGHT be legitimately able to consider your position. As it stands now, to accept your position would require us to abandon rationality.
 
In short the current system is failing because it is managed by people of science who are willing to turn a blind eye when members of their profession commit fraud.

No. it isn't. You've shown no evidence that this is so.

That explains why so few fraud cases are exposed and why the majority of scientific fraud goes undetected/unchallenged.

Give us a nice list of the fraud cases that have gone unexposed, and we'll consider listening to you for something other than entertainment.

Statistics were provided that proved scientists are just as criminally inclined as the general population and even fail to meet the high standards they set for themselves.

No, such statistics were not provided.

I wrote what I believe will change the current lopsided review and investigative process.

Said belief is unfounded and ridiculous.
 
Madalch said:
No, such statistics were not provided.
Just as a reminder, and to emphasize this point, the only statistics provided thus far are for medical research, and show that fraud rates are >1% of 1% of all published research. An argument was made that we should expect fraud rates in science similar to those in other fields, but when a method for demonstrating this with something even close to rigor was proposed the advocates of the idea that scientific fraud is more common than typically thought basically fled form the thread.

Also, I want to point out that in some cases the review process isn't unbiased--it's actually quite biased against the researchers. It's not uncommon for my reports to be examined by my competitors, and I've reviewed a number of reports by competitors myself. Think about that for a minute: they give the reports to the groups with the most incentive to find fault. I know environmental compliance is only one aspect of corporate science, but I doubt that it's terribly uncommon in private-sector science. I've heard of this method being used in a number of cases, both in other fields of science (biology, archaeology, etc) and in other fields (civil engineering, for example).
 
Shoud this thread be moved to CT?

Nah. It doesn't really fit. It's more a gross misunderstanding of science on justintime's part than a conspiracy. I mean, can you really have a conspiracy that includes all of science? Is that even possible?
 
Nah. It doesn't really fit. It's more a gross misunderstanding of science on justintime's part than a conspiracy. I mean, can you really have a conspiracy that includes all of science? Is that even possible?


That's why I was suggesting the CT subforum. Improbability of this sort doesn't seem to be much of a problem for conspiracy theories.
 
I think it's telling that the same lie is told over and over.

At some point, one must question the motives and ethics of someone who repeats a claim, without providing even scant evidence for the assertions, and in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary.


We're long past that point WRT Justintime's claims.

I have to be delicate to avoid MA violations. Let me just say that someone has been busted for outright lies before.
 
To active lurker like me, justintimes claims sound almost as paranoid as claims of those who believe reptilians are controlling the world. After all both of them just insist they are right just because they say so.

I wonder if he/she realizes this.
 
Originally Posted by justintime
Here is a quote from NIH and Research Misconduct Dr. Sally Rockey is NIH's Deputy Director for Extramural Research. (Note the amount of trust placed on the integrity of the researcher....scientific naivety I presume).


Note the lack of reference by justintime to external review and investigation into allegations of Research Misconduct.

:rolleyes:

You will find her quote in the link below.
http://nexus.od.nih.gov/all/2012/03/16/nih-and-research-misconduct/
 
False. Every researcher functions as an independent third party reviewer. Science was specifically built such that it is impossible to avoid third-party review.

You continue to be unable to provide a single case of any scientific fraud discovered by non-scientists. Forget the self-serving excuses; in order to demonstrate that science is ineffective you need to prove that the overwhelming number of cases of fraud were discovered by some other method and you cannot present even ONE such case. EVERY legitimate case of scientific fraud (as defined in this thread, and as opposed to nonsense like defining all of paleontology as fraudulent) that has thus far been raised in this thread was discovered by scientists.

Provide ONE case of scientific fraud that was discovered by non-scientists and we MIGHT be legitimately able to consider your position. As it stands now, to accept your position would require us to abandon rationality.

The Office of Research Integrity is made up of like minded scientists. The only reason non-scientists have not exposed scientific fraud is because they are not part of the oversight commissions which are mainly staffed by members of the science institutions.

Check the staff list of the Office of Research Integrity.
ORI Staff
http://ori.hhs.gov/ori-staff

But scientific fraud is exposed by journalist to the general public which is creating the backlash against the scientific community. Change will happen when the media/press and the general public are made aware how common science fraud is and every study reveals it is the senior career scientists and people high in the organization that are committing the fraud. It is an institution where the fraud is perpetuated at the top and trickles down.
 
Last edited:
Here is a splendid example of critical thinking:
justintime
Muse
Join Date: Dec 2012
Posts: 921 John Edward - psychic or what?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

John Edwards is a true psychic. He looks, talks and walks like one.
I personally know a psychic who is totally illiterate. But during a seance she is able to read messages sent to and from the dead (past correspondence) She even has a married daughter who never learned to read or write but fluently speaks 10 languages.

The lady could easily meet the Randi challenge if only she could read and write outside of the seance to take up his offer.
This is the same justintime who finds fraud in science and, by the way, believes Maartenn's crackpot theories.
 
Last edited:
Justintime, is there some reason why you won't answer my question regarding the total amount of known scientific fraud? And in a similar vein, is there any reason why you can't provide any cases of scientific fraud uncovered by non-scientists?
 
The only reason non-scientists have not been exposed scientific fraud is because they are not part of the oversight commissions which are mainly staffed by members of the science institutions
You do realize they don't have to be on an oversight commission to expose fraud, right?
:rolleyes:
 
...
But scientific fraud is exposed by journalist to the general public which is creating the backlash against the scientific community. Change will happen when the media/press and the general public are made aware how common science fraud is and every study reveals it is the senior career scientists and people high in the organization that are committing the fraud. It is an institution where the fraud is perpetuated at the top and trickles down.

If you were right, you could be bringing charges against such fraud yourself:
... empower the non-scientific population to bring criminal charges. ...
instead of waiting for others to do this.

:rolleyes:
 
I was just reading some old posts in a now locked thread, and came across this post.
athon said:
I just got back from a three day science communications conference where one of the biggest topics was climate change communication. One thing I discussed with a handful of ex and current scientists was this very illusion of climatology being somehow inferior to other sciences.

Yes, there is missing data, lying and cheating going on. But that's science for you. Pick any field and you'll find dodgy data, photoshopped images getting into journals, missing error bars, liars and cheaters. The thing is, most of the science is damn good. But there isn't the same level of public scrutiny on the differences in amino acid sequence of some enzyme in species X and Y. You won't find a front page article saying 'Aha! Genetics is all a farce! We've found Professor Plum actually photoshopped a lane from his gel run!'. Oh, believe me, it does happen, and in some respectable journals too. But the bulk of the science makes it through unscathed and unnoticed by any apart from the experts.

Climate change science isn't perfect. It's done by people, some of whom have agendas and act in less than respectable ways. It's also easy to take snippets of their conversations and views and take them out of context, as with any other science. The difference is that politics and emotional opinions put climatology under the public's microscope far more than any other science.

So, real science? Pft - it's not as pure and glorious as you'd think.

Athon

It seems the argument is between two fallacies here. the first is that science fraud is rampant and common place. It happens all the time, everywhere.

The other fallacy is that it hardly ever happens, and when it does it is promptly dealt with somehow.

I don't believe either position.
 
Here is a splendid example of critical thinking:

This is the same justintime who finds fraud in science and, by the way, believes Maartenn's crackpot theories.

I suspect he chose Maartenn100 as a buddy because justintime can recognize that Maartenn100's gullibility is in line with justintime's own agenda.
From justintime's perspective, Maartenn100 is easily recruted for that agenda.
 
You do realize they don't have to be on an oversight commission to expose fraud, right?
:rolleyes:

Even the oversight body like the Office of Research Integrity states exposing fraud is a lengthy and difficult process which takes extended time, effort and resources often expensive and time consuming.

It isn't going to be any easier for an independent public body to conduct the same oversight. But being mindful science fraud is commonplace and science is not self-correction nor are scienti9sts above criminal intent will change public opinion against the scientific community already held in low esteem and focus on their criminal activity instead.

Now that there is a move to decriminalize pot smoking, law enforcement can be freed to concentrate on the real criminals committing scientific fraud.
 
...
Now that there is a move to decriminalize pot smoking, law enforcement can be freed to concentrate on the real criminals committing scientific fraud.

And here you are, although frothing at the mouth with your claim of widespread fraud, not bringing charges against anyone.

:rolleyes:
 
And here you are, although frothing at the mouth with your claim of widespread fraud, not bringing charges against anyone.

:rolleyes:

I am performing my civic duty by alerting the general public how common science fraud is and by supporting Maartenn100 in his endeavor to do the same.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom