science fraud is common place

And the members are also wrong when they refuse to accept such a thing as 200%.

We are not wrong when we reject your half-dozen or so attempts to cobble together some pseudo-math in order to justify your predetermined need for a "large number" of fraud cases in science.

It has been explained to you ad nauseam why you cannot have an over-unity result in your computation. You simply don't care whether you're right or wrong.

Well, here is another math tutorial on percentages taken from a math forum.

Post your examples on that forum and see what they tell you. You are conflating abstract considerations of percentage as the expression of a general ratio with percentages intended to be the fraction of a real-life whole. In the latter case, which is what your examples deal with, you cannot have a meaningful over-unity result.
 
The percentages of science fraud just keep increasing with each new revelation.

This explains a lot. Unlike your misinterpretation of science, actual science is not done via revelation. It's done via systematic analysis.

And if for every fraudster a 100 goes undetected, science is worse off than it was before Anders post.
I'm quoting this because I wouldn't believe it if someone had told me you'd say something this stupid. Ignoring the fact that Anders' arguments are the worst sort of nonsense, you are arguing that exposing fraud causes 100 more researchers to become frauds. Not that the exposure influences them, or encourages them, or drives them to it--you are arguing that exposing fraud is a magical incantation that directly produces more frauds.

This is just so bizarre that I'm not sure how to even process it, much less respond.

Belz... said:
Quick question: what are you ?
I feel like I've answered this question a few hundred times. I've even updated my signature to pre-emptively answer it. I'm an Objectivist. And before anyone says it, I do not believe that skepticism in practice is the same as skepticism in theory--meaning that the reason I do not call myself a skeptic isn't because of an uncritical acceptance of Objectivism (far from it), but rather because the skeptical movement contains elements I have no desire to be associated with. The fanatical devotion shown by some towards the likes of Dawkins, for example; pretty much any thread on social issues would be enough to drive someone away as well, as they demonstrate that skeptics fall into the same traps as theists, just in different arenas, and that many of them can't tollerate disagreement and feel the need to engage in verbal abuse directed towards those they disagree with.

Disclamer: I will not be answering any questions regarding Objectivism in this thread. This is neither the time nor the place. Nor will I defend my decision to explicitey dissociate myself from the skeptic movement. You want to associate with it, that's your call--I'm not saying anything about your activities. I'm reporting what I've done and my reasons; this is, again, neither the time nor the place to expect me to defend it.
 
These figures in this article you have appeared to have inflated using proved to be faulty mathematics.
 
These figures in this article you have appeared to have inflated using proved to be faulty mathematics.

Plus there are a bunch of other flaws we've pointed out, such as the fact that the 14% reporting they know someone who's committed some inappropriate action doesn't mean that 14% of scientists have done anything wrong (one scientist committing fraud can be known by dozens of people).
 
These figures in this article you have appeared to have inflated using proved to be faulty mathematics.

That is a matter of opinion. I have used independent number crunches and presented their results.

I even solicited independent calculations from members to eliminate personal bias. And many volunteered their calculations.

jt512 wrote: OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9744168&postcount=680

Belz wrote: 25 million.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9751263&postcount=781

temporalillusion wrote: 6,500%!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9751886&postcount=794

temporalillusion wrote: 25,000,000%!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9752048&postcount=797

temporalillusion wrote: ∞% (which is symbol for infinity)
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9752771&postcount=815

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9753674&postcount=819
 
That is a matter of opinion.

No, it is not. Your arguments have yet to demonstrate any meaningful understanding of statistics, or even of basic arithmetic concepts such as ratios and fractions.

You did not "solicit" other opinions, and those posts most certainly do not back your claims. They are other posters doggedly attempting to teach you remedial mathematics. Again, do not assume that because you struggle with arithmetic, that others on this board are similarly hobbled. You cannot bluff your way past others' competence in basic mathematics by claiming there is some unknown ambiguity that afflicts us all.

You. Are. Wrong.
 
No one is arguing against the numbers from the study, justintime.

Peoiple are arguing against your failed interpretation of those numbers, and your lack of understanding of what they actually mean.

Not to mention that you apparently seriously believe that you can have (for example) 200% of science be fraudulent.

Let me ask you a question, and please, I'd like to see you answer it.

If I you ate 200% of a pie, how much of that pie would you have eaten? Would it be more or less than if I you ate 100% of the pie?
Please give the answer in units of pie (i.e.-one pie, one-half pie, etc).

Or let's apply this to something else. Let's say you have $10,000...no more, no less. If you spend 50% of it, how much do you have left in dollars? If you spend 200% of it, how much do you have left?

ETA: If you'd like, I can get my 12 year old son to help here. He's covered percents and fractions in math and can understand these concepts.

But you are refuting numbers that came from independent sources, from fellow members who have no reason to fabricate their calculations. They all can't be wrong.

You have to prove PLOS the survey, jt512, temporalillusion, Belz and many others all colluded to prove science fraud is common place.
 
But you are refuting numbers that came from independent sources...

No, he's refuting your insistence on an over-unity result, and your unjustified desire to multiply every reported rate by a factor of 100. You've already revealed that your reason for doing this is to result in a "large number," so it will be difficult for you now to argue that you're actually trying to discover the real rate of misbehavior in science.
 
That is a matter of opinion.

No, math is not a matter of opinion. You are wrong, entirely.

jt512 wrote: OMG! 200% of science is fraudulent!

Belz wrote: 25 million.

temporalillusion wrote: 6,500%!

temporalillusion wrote: 25,000,000%!

temporalillusion wrote: ∞% (which is symbol for infinity)

All of which were provided to illustrate how wrong your are, since those percentages are impossible in this context.
 
Someone once describe the scientific method as "Asking questions and not ignoring the answers," and everything else is just methodology.
 
justintime said:
The 14% is from PLOS survey where 14% admitted they knew someone guilty of science fraud but were not detected.
No. 14% said they knew someone guilty (by some undefined metric) of MISCONDUCT, not fraud. Fraud is a subset of misconduct.

So working with real numbers and not just the scientists admitting fraud 14% was the more accurate number of actual scientists who committed fraud but not all were detected..
No. The 14% included more than fraud. Even ignoring that, at best you can only say that AT MOST 14% of scientists are guilty of misconduct. There is almost certainly going to be massive overlaps in who knows whom, resulting in the actual number of misconduct cases being much lower (Akri explained it to you a week or two ago).

14% of 25,000,000 is 3.5 million papers are actually fraudulent which is all papers considered and not just the 2000 studied.
This is not a valid way to determine rates of fraud going undetected.

Here if we apply Board and Wade's analysis where for every major fraud 100 go undetected
That wasn't an analysis, it was a baseless assumption made as a rhetorical device to drive a point home.

Now convert 350,000,000 to a percent of 25 million. ????
You are honestly willing to argue that more papers are fraudulant than even exist. This is why people mock your inability to do math.

If you apply scenario 2 where each scientists published 5 papers under a pseudonym...
Such events are exceedingly rare. There is no advantage to publishing under a pseudonym in science, and in fact it can be detrimental--publication rates are used to determine things like whether you keep your job. The only times this happens are the tremendously rare cases of someone attempting to prove a point about the peer review process.

Let's put it this way: I've met hundreds of scientists, and read thousands of papers. I've yet to meet one that's published under a pseudonym, or read a paper published under one. My experience is not unique. If pseudonmys were common enough to impact calculated fraud rates, this would not happen.

The numbers we get start from 3.5 million to 17.5 million to 350 million. If you take away the low and high numbers you get 17.5 million which is 70% out of 25 million papers are fraudulent.
This is based on nothing more than wishful thinking, inability to do math, and that old favorite, making crap up.
 
You have not followed my posts correctly.

Oh the irony...

If you apply scenario 2 where each scientists published 5 papers under a pseudonym then the actual number of fraudulent papers will be 3.5 million x 5 = 17.7 million

No. The number of supposedly fraudulent scientists is the same and no distinction was made in the type of fraud you are claiming - you have already counted the papers they have published.

Furthermore, you have no evidence that these duplicate papers contain fraudulent data, just that the authors are fictitious.
 
justintime said:
That is why you discard the low and high numbers which I have and came up with 17.5 million out of 25 million papers are fraudulent.
Discarding the high and low numbers doesn't make your entirely fictional calculations any less fictional.

If you like percentages it is 70% of 25 million papers are fraudulent.
So that means roughly three out of every four papers are fraudulent--all based on the assumption that 14% of scientists engage in fraud. You REALLY don't see a problem with that?!

There no more over-unity fractions or ultra high numbers.
It's only taken us two weeks to convince you that such are impossible. Were I you, I'd drop the smug tone.

Every calculation presented several scenarios.
None of which reflect reality in the slightest.

By discarding the high and low numbers we have followed standard statistical procedures.
I don't think you understand what standard statistical procedures are.

Remember average, mean, median and mode.
The mean, median, and mode of made-up nonsense is still made-up nonsense. These also have nothing to do with discarding the high and low numbers of any calculation, much less flagrantly erroneous ones.
 
That is why you discard the low and high numbers which I have and came up with 17.5 million out of 25 million papers are fraudulent. If you like percentages it is 70% of 25 million papers are fraudulent.

No. The reason I discarded those other values is because they are demonstrably impossible, and I have explained to you at length why they are.

There no more over-unity fractions or ultra high numbers. Every calculation presented several scenarios.

No. Just because you finally settled on a value that isn't more than 100% doesn't mean it still isn't the same sort of arithmetic voodoo you've relied upon all through this thread. You're still just randomly throwing numbers together and applying random arithmetical transformations. It's not an actual viable model.

Arriving at an over-unity result is ipso facto proof that a model is invalid. Arriving at a proper fraction is not, conversely, proof that the model is valid.

By discarding the high and low numbers we have followed standard statistical procedures. Remember average, mean, median and mode.

No. Disregarding outlying values in a measured variable (i.e., because it exhibits normal variance) is not the same "statistical" process as you randomly grasping at inferred values through various pseudo-mathematical gymnastics.
 
http://einstein.stanford.edu/

Final results of the GP-B experiment were announced at NASA HQ in Washington DC on 4 May 2011.

The experimental results are in agreement with Einstein's theoretical predictions of the geodetic effect (0.28% margin of error) and the frame-dragging effect (19% margin of error).
 
If the known percent of fraudulent scientists are duplication their fraudulent paper across several publications. Then all the publication under their pseudonym will all be the same. Duh!!!!!

You have yet to demonstrate that

1) scientists duplicate fraudulant portions of their research in ways that were not accounted for in the original study (remember, fraud rates are 0.005% of publication rates); or

2) that significant numbers of scientists use pseudonyms.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom