The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Brilliant, comets have little to no ice!

Now...wheres all the ice and gas coming from sport?

Stop being idiotic. It comes from the observed ice. The thousands of tonnes in the near surface layers from just a small area of Tempel 1, for instance. Remember? It killed your woo stone dead. 13 years ago. And yet you are still here. Why? What is the point? Your woo is long dead. No mechanisms, no science, no evidence, no model.
 
I love it when a plan comes together!
I refer to this post by myself in the previous incarnation of this thread;

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12352720&postcount=3298

This was one of a number of posts by Tusenfem and myself criticising the paper by Yao & Giapis, re their proposed mechanism for the O2 seen at 67P. They conceded the argument on the quantities, as pointed out in a reply to their paper by Heritier, et al;

On the origin of molecular oxygen in cometary comae
Heritier, K. L. et al.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-04972-5

As pointed out, Yao & Giapis replied to that paper, as referenced in the original post. Despite conceding that the quantities were way off, they still tried to salvage their mechanism with the process happening close to the spacecraft, from its solar panels, in particular.
As I pointed out in July 2018, that seemed to be contra-indicated by the Alice findings.

I said;

The impact parameter is the distance between the line of sight and the nucleus. This was increasing as the two observations were made. It is therefore very difficult to see how the environment around the spacecraft could have shown a decreasing amount of O2 relative to water, in ten minutes, if the ALICE team were being fooled by O2 produced in the close vicinity of the spacecraft. For all the world, it looks like they were indeed observing the molecules close to the nucleus.

I referenced Keeney (2017) for that observation. Imagine my surprise on finding the following paper;

Origin of Molecular Oxygen in Comets: Current Knowledge and Perspectives
Luspay-Kuti, A. et al.
https://www.researchgate.net/profil...Comets-Current-Knowledge-and-Perspectives.pdf

That was published in October 2018. They say (among other things);

It is also important to note that Alice has detected O2 independently of ROSINA (Keeney et al. 2017a), and post-perihelion Alice results indicate that the relative O2/H2O decreases with increasing impact parameter above the nucleus (Keeney et al. 2017b). Although the Alice measurements may arguably be affected by spacecraft-produced O2, the observed O2/H2O variation with impact parameter would be unlikely within this framework.

Bugger me if that isn't almost exactly what I'd said three months before that publication!

Who's a Smart Alec then! The sad thing is, that I had pointed these things out in a couple of emails to Giapis prior to their reply to the reply. If a layman like me (OK, a couple of kind of relevant BSc's) could see this, why couldn't these guys, even when it was pointed out to them?
At the end of the day, it bolsters one's confidence in the peer-review process. It isn't perfect, but at least these erroneous claims do usually get picked up on.
 
It's been rather quiet here in the 'electric comet' thread.

Sol88! Your failures in comprehension are legendary! Shall we discuss?

I give you an opportunity to educate and enlighten the science community! You give us NOTHING!

In my last post, I asked you 56 specific questions designed to explore your 'electric comet' model! Your response? SILENCE! DEAD AIR! NOTHING!

How can I help you build a working model of an 'electric comet' or an 'electric star' if you don't answer my questions? How can we get to the meat of your model without numbers?

And where's the link to the A'Hearn et al (TBD) paper that talks about comets not being made of ROCK? What are you afraid of discovering, Sol88? Why do you fear looking through the telescope? What might you find?

Please reread my last post, and try again! There are some really important 'electric comet' modeling questions that require your expert input! I offer my thanks in advance!

Now, let's address your pithy response to my last post ...
No, A'Hearn said mostly rock, not rock rock. Everybody knows comets are not rocks.

But...

I’d be able to call them stoney agglomerations with h little no ice, if that’s what’s settled on for the future description of cometary nuclei.

Really? "Everybody knows comets are not rocks." Did you really say that? "Everybody ...?"

Remember, Sol88! The internet never, ever forgets! I present for your consideration, a few random quotes from our resident 'ec' expert! Please, note the dates!

Date = 2009/07/09
I mean nothing has really changed in the Electric comet theory camp per say, but evidence for the electric comet model has become much stronger and the dirtysnowball (or whatever mainstreams "model" is ) position has become untenable!

Simple and unexciting, apologies again.

I mean if it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck and walks like a duck...then it is most likely a DUCK!
So, nothing has changed in nearly ten years! Including the fact we still have no 'electric comet' model!

Date = 2009/07/09
They smashed into a rock, you know, like an asteroid!
Not what the science says!

Date = 2009/07/19
The fact remains they, comets, are rock, not dirty snowbanks as calculated! And as a prediction they will be found to be so, rock!

Comets are "rocks" on eccentric orbits!

<...>

your are the brilliant mathematicians your work it out into any unit you like, facts are still the same, asteroids like comets are "rock"!!
Like 21/Lutetia with a bulk density of 3400 kg/m3? Or 4/Vesta with a bulk density of 3456 kg/m3?

Date = 2009/07/28
This puts at odds the long held belief that comets are left over dusty iceballs but really "rock", on an eccentric orbit around and through the sun's weak electric field, when a large enough potential develops a sheath will form around the comet and it will glow in X-rays/UV. This is what we've called the coma.


Date = 2009/08/07
Or we could take all the data we have collected so far about "rocks" hanging out in the solar wind and work from there instead!

Lets take what we do know;

Any object not protected by an atmosphere or magnetosphere and in the solar wind stream will charge positive and the sunward facing side and negative on the nightside. This is a fact.


Date = 2009/08/26
Rock is what "we" all call rock, rock
Wikipedia said:
In geology, rock is a naturally occurring solid aggregate of minerals and/or mineraloids.
LINK

The new Wikipedia definition (as of 2019/01/29) has been modified thus, ...
Wikipedia said:
Rock or stone is a natural substance, a solid aggregate of one or more minerals or mineraloids. For example, granite, a common rock, is a combination of the minerals quartz, feldspar and biotite. The Earth's outer solid layer, the lithosphere, is made of rock.


Date = 2009/10/16
And comets??? far as I can tell they're rocks??? Same as the moon asteroids and rocky planets!

The process is just far more energetic on comets (highly charged rocks). Simple really!


Date = 2010/02/26
Comets are rocks!!!
Emphatic statement!!!

Date = 2010/11/07
Space is full of plasma 99.9 % actualy and yes I'm aware that it is quasi-nuteral but stick a rock in the way and bingo, CHARGE SEPERATION!!!
Sadly NO! Magic is not science! Magic is slight-of-hand! Magic is deception! Magic is the 'electric comet!'

Date = 2014/04/09
I predict the lander will encounter SOLID rock.

Scientist will be surprised at its denser than icy-fluffball consistency!

not sure if its gunna give as anything regarding the Oort Belt/Pristine left overs but Rosetta will tell us if they are Dirty Snowballs or solid bone dry rock.

Interesting times ahead and fully hope they achieve thier primary goal.


Date = 2014/11/13
Lets again have a discussion about fluffy bunnies (Looking at pictures)

lets look at this beauty CIVA: Composite of P-3 and P-4 Cameras / Credit: ESA/Rosetta/Philae/CIVA

Mmmm.....looks like rock....melted rock!!!
Please note, Sol88, I modified your quote to embed the url and "identify" the content of the image in the event the link breaks in the future (which they often do).

Date = 2014/11/14
Reality Check as been jamm'n this down my throat since we started, so to me I'm more happy to see solid rock and NOT a FluffyDirtySnowball

Just say'n


Date = 2014/11/16
Let's just talk about the science I.e the facts as presented and not some misunderstood interpretation of the the Electric comet theory.
The previous quote is included just for fun! I ask, when will you clarify what an 'electric comet' is? When will you provide a functional, predictive model? When will you give us some science?

Date = 2015/04/28
So to taking 470 kg/m^3 as gospel is your fatal error.

Looks like rock smells like rock feels like rock but is deep fried ice cream
Smells and feels like rock? Not what we would call scientifically objective measures, Sol88!

Date = 2015/10/09
Considering the paper on Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity we are discussing ATM Jonesdavid116, when the impactor vaporised the rock into dust, lots and lots of dust and not much to very little ice, what would we observe?
Would you like to discuss Nordheim et al (2015) (another mainstream paper, written by mainstream scientists, in support of the mainstream comet model)? Or perhaps you would like to continue our discussion of Lisse et al (2006) instead?

Date = 2016/11/14
But NONE are are problem if as the ELECTRIC COMET postulates, they are ROCKS discharging in the radial electric field of the ELECTRIC SUN.


Date = 2017/07/05
COMETS ARE MOSTLY ROCK!!!

Not mostly hidden subsurface ice.

Comets are rock...as the EU has been saying all along... knee slap!


Date = 2018/04/22
Yes, the Sun is externally powered.
The previous quote is also included just for fun! We'll get back to this error later!

Date = 2018/04/22
Comets are rocky objects with minimal to no "ice/s", seeking electrical equilibrium with the surrounding plasma!

That’s it...the ELECTRIC COMET!!!


Date = 2018/05/14
JT08: This question seeks to clarify the meanings of the various terms for parts of a comet. In the latest version of the ELECTRIC COMET model (bold added):
1) comets are rocky objects
2) the nucleus of a comet contains no ices for sublimation
3d) there are (nested/stairstep transformer/capacitor) double layers at comets
3e) these double layers form the comets' comas
6) the charged dust so machined forms highly collimated, bursting jets; these are the jets we observe

There seems to be a small contradiction in 1) vs the rest: comet seems to refer to more than the rocky nucleus (in the ELECTRIC COMET model); specifically, a comet has a (non-rocky) coma and jets which are collimated charged dust in addition to a rocky nucleus. Not mentioned are tails.

Two types of tails are observed, I believe, Dust and Plasma.

The dust will be the electrically neutral dust that has previously been machined of the rocky nucleus.

The plasma tail will be another nail in the coffin for the dirtysnowball model.

It forms part of the the overall current system at comets.


Date = 2018/06/20
It's very simple: Comets are rocks discharging in the solar wind....
You keep saying that, yet never answer the question ... What "ROCKS" are comets made of?

Date = 2018/06/25
The comets is a rock violating the quasi-neutrality of the solar plasma stream!

From that we get complex electric fields, double layers, beams or "jets", charged nano-dust, electric currents...kinetic plasma effects!

These applied electric fields on the surface of the comet, most commonly along the terminator but also the small scale terminators from over hangs, boulders, scarps, depressions..etc can be extremely intense this can cause electrostatic disruption of the surface rock releasing fine dust and trapped water from the hydrated minerals along with electrochemical reactions.
Magic, Sol88? As YOU have no way to scientifically expand on this ... MAGIC will have to do!

Date = 2018/06/28
And it’s only the errors that make the mainstream think there some hyper porous dust with a little "hidden subsurface ice"

There made of rock!


Date = 2018/07/02
Coulomb Explosion under applied electric fields causing the dust to be machined from polarised ROCK is on the table for MAINSTREAM DISCUSSION!


Date = 2018/07/02
The nucleus is composed of homogeneous consolidated refractory material with an organic coating!

ROCK


Date = 2018/07/06
Sorry sorry, I meant liberating dust down to the microscopic scale from the LAYERED, CONSOLIDATED, REFRACTORY BEDROCK that is the rocky looking nucleus of ALL comet visited thus far.

So basically we are down to this? Is is not ROCK?


Date = 2018/07/12
The rock seperates the solar wind protons and electrons.

So so simple.

Please provide an example where I have "changed my mind".

Comet are rocks separating the charges contained with in the solar wind plasma?


What are you failing to grasp, ...?
Would love to see a physical mechanism that describes how a "rock" (e.g., granite) seperates charge!

Date = 2018/07/14
I’m talking about the real dust
Compact and dense particles with bulk density constrained in the range (1.9 ± 1.1)x103kgm-3
like the rock that it came from
Dust machined from SOLID ROCK? With a bulk density as low as 800 kg/m3?

Date = 2018/07/14
But your balls up with the RSI experiment has giving you 70%-80% of NOTHING?

So with a little help from generous soul/s over on the thunderbolts forum and with this new data and simulations at hand, I am going to prove that what we infact see, touch and taste is indeed ROCK!

So strap in champ we are going for a ride!
How'd that work out for ya, Sol88? 70%-80% of NOTHING? Crickets? No model! No science! No evidence!

Date = 2018/09/25
The model that says comets are just rocks (like asteroids) on eccentric orbits discharging in the solar wind plasma????

You not up to speed yet


Date = 2018/09/25
The universe is electric, life is electric.

As above, so below.
Do 'eu' supporters chant this "religious" mantra before all their conventions?

Date = 2018/09/30
Mmmmmm...Sol88 thinks to himself what would happen if the comets is rock blasted of a planetary surface within recorded human history and that this planet once had liquid water or water ice on the surface? This might include CARBONATE type rocks along with rocks containing HYDRATED minerals...

And not the "leftovers" from the formation of the solar system...????

More thinking.....
Yes! It would be nice if you started thinking, Sol88! Start by questioning your own world view!

Date = 2018/10/10
Let's see if you can do better this time with smaller easier questions.

1) Do you believe that comets are solid rock?

YES i do ltt!!!
Note the date of this particular pronouncement, Sol88!

Date = 2018/10/16
No, I also call rock, rock!

Now, we all call the nucleus rock.

Not actual rock, pseudo rock.

Hard like rock, looks like rock , taste like rock but not actual rock.


Date = 2018/11/05
<SNIPPY>

ELECTRIC COMET MODEL = A Rock on an eliptical orbit, discharging in the solar plasma flow.

<SNIPPY>


[size=+2]WOW![/size]

In light of what I've just presented, would you please explain your statement, ... "Everybody knows comets are not rocks." From what we've just read, Sol88, you do not seem to know what your 'electric comet' is actually made of!

And those quotes represent a wee random sample from your confused, disjointed, fragmented, unstructured 'electric comet' model! Would you like to see more?

Or perhaps you would like to take a moment to define in gory detail the following terms and statements!
  1. rock
  2. mostly rock
  3. not rock rock
  4. solid rock
  5. SOLID rock
  6. solid bone dry rock
  7. melted rock (???)
  8. polarized rock
  9. homogeneous consolidated refractory material with an organic coating rock
  10. layered, consolidated, refractory bedrock that is the rocky looking nucleus rock
  11. actual rock
  12. pseudo rock
  13. hard like rock
  14. looks like rock
  15. tastes like rock (???)
  16. feels like rock (???)
  17. not actual rock
  18. a ROCK on an elliptical orbit, charging AND discharging on "inbound" AND "outbound" legs ...!

Tis no wonder there's NO 'electric comet' model! OUR resident 'ec' expert appears utterly confused about the bulk composition and structure of an 'electric comet!' It might help if you STOPPED looking at 'electric' bunny pictures and learned to observe! More to follow on that point ...!

Heads up, Sol88! Before you fire off another post, START THINKING! Slow down when posting! Make an effort to construct sentences that use the "Queen's" English! Or at least the Australian equivalent of same! You may also want to avail yourself of the Spell Checker in the editing window! Doing this will improve your communication skills! Not necessarily your credibility on issues of science! But we can, and will, work on that, too!

Remember, Sol88! Science is hard! Communicating scientific information is hard! If you want anyone to give your 'electric comet' a fair hearing, you need to say what you mean, and mean what you say! Be precise! Be unambiguous! Be "crystal" clear!

Remember, the internet never forgets, Sol88! In the last ten years at the ISF, you have left a trail of EPIC FAILURES, be they technical 'eu/es/ec' errors, logical errors, or failures in basic physics and math (you know, the "fun stuff" your 'electric comet' MUST violate to exist)!

Some more simple questions, Sol88!
  1. How is dust "machined" from a rocky surface without leaving a thermal signature?
  2. What is the "rotational" velocity for a point on 67P's equator?
  3. What is the "time constant" for the capacitance of your 'electric rock?'
  4. ...

Sol88! I've literally thousands of questions that you can't answer regarding your 'electric comet!' And why can't you answer? Simple really! No model! No science! No evidence! Physically IMPOSSIBLE!

I'm not going away, Sol88! This is your 'electric comet' thread! It is incumbent upon you to PROVE your 'electric comet' is physically POSSIBLE!

Post Script 1:

Date = 2018/07/12
Whooo boy are you one mixed up cat!

Go find ALL my past post on charge separation at a comet comets being made of solid rock, or more precisely the my epic and total FAILURE of MHD to provide a coherent, scientifically consistent description of what an electric comet is!!!

What do you think, Sol88? A more appropriate statement? When are you going to start answering my questions! When are we going to start building a functional model of an 'electric comet?'

Post Script 2:

Date = 2018/07/20
[3rd person]Sol88 looks at his signature line and remembers those immortal words "The WWW never forgets".[/3rd person]

Oops! It appears you've replaced that line! Any reasons? :D

Post Script 3:

Date = 2018/09/11
Ummmmm.....every new paper CONFIRMS that electric fields and related plasma processes are the dominate factors at play here.

The paper CONFIRMING the ELECTRIC COMET model will be whoever puts the paper out modeling ... blah, blah, blah!

"... every new paper CONFIRMS ..."
"... dominate factors ...."
"The paper CONFIRMING the ELECTRIC COMET model ...."

Sol88, do you know how we might build a functional 'electric comet' model?

You start by answering my questions! It's really that simple!

Remember --- No numbers! No model! Bad fiction!

What's your next move, Sol88? Will you start answering my questions so that we may attempt to build a working model of an 'electric comet?' Or will you continue to cower in a corner?
 
Last edited:
Look it's real easy.

Comets are not mostly ice, ergo Whipple's model is incorrect and the mainstream have NO WORKING model of comets!

This has been proven by the mainstream! Unless of course you choose not to believe peer reviewed papers??
 
Last edited:
Sol88!

As a change of pace, I would like to offer you an easier post to deal with!

Whilst compiling the quotes for my last post, I came across something delightful! Something I'd missed!

Your answers (2018/11/15) to my original 20 questions (2018/06/13)!

Sol88! I would like to sincerely thank you for taking a moment to provide answers to my initial questions! And to apologize for not responding sooner! Sometimes there can be so much noise on this thread that it is easy to miss something important!

So, the issue here is trivial! I note that you only answered 19 of 20 questions. Because you employed the BB Code "
  1. " function, it may be possible that some of your 19 answers do not properly line up with my original 20 questions. If you would be so kind, could you inspect the table to confirm that the answers you gave are, indeed, consistent with your intent! You'll note that I've made the assumption in the table that you did actually answer just the first 19 questions. Please let me know if there are any changes required, and I will correct the table accordingly!

    Thanks again for your patience, Sol88!

    Thanks again for your answers to my First 20 Questions!

    Thanks again (in advance) for all your future 'electric comet' related answers and associated civil discourse!

    And thanks again for helping me understand your view of the 'eu/es/ec!'

    TABLE: Sol88's 20 Answers to Indagator's 20 Questions
    # | Questions | Answers
    01 | Could any principles/physics of the electric comet be wrong? | Yes
    02 | Could any principles/physics of the electric star be wrong? | Yes
    03 | Could any principles/physics of the electric universe be wrong? | Yes
    04 | Could every aspect of the electric universe be wrong? | No
    05 | Does gravity play any part in orbital mechanics? | Yes
    06 | Does gravity play any part in star formation processes? | No
    07 | Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in orbital mechanics? | Yes
    08 | Does electrostatics/electrodynamics play any part in star formation processes? | No
    09 | Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring in the core? | Yes
    10 | Are stars powered by nuclear fusion occurring on the surface? | Yes
    11 | Are asteroids made of rock? | No
    12 | Are asteroids made of volatile ices and dusts? | Yes
    13 | Are comets made of rock? | No
    14 | Are comets made of volatile ices and dusts? | Yes
    15 | Is sublimation (i.e., a state change from solid to gas) a real physical process? | Yes
    16 | Is eccentricity important to comet charging and discharging processes? | Yes
    17 | Is electric discharge machining responsible for terrestrial geomorphology (e.g., the Grand Canyon)? | Yes
    18 | Does a magnetic field always indicate the presence of an electric current? | Yes
    19 | Do you know where the water ice line is for our star at this point in its life cycle? | No
    20 | Do you know what a sedimentary tidal rhythmite is? | -?-

    Again, Sol88, I thank you for your time and attention in this matter!!! :)

    Post Script - As it turns out, it was question #13 that got swept up in my search algorithm! Otherwise, I may not have come across your answers for many months!
 
1. The RSI findings = (9.982±0.003)×10^12 kg
2. The Shape Model = 18.7 km3
3. The dust density = ~3g/cm3


Indagator, are you happy with the above?

Stay with me here champ, this has a direct bearing on all those really good questions you have.


Comets are rocky objects. :)
 
Yes I’d say there’s a cockup.

Happy to correct them if you find some value.
 
1. The RSI findings = (9.982±0.003)×10^12 kg
2. The Shape Model = 18.7 km3
3. The dust density = ~3g/cm3


Indagator, are you happy with the above?

Stay with me here champ, this has a direct bearing on all those really good questions you have.

Irrelevant. This is about your failed model. That definitively failed in 2005, when thousands of tonnes of ice were excavated from Tempel 1. Something that you continually avoid. Fail.
 
Irrelevant. This is about your failed model. That definitively failed in 2005, when thousands of tonnes of ice were excavated from Tempel 1. Something that you continually avoid. Fail.

Go read the paper again, they used the wrong assumptions based on...
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4]

In the old days of Temple 1 and I believe A’Hearn was the PI this was the thinking, now they are known to be stoney agglomerations with little to no ice!

Unless you think one of the parameters used by Pätzold is incorrect? As far as I can tell The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications are using solid measured, observed data that the a Rosetta mission to 67P has giving us. This paper has serious implications for the standard mainstream model of comets. Unfortunately, for the likes of the staunchly entrenched dogma believed by the old school brigade.

I’m still calling more or less solid rock (consolidated dust) composed of at least hydrated minerals, clays and carbonates.

The error still lays in the RSI experiment.
 
And why isn't it happening at asteroids?

It is ya duffer. :rolleyes:

The surface electric fields at asteroids can allow probes to navigate more or less indefinitely.

The E-Glider May have been a more viable option to carry on board Rosetta instead a probe designed for a Dirtysnowball.

We see outgassing at Ceres even Pluto has an atmosphere!
 
It is ya duffer. :rolleyes:

The surface electric fields at asteroids can allow probes to navigate more or less indefinitely.

The E-Glider May have been a more viable option to carry on board Rosetta instead a probe designed for a Dirtysnowball.

We see outgassing at Ceres even Pluto has an atmosphere!

No it is not. Why are the vast majority of asteroids not outgassing? Where is the dust? Stop lying.
 
Unless you think one of the parameters used by Pätzold is incorrect?

Well, Fulle seems to think differently. And thousands of tonnes of ice was ejected from Tempel 1, thereby debunking your idiocy. And any ice at all debunks your woo. It failed. Get over it.
 
Last edited:
Dude dude dude.....
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Sol88's insane delusion that we (and I) do not know how the diamagnetic cavity detected in the coma of 67P and earlier (1986) at P/Halley formed. It is textbook cometary physics, e.g. The formation of magnetic cavities in comets (1992).

Anyone with a basic knowledge of physics will suspect that a diamagnetic cavity can exist. A plasma (the solar wind) hits another plasma (the coma). There will be turbulent interactions creating varying magnetic fields. It is reasonable to suspect that these varying magnetic fields can cancel in a region.

Sol88's insane delusion that a diamagnetic cavity hundreds or thousands of kilometers away from the comet nucleus has anything to do with Sol88's electric comet insanity.
 
Last edited:
Sol88's insane insult that Michael O'Hearn thought comets were rock

No, A'Hearn said mostly rock, not rock rock. ...
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Sol88's insane insult that Michael O'Hearn was insane enough to think that comets were actual rock. That is the position of Sol88's ignorant, deluded and lying Thunderbolts cult.

Sane, knowledgeable people know the physical evidence that comets are made of ices and dust and are not rock. Michael O'Hearn was same and knowledgeable. Thus his "mostly rock" is "mostly dust with at least 17% ices" (from memory, the high side of the few measurements of the volatiles/dust ratio is 1/6).
 
Last edited:
Sol88's repeated insane lie that there is no working mainstream comet model

Look it's real easy. ...
It is really easy: Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Sol88's repeated insane lie that there is no working mainstream comet model.

Sol88's insane lie that his first insane lie has been "proven by the mainstream" when no paper has stated that comets are not made of ices and dust and many have "proved" that comets are made of comets and dust.

Sol88's insane lie that "Whipple's model" was that comets have to be made of mostly ice. That was an assumption based on the knowledge in the 1950's. Scientific models (unlike Sol88's insane cult dogma) change when new empirical evidence presents itself. The modern "Whipple's model" is that comets are still made of mostly ices and dust but evidence of 2 comets with more dust than ices suggests a future change to mostly dust and ices.
 
Sol88's insane lie that the density of dust shows that comets are rocks.

1. The RSI findings = (9.982±0.003)×10^12 kg
2. The Shape Model = 18.7 km3
3. The dust density = ~3g/cm3
...
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Sol88's insane lie that the density of dust shows that comets are rocks.

Smart people divide the RSI findings (the total mass of 67P) by the Shape Model (the volume of 67P) to get the real bulk density of 67P. Or look up the published mean density = 0.533 ± 0.006 g/cm3 :eye-poppi!

Smart people do not deny the evidence of ices on comets, e.g. the ices blasted from Tempel 1 by Deep Impact (A total of 5 million kg (11 million lb) of water[41] and between 10 and 25 million kg (22 and 55 million lb) of dust were lost from the impact.[39] ).

Smart people do not deny the measured high bulk porosity of comet 67P (up to 70%).

Smart people see that a reason the comets are much less dense than rock is that they are mixtures of ices and dust.

Smart people see that another reason the comets are much less dense than rock is that mixtures of ice and dust grains in very low gravity stick together with gaps, i.e. high bulk porosity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom