How good is your theory?

lpetrich

Muse
Joined
Feb 14, 2007
Messages
762
How Good is Your Theory? Open Thread I – Starts With A Bang Ethan Siegel proposed this hierarchy:

3. Scientific law - superstrong, very well tested, though may still get some modifications.
2. Validated - strong, but with some problems.
1. Speculative - neither well-supported nor rejected.
0. Ruled out - rejected with the force of scientific law.

(my descriptions) This is for assessing what one sees in news-media stories, because all too often such stories don't present how strong various theories and results are. Furthermore, speculative stuff is often more dramatic than well-established stuff.

His ratings:
  • General relativity: 3
  • Dark matter: 2.2
  • Cosmic inflation: 1.9
  • Extra dimensions: 0.975
  • The Earth being 6000 years old: 0.0375
(measured off of his graph) There are some problems. In the late 19th cy., one would plausibly have claimed that Newtonian mechanics was close to 3, but a few decades later, relativity and quantum mechanics became very well established, reducing Newtonianism to an approximation for (length)/(time) << c and (mass)*(length)^2/(time) >> h. A very successful approximation nonetheless, and still worth a 3 there.


Here are some notable speculative or controversial hypotheses of the past that are nowadays pretty close to 3:

Continental drift, Late-Pleistocene giant floods, impact cratering, eukaryotic endosymbiosis

Here are some more speculative hypotheses that have gotten a lot of support in recent years, and that may be close to 2:

The RNA world in the early evolution of life, Mars's former ocean, the Moon's origin by a giant impact, cosmic inflation

These ones are closer to 1, I think:

Supersymmetry, grand unified theories, string theory (pretty much 1, I'd say)
 
Not wild about the designations. I think there is a semantics issue that does not help and I don't really understand how a numerics rating would help anything.

I prefer confidence levels ala AGW 95% that current global warming is primarily of human origin due to use of fossil fuels.
I think that is a better gradient than fractions of 0-3.

Dark matter at 2.2 strikes me as overly confident and cosmic inflation as under confidence given the latter is so central to Big Bang theory
Metric expansion is a key feature of Big Bang cosmology
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metric_expansion_of_space
 
Well I can't speak to many of the other theories out there, but the post asked "How good is your theory?".

MY theory is a 1. The good news is that a couple days ago I ran it by a Phd scientist from the state university, (as well as a few others from various states) and he will help me in the verification.
 
Well, it misunderstands what a law is. A law isn't a theory that is almost certainly true. A law describes observations. A theory proposes a mechanism to explain observations. Not the same thing.
 
His arbitrary point systems sounds like it was written by someone who doesn't science. Allow me to introduce my own arbitrary point system. Also, there is no such thing as an immutable "law" in actual science, it's a term often misused outside of science. Laws are just very useful theories.

In my opinion, a theory is measured by the accuracy of it's predictions. Take the theory of gravity:

Copernicus: Heliocentrism with orbits being circles, was no more accurate or less convoluted than the geocentric models at the time. (3/10)

Galileo's Kinematics: What you learned in high school. Useful for large objects falling short distances. 9.8m/s, etc. Useful for more than half of life's everyday dilemmas in physics. (6/10)

Newton's law of universal gravitation: Was derived from Kepler's laws of planetary motion, describes the inverse square law and accurately predicts the motion of celestial bodies. This is college level orbital mechanics. We used these to get the Apollo Astronauts to the moon. The only exception, Mercury eludes prediction with this theory. (9/10)

Einstein's relativity: Predicts that Mercury is moving so quickly in it's speedy orbit around the sun that it is subject to effects of relativity. Also introduces interesting dilemmas, like what happens at the speed of light. (9.8/10)

None of these theories overturn each other, they just increase in accuracy. Similarly sundials<grandfather clocks<atomic watches. You don't always need an atomic watch down to the millisecond, sometimes a sundial will suffice.
 
Last edited:
My theory is excellent, regardless of what close-minded mainstream scientists and the so-called skeptics say.
 
lpetrich said:
Here are some notable speculative or controversial hypotheses of the past that are nowadays pretty close to 3:

Continental drift, Late-Pleistocene giant floods, impact cratering, eukaryotic endosymbiosis
This demonstrates the problem with this hierarchy: it relies upon knowledge of the thing. There is no way to view geology except through the lens of plate tectonics (continental drift has been disproven--you cannot push felsic crust through mafic crust). Late-Pleistocene giant floods are as certain as the existence of Julius Ceaser; the issue is scale. They were regional events, not global ones. I can think of three off the top of my head (though not the names). The Salton Sea is in the site of one periodic flood event, as is the Mediterranian Sea. Impact craters are proven as well--just about the only question remaining is "What caused them?" (Unless you're going with the nonsensical "Geology is a lie!" impact crater concept that pops up from time to time on this forum).

I can see why someone who hasn't studied geology is underestimating the amount of support these concepts have. Once you actually sink your teeth into the literature, however, it becomes clear that it is not possible to reject these ideas rationally. So clearly knowledge is influencing the ranking.

I also don't see the utility of this ranking. What difference does it make whether something is a 2 or a 4? The only valid question is "Do the data support the conclusion?" If no, we're done. If yes, we can ask "To what degree?" and "Where are there problems?" Repeat until you know everything or the death of the universe, whichever comes first.
 
His arbitrary point systems sounds like it was written by someone who doesn't science. Allow me to introduce my own arbitrary point system. Also, there is no such thing as an immutable "law" in actual science, it's a term often misused outside of science. Laws are just very useful theories.
Hmm, Ph. D. in theoretical astrophysics (is their any other kind?) from U.Flor., worked astrophysics research at the University of Arizona, professor at the University of Portland currently the head curator at Trapit.
While I disagree somewhat with his attempt to create a hierarchy he has a good hard science background.

Anyway, I have a theory.
 
Ha! Yeah, I did qualify with a "sounds like" not a science background. Perhaps this is his attempt to explain theories to the layman?
 
Just because someone has a good science background doesn't mean that their understanding of science is good. Most scientists I've met have an extremely good understanding of their chosen field, but a very, very poor understanding of science itself. They are generally ignorant of the history of their fields, let alone anyone else's, for example. This results in ideas being tried repeatedly, and getting the same results.

There have always been attempts to formally designate and differentiate between theories with varying degrees of support. They all fail for the simple reason that each researcher is obliged to come to their own conclusions about this issue. This is one of the foundational concepts of science: each researcher is independent and obliged to follow the data, resulting in the increase in knowledge along all fronts and the ability to self-correct. Establishing a formal system to designate well-supported theories vs. unsupported vs. disproven undermines this, since someone has to do the designating. Even if we say "Everyone can do it", in practice you'd still end up with a small handful of people making these determinations. That's not science; that's politics.
 
3. Scientific law - superstrong, very well tested, though may still get some modifications.
2. Validated - strong, but with some problems.
1. Speculative - neither well-supported nor rejected.
0. Ruled out - rejected with the force of scientific law.
My theory is that you are on to something here.

Anybody want to rate my theory at more than zero? :p
 
I prefer confidence levels ala AGW 95% that current global warming is primarily of human origin due to use of fossil fuels.
I think that is a better gradient than fractions of 0-3.
You have a 76.23% chance of having a more reliable rating system than the OP has. :D
 
And of course:

"My theory, that I have, that is to say, which is mine... is mine."



Edit: Miss Anne Elk's theory may be that rare case which is both a three and a zero (the latter because the creature in question is no longer considered a thing).
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom