science fraud is common place

65% of 2000 papers studied were found fraudulent.
That is a lie, justintime.
43% of the 2047 retracted papers out of 25 million papers studied were retracted because of fraud or suspected fraud.
I do not recall any number in the paper for actually fraudulent retracted papers.

Followed by a fantasy of a 100 frauds per 1 detected. Then simple math screwed up based on the other fantasy that the 2047 retracted papers were every paper published in PubMed :jaw-dropp!

The proper math is:
* 43% of 2047 retracted papers = 962 retracted papers due to fraud or suspected fraud.
Now apply your fantasy:
* 100 * 962 = 96200 "fraudulent" papers.
* Fraction of "fraudulent" papers = 96200/25000000 =0.0038
* Percentage of "fraudulent" papers = 0.0038 * 100 = 0.38%
 
That is a lie, justintime.
43% of the 2047 retracted papers out of 25 million papers studied were retracted because of fraud or suspected fraud.
I do not recall any number in the paper for actually fraudulent retracted papers.

Followed by a fantasy of a 100 frauds per 1 detected. Then simple math screwed up based on the other fantasy that the 2047 retracted papers were every paper published in PubMed :jaw-dropp!

The proper math is:
* 43% of 2047 retracted papers = 962 retracted papers due to fraud or suspected fraud.
Now apply your fantasy:
* 100 * 962 = 96200 "fraudulent" papers.
* Fraction of "fraudulent" papers = 96200/25000000 =0.0038
* Percentage of "fraudulent" papers = 0.0038 * 100 = 0.38%

Lets try it this way. 25 million papers published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.
 
Lets try it this way. 25 million papers published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

No wonder you apparently hate math and science,...it seems they don't care much for you either.
 
Lets try it this way. 25 million papers published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.

lol. If 14% of scientists report to know another scientist that published fraudulent data it does not mean 14% of scientists publish fraud. Scientists know hundreds of colleagues and if one of them thinks someones work is suspect, it does tend to get around. I'm actually surprised the number is as low as 14%, you'd think every scientist would know of at least 1 person if fraud was at all common. Also, even if one scientist does published some fraudulent data, it doesn't mean every paper they published is fraudulent. Likely that is not the case, so you cannot extrapolate the number if scientists that committed fraud at least once to the total number of fraudulent papers.
 
Originally Posted by justintime View Post
Lets try it this way. 25 million papers published. 14% of scientist are reported by their peers as guilty of fraud. what is 14% of 25million? 3,500,000 papers are fraudulent.

for every fraud a 100 goes undetected.
3.5 million papers x 100 = 350,000000. OMG 1,400% of papers are fraudulent.


lol. If 14% of scientists report to know another scientist that published fraudulent data it does not mean 14% of scientists publish fraud. Scientists know hundreds of colleagues and if one of them thinks someones work is suspect, it does tend to get around. I'm actually surprised the number is as low as 14%, you'd think every scientist would know of at least 1 person if fraud was at all common. Also, even if one scientist does published some fraudulent data, it doesn't mean every paper they published is fraudulent. Likely that is not the case, so you cannot extrapolate the number if scientists that committed fraud at least once to the total number of fraudulent papers.

Read the post again. 2% of scientists admit to committing fraud. When asked about the behavior of their colleagues scientists admitted knowing a good 14% of their colleagues were guilty of fraud. It is not 14% of scientists reporting they know other scientists committing fraud. They believe 14% of scientists are also committing fraud but not admitting it.
 
He's not even pretending to be serious anymore. Why keep feeding him?
 
Some basic reading and math for justintime

...snipped justintime embarrassing themself...
Lets try some basic reading and math (you do know basic reading and math, justintime :rolleyes:?)
That is a lie, justintime.
43% of the 2047 retracted papers out of 25 million papers studied were retracted because of fraud or suspected fraud.
...
The proper math is:
* 43% of 2047 retracted papers = 962 retracted papers due to fraud or suspected fraud.
Now apply your fantasy:
* 100 * 962 = 96200 "fraudulent" papers.
* Fraction of "fraudulent" papers = 96200/25000000 =0.0038
* Percentage of "fraudulent" papers = 0.0038 * 100 = 0.38%
 
It's obvious that somewhere, sometime, some skeptic/scientist pissed in your paranormal cornflakes.

I'll ask again JiT, What woo do you do?
Apparently he thinks he's overturned Evolutionary theory:

Evolution is true but not as it is taught or believed by evolutionists.

Here is a link to my Unified Theory of Evolution...work in progress. It is not your typical creationists arguments. I provided some new ideas by unifying new data and discoveries. And of course there are detractors who challenged my views.


Unified theory of evolution...work in progress
http://www.rationalskepticism.org/c...ory-of-evolution-work-in-progress-t29769.html
So there you have it. The guy who can't understand how percentages work thinks he's overturned our understanding of evolution.
 
Read the post again. 2% of scientists admit to committing fraud. When asked about the behavior of their colleagues scientists admitted knowing a good 14% of their colleagues were guilty of fraud. It is not 14% of scientists reporting they know other scientists committing fraud. They believe 14% of scientists are also committing fraud but not admitting it.

Dead wrong. The 14% number is from the surveys where scientists were asked if they knew of a colleague that had committed misconduct. If they knew of one colleague that committed misconduct once, it would count as a "yes."


"Many surveys have asked scientists directly whether they have committed or know of a colleague who committed research misconduct"
 
"Many surveys have asked scientists directly whether they have committed or know of a colleague who committed research misconduct"
An extreme (non-real!) example of how those surveys may have got the wrong results.
Scientists do not work in isolation. Say Bob is a fraudulent scientist who is a chatterbox. Bob lets it slip to 99 other scientists that some of his work is dubious. All 100 scientists get the survey. The result will much bigger than the expected 1%!

So I hope that these surveys separated the questions, e.g.
A) Have you committed research misconduct?
B) Do you know anyone who has committed research misconduct?
Even then question B is dubious since the survey may end up with multiple reports of the same person.

ETA: The meta-analysis paper does separate the 2 questions and gets the result that reporting others misconduct is higher then self reporting. Not much of a surprise.
 
Last edited:
I hope everyone folliwng this thread can see that justintime's argument is not only dishonest, it reflects profound innumeracy. 6500% indeeed.
 
lol. If 14% of scientists report to know another scientist that published fraudulent data it does not mean 14% of scientists publish fraud.
This is more true than JiT knows. If someone asked me "Do you know any scientist who has committed fraud?" I would have to say yes. However, the fraud they committed had to do with accounting, not the actual scientific process--as far as the scientific process goes, this organization is actually quite good. So I'd be part of that 14%, but my results would enver add to the number of papers that contained fraud.

Secondly, a lot of work in science never gets published. There's no good venue for publishing experiments that fail, for example, so anyone who commits fraud and fails anyway would be part of the 14% but not part of the frauds in published literature.

Third, there's a question of "What IS fraud?" If they allowed the individual researchers to define it they'd get as many answers as there are researchers. If THEY define it, however, their definition is open for debate. For example, is removing obviously erronious data from the dataset fraud? Some people say so, others do not. How much manipulation can you do to the data before it's fraud? Some manipulation is obviously necessary; however, too much distorts the data. As a professor once told me, take the log enough times and you eventually get a straight line. Is inclusion of profesional opinion fraud? I've made arguments to multiple federal agencies that amount to "because I say so", despite the fact that I can't cite a single source for my argument. These were based on extensive field work done in the past in the area, but they remain unsupported via the literature. Any of that can be included as fraud, or not, depending on the researcher's mood.
 
I hope everyone folliwng this thread can see that justintime's argument is not only dishonest, it reflects profound innumeracy. 6500% indeeed.

You have my source and the numbers are taken from a peer-review study. I even solicited independent calculations from members to eliminate personal bias. And many volunteered their calculations.

jt512 wrote: OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9744168&postcount=680

Belz wrote: 25 million.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9751263&postcount=781

temporalillusion wrote: 6,500%!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9751886&postcount=794

temporalillusion wrote: 25,000,000%!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9752048&postcount=797

temporalillusion wrote: ∞% (which is symbol for infinity)
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9752771&postcount=815
 
John Jones said:
I hope everyone folliwng this thread can see that justintime's argument is not only dishonest, it reflects profound innumeracy. 6500% indeeed.
Add "completely lacking in humor, a sense of irony, and the capacity to understand the written word" to that. Just so no one needs to click the links, every one of those were mocking JiT's ideas by demonstrating the mathematical absurdity. I honestly didn't think it possible that JiT would take them seriously, but apparently I was wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom