The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So was that a yes, comet 67p as an ambipolar electric field?

Or

No, comet 67p does not have an electric field?

And

Perhaps you could explain why you think it’s irrelevant?




Feel free to stop posting then.

So, you agree that your model failed? Good. You are the one that needs to stop posting - no evidence, no mechanisms, no science. And a total refusal to address the failures of the idiotic model;

Comets are rocks, blasted from planets by unknown electric woo.
Leaving aside the scientifically impossible mechanisms described to achieve this, we need only look at the composition of planets and moons, and at the composition of comets, and do a comparison. Earth, Mars, Mercury and Venus; all rock with high density. Comets; highly porous mixture of dust (fluffy and compact), ice and organics, with very low density.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Comets are merely asteroids on elliptical orbits.
Any cursory examination of the many asteroids on elliptical orbits shows this to be wrong.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

The jets observed are electric discharges to (from?) the nucleus.
Electric discharges would show up in the magnetometer data. There was nothing. The jets are observed to be gas, dust and, sometimes, ice.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

There is little to no ice, and the water observed is actually OH.
Water has been definitively detected at comets since 1986. So that was a lie.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

The OH (H2O?) that is observed is due to solar wind H+ combining with O-.
Impossible. The H+ ions are far too energetic to combine with anything.
There is nowhere near enough H+ to explain even 1 litre of water per second.
There is little to no O-.
The solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus for about 8 months around perihelion.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Those are the fundamental building blocks underlying the electric comet model. Verdict? It fails. Horribly, and indisputably. The electric comet model was stillborn. It was never alive, and nobody has come close to zapping its stinking corpse with 50 000 volts to bring it to life. It is a miserable, neo-Velikovskian heap of trash, dreamed up by unqualified woo merchants. It is a joke. It isn't worthy of our attention.

Still waiting...........
 
Pretty obvious what your answer is.


So don’t be shy now, simple Y or N will do.

Totally irrelevant. Your model failed. Ambipolar fields have nothing to do with that failure. Stop avoiding the failure of your model.
 
A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it.”

Max Plank

You see this quote often from folks pushing pseudoscience, especially from the "Einstein was wrong" crowd. Problem is, good old Max was referring to scientific truths, which the EC idea isn't and never will be.
 
So was that a yes, comet 67p as an ambipolar electric field?

Or

No, comet 67p does not have an electric field?




Feel free to answer free burfle as jonesdave 116 will not.

Very simple,
 
Oh and merry Christmas.


Hope the big fella put some good news on sublimation under the tree for you.
 
Totally irrelevant. Your model failed. Ambipolar fields have nothing to do with that failure. Stop avoiding the failure of your model.

Is that a yes, jd116?

Comet 67P has a ambipolar electric field?


Can’t see why it’s irrelevant as your refusal to answer is quite entertaining.

Even Fred burfle can not answer a simple straight forward question..
 
So was that a yes, comet 67p as an ambipolar electric field?

Or

No, comet 67p does not have an electric field?




Feel free to answer free burfle as jonesdave 116 will not.

Very simple,

It is of no relevance to the failure of your model. Having an ambipolar field is nothing to do with the complete lack of discharges and EDM (lol). It is nothing to do with a density of ~ 530 kg/m3. It has nothing to do with the detection of water vapour, and ice. It is nothing to do with the EC's impossible method for manufacturing water. It has nothing to do with the D/H ratio of the water vapour not matching solar wind values.
Your model has failed. No point in discussing an irrelevancy like ambipolar fields. They are not going to fix any of the above. The EC woo has 100% failed.
 
Is that a yes, jd116?

Comet 67P has a ambipolar electric field?


Can’t see why it’s irrelevant as your refusal to answer is quite entertaining.

Even Fred burfle can not answer a simple straight forward question..

It is irrelevant. I am not getting drawn into a discussion of something that is totally irrelevant. Your model failed. I have outlined the fundamental claims that have failed. Your refusal to deal with them is telling.
 
And again. Deal with it. Ambipolar fields have nothing to do with the complete failure of your model.


So, where are we now with the electric comet 'model'? What have we learned after over a decade of this woo being spammed around various fora on the internet? Let's break it down to its most fundamental claims, as per the Thornhill & Talbott poster from 2006;

Comets are rocks, blasted from planets by unknown electric woo.
Leaving aside the scientifically impossible mechanisms described to achieve this, we need only look at the composition of planets and moons, and at the composition of comets, and do a comparison. Earth, Mars, Mercury and Venus; all rock with high density. Comets; highly porous mixture of dust (fluffy and compact), ice and organics, with very low density.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Comets are merely asteroids on elliptical orbits.
Any cursory examination of the many asteroids on elliptical orbits shows this to be wrong.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

The jets observed are electric discharges to (from?) the nucleus.
Electric discharges would show up in the magnetometer data. There was nothing. The jets are observed to be gas, dust and, sometimes, ice.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

There is little to no ice, and the water observed is actually OH.
Water has been definitively detected at comets since 1986. So that was a lie.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

The OH (H2O?) that is observed is due to solar wind H+ combining with O-.
Impossible. The H+ ions are far too energetic to combine with anything.
There is nowhere near enough H+ to explain even 1 litre of water per second.
There is little to no O-.
The solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus for about 8 months around perihelion.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Those are the fundamental building blocks underlying the electric comet model. Verdict? It fails. Horribly, and indisputably. The electric comet model was stillborn. It was never alive, and nobody has come close to zapping its stinking corpse with 50 000 volts to bring it to life. It is a miserable, neo-Velikovskian heap of trash, dreamed up by unqualified woo merchants. It is a joke. It isn't worthy of our attention.
 
Is that a yes, jd116?

I very much would like to answer the questions in your list, again, but need you not to stick your fingers in your ears and go la la la.

Why so childish?


This is a valid question I ask of you that is on topic.
 
Last edited:
Is that a yes, jd116?

I very much would like to answer the questions in your list, again, but need you not to stick your fingers in your ears and go la la la.

Why so childish?


This is a valid question I ask of you that is on topic.

It is NOT on topic. Read my post and tell me what relevance it has. Is it going to make the thousands of tonnes of excavated ice at Tempel 1 disappear? Is it going to create granite? Is it going to create water vapour? And CO2? Et cetera.
It is irrelevant to my post. Your failure to deal with the failures I pointed out renders your model dead in the water. Game over.
 
Last edited:
It is NOT on topic. Read my post and tell me what relevance it has. Is it going to make the thousands of tonnes of excavated ice at Tempel 1 disappear? Is it going to create granite? Is it going to create water vapour? And CO2? Et cetera.
It is irrelevant to my post. Your failure to deal with the failures I pointed out renders your model dead in the water. Game over.

So, again, yes or no?

Does 67P have an ambipolar electric field?

Then we can get onto you dead easy but irrelevant, as you say, questions.
 
Comets are rocks, blasted from planets by unknown electric woo.
Leaving aside the scientifically impossible mechanisms described to achieve this, we need only look at the composition of planets and moons, and at the composition of comets, and do a comparison. Earth, Mars, Mercury and Venus; all rock with high density. Comets; highly porous mixture of dust (fluffy and compact), ice and organics, with very low density.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?
 
Comets are merely asteroids on elliptical orbits.
Any cursory examination of the many asteroids on elliptical orbits shows this to be wrong.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?
 
The jets observed are electric discharges to (from?) the nucleus.
Electric discharges would show up in the magnetometer data. There was nothing. The jets are observed to be gas, dust and, sometimes, ice.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?
 
Comets are rocks, blasted from planets by unknown electric woo.
Leaving aside the scientifically impossible mechanisms described to achieve this, we need only look at the composition of planets and moons, and at the composition of comets, and do a comparison. Earth, Mars, Mercury and Venus; all rock with high density. Comets; highly porous mixture of dust (fluffy and compact), ice and organics, with very low density.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?


Does an ambipolar electric field exist at comet 67P, jonesdave116?
 
There is little to no ice, and the water observed is actually OH.
Water has been definitively detected at comets since 1986. So that was a lie.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?
 
Does an ambipolar electric field exist at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Irrelevant. Your model has failed. And the reasons it fails have nothing to do with the existence or otherwise of ambipolar fields. I doubt you even know what they are.
 
The OH (H2O?) that is observed is due to solar wind H+ combining with O-.
Impossible. The H+ ions are far too energetic to combine with anything.
There is nowhere near enough H+ to explain even 1 litre of water per second.
There is little to no O-.
The solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus for about 8 months around perihelion.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

Ambipolar field explains this how?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom