I can't tell if justintime's being deliberately dishonest, or if he's actually having trouble understanding the numbers. Probably a little of both.
justintime, if you think you can sample RETRACTED papers and extrapolate that to discuss PUBLISHED papers, you have no bloody idea how to do research.
...for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected, and that for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed."
At this point, I believe justintime is engaging in the time-honored argument tactic of "If I repeat it often enough, the lies become true."
Is the key word clear enough now, justintime? This isn't data; it's speculation. It has every bit as much scientific merit as discussions of homeopathy and magical shoe-making elves. It's an unsupported assertion that came from the author's nether regions. IT IS NOT A VALID DATUM.
I have provided a rigorous methodology to discover the actual rates of fraud. Either start doing that, propose a better method (with references, as I have), or turn yourself in for prosecution of fraud. Those are the only honest options at this point for you.
Yes 'perhaps' is speculative because the number could be much higher.
Yes 'perhaps' is speculative because the number could be much higher. But there is a higher magnitude expressed for lesser violations like for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed.
Aside from such guesses, however, or indications in surveys, exact figures do not exist.
Undoubtedly, most scientists are honest, and most scientific research derives from sound, ethical methods.
Of course there's the rest of that sentence:
And this one from the same article:
However, it is likely that, if on average 2% of scientists admit to have falsified research at least once and up to 34% admit other questionable research practices, the actual frequencies of misconduct could be higher than this.
"In Betrayers of the Truth, Broad and Wade speculate that for every major of case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected, and that for each major case, another 1000 lesser violations are committed."
http://ischoollmpiadozo.wordpress.com/fraud-in-science/"
Still gonna go with mere speculation?And if according to Broad and Wade for every major case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected which even the survey concedes the actual frequencies of misconduct could be higher. We are looking at a staggering number of science fraud committed.
The number arrived is 2% of scientists admit to fraud which is higher than the 1% quoted in other studies. And if according to Broad and Wade for every major case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected which even the survey concedes the actual frequencies of misconduct could be higher.
Here is an actual study.
How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data
http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0005738
The number arrived is 2% of scientists admit to fraud which is higher than the 1% quoted in other studies. And if according to Broad and Wade for every major case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected which even the survey concedes the actual frequencies of misconduct could be higher. We are looking at a staggering number of science fraud committed.
The numbers are so alarming that the UK government has introduced new policies to curb the damage it is doing to their reputation and competitiveness as a global researcher.
The bad science scandal: how fact-fabrication is damaging UK's global name for research.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/s...ing-uks-global-name-for-research-8660929.html
As for actual numbers of fraud committed, concealed, escaped detection or were just ignored is substantial. One article stated 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment(2012).
[...]
How many papers were studied? 2000Read the article again. It is exactly as I quoted it.
http://www.the-scientist.com/?articles.view/articleNo/33695/title/Top-Science-Scandals-of-2012/
"In fact, more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment. "
How many papers were studied ? 2000
What percentage were retracted ? 65%
Put that together.
In fact, more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment.
It's not all studies indexed by PubMed - it's all studies indexed by PubMed as retracted. The studies were "indexed" as "retracted". I know I'm about the eighth person to point this out to you, but I'm optimistic that eventually you will grasp the fact that the researchers selected only those studies that had been retracted.A detailed review of all 2,047 biomedical and life-science research articles indexed by PubMed as retracted on May 3, 2012
How many papers were studied? 2000
What percentage were retracted? 100%
What percentage were retracted due to misconduct? 65%
Try highlighting a different bit of your quote and re-reading it:
"In fact, more than 65 percent of the 2,000 or so papers studied were retracted because of poor ethical judgment. "
All the papers were retracted, but not all of them were retracted for misconduct. The percentage that was retracted because of misconduct was 65%.
The researchers selected, from the pool of all studies, only those studies which had been retracted.
It's not all studies indexed by PubMed - it's all studies indexed by PubMed as retracted. The studies were "indexed" as "retracted". I know I'm about the eighth person to point this out to you, but I'm optimistic that eventually you will grasp the fact that the researchers selected only those studies that had been retracted.
So, if that speculation about fraud being 100x more prevalent than reported is right then we'd be faced with the horrifying prospect of a fraud rate of 5%? So 95% of papers indexed on PubMed are not the result of fraud? And this is the worst case scenario? Huh. It's not as bad as I'd expected given justintime's outrage.How many papers total on PubMed since 1977?
EDIT: Wikipedia says 2.7 million. 1380 of them retract due to misconduct. That's what, 0.05%?
justintime's freaking out over 0.05%? Crazy.
Ah, he's an optimist then.He gets it.
He's hoping that there is an audience out there that won't see how disingenuous he's being.
Oh, my. Another book you have not read.Here is an actual study.
How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data
http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0005738
The number arrived is 2% of scientists admit to fraud which is higher than the 1% quoted in other studies. And if according to Broad and Wade for every major case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected which even the survey concedes the actual frequencies of misconduct could be higher. We are looking at a staggering number of science fraud committed.
Actually, according to you sources, we are perhaps looking at what could be a staggering number of science fraud being committed.The number arrived is 2% of scientists admit to fraud which is higher than the 1% quoted in other studies. And if according to Broad and Wade for every major case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected which even the survey concedes the actual frequencies of misconduct could be higher. We are looking at a staggering number of science fraud committed.
Actually, according to you sources, we are perhaps looking at what could be a staggering number of science fraud being committed.
Here is an actual study.
How Many Scientists Fabricate and Falsify Research? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Survey Data
http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0005738
The number arrived is 2% of scientists admit to fraud which is higher than the 1% quoted in other studies. And if according to Broad and Wade for every major case of fraud that comes to light, perhaps 100 go undetected which even the survey concedes the actual frequencies of misconduct could be higher. We are looking at a staggering number of science fraud committed.