The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
A’Hearn still said comets are MOSTLY ROCK.

Then he must have referenced this heretofore never detected rock. Where is it? He referenced some papers, but none of them detected rock, because there isn't any. Wrong density, wrong strength, wrong thermal inertia. You lose again. However, you must be getting used to it by now!
 
Last edited:
Where the plasma and charged dust?

And where is there ice on the surface of a comet? We’ve observed frost patches from the mechanism I’ve explained above.

Incomplete first grader experiment. :rolleyes:

Stick the mostly ice comet under 10cm dust...no sublimation possible.

Go read up on the “Activity Paradox”.

Dirtysnowball lol :D

What the hell has plasma got to do with sublimation? Go get an education. And who said the ice was 10cm below the surface? Still batting zero, woo boy. Oh, and you don't have a mechanism for water production. It failed, remember? No EDM woo (lol), and no solar wind H+ to impossibly combine with non-existent O-. Let's be honest - who could possibly be stupid enough to fall for that garbage, anyway? (rhetorical)
 
Last edited:
Sol woo.jpg

Now, perhaps whoever starboy is/ was :) can answer the following;

  • What sort of rock are we dealing with? Where is it detected? What is its density? What is its thermal inertia? What is its strength?
  • Where is this radial field from the Sun? Where has it been detected? What is causing it? What is it doing?
  • What is this 'EM stress'? What phenomena is it responsible for? How is it achieving this? How would we detect it?
  • Why would a circular or elliptical orbit make a difference? Which highly elliptical asteroids are seen to be comet-like? Why are the few active asteroids on circular orbits?

The internet never forgets. There is plenty more out there.

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showthread.php?41761-Electric-Comets&p=899506#post899506
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insane lies about science. This post is the demented lie that we cannot detect anything at comets because we apply the laws of electromagnetism to empirical evidence. Spectroscopy has been around for close to 200 years, maybe 150 years as textbook astronomy.

The demented part is that this is the electric comet insanity thread. Sol88 is denying the laws of electromagnetism :jaw-dropp!

Sol88's usual insane insults of astronomers.
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insane lies about posts. The insanity here is that a For anybody interested in the real science still going on regarding laboratory comet experiments, see here has to be about the entire field of cemetery science :jaw-dropp!

Sol88's usual insane lies about comets. We detect ices on comet surfaces under condition that means they are sublimating.

Sol88's usual insane lies about basic science. This is Sol88's pathetic lie that surface layers stop ices under then from heating up and sublimating. This is something any cook can say is insanely wrong, e.g. baked potatoes do not have stone cold interiors!
 
Last edited:
What the hell are you prattling on about now? The ice was seen. Get over it. There is no FLAWED (learn to spell) model. That is just the opinion of a scientifically illiterate layman with quasi-religious beliefs based around misinterpreted mythology. Of no relevance at all. Has never been written up, and never will be. You would need to learn to spell first, and then spend a number of years studying actual science.

[qimg]https://smd-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/science-red/s3fs-public/mnt/medialibrary/2010/11/17/snowstorm_strip.jpg[/qimg]

And it wasn't a dust up, you liar. Read the literature, instead of relying on the liar Thornhill quoting press releases just hours after the event, from one instrument. The ice was seen by three separate instruments. And nobody has questioned their conclusions. Other than irrelevant, unqualified, wooists.

EDM! Lol. Sorry, where is the signature of EDM from any comet mission? Please point to it, before lying about impossible things happening. We see the ice in the retreating cliffs at 67P. You lose again.

And you are not getting water out of rock. Impossible at those temperatures.

So, you are still batting zero. No evidence, no mechanisms, no science. Strike out. Go play on an astrology forum or something more befitting your total lack of scientific knowledge.

So you think that’s all ice?

:eusa_whistle:
 
The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insane lies about posts. The insanity here is that a For anybody interested in the real science still going on regarding laboratory comet experiments, see here has to be about the entire field of cemetery science :jaw-dropp!

Sol88's usual insane lies about comets. We detect ices on comet surfaces under condition that means they are sublimating.

Sol88's usual insane lies about basic science. This is Sol88's pathetic lie that surface layers stop ices under then from heating up and sublimating. This is something any cook can say is insanely wrong, e.g. baked potatoes do not have stone cold interiors!


Whoo boy, your losing the plot champ.

What can you tell the lurkers about the “activity paradox”, reality check, in relation to your above assertion?

Abstract Comets are made of volatile and refractory material and naturally ex- perience various degrees of sublimation as they orbit around the Sun. This gas release, accompanied by dust, represents what is traditionally described as activ- ity. Although the basic principles are well established, most details remain elusive, especially regarding the mechanisms by which dust is detached from the surface and subsequently accelerated by the gas flows surrounding the nucleus.

Rhetorical question anyway really.

Is the dust charged? YES
Is there multiple electric fields in operation at comets? YES

So ummmmmm.....details remain elusive that’s a solid Lol

Do you people not talk to each other?
 
View attachment 40296

Now, perhaps whoever starboy is/ was :) can answer the following;

  • What sort of rock are we dealing with? Where is it detected? What is its density? What is its thermal inertia? What is its strength?
  • Where is this radial field from the Sun? Where has it been detected? What is causing it? What is it doing?
  • What is this 'EM stress'? What phenomena is it responsible for? How is it achieving this? How would we detect it?
  • Why would a circular or elliptical orbit make a difference? Which highly elliptical asteroids are seen to be comet-like? Why are the few active asteroids on circular orbits?

The internet never forgets. There is plenty more out there.

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/showthread.php?41761-Electric-Comets&p=899506#post899506


Has my story changed? :D

The Dirtysnowball has massively, ergo you have no model. :blush:

Have clays, carbonates, refractory minerals, dust, dirt OH...hang on got a quote from the preeminent cometary scientist of the time who was a FIRM believer that Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model, the first quantitative model, that comets were MOSTLY ICE with little Dust thrown in.

Seems he’s (our) understanding was evolving to comets being MOSTLY ROCK!


Now, let’s see if I can find the quote... ahhh found after much looking. :D

(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

A very basic question. Suck it up buttercup.
 
Last edited:
So you think that’s all ice?

:eusa_whistle:

I think WHAT is all ice? Try making sense for a change. The stuff whose absorption spectrum shows it to be ice? Yes. What else would it be? The stuff glinting in the sunlight around Hartley 2 that is also spectroscopically ice? Yes, what else would it be? Chalk in disguise? Lern to scienz.
 
Has my story changed? :D

The Dirtysnowball has massively, ergo you have no model. :blush:

Have clays, carbonates, refractory minerals, dust, dirt OH...hang on got a quote from the preeminent cometary scientist of the time who was a FIRM believer that Whipple’s Dirtysnowball model, the first quantitative model, that comets were MOSTLY ICE with little Dust thrown in.

Seems he’s (our) understanding was evolving to comets being MOSTLY ROCK!


Now, let’s see if I can find the quote... ahhh found after much looking. :D



A very basic question. Suck it up buttercup.

More lies. Why do you lie so much? It's all you've got left, isn't it? You have no science. No mechanisms. No evidence. I have linked your lying self to papers showing that the dust/ ice ratio was known to be 1 or greater than 1 from two decades ago. And yet still you come with this lying dirty snowball strrawman. You are a pathological liar.
And no rock has ever been detected at a comet. Ever. So you can stop lying about that, as well. Your woo has failed, and you simply don't want to address that failure. You just carry on lying and trolling. Go away.
 
Whoo boy, your losing the plot champ.

What can you tell the lurkers about the “activity paradox”, reality check, in relation to your above assertion?



Rhetorical question anyway really.

Is the dust charged? YES
Is there multiple electric fields in operation at comets? YES

So ummmmmm.....details remain elusive that’s a solid Lol

Do you people not talk to each other?

How many times? Can you not read? Are you completely ignorant of all things scientific? Which way is the putative ambipolar field pointing? Will that accelerate negatively charged anything away from the comet? Really, how many times is it going to have to be pointed out to you before you understand? Seriously, I could have explained this to a 12 year old, just once, and the twelve year old would have got it. Why can't you? Never studied science, have you? Or maths. Or much of anything, as far as I can see.
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insanity about science changing as new data is collected.
Sol88's usual "Whipple's model" insanity.
Sol88's usual insane lie about that there is no mainstream model of comets when he cites mainstream papers :jaw-dropp! .

Sol88's persistent insane insults of astronomers.

Sol88's usual lies about posts.
jonesdave116's post was questions that Sol88's electric comet insanity has not been able to answer for almost 50 years and of course Sol88 ignores this fact :jaw-dropp!
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

What can you tell the lurkers about the “activity paradox”, reality check, in relation to your above assertion?
What I can tell lurkers is this is yet more of The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88 as usual lies about mainstream papers.
The conundrum is that there are scenarios in which cohesion of the ices and dust on the surface of a comet is stronger than gas pressure. This suggests that the comet should become inactive after a short time. This happens in computer simulations. The "conundrum is sometimes referred to as the activity paradox" and has solutions in the next paragraph.
  • A low dust to ice volume ratio.
  • Enhanced gas pressure from "supervolatiles like CO2 and CO".
  • Additional heat sources in the nucleus.
  • A "pressure cooker" effect.
  • Fractures acting as nozzles.
  • Unconsidered effects in the computer simulations.
 
More lies. Why do you lie so much? It's all you've got left, isn't it? You have no science. No mechanisms. No evidence. I have linked your lying self to papers showing that the dust/ ice ratio was known to be 1 or greater than 1 from two decades ago. And yet still you come with this lying dirty snowball strrawman. You are a pathological liar.
And no rock has ever been detected at a comet. Ever. So you can stop lying about that, as well. Your woo has failed, and you simply don't want to address that failure. You just carry on lying and trolling. Go away.

Greater than 1????

Good one champ.

Again for the slower learners here.

first though, for context I have linked your lying self to papers showing that the dust/ ice ratio was known to be 1 or greater than 1 from two decades ago. And yet still you come with this lying dirty snowball strrawman strawman.

You are 100% correct :D :thumbsup: Well done sport for the history lesson.

Now again
(c) What are comets made of?
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

So yeah, scienz!

You, my friend need to also EVOLVE!

:D

So cob, what model are you using? :boggled:
 
What I can tell lurkers is this is yet more of The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88 as usual lies about mainstream papers.
The conundrum is that there are scenarios in which cohesion of the ices and dust on the surface of a comet is stronger than gas pressure. This suggests that the comet should become inactive after a short time. This happens in computer simulations. The "conundrum is sometimes referred to as the activity paradox" and has solutions in the next paragraph.
  • A low dust to ice volume ratio.
  • Enhanced gas pressure from "supervolatiles like CO2 and CO". nope, see below.
  • Additional heat sources in the nucleus.
  • A "pressure cooker" effect.
  • Fractures acting as nozzles.
  • Unconsidered effects in the computer simulations.

Yup, thought so!

Conclusions.

In the framework of the presented model, which can be considered common in terms of assumptions and physical parameters in the cometary community, the dust removal by a gas drag force is not a plausible physical mechanism. The sublimation of not only water ice, but also of super-volatile ice (i.e., CO) is unable to remove dust grains for illumination conditions corresponding to 1.3 AU. A way out of this impasse requires revision of the most common model assumption employed by the cometary community.
Is near-surface ice the driver of dust activity on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Common model????

What common model? jonesdave116 says the dirtysnowball, the first and ONLY quantitative model is dead.

  • A low dust to ice volume ratio. Nope
  • Enhanced gas pressure from "supervolatiles like CO2 and CO".
    [*]Additional heat sources in the nucleus.
    Nope
  • A "pressure cooker" effect. Nope
  • Fractures acting as nozzles. Lol Classic, but nope
  • Unconsidered effects in the computer simulations. Nope

No plasma?? No electric fields? No charged dust? :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom