If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Did you open your first-year high-school physics book to find that?

Perhaps you shouldn't laugh at people who clearly know a lot more than you on the topic.

I explained where I got my sources. I even posted links, which you obviously ignored.

Please post a link to another source, or anything, that shows how I don't know anything on the topic.
 
Please post your certifications, licenses, and educational history.

As I asked in the "Summary" thread, what would this accomplish? You have already dismissed the consensus among a host of relevant experts as "simply ignor[ing] the basic physics and pretend[ing] not to see what is clearly there", even though you admit you yourself are not an expert.

So what is the point of even asking about his "certifications, licenses, and educational history"? Would that in any way affect how you evaluate what he has to say? This is not a trick question.

My conclusions, although not made by an expert, are based on an accurate and correct understanding of basic physics.

How did you verify that you have "an accurate and correct understanding of basic physics"? How did you validate that your application of basic physics is appropriate to the problem? Again, these are not trick questions.

See, I've seen a similar approach among a lot of Apollo "hoax" believers, who question others' understanding of the topic, and assert that their "common sense" and understanding of basic physics trump the consensus of domain experts (whom they typically claim are part of the hoax). So I'm curious as to if, and how, your application of this approach differs from theirs.
 
So any old experiment will do? Doesn't it have to be designed to replicate the events he was actually viewing?
Please explain how Cole needs a mathematical model to validate his experiments.
Your claim, and others, is that Cole's experiments are invalid without math. If you want to prove this, then you need to show how math proves the experiments he performed in his video are wrong.
 
OK. Fair game, although not an experiment. I can't do an experiment, because it would be impossible to do so. I can provide proof, though.

He says he is an engineer. I will believe him. No argument there, I will take him at his word.

He says that because he is an engineer he is right. I say he's wrong. His posts prove I'm right.

Done.

Oh, wait. I can perform an experiment. My hypothesis is that his next post will be more garbage. His next post will be the experiment. Let's watch and see what happens.
Nope. I said you are wrong and I know you are wrong because *I have the education to know you are wrong.

If, as you claim, you accept that I am an accredited engineer and you also accept, as you claimed, that you are an amateur with no credentials whatsoever, where does that leave us?

Would you really accept medical advice from a street person in preference to your doctor because you did not agree with your doctors diagnosis? Really?
 
Please explain how Cole needs a mathematical model to validate his experiments.
Your claim, and others, is that Cole's experiments are invalid without math. If you want to prove this, then you need to show how math proves the experiments he performed in his video are wrong.
You have failed to show they are relevant to prove his hypothesis. Get to work.
 


I just now answered your question in that thread.


Although I am not an expert, my educational background supports my claim that I understand basic physics. My understanding of basic physics is enough to draw accurate conclusions based on what I can see during the collapses of WTC1, 2 and 7.

Your next question is, what is my educational background. Answer: It's more than enough to understand basic physics. You can take a grade-school science class and understand Newton's laws of motion. I know you going to argue against this, because you must argue against everything I say. That does not mean you are right, or that I am wrong.
 
...
Although I am not an expert, my educational background supports my claim that I understand basic physics. My understanding of basic physics is enough to draw accurate conclusions based on what I can see during the collapses of WTC1, 2 and 7. ...
Have you retracted the constant acceleration yet? Or do you have evidence, data, numbers from the event?


Cole's models are silly. If you place 12 floors on a WTC floor, it fails, end of story. Cole's video to support his insane CD claims has experiments which are not like the WTC on 9/11. Why is 9/11 truth incapable of understanding how the WTC collapsed? No practical knowledge of physics.

You have failed to support Cole's video with anything, and Cole's experiments are failed examples for WTC 1 and 2. Any grade school kid could understand it.
The firecrackers going off to show it was more like the WTC collapse was delusional, and insane.
The support you can come up with for Cole's failed experiments, nothing.
You failed to support Cole's experiment's with facts and evidence.
 
Last edited:
Nope. I said you are wrong and I know you are wrong because *I have the education to know you are wrong.

If you actually had the education you claim you have, you would know that proof is required to support a claim.

Where is the proof that I am wrong?

If, as you claim, you accept that I am an accredited engineer and you also accept, as you claimed, that you are an amateur with no credentials whatsoever, where does that leave us?
1. You didn't pay attention in school.
2. You suffer from serious delusions, cognitive dissonance, cognitive impairment, or some other similar disorder.
3. You like to lie.
4. You are bored.
5. Discussing the other options violates forum rules.
 
How much more childish can your posts get? You're pretty close to hitting rock-bottom there.

It must be from 40 pages ago at least that we were talking about requiring maths as a critical part of the analysis of any ...... any.......experiment, yet you keep asking about it. Therefore, in the context of you asking (in a manner which suggests you have never heard the suggestion before) what maths has to do with an experiment, my answer ("if you've got to ask you'll never know") seems pretty apposite.
 
Last edited:
If you actually had the education you claim you have, you would know that proof is required to support a claim.

Where is the proof that I am wrong?

If you had any sort of grasp of science or logic, you would understand where the onus lay.


1. You didn't pay attention in school.
2. You suffer from serious delusions, cognitive dissonance, cognitive impairment, or some other similar disorder.
3. You like to lie.
4. You are bored.
5. Discussing the other options violates forum rules.

When you stomp off in a huff again, please tell us again that our relatives all deserve to die in the next terrorist attack.
 
If you actually had the education you claim you have, you would know that proof is required to support a claim.

Where is the proof that I am wrong?

Start with your baffling inability to grasp the relevance of scale.


1. You didn't pay attention in school.
Is that why I am an accredited engineer and you are not?

2. You suffer from serious delusions, cognitive dissonance, cognitive impairment, or some other similar disorder.
Mote, beam, eye, etc.

3. You like to lie.
Part of being an accredited engineer is the requirement to sign up to a code of ethics for which one can be found liable should one be found to be unethical. Unlike you.

4. You are bored.
My time is my own to spend as I will. I consider it a pro bono public service to counter the nonsense some post on the internet.

5. Discussing the other options violates forum rules.
IOW, all you have left is insults.
 
How did he measure accelerations? Let's see the data.




How did he measure net force? Let's see the data.




What measurement did he show was indecent of scale? Which scales did he compare? Let's see the data.

Acceleration is irrelevant, Cole's experiments do not have sufficient momentum, Momentum not acceleration is the critical factor.
 
If you actually had the education you claim you have, you would know that proof is required to support a claim.

Where is the proof that I am wrong?


1. You didn't pay attention in school.
2. You suffer from serious delusions, cognitive dissonance, cognitive impairment, or some other similar disorder.
3. You like to lie.
4. You are bored.
5. Discussing the other options violates forum rules.
Every sentence you type is incontrovertible evidence that you are wrong. the way they string together is proof.
 
Bwahahahahahaha.

OK, seriously. Bwahahahahahaha.

Despite everything I just posted about the scientific method, you still claim Cole didn't follow it.

OK. Let's do this step by step.

Here is scientific method

Ask a Question
Do Background Research
Construct a Hypothesis
Test Your Hypothesis by Doing an Experiment
Analyze Your Data and Draw a Conclusion
Communicate Your Results

1. Ask a question.
How did the towers collapse?

2. Do background research.
Watch videos of the collapse. Read what NIST has said. NIST said the pancake theory was incorrect. NIST says the pile driver theory is correct.

3. Construct a hypothesis.
NIST's papers don't match what is observed. NIST might be wrong. What experiment will duplicate the observed motions?

Hold up. At this point, the hypothesis that Cole actually constructs is that a scale model will tell him something about the behavior of the WTC towers. This would have been a good point for him to revisit the "do background research" step. It would also be a great place for you to begin to understand what's wrong with his approach, but you refuse to do that even when it's put right in front of your nose.

4. Test your hypothesis by doing an experiment.
Cole tries to replicate the pancake theory of collapse. The motions observed in Cole's experiments do not match the observed motions. If it doesn't match experiment, it must be wrong.
Cole tries to replicate the pile driver theory of collapse. The motions observed in Cole's experiments do not match the observed motions. If it doesn't match experiment, it must be wrong.
Cole then does another experiment which he calls the controlled demolition theory. He is trying to replicate the observed motion of the collapses of the twin towers, which is down and out. His experiment more closely matches the observed motion of the actual collapse.

LOL, Cole simply assumes the truth of his actual hypothesis -- the applicability of his scale models -- and proceeds as if he can perform experiments on his models and learn something about the behavior of the towers. Are you seriously saying you can't see that?

5. Analyze the data and draw a conclusion.
The data shows that the pancake theory and pile driver theory do not match experiment. If it does not match experiment, it must be wrong. The data shows that removing the support columns in sequence, as best he can, closely mimics the motion observed during the actual collapse. Conclusion, NIST was wrong. If NIST was wrong, we need a real investigation.
After going this far wrong, what's the point of drawing invalid conclusions? Nonetheless, this is where it might have occurred to him that maybe the "analysis" of his "data" ought to include at least a little of that Newtonian math stuff. Perhaps he would have discovered the effects of scale for himself and returned to step 1. But instead, we get this:

6. Communicate the results.
Cole did. He posted the video.

... on YouTube and AE911truth? Here's an experiment we can try: Communicate Cole's results to any physics professors of your choice and promise in advance to publish their replies.

Please explain how any math is needed.

I already did: The math reveals the effects of scale, unambiguously, and unaffected by your "opinions" otherwise. The list of thing that you don't understand never gets any shorter, does it?

You are simply throwing every red herring you can at this because it's kicking your *****.

You were quibbling over when math should enter into the scientific method, and I pointed out that in Cole's case, (a) it never did, and (b) it really, really should have. Now, you assert that the math is irrelevant, contrary to any common sense? I'm going to predict that you won't have a cogent reply to the "red herrings" in this post, either. Sadly, you, Criteria, and NotConvinced are a microcosm of what's left of the "truth movement."
 
I just now answered your question in that thread.

Thanks. Rather than splitting discussion across two threads, I'll reply to both your posts here.

If he was assistant manager at a Baskin-Robbins I would consider him an authority on ice cream. I might ask him for suggestions on a good flavor, but I would not consider him an expert on engineering topics.

Reasonable enough. Similarly, I do not consider you an expert on engineering, physics, or firefighting topics - all domains on which you have rendered opinions in this forum.

If he was an engineer, I would consider him an authority on topics related to engineering. I might ask him for his opinions on engineering topics. If he gave his opinion, and it clearly contradicted basic physics

See below; you're assuming that you understand and appropriately apply "basic physics" to the issue.

... and the opinions of other engineers,

But, generally speaking, his opinions are in line with the consensus of the engineering community. What you're saying here is that his opinions contradict a relatively small number of engineers with whom you agree. But your agreement rests on implicit assumptions of your own ability to gauge the validity of "your" engineers. That's what I'm poking at - again, see below.

...I would still consider him an authority but his opinions would have no credibility. I would not ask him for future opinions. I would also consider his presence on a forum such as this highly suspect.

Then, as I've asked before, what is the point of asking him for his credentials? If he says that WTC buildings collapsed as a result of impact and fire damage, will his credentials have any effect whatsoever on your assessment of his position?

To beat you to your next post - I already said I am not an expert. You should not consider me an authority on engineering issues.

I can assure you, that is not a mistake I am likely to make.

What you should do is pay attention to credible engineers, and use your own judgement and understanding of basic physics to know who is right.

... Which brings us back to the problem of how you establish who is "credible", and how you know you understand and correctly apply "basic physics".

Although I am not an expert, my educational background supports my claim that I understand basic physics...

...Your next question is, what is my educational background. Answer: It's more than enough to understand basic physics.

I wasn't going to ask what your educational background in physics is. I'm guessing high school, tops, but that's not really the point. How did you verify that you "understand basic physics"? I'm not talking QM or electrodynamics or thermodynamics or even college-level mechanics. Just basic kinematics and dynamics.

My understanding of basic physics is enough to draw accurate conclusions based on what I can see during the collapses of WTC1, 2 and 7.

Exactly how did you validate the assumptions implicit in your claim? In other words, how do you know that applying your "understand[ing] of basic physics" to your viewing of collapse imagery is done correctly, or even appropriately? How did you validate that you really understand what you're seeing?

You can take a grade-school science class and understand Newton's laws of motion. I know you going to argue against this, because you must argue against everything I say. That does not mean you are right, or that I am wrong.

Of course not. The problem is, how do you know that "understand[ing] Newton's laws of motion" is sufficient for you to understand the failure mechanisms under discussion? Especially for you to dismiss the technical consensus of domain experts?

And, given your remarks about "credible" authority, I ask again - why does it matter to you at all whether he is a domain expert or not? Let me flip it around for you. If he was assistant manager at Baskin-Robbins, but he agreed with everything you said, would you then find him a "credible" layman who understood "basic physics" and had "common sense"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom