The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yup, he's the man!

Deep Impact: Excavating comet Tempel 1

DEEP IMPACT: THE FIRST SECOND

Comets: looking ahead

Yeah, nah M.A'Hearn knew the difference between dust and rock.

MAINSTREAMS understanding of what comets are made of is (slowly) evolving towards MOSTLY rock. :)

Hydrated ROCK at that!

Nope, no rock. Show me the detections. Otherwise, ST...........
 
For anybody with an IQ less than that of a badger, where did the ice come from in the DI impact? Proper science, please. No word salad. While they are at it - in roughly what year was Earth orbiting Saturn, and at what distance from the Sun? Did this coincide with the period when giant electric thunderbolts blasted comets off of planets? Lol. Religionists, what can you do with them?
 
No, Mike A'Hearn authored and co-authored more papers on comets than you can shake a stick at. From memory, he was the PI of the Deep Impact mission. The one that completely shattered this EC woo, remember? Here is one of his papers from that mission;

Deep Impact: Excavating Comet Tempel 1
A'Hearn, M. F. et al
https://www.researchgate.net/profil...t_Tempel_1/links/0912f508e5e3a713c0000000.pdf


Do you know what Rosetta said jd116?

"Rosetta has said comets are much different than expected" Matt Taylor

Reckon Matt would know the difference between rock and a mixture of mostly ice and some dust.

Since we already know comets are the leftovers from the formation of the solar system. The frozen dirtysnowballs that we KNOW are comets...:D
 
For anybody with an IQ less than that of a badger, where did the ice come from in the DI impact? Proper science, please. No word salad. While they are at it - in roughly what year was Earth orbiting Saturn, and at what distance from the Sun? Did this coincide with the period when giant electric thunderbolts blasted comets off of planets? Lol. Religionists, what can you do with them?

Been here 'ol mate

Hydrated ROCK releasing H20 that Spontaneous formation of non-spherical water ice grains in a plasma environment 10.1002/2013GL058268

Yawn

Your running pretty low on ammo not champ! :blush:
 
Been here 'ol mate

Hydrated ROCK releasing H20 that Spontaneous formation of non-spherical water ice grains in a plasma environment 10.1002/2013GL058268

Yawn

Your running pretty low on ammo not champ! :blush:

Complete crap. How are you getting water from hydrated minerals, you fraud? Where was the ice coming from at Hartley 2?
Give up, your scientific ignorance knows no bounds, and I'm getting sick of the lying, you religionist loon.
 
Do you know what Rosetta said jd116?

"Rosetta has said comets are much different than expected" Matt Taylor

Reckon Matt would know the difference between rock and a mixture of mostly ice and some dust.

Since we already know comets are the leftovers from the formation of the solar system. The frozen dirtysnowballs that we KNOW are comets...:D

Want me to email Matt Taylor, you lying fraud? Yes or no? Now go away and pollute somewhere else, you delusional clown. Try Dunderdolts. More in line with your lack of knowledge of all things scientific, I would have thought. Leave your religion off of these pages.
 
Complete crap. How are you getting water from hydrated minerals, you fraud? Where was the ice coming from at Hartley 2?
Give up, your scientific ignorance knows no bounds, and I'm getting sick of the lying, you religionist loon.

Are you saying can not happen? Why?

Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment

Was a there dusty (Complex) plasma's found at 67P? yes/no

Are there electric fields at play at 67P? yes/no

Give it a real fair dinkum go sport! :boggled:
 
Are you saying can not happen? Why?

Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment

Was a there dusty (Complex) plasma's found at 67P? yes/no

Are there electric fields at play at 67P? yes/no

Give it a real fair dinkum go sport! :boggled:

Quit with the crap, liar. I asked for a scientific explanation, not word salad. Where are metre sized chunks of ice coming from at Hartley 2? How are you getting them at Tempel 1? Science, or STFU. Yes? Forget your dumb religion.
 
What did the idiot Thornhill say? Want me to quote it again, liar? Where is this dust coming from, huh?

Obviously the whole comet is made of dust with some ice!

Except scientist understanding is now evolving toward mostly ROCK.!

Such an unfortunate turn of phrase from A'Hearn. :D
 
Quit with the crap, liar. I asked for a scientific explanation, not word salad. Where are metre sized chunks of ice coming from at Hartley 2? How are you getting them at Tempel 1? Science, or STFU. Yes? Forget your dumb religion.

So you cant or wont answer two very simple questions? :D
 
Obviously the whole comet is made of dust with some ice!

Except scientist understanding is now evolving toward mostly ROCK.!

Such an unfortunate turn of phrase from A'Hearn. :D

Want me to email any of A'Hearn's colleagues, you liar? Yes or no? Now go away, and quit with the uneducated, religionist garbage. Not a cretin on the planet believes your idiotic woo. Nothing with an IQ above that of a badger, yes?
 
Not real rock ya goose!

So what are the planets made of that the idiot Thornhill says the comets were blasted off of? Huh? Ice and frigging dust? Where did the idiotic loon explain this?
 
Last edited:
And again;

Where are metre sized chunks of ice coming from at Hartley 2? How are you getting them at Tempel 1? Science, or STFU.

And again and again, until we get an answer.
Why are asteroids not turning into comets? Again and again, until we get an answer.

Come on, let's hear it. Sick of this uneducated garbage. Come on woo boy, explain.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom