How Good is Your Theory? Open Thread I – Starts With A Bang Ethan Siegel proposed this hierarchy:
3. Scientific law - superstrong, very well tested, though may still get some modifications.
2. Validated - strong, but with some problems.
1. Speculative - neither well-supported nor rejected.
0. Ruled out - rejected with the force of scientific law.
(my descriptions) This is for assessing what one sees in news-media stories, because all too often such stories don't present how strong various theories and results are. Furthermore, speculative stuff is often more dramatic than well-established stuff.
His ratings:
Here are some notable speculative or controversial hypotheses of the past that are nowadays pretty close to 3:
Continental drift, Late-Pleistocene giant floods, impact cratering, eukaryotic endosymbiosis
Here are some more speculative hypotheses that have gotten a lot of support in recent years, and that may be close to 2:
The RNA world in the early evolution of life, Mars's former ocean, the Moon's origin by a giant impact, cosmic inflation
These ones are closer to 1, I think:
Supersymmetry, grand unified theories, string theory (pretty much 1, I'd say)
3. Scientific law - superstrong, very well tested, though may still get some modifications.
2. Validated - strong, but with some problems.
1. Speculative - neither well-supported nor rejected.
0. Ruled out - rejected with the force of scientific law.
(my descriptions) This is for assessing what one sees in news-media stories, because all too often such stories don't present how strong various theories and results are. Furthermore, speculative stuff is often more dramatic than well-established stuff.
His ratings:
- General relativity: 3
- Dark matter: 2.2
- Cosmic inflation: 1.9
- Extra dimensions: 0.975
- The Earth being 6000 years old: 0.0375
Here are some notable speculative or controversial hypotheses of the past that are nowadays pretty close to 3:
Continental drift, Late-Pleistocene giant floods, impact cratering, eukaryotic endosymbiosis
Here are some more speculative hypotheses that have gotten a lot of support in recent years, and that may be close to 2:
The RNA world in the early evolution of life, Mars's former ocean, the Moon's origin by a giant impact, cosmic inflation
These ones are closer to 1, I think:
Supersymmetry, grand unified theories, string theory (pretty much 1, I'd say)