I experience, therefore I am

To be clear for the people who do not understand this idea (or won't understand this idea)=

Light has absolute properties.
It means: reference-frame-independent it has always the same value:
Its value is exactly 299,792,458 metres per second in vacuüm, reference-frame-independent.

Light is een Absolute object in this world.

It means: its clock is always zero.
And whenever a clock of an object is always equal to zero, this object cannot have any spatial dimension.
Because space=time and vice versa. Space means: a timescale and vice versa.

Ergo light is not from this world as we understand it.

It has properties independent from space and time-measurements.
It's absolute value, c, is the backbone for the referenceframes for time and space-measurements. (and observers of course)

So, we may have reasons to be suspicious when we discover the values of this object.
 
Last edited:
Okay, fewer words.

  • I can fly by flapping my arms.
  • I can turn left.

What is different and what is similar?

Hmmm. An IQ test. Lemme see. Um:
``I can`` is the same. Both sentences are in regard to you. Both sentences are in English. Both are typed on a forum called JREF. They are both motions. Both lines are short sentences. They both share r, l, and f in their sentences(besides the words ``I can``.
.
The tricky thing i am pondering is that maybe someone flapping their wings is turning left while doing so. Then `inclusive` would be a better word than `similar.
.
What`s different about the two sentences? Everything other than stuff i said...unless i am missing some stuff.
 
Light is een Absolute object in this world.

It means: its clock is always zero.
And whenever a clock of an object is always equal to zero, this object cannot have any spatial dimension.
.

Light is not an object. What do you mean by ''absolute object''? Please stop peddling your mistaken ''theories'' and actually answer some questions. Why can't you do that?
 
dafydd said:
(Post not directed at me, fyi)
.
How about flowers that get off on listening to Led Zeppelin?

Flowers never did have any taste. Vegetables listen to Captain Beefheart.

And the stereotypes would have us believe that fruits listen to show tunes.
 
So you don't consider it worthwhile to differentiate between subjective and objective as to different kinds of processes of if you like all of reality works the same because a material explanation amounts to exactly the same as both an objective and subjective explanation.

Objectively speaking, there is no qualitative difference between the two. Of course, from a subjective point of view, there is, but that's the whole thing with subjectivity.
 
So, the people who want to discuss on topic (with the content):

The tools of the materialist are limited to discover everything there is to know about this world.
The materialist is a blind fool when it comes to our own existence. Your awareness or consciousness is nonsense for him. Your 'experiening the world' is gibberish or wordsalad in his language.
How foolish and blind can you be?

Ergo (logic conclusion)

He cannever make a descent model of the whole Nature of the Universe with his poor tools. Never. He will be blind for certain 'things' in this world and his language will stay limited to describe them.

But, you may have some reasonable doubts about his model, when you look at his tools (math and verifiable evidence).
You may have doubts that he is capable a giving us a descend description of the whole Nature of the Universe.
 
Last edited:
So, the people who want to discuss on topic (with the content):

The tools of the materialist are limited to discover everything there is to know about this world.
The materialist is a blind fool when it comes to our own existence. Your awareness or consciousness is nonsense for him. Your 'experiening the world' is gibberish or wordsalad in his language.
How foolish and blind can you be?

Ergo (logic conclusion)

He cannever make a descent model of the whole Nature of the Universe with his poor tools. Never. He will be blind for certain 'things' in this world and his language will stay limited to describe them.

But, you may have some reasonable doubts about his model, when you look at his tools (math and verifiable evidence).
You may have doubts that he is capable a giving us a descend description of the whole Nature of the Universe.

Still not answering questions?
 
He cannever make a descent model of the whole Nature of the Universe with his poor tools. Never. He will be blind for certain 'things' in this world and his language will stay limited to describe them.

Describe your tools and tell us what the whole nature of the universe is, whatever that means.
 
I suspect that we functionally both at some level "play" in part a fallacy of equivocation, namely that all usages of the words objective and subjective amount to the same respectively for both words individually.

As to "you are wrong", yes I know that it is not a property of you as you being wrong! Now please explain that to all you observe doing that within the contexts of the group of functional non-believers. Ask them, what wrong looks like???

So back to subjective and objective; I can if you want treat subjective and objective as processes and the same with experience as long you don't treat all experiences as the same. I.e. for the words objective and subjective in toto they overlap in some sense, but in others they differ:
  • I experience a computer screen in front of me.
  • I experience love for my wife.

So I will give you a choice well knowing that it is in part a false dichotomy in a sense, because you have other options; you can choose to list as many different usages of objective and subjective as you are able to or you can ask me to do so. If we then can agree somewhat upon those, we can start with measurement and what that is as a process, because we will be running in circles if we use the words objective and subjective differently together with the word measurement.

With regards
Tommy


Easy peasy. :D

An objective process is one that can be directly observed, a subjective process is one that can only be indirectly observed. I can watch you look at your monitor, but to watch you love your wife, I can see how you treat her, and react to even just the mention of her name. Either way, the results of you watching your monitor and loving your wife can be measured.

I do notice that neither you nor Maartenn100 addressed the fact that material changes, via drugs or physical trauma, can affect subjective experiences. If experience isn't material, why do material changes affect it so reliably?
 
Stand by for a have your cake and eat it answer.
Of course you could become a Jamesian radical empiricist (or so I dimly recall from studies nearly 50 years ago) and contend that experience is the only thing we can really confirm. We surmise the rest, and exactly what we call it may not matter. It doesn't help Martenn much, especially if he doesn't try reading any of it, a suspicion I have since no reader of James would assert that consciousness exists.
 
The limited tools of knowledge of the (idealised) materialist:

So, we can at least conclude this:

When you ask a pure materialist:
How do you discover that you had a certain dream last night?
Did you follow the math? Or did you use a detector or a measuring device?

When he is intellectually honest, he would say: indeed 'my own experience' was my only portal to this fact in Nature.

This would be the usual situation, but indeed the materialist could have placed electrodes on his head and obtained objective, material proof of his dream.

Or when you ask a materialist how he checked the evidence when a friend told him: I have an image of a big sculpture in my mind I want to make.

Again, he might place electrodes on his friend's head and obtain objective evidence.

(I don't want to see him open your head and detect some pulses in your brain. How would he do that?)

Irrelevant. If I give you a closed box with something inside but no means to open the box, the content is still there, even if you are not currently able to observe it. The existence of reality does not depend on our ability to observe it.

No mathematics at all can reveal us this information.

No scientific device in the world can reveal us the content of this image in the mind of our friends and family memebers.

As pointed out above, wrong.

Hans
 
Of course you are right. But that's not what I mean.
Without humans (or animals) or conscious objects in general in this world, this detector, on its own, can never discover such things like conscousness, awareness, experiening, believing, imagination, etc... in the chemistry he is anilizing.

Only when it's a conscious object itself.

Reality does not depend on our ability to observe it.

Have you ever considered the fact that 'consciousness' is only one phenomenon of a whole category of phenomena.
Our sort of matter has awareness. When you are such an object, you discover what 'awareness' is. (that's your only tool)

Unsupported claim.

But how would you exclude the fact that other materials, totally different from brains or computers in this world have something like conscousness or awareness too, but different.

I am a materialist: I have no reason to actively exclude it. It is your claim, you have to produce eveidence for it.

How would you exclude that electromagnetic radiation is 'something else too'? That light is not only what we can measure when we are studying the properties of electromagnetic radiation or fields?

How would you be able to exclude that a wave is not only a wave?

Why should I suspect it is anything but what I can observe?

Hans
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom