Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

My need for closure appears to be on a par with my ability to figure out how to use my mousepad to select the "send a PM to Kid Eager" option - below average.

Dave
 
Thanks to all that have contributed survey responses so far - keep them coming!
 
Here's some additional information that puts the claim in jakesteele's post in context:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closure_%28psychology%29#Need_for_Closure_Scale

And here's an online survey that one can do regarding need for closure:

http://www.psyctherapy.com/Enrolled/Activities/NeedForClosure.aspx

Perhaps if we get enough data from the surveys we can move from assertion to examination of evidence.

It would need to be answered honestly for it to be any good. It's easy for people to understand what answers lead to what results.
 
It would need to be answered honestly for it to be any good. It's easy for people to understand what answers lead to what results.

We completely understanding how that would be a challenge for you ;)
 
Last edited:
They've already argued against the idea that they're sensitive to cognitive dissonance. It's not like that test is going to fool them, especially when they can see the results at the end ;)
 
They've already argued against the idea that they're sensitive to cognitive dissonance. It's not like that test is going to fool them, especially when they can see the results at the end ;)

As always your not making any sense... But keep up the babbling ;)
 
It would need to be answered honestly for it to be any good. It's easy for people to understand what answers lead to what results.

Excuse me.

Even reading this charitably, this seems as if you are accusing me, and others, of dishonesty.

I suggest you consider restating your post.
 
It would need to be answered honestly for it to be any good. It's easy for people to understand what answers lead to what results.

Considering the topic of this thread, I'm sure you see the irony of this comment. Why try to get data when we can use anecdotes and assertions?
 
Last edited:
Why don't you start a psychology of skeptics thread? I would be happy to participate and answer any questions you might have. That way you don't have to complain how every other thread is not the psychology thread you so strongly wish it to be.

Win. Win.

Ontario already tried that with his Mentality thread and look what happened. It was quickly derailed into Bigfoot Bashing™. At some point down the line I rejacked™ the thread and got it back on track only to have it derailed again. People said Ontario was trying to be disingenuous and was secretly starting a thread about Bigfoot using insane logic like this:

His avatar is a bloke in a bad Chewie suit with a diaper on. I'll let that sink in for a moment.
Or:
What exactly are people steering the thread away from? Bigfoot is mentioned because that is what OS posts about. That is what OS comes here to discuss. It's in his name for Petes sake. Those of us who post regularly in the bigfoot threads know this. We knew it coming into the thread.

This is not just bad logic it’s FUBAR logic. How can anyone on this forum who considers themselves a skeptic let something like that slide by without pouncing on it and killing it before it grows?

By that same FUBAR illogic, if I started a psychology thread it could be derailed, the justification being what’s under my avatar. “We didn’t hijack the thread. Jake always intended this thread to be about UFOs. Look at what’s under his avatar, for God’s sake! InterGalactic! He secretly wants this thread to be about UFOs.

But before I go any further, I would like you to check these out:

http://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/

Yes, yes, I know; you’re thinking woo city. So did I when I first went there. Those kind of things interest me. It’s kind of like sci fi to me. What I didn’t expect was that there seem to be many ration, straight down the middle-of-the-road skeptics there. I’ve seen them many times refute things or at least point out that someone, like Michael Cremo, has been discredited or what not, but it does so without the rancor, disdain, mockery and condescension…almost.

Here is another link to a thread on SGU which is most telling in that it is coming from your own brethren:
http://sguforums.com/index.php/topic,33029.0.html
How often do you visit the JREF forums?

This one is quite interesting in that it is a less than glowing review of this site and its peoples. I recommend reading the thread in its entirety to get a look at how other like-minded people view you. It is doing something that you cannot paint with a broad brushstroke and dismiss as most people here doo with woo.

To start a psychology forum is something that would only work if it came from the main body of this site. That would give it gravitas and legitimacy. Coming from a guy like me or Ontario, who get automatically painted into the woo corner of the room with the Law of the Broad Brushstroke™ for daring to utter a dissenting word carries little or no gravitas. It needs to come from the will of the people.

I have been thinking about that a bit and I came to realize that the best type of forum would be one of psychology and logic combined. Call it The Psychology of Logic forum, the Logic of Psychology, LogiChology™ or PsychoLogical™ (has a nice ring to it), or whatever. It would help clean up the forum, help everyone learn about the psychology behind their logic and the logic or lack thereof, behind their psychology. It would be a place where bad logic and bad psychology goes to die. A place where healthy, ration skepticism can spread its gossamer wings and dance to the Music of the Spheres.

Strike that last sentence, I was waxing poetic and it makes my heart goe aflutter. Just being satirical, or sarcastic, whichever you prefer.

There, I’ve said my piece and I would like to thank you for asking a simple question without snark or rudeness…at least I hope it was intended that way.

Signing off for now

Jake Steele
InterGalactic Repo Man™
 
Last edited:
Here is another link to a thread on SGU which is most telling in that it is coming from your own brethren:
http://sguforums.com/index.php/topic,33029.0.html
How often do you visit the JREF forums?

This one is quite interesting in that it is a less than glowing review of this site and its peoples. I recommend reading the thread in its entirety to get a look at how other like-minded people view you. It is doing something that you cannot paint with a broad brushstroke and dismiss as most people here doo with woo.

I read the whole thread and I don't see what you claim to see. Now how on earth could that be?

To start a psychology forum is something that would only work if it came from the main body of this site. That would give it gravitas and legitimacy. Coming from a guy like me or Ontario, who get automatically painted into the woo corner of the room with the Law of the Broad Brushstroke™ for daring to utter a dissenting word carries little or no gravitas. It needs to come from the will of the people.

Well, don't hold your breath. From what I've seen, the psycholomahjizing you and OS are doing is simply worthless psychobabble. Why would we need a whole new category for this? No one else has needed a special place to park their whining lapses in logic, so why do you?
 
Aren't you of the opinion that these many members here are in fact pseudo-skeptics and the op and perhaps you are the (real) skeptics?

E.T.A.: I left a question for you in the other thread, here and here.

These SkeptiBunkersTM, are they the skeptics or the pseudo-skeptics?

What I mean about SkeptiBunkers is that I see people wearing two hats. One is the skeptic hat on other forums such as science and math. Good logical thinking and reasoning. No woo bashing, no insults, no snarkyness.

The other hat is a debunker's hat. Someone who already has their mind made up beforehand and is just looking for a way to justify their predetermined mindset.

Are you saying that the majority of the posters in this thread (SkeptiBunkersTM?) are in fact the real skeptics and not the pseudo-skeptics?

That question is a bit confusing. Yes, IMO most posters in this thread are SkeptiBunkers The next part of your question doesn’t compute.
 
It computes, but OntarioSquatch has already said that the title for the other thread was wrong and it's still not right. His choice of words appears to be wrong more than only once.

Also, he is unable to show the dissonance he talked about. I asked you as well up in this page, but no answer from you yet.
 
These SkeptiBunkersTM, are they the skeptics or the pseudo-skeptics?

What I mean about SkeptiBunkers is that I see people wearing two hats. One is the skeptic hat on other forums such as science and math. Good logical thinking and reasoning. No woo bashing, no insults, no snarkyness.

The other hat is a debunker's hat. Someone who already has their mind made up beforehand and is just looking for a way to justify their predetermined mindset.
Are you saying that the majority of the posters in this thread (SkeptiBunkersTM?) are in fact the real skeptics and not the pseudo-skeptics?

That question is a bit confusing. Yes, IMO most posters in this thread are SkeptiBunkers The next part of your question doesn’t compute.

After investigation do you make your mind up about things or are you perpetually on the fence?
 
^^^
Isn't it strange the constant re-defining/re-proposing of words for what purpose?
 
Ontario already tried that with his Mentality thread and look what happened. It was quickly derailed into Bigfoot Bashing™. At some point down the line I rejacked™ the thread and got it back on track only to have it derailed again. People said Ontario was trying to be disingenuous and was secretly starting a thread about Bigfoot using insane logic like this:

His avatar is a bloke in a bad Chewie suit with a diaper on. I'll let that sink in for a moment.
Or:
What exactly are people steering the thread away from? Bigfoot is mentioned because that is what OS posts about. That is what OS comes here to discuss. It's in his name for Petes sake. Those of us who post regularly in the bigfoot threads know this. We knew it coming into the thread.

This is not just bad logic it’s FUBAR logic. How can anyone on this forum who considers themselves a skeptic let something like that slide by without pouncing on it and killing it before it grows?

By that same FUBAR illogic, if I started a psychology thread it could be derailed, the justification being what’s under my avatar. “We didn’t hijack the thread. Jake always intended this thread to be about UFOs. Look at what’s under his avatar, for God’s sake! InterGalactic! He secretly wants this thread to be about UFOs.

But before I go any further, I would like you to check these out:

http://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/

Yes, yes, I know; you’re thinking woo city. So did I when I first went there. Those kind of things interest me. It’s kind of like sci fi to me. What I didn’t expect was that there seem to be many ration, straight down the middle-of-the-road skeptics there. I’ve seen them many times refute things or at least point out that someone, like Michael Cremo, has been discredited or what not, but it does so without the rancor, disdain, mockery and condescension…almost.

Here is another link to a thread on SGU which is most telling in that it is coming from your own brethren:
http://sguforums.com/index.php/topic,33029.0.html
How often do you visit the JREF forums?

This one is quite interesting in that it is a less than glowing review of this site and its peoples. I recommend reading the thread in its entirety to get a look at how other like-minded people view you. It is doing something that you cannot paint with a broad brushstroke and dismiss as most people here doo with woo.

To start a psychology forum is something that would only work if it came from the main body of this site. That would give it gravitas and legitimacy. Coming from a guy like me or Ontario, who get automatically painted into the woo corner of the room with the Law of the Broad Brushstroke™ for daring to utter a dissenting word carries little or no gravitas. It needs to come from the will of the people.

I have been thinking about that a bit and I came to realize that the best type of forum would be one of psychology and logic combined. Call it The Psychology of Logic forum, the Logic of Psychology, LogiChology™ or PsychoLogical™ (has a nice ring to it), or whatever. It would help clean up the forum, help everyone learn about the psychology behind their logic and the logic or lack thereof, behind their psychology. It would be a place where bad logic and bad psychology goes to die. A place where healthy, ration skepticism can spread its gossamer wings and dance to the Music of the Spheres.

Strike that last sentence, I was waxing poetic and it makes my heart goe aflutter. Just being satirical, or sarcastic, whichever you prefer.

There, I’ve said my piece and I would like to thank you for asking a simple question without snark or rudeness…at least I hope it was intended that way.

Signing off for now

Jake Steele
InterGalactic Repo Man™

Stop deliberately taking my comment about OS' avatar so literally. You only focus on that one comment while conveniently ignoring how I also pointed out that OS' posting history is all about bigfoot. In case you didn't get the point, I do not think that just because he has Sasquatch in his name, that every post must be about bigfoot. I think every post by him must be about bigfoot, because up to this point, every post by him has been about bigfoot. Got it? You can stop whacking that strawman now.

So, why don't you start a psychology of skeptics (or skeptibunkers of ISF skeptics, or whatever you want to label us) thread, instead of posting lengthy explanations as to why you cannot or will not? Just do it already.

You are starting to look like the one who does not want to actually talk about psychology. You seem to want to use it as an excuse to vilify and derail instead. Not looking good for you right now.

You don't need gravitas to start a thread, for crying out loud. The quality of comments of participants will determine the value of the thread, not who started it. The Queen of England could start a thread about nose picking, and it would still just be a thread about nose picking. Again, enough excuses. Start your thread and pursue your curiosity. Why would you not? Anxious?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom