Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am waiting to be shown where I went wrong and how the EC is going to correct my paper (apart from the two blatant mistakes in the introduction, which are luckily irrelevant for the rest of the paper).
 
Right.

But this thread is not about "comets". In fact, I think Sol88 has clearly established that the relationship between "comets" and "the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory)" is poorly understood (let me leave it at that). And unless and until it is, posting stuff about comets is not going to help us discuss the ELECTRIC COMET model, is it?

Comets, of course, are fascinating; why not start a separate thread on them?

I agree. However, if I did that it would only get hijacked, and swiftly turned into another 'electric comet' thread. One of Sol's fascinations has been on the tail excursion paper by Tusenfem, which isn't freely available, and hasn't yet officially appeared. He is of the mind that there will be some sort of electric woo happening in the tail. My post was merely to point him to a paper of a similar nature that may (or most likely, may not) disabuse him of said notion.
 
Perhaps Sol88 just needs to be coxed back.

Sol88!

Evidence indicates you are the only representative of the "eu" posting on this thread at this time. Perhaps you would like to invite some of the "eu brain trust" to come help you address issues related to the electric comet, electric star, and SAFIRE (as noted by the title of this thread).

In order to properly discuss your electric comet and electric star, I have assembled a short set of simple "Yes/No" questions, designed to build some "boundary conditions" on which we may discuss these entities. Please note, several questions are included to establish your "big picture" view, while others are specific to various aspects and details of the "ec" and "es" model.

Sol88, In your opinion / To your knowledge ...

01) Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? ... Yes/No
02) Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? ... Yes/No
03) Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
04) Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? ... Yes/No
05) Does gravity play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
06) Does gravity play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
07) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in orbital mechanics? ... Yes/No
08) Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in star formation processes? ... Yes/No
09) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring in the core? ... Yes/No
10) Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring on the surface? ... Yes/No
11) Are asteroids made of rock? ... Yes/No
12) Are asteroids made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
13) Are comets made of rock? ... Yes/No
14) Are comets made of volatile ices and dusts? ... Yes/No
15) Is sublimation (i.e., a state change from solid to gas) a real physical process? ... Yes/No
16) Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes? ... Yes/No
17) Is electric discharge machining responsible for terrestrial geomorphology (e.g., the Grand Canyon)? ... Yes/No
18) Does a magnetic field always indicate the presence of an electric current? ... Yes/No
19) Do you know where the water ice line is for our star at this point in its life cycle? ... Yes/No
20) Do you know what a sedimentary tidal rhythmite is? ... Yes/No

Of course, other questions will follow as we discuss the "ec/es" models.

Remember, Sol88, these are simple "Yes/No" questions that require no explanation. Your explanations, and our discussions of same, will come later. All I want to do right now is establish where you stand on several "big picture" issues. I realize, your responses may not reflect those of the "eu brain trust" at the TB corporate head office. In my opinion, any differences are not necessarily a problem, I just want to know where your views align with, or diverge from the baseline of individuals like Thornhill and Scott.

I do, sincerely, hope you will take a moment to answer these simple "Yes/No" questions.

I look forward to your responses, and I thank you in advance!

PostScript - Please note, I would also like to hear from any and all "eu" supporters lurking in the shadows. Come join the discussion! Let's have some fun!
 
Last edited:
16) Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes?

Oh, please Sir, can I answer? I have a list of thingies that have more eccentric orbits than 67P. I think there might be ~ 1900 of them. However, they do not behave like comets. I'm confused!
 
Two (of many) notable quotes that I have built and sustained my career around ...!

"Mathematics is the key and door to the sciences." --- Galileo Galilei

"Count what is countable, measure what is measurable, and what is not measurable, make measurable." --- Galileo Galilei

FYI - I have been known to change my position on a subject! Not with words, but with NUMBERS! Now, I really do hope those members of the "eu" community that choose to discuss their "ec" and "es" models with me will not disappoint the fine gentleman from Florence, Master Galilei!

Whilst waiting for "20 answers to 20 questions" from Sol88, and anyone else from the "eu" community, I would like to open some holes in a claim made by the "eu brain trust" regarding orbital eccentricity, and the physical mechanism responsible for the charging and discharging of a comet nucleus (my Question #16).

Eccentricity and the electric comet: "It's your model! You fix it!"

Sol88 (or any brave individual from the "eu" community), my understanding, according to "eu" doctrine, is that eccentricity is somehow responsible for building and dissipating charge on the nucleus of a comet. If eccentricity is at all important, please explain the following tabulated discrepancies ....!

Object ID | a | e | i | q | Q
Astrd: 2001 KD55 | 3.344 | 0.6235 | 9.98 | 1.26 | 5.43
Astrd: 2014 LS26 | 3.364 | 0.6289 | 10.86 | 1.25 | 5.48
Astrd: 2000 DQ110 | 3.361 | 0.6297 | 58.28 | 1.25 | 5.48
Astrd: 2016 RP33 | 3.334 | 0.6343 | 23.04 | 1.22 | 5.45
Astrd: 2014 XN40 | 3.381 | 0.6349 | 14.20 | 1.24 | 5.53
Astrd: 1986 RA | 3.327 | 0.6358 | 19.13 | 1.21 | 5.44
Comet: 67P/C-G | 3.463 | 0.6414 | 7.05 | 1.24 | 5.69
Astrd: 2014 HW177 | 3.302 | 0.6437 | 13.00 | 1.18 | 5.43
Astrd: 1995 QN3 | 3.300 | 0.6450 | 14.79 | 1.17 | 5.43
Astrd: 2014 HY196 | 3.526 | 0.6561 | 42.29 | 1.21 | 5.84
Astrd: 2016 WX8 | 3.529 | 0.6572 | 13.29 | 1.21 | 5.85
Astrd: 2016 LA2 | 3.565 | 0.6748 | 17.43 | 1.16 | 5.97
Astrd: 2011 YY28 | 3.388 | 0.6765 | 7.35 | 1.10 | 5.68

Columns: a = Semi-major axis (AU), e = Eccentricity, i = Inclination, q = Perihelion (AU), Q = Aphelion (AU). All data extracted from the JPL SBDB. Please note, the tabulated data, above, is a trivial subset of a greater whole.

Sol88? Please explain, in mathematical terms, how eccentricity is physically involved in the charging and discharging of an electric asteroid ... I mean comet? You'll note, I've bracketed a known comet (67P) with 12 randomly selected mainstream asteroids! Help me out here! What "electrical" mechanisms are missing in your eccentricity calculations? Why is only one of 13 objects in this list deemed to be a comet? Why are the 12 mainstream asteroids inert in the same solar e-field as that surrounding 67P?

CONCLUSION: Based on simple observation, eccentricity is NOT involved in the electric comet model!!!

Prove me wrong!!! Present a mathematical model that can predict when a celestial object will become an electric comet!!! This mathematical model must use the 13 data points provided. You may also reference the JPL SBDB and any other sources to gather additional physical parameters and data that may be needed to complete your calculations! Good luck!

Sol88! Can we declare the electric comet dead yet?
 
Does that make you happy, jonesdave116?

And I've got a thousand horrors waiting for anyone in the "eu" that wants to discuss their .... non-science!
 
I am waiting to be shown where I went wrong and how the EC is going to correct my paper (apart from the two blatant mistakes in the introduction, which are luckily irrelevant for the rest of the paper).

Has “A Tail Like No Other” been published yet, tusenfem?
 
Two (of many) notable quotes that I have built and sustained my career around ...!

"Mathematics is the key and door to the sciences." --- Galileo Galilei

"Count what is countable, measure what is measurable, and what is not measurable, make measurable." --- Galileo Galilei

FYI - I have been known to change my position on a subject! Not with words, but with NUMBERS! Now, I really do hope those members of the "eu" community that choose to discuss their "ec" and "es" models with me will not disappoint the fine gentleman from Florence, Master Galilei!

Whilst waiting for "20 answers to 20 questions" from Sol88, and anyone else from the "eu" community, I would like to open some holes in a claim made by the "eu brain trust" regarding orbital eccentricity, and the physical mechanism responsible for the charging and discharging of a comet nucleus (my Question #16).

Eccentricity and the electric comet: "It's your model! You fix it!"

Sol88 (or any brave individual from the "eu" community), my understanding, according to "eu" doctrine, is that eccentricity is somehow responsible for building and dissipating charge on the nucleus of a comet. If eccentricity is at all important, please explain the following tabulated discrepancies ....!

Object ID | a | e | i | q | Q
Astrd: 2001 KD55 | 3.344 | 0.6235 | 9.98 | 1.26 | 5.43
Astrd: 2014 LS26 | 3.364 | 0.6289 | 10.86 | 1.25 | 5.48
Astrd: 2000 DQ110 | 3.361 | 0.6297 | 58.28 | 1.25 | 5.48
Astrd: 2016 RP33 | 3.334 | 0.6343 | 23.04 | 1.22 | 5.45
Astrd: 2014 XN40 | 3.381 | 0.6349 | 14.20 | 1.24 | 5.53
Astrd: 1986 RA | 3.327 | 0.6358 | 19.13 | 1.21 | 5.44
Comet: 67P/C-G | 3.463 | 0.6414 | 7.05 | 1.24 | 5.69
Astrd: 2014 HW177 | 3.302 | 0.6437 | 13.00 | 1.18 | 5.43
Astrd: 1995 QN3 | 3.300 | 0.6450 | 14.79 | 1.17 | 5.43
Astrd: 2014 HY196 | 3.526 | 0.6561 | 42.29 | 1.21 | 5.84
Astrd: 2016 WX8 | 3.529 | 0.6572 | 13.29 | 1.21 | 5.85
Astrd: 2016 LA2 | 3.565 | 0.6748 | 17.43 | 1.16 | 5.97
Astrd: 2011 YY28 | 3.388 | 0.6765 | 7.35 | 1.10 | 5.68

Columns: a = Semi-major axis (AU), e = Eccentricity, i = Inclination, q = Perihelion (AU), Q = Aphelion (AU). All data extracted from the JPL SBDB. Please note, the tabulated data, above, is a trivial subset of a greater whole.

Sol88? Please explain, in mathematical terms, how eccentricity is physically involved in the charging and discharging of an electric asteroid ... I mean comet? You'll note, I've bracketed a known comet (67P) with 12 randomly selected mainstream asteroids! Help me out here! What "electrical" mechanisms are missing in your eccentricity calculations? Why is only one of 13 objects in this list deemed to be a comet? Why are the 12 mainstream asteroids inert in the same solar e-field as that surrounding 67P?

CONCLUSION: Based on simple observation, eccentricity is NOT involved in the electric comet model!!!

Prove me wrong!!! Present a mathematical model that can predict when a celestial object will become an electric comet!!! This mathematical model must use the 13 data points provided. You may also reference the JPL SBDB and any other sources to gather additional physical parameters and data that may be needed to complete your calculations! Good luck!

Sol88! Can we declare the electric comet dead yet?

G’day Indagator, welcome to the thread :)

Great question.

Are you able to also list the max assumed diameters for the above asteroids?
 
Last edited:
Fascinating response!

Sol88! Allow me to refresh your memory, as it appears your reading comprehension is somewhat ... weak!

The success or failure of your electric comet model depends on whether or not it is physically feasible! Claims have been made! Its time to show, in mathematical terms, how your electric comet actually operates ... with whatever data and NUMBERS you deem appropriate!

First, recall this observation ...!

"It's your model! You fix it!"

Its not my model. Convince me that your electric comet is worthy of my time and limited resources!

Next ...!

Sol88? Please explain, in mathematical terms, how eccentricity is physically involved in the charging and discharging of an electric asteroid ... I mean comet!

If you wish to suddenly introduce physical dimensions, go right ahead! And then tell me, in mathematical terms, how eccentricity and an objects dimensions are physically involved in the charging and discharging of an electric asteroid!

And finally ...!

Present a mathematical model that can predict when a celestial object will become an electric comet!!! This mathematical model must use the 13 data points provided. You may also reference the JPL SBDB and any other sources to gather additional physical parameters and data that may be needed to complete your calculations! Good luck!

Again, if you suddenly feel that physical dimensions will fix your model, please, show me how dimensions, or rotation rates, or any other physical parameters from the JPL SBDB and the thousands of other readily available data sources will make it possible to predict when a celestial object becomes an "eu" electric object!

Remember! This is all about you and YOUR model! Convince me that your electric comet has merit! Otherwise we will declare it dead! OK? Don't waste my time with deflections! What your question says to me is that you haven't a clue how an electric comet could operate, just like everyone else from the "eu" that I have dealt with to date! Prove me wrong! Make me proud! Be better than the rest!

Remember!

It's your model! You fix it! Dig?

PostScript 1 - As it turns out, you don't need specific physical dimensions for the 13 objects! Just build your mathematical model in such a way that above or below a certain size the object will remain inert, regardless of its eccentricity! These are the first constraints you need to build into your model! It also gives us a way to validate or falsify your model! And don't be afraid to ask your "eu" buddies to come give you a hand in building a mathematical model that does not violate basic laws of physics! OK? Remember, this model has to represent a feasible, physical, economically exploitable object!

PostScript 2 - When might ye provide answers to my simple "Yes/No" questions listed above? There is much to discuss!

PostScript 3 - When might ye get back to answering some of Jean Tate's excellent questions?

And again, Sol88, thanks in advance! I am so looking forward to seeing how your mathematical model evolves and grows here at the ISF!
 
Are you able to also list the max assumed diameters for the above asteroids?

As Indagator said, why would the physical dimensions matter? As a reference point, here are some rough cometary dimensions:

67P: 4 km x 2 km
Halley: 15 km x 8 km
Hale-Bopp: 40-80 km
Hartley 2: 2 km x 1 km
Tempel 1: 7 km x 5 km
 
Fascinating response!

Sol88! Allow me to refresh your memory, as it appears your reading comprehension is somewhat ... weak!

The success or failure of your electric comet model depends on whether or not it is physically feasible! Claims have been made! Its time to show, in mathematical terms, how your electric comet actually operates ... with whatever data and NUMBERS you deem appropriate!

First, recall this observation ...!



Its not my model. Convince me that your electric comet is worthy of my time and limited resources!

Next ...!

SNIPPED

Remember! This is all about you and YOUR model! Convince me that your electric comet has merit! Otherwise we will declare it dead! OK? Don't waste my time with deflections! What your question says to me is that you haven't a clue how an electric comet could operate, just like everyone else from the "eu" that I have dealt with to date! Prove me wrong! Make me proud! Be better than the rest!

Remember!

It's your model! You fix it! Dig?

ok then from the new paper by A tail like no other - The RPC-MAG view of Rosetta’s tail excursion at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko M.Volwerk et al.

Rosetta from the nucleus, and thus kinetic effects on the structure
of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type
of tail structure.

@tusenfem, would you like to fill Indagator in on the details? We've already covered this ground I think. Is this correct tusenfem?

:D
 
Last edited:
Indeed wtf, because, as usual you don't answer my questions, but come up with vaguely related random quotes.

So, once more:
Is there any reason you can come up with why ideal MHD would (not) hold for Birkeland currents?
Do you actually know what (ideal) MHD is, and what the restricting parameters are for (ideal) MHD, and do you think that field aligned currents are affected by that?

Indeed, field aligned electric fields cannot exist in ideal MHD (do you know why?), but does that mean that field aligned currents cannot exist in ideal MHD (if yes, why not, if no why?).

You have a completely twisted idea of what plasma physicists are doing (unsurprisinly), you really think we are still in the 1950s/60s around the birth of Alfven's MHD, and we have not developed any further. Well, that is also not surprising, as you keep on insisting that we still assume Whipple's 1950s model for a comet.

I guess I can only come to the conclusion that YOU Sol88 were not borne in 1988 but actually are from the 1950s and you have not developed any further.

Now maybe we could talk MHD and wether it holds...oh. Never mind.

During the tail excursion the magnetic field strength around comet 67P was B ≈ 10 nT; this means that when water ions are picked up by the magnetic eld of the solar wind at v ≈ 350 km s−1, the gyro radius of these ions is ρi ≈ 6000 km. This radius is much larger than the radial distance covered by Rosetta from the nucleus

The clock-angle φc of the magnetic field in the tail shows a rotation of the field, which is slowly moving down-tail.
intriguing!!

A Tail Like No Other
 
Last edited:
Sol88!

More misdirection? How typical! How dishonest! How pathetic! What are you afraid of? Is your electric comet a joke? Is it not worth discussing? I came here to discuss the physical mechanisms and behaviour of your electric comet!

Now, why are you citing a mainstream article that discusses magnetic structures in the tail of a weakly outgassing comet? Everyone that matters, knows that this mainstream article does NOT support, or provide evidence for your electric comet model! Are you confused? Does your comet model now involve the sublimation of volatile ices via insolation as the object follows a Keplerian orbit around a main sequence star? Are you admitting that the electric comet is a failure and you now wish to embrace mainstream models?

If true, then it is a glorious day! Sol88 is renouncing the electric comet by citing and discussing a mainstream paper, which is based on mainstream physics and mainstream knowledge accumulated over decades!

Or are you running away? Evidence indicates you are running away! Why have you stopped answering Jean Tate's probing questions? Perhaps you have no answers, because the electric comet is physically impossible! Why will you not answer the 20 simple "Yes/No" questions I asked you in my first post? Perhaps you have no answers, because, again, there is no electric comet!

But let's get back on track, shall we?

Sol88! This ISF thread is about you and YOUR model! It is not about mainstream comets! Get with the program! Prove to me the electric comet is worthy of my scientific consideration! Prove to all of us that the electric comet is worthy of scientific investigation!

Remember, It's your model! Either it exists or it does not! As you cannot produce a working model that shows how eccentricity is involved in charging and discharging a celestial object, we can state as fact, that there is no electric comet!

Prove me wrong! Present a mathematical model that shows which celestial objects will become electric comets and how they operate at all points in their particular orbits! Should be simple if the electric comet is not an extraordinary failure!

FACT: I admire and respect tusenfem's work! However the paper you've cited has absolutely nothing to do with how eccentricity controls your charging and discharging mechanism! If it does, your mathematical proofs will be ... mind bending, to say the least! However, I suspect there will be nothing of value forthcoming in that regard!

FACT: Scientists love solving problems! Do you wish to be seen as a scientist? Or a lowly priest? I think we all know the answer to that, but I would love for you to prove me wrong!

FACT: It's your model! You fix it! Or state with all honesty and humility that you cannot build a working mathematical model that describes the physical behaviour of an electric comet.

FACT: Without a working mathematical model, the electric comet is DEAD!

As an aside, your "big green grin" emoticon makes your comment look like a childish joke! Was that your intent? Are most of your comments on ISF just childish jokes? You seem to use an inordinate number of emoticons in your posts. Is it fair to say that you, yourself, see your electric comet as nothing more than a childish joke? If you want people to see your "religion" as genuine science, then perhaps you need to take our discussions here seriously!

Sol88! My plan is to kill the electric comet! Your plan should be to prove its worthy of scientific study! Let's dance! Or you can continue to run and hide and misdirect! Your thread! Your choice! I'm not going away!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom