Who said conspiracy theorist ?

So I see you've linked to the homepage of a journal, with no reference to what article in that journal supposedly backs up what you claim, and no details on what claim you think it supports. We don't know what you believe... the CIA is responsible? Is that what you believe? Or that it was NEVER used pejoratively before the 60s? Well, I know why you're not making any hard claims, you're trying to muddy the waters, a step up from trolling I guess.

As generous as I am, I tried to find what on the wikipedia page that journal is referencing. You have made an error in logic, assuming that the format of a wikipedia page is evidence. I actually looked up the article in [2], and it states nothing of the kind. Major fail caveman. That was mighty lazy. The sole source for this claim remains "20th century words" by ayto.

We can see clearly the evidence from the csicop article of pejorative use, and your mental gymnastics that try to explain these examples away. And it's also obvious that the more popular conspiracy theories become, the more pejoratively they will be seen due to their pernicious effect on society. There is no conspiracy about the term conspiracy theory to rest the sad rejected cognitive load of being a conspiracy theorist upon.
 
Quick Joey! The loonies have taken over RationalWiki as well
Actually it is a fact that the loons have taken over rationalwiki. Serious people have known this for some time. For example.

https://whyevolutionistrue.wordpres...ect-its-article-on-female-genital-mutilation/

- after already taking over Wikipedia, peer reviewed journals and academic book-length texts, you must go save it! They're taking over everything!
All of this comes down to Ayto's book, all of it. It is possible for a compendium of words to make a mistake or overstate it's case. You just handwave away the csicop article and say they must be wrong! Look at this other book! :rolleyes: Is there some truth to the idea that over time it has gained more and more venom behind it? Definitely, because conspiracy theorists have become more and more annoying, and entrenched and agitating, over the years. But that doesn't give credence to some conspiracy theory about how the CIA conspired to silence debate.

Keep dreaming...
 
deleted

I thought I had something interesting to share but I made an error
 
Last edited:
I actually looked up the article in [2], and it states nothing of the kind.

It uses "recent and contemporary" rather than "since the 60's" so I guess you could argue that, but it's far from "stating nothing of the kind"
article said:
When people say or imply that conspiracy theories ought not to be believed, what they actually mean (in so far as they have a coherent idea) is that we should not believe theories that postulate evil schemes on the part of recent or contemporary Western governments (or government agencies) and that run counter to the current orthodoxy in the relevant Western countries.

We can see clearly the lack of evidence from the csicop article

FTFY
 
It uses "recent and contemporary" rather than "since the 60's" so I guess you could argue that, but it's far from "stating nothing of the kind"

FTFY
This bit of linguistic philosophy says nothing about the claim that the term never had a pejorative meaning attached to it before the mid 1960s which is the claim we are discussing... :rolleyes:
 
'conspiracy theorist' and 'conspiracy theory' in its modern usage is a label that is used by lazy people to shut down discussions, to avoid discussions.
discussions are always better.
 
'conspiracy theorist' and 'conspiracy theory' in its modern usage is a label that is used by lazy people to shut down discussions, to avoid discussions.
discussions are always better.
Actually, a conspiracy theorist is a snake who is out to destroy a person or group and can't muster the balls to take them on directly, so slander, libel, and calumny are the weapons of choice. This does not include the grass level idiots who always believe the last thing they hear.

Just sayin'.
 
Last edited:
Borrowed from Skeptic.com:

Pyrrho said:
http://www.psypost.org/2016/02/narcissism-and-low-self-esteem-predict-conspiracy-beliefs-41253

Individuals who hold strong beliefs in conspiracies often also score high in narcissism and low in self-esteem, according to 2015 research.

The series of studies, published in Social Psychological and Personality Science, examined individuals to determine whether self-evaluation plays a role in predicting conspiracy beliefs.

“Previous research linked the endorsement of conspiracy theories to low self-esteem,” said Aleksandra Cichocka, principal investigator and corresponding author of the study.

“We propose that conspiracy theories should rather be appealing to individuals with exaggerated feelings of self-love, such as narcissists, due to their paranoid tendencies,” she continued.

The abstract:

http://spp.sagepub.com/content/7/2/157.abstract

Does Self-Love or Self-Hate Predict Conspiracy Beliefs? Narcissism, Self-Esteem, and the Endorsement of Conspiracy Theories
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom