science fraud is common place

If a survey was done to point out how many JREF members supported fraud in science. Those participating in the OP 'science fraud is commonplace' would be included in the survey and the result would show the majority except Maartenn and Justintime support science fraud, which accurately reflects what the scientific community is saying about scientific fraud in the scientific community. It is real and many accept it and are even willing to defend it.

Maartenn is a wiki user with applicable antecedent. Maartenn100 is a user here with antecedents in changing his own post content substantially after it has been responded to or after discussion has moved past that point.
You likely intended to refer to the latter user so we'll stick to that one.

The other user you mention appears to possess antecedents in misrepresenting and misassigning data.

Perhaps, justintime, if you want to accuse parties of fraud, you may want to be more careful.


E.T.A.: Even if your spelling of (still assignable to users here) usernames was intentionally off.
 
Last edited:
If a survey was done to point out how many JREF members supported fraud in science. Those participating in the OP 'science fraud is commonplace' would be included in the survey and the result would show the majority except Maartenn and Justintime support science fraud, which accurately reflects what the scientific community is saying about scientific fraud in the scientific community. It is real and many accept it and are even willing to defend it.

None of that is anything like the survey you keep quoting. You are simply lying, now.
 
If a survey was done to point out how many JREF members supported fraud in science. Those participating in the OP 'science fraud is commonplace' would be included in the survey and the result would show the majority except Maartenn and Justintime support science fraud, which accurately reflects what the scientific community is saying about scientific fraud in the scientific community. It is real and many accept it and are even willing to defend it.
Hmmm, I notice you don't disagree with my logic.

That settles it then. Someone draw up a survey; I want to build an army.


:D
 
If a survey was done to point out how many JREF members supported fraud in science. Those participating in the OP 'science fraud is commonplace' would be included in the survey and the result would show the majority except Maartenn and Justintime support science fraud, which accurately reflects what the scientific community is saying about scientific fraud in the scientific community. It is real and many accept it and are even willing to defend it.

No one has supported, endorsed, defended, or even suggested support of science fraud.

I have some difficulty understanding how anyone of reasonable sanity could be THIS against science as process. It's like being against progress, or knowledge, or something. Oh... I see....
 
In reading through this thread, the tone seems far more Conspiracy Theory vs Science focused; as such moved to Conspiracy Theories.
Posted By: Locknar
 
Of course no-one has "discovered" that science fraud is commonplace. You have just claimed it.

My point (since you missed it) is that I don't get how anyone can be opposed to science in general. It's like being against, say, auto mechanics, the sunrise, puppies, or the spleen. It makes no sense. So yeah, CT is a lovely place for it.

But science fraud is not a conspiracy. It is fraud. It was always thought science was self correcting and therefore un-corruptable. But with so many scientists engaged in fraud and a culture of deceit in the scientific community, the appearance of a conspiracy is not overblown hyperbole. Scientists are quite capable of organizing such grand schemes of deception.
 
But science fraud is not a conspiracy. It is fraud. It was always thought science was self correcting and therefore un-corruptable. But with so many scientists engaged in fraud and a culture of deceit in the scientific community, the appearance of a conspiracy is not overblown hyperbole. Scientists are quite capable of organizing such grand schemes of deception.


Please define the following terms:

science

scientist

fraud

culture of deceit

scientific community

scheme(s) of deception
 
But science fraud is not a conspiracy. It is fraud. It was always thought science was self correcting and therefore un-corruptable. But with so many scientists engaged in fraud and a culture of deceit in the scientific community, the appearance of a conspiracy is not overblown hyperbole. Scientists are quite capable of organizing such grand schemes of deception.

Sentences 3 and 4 here are just, well, incorrect. There is fraud in science, sure, just as there is in accounting, carpentry, or the national football league.

Thing is: "science" is really just the label we put on the process of finding things out about stuff. I guess you are against that whole thing because you have a favorite book. Whatever floats your boat...
 
But science fraud is not a conspiracy.

You are assuming that frauds in science are WAY higher than they actually are and that, presumably, scientists are keeping mum about it. What is that if not a conspiracy ? And since it's totally unevidenced and mostly driven by your incredibly inane misinterpretation of actual data, I think it's a good fit for this subforum.

It was always thought science was self correcting and therefore un-corruptable.

What sheer fantasy. No one every thought or claimed this.

But with so many scientists engaged in fraud

0.005% is NOT many.

and a culture of deceit

Unevidenced drivel.

Scientists are quite capable of organizing such grand schemes of deception.

So now you admit that it IS a conspiracy ? Your frothing rage against science is having quite an effect on your posting consistency.
 
But science fraud is not a conspiracy. It is fraud. It was always thought science was self correcting and therefore un-corruptable. But with so many scientists engaged in fraud and a culture of deceit in the scientific community, the appearance of a conspiracy is not overblown hyperbole. Scientists are quite capable of organizing such grand schemes of deception.

And that is the conspiracy: organizing such grand schemes.

... which you have not demonstrated. Your posts have, so far, demonstrated no awareness and/or acknowledgement of the fact that you have yet to demonstrate your basic thesis. You have been repeatedly told why, yet you seem to cling to your idea that all papers have a high rate of fraud. This is most likely either innumeracy, reading comprehension problems, or intentional. The latter seems likely given your repeated ignoring of questions on the meaning of values like 200% (e.g. what does it mean if I eat 200% of my dessert pie?).
 
Lets revist the math.

The study found 2% of scientists admit to fraud. It was also reported elsewhere scientists publish under several different names to avoid detection or to enhance their chances of getting publicity. Let us give it a number say 5 different publishers or publications.
2% x5 = 10% of publications are fraudulent.

Now for every 1 major fraud 100 go undetected.
10% x 100 = OMG 1000% of science is fraudulent.

But the survey found 14% of scientists admitted to knowing someone a peer/collegue committing fraud.

Rework the math.

14% x 5 = 70%

Now for every 1 major fraud 100 go undetected.
70% x 100 = OMG 7,000% of science is fraudulent.

Of course 0.005% is not many. But 7,000% is.
 
Your basic math is broken. Your statistics are even worse. These numbers do not work the way you think they do.
 
Lets revist the math.

The study found 2% of scientists admit to fraud. It was also reported elsewhere scientists publish under several different names to avoid detection or to enhance their chances of getting publicity. Let us give it a number say 5 different publishers or publications.
2% x5 = 10% of publications are fraudulent.

Now for every 1 major fraud 100 go undetected.
10% x 100 = OMG 1000% of science is fraudulent.

But the survey found 14% of scientists admitted to knowing someone a peer/collegue committing fraud.

Rework the math.

14% x 5 = 70%

Now for every 1 major fraud 100 go undetected.
70% x 100 = OMG 7,000% of science is fraudulent.

Of course 0.005% is not many. But 7,000% is.

So not only is ALL of science fraudulent, but so are 6 other things? Fascinating....
 
Lets revist the math.

The study found 2% of scientists admit to fraud. It was also reported elsewhere scientists publish under several different names to avoid detection or to enhance their chances of getting publicity. Let us give it a number say 5 different publishers or publications.

So we revisit the math by imagining numbers and multiplying them together ?

Now for every 1 major fraud 100 go undetected.
10% x 100 = OMG 1000% of science is fraudulent.

Yeah, that's idiotic, and YOU came up with it.

But the survey found 14% of scientists admitted to knowing someone a peer/collegue committing fraud.

Could all be the same guy, for all you know.

Rework the math.

14% x 5 = 70%

Again, that factor of 5 is complete fabrication. In addition to that, the 14% DOESN'T MEAN that 14% of science papers are frauds. How you can come to that conclusion, without being lying, boggles the mind.

Now for every 1 major fraud 100 go undetected.
70% x 100 = OMG 7,000% of science is fraudulent.

Of course 0.005% is not many. But 7,000% is.

It's also impossible. You can't get a number above 100% one way or another.

0.005% is the real number: (0.65 x 2000) / 25M = 0.000052 or 0.0052%

Seriously, you're either dishonest and lying, or you are the absolute worst person at math and statistics I've ever encountered.
 
Why couldn't he be both? Either way, the "calculations" (or, to borrow justintime's phrase, "the math") are beyond ludicrous.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom