By the way, what evidence has anyone posted here that supports the natural spillover origin?
So far it is mostly: it could have happened.
Double standard much?
Checking in to see if any actual evidence of a natural spillover has surfaced.
Nope.
It doesn't work like that.
That viruses, particularly novel viruses, emerge from nature is the null hypothesis.
Now, if we are talking about someone working in a lab and getting smallpox, then obviously the null hypothesis is that it came from the lab.
It would require extraordinary evidence to show otherwise.
In this case, we are talking about a new virus. So, even it it leaked out of a lab, we need evidence that somehow it got into the lab, or was engineered there.
Well, SG got really angry when asked for evidence that it was engineered and claims that such theories are strawman arguments deliberately made up by devious virologists who want to throw people off the scent that this was a captured virus that somehow got out after gain-of-function experiments.
The problem is that none of the "evidence" adds up at all. We have no candidate virus (RaTG13 has sometimes been floated but then discarded; SG has made the claim that it came from the Monjiang mine, but then it makes no sense that another piece of evidence - the taken down database - would have had this virus up there the whole time).
Basically, if we have no evidence that such a virus was there to begin with, why do we have evidence that it leaked from a lab?
The possibility that it came from nature is one that is, clearly, going to be difficult to verify. This is true of almost every aspect of viruses and spillovers. It is apparently very difficult to find viruses in the wild. Maybe Capsid could come in here and confirm, because I am not a virologist and I am mostly going by what I read in Spillover by David Quanmen.
Besides, if the lab leak is true, then we have to also explain various other more difficult problems, such as why it is that most virologists seem to think it came from nature (SG will claim this is BS and point to, maybe Drastic, or Yuri Deigin etc... but they are not virologists - or perhaps to people like Richard Ebright, etc... but they are people who have had long running arguments about gain-of-function etc...).
It seems to me that most of what is presented as "evidence" for lab leak is extremely distorted. Sometimes because the people presenting it are just ignorant, and sometimes because they are willfully distorting it.
On the other hand, I don't see evidence for thinking that Zhengli Shi, Peter Daszak, Anthony Fauci, Kristian Andersen, Robert Garry, etc... are lying. Most of the time their apparent "inconsistencies" seem to be misunderstandings (again, sometimes accidental, and sometimes deliberate).
So on balance, I go with the null hypothesis and the opinion of the experts. That is what seems to me to be the most rational thing to do and most consistent with scientific skepticism.