Origins of Covid

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not quite correct, Skeptic Ginger.
The report on pages 19 and 20 has a list of maintenance and renovation projects. Commonsense says this would be expected for any laboratory because equipment ages needing repair and becomes outdated. Some projects were for the BSL-3 and animal center at the WNBL. The locations of others were unclear. Then we have a comment from a committee of Republican politicians.

That is evidence of a functioning air circulation system that is being maintained and renovated. The unanswered question is how well the systems were functioning.

The report is biased. There is no "preponderance of evidence" suggesting that SARS-CoV-2 was accidentally released from the Wuhan Institute of Virology. They present no evidence that the virus was ever at WIV.
For example they cite Current status and future challenges of high-level biosafety laboratories in China by Yuan Zhiming.

This is a general review, not an analysis of the WIV.

What!?! The GOP report is biased and full of BS! Tell me it ain’t so! Break out the smelling salts. I think I’m going to faint!
 
Oh, I see. So now you are going to show me how the first cases in Wuhan were connected to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. No doubt that evidence is right at your fingertips.

Let's see it!
We are so far past the seafood market, you really need to make an effort to understand the difference between no evidence except claiming it is possible and evidence supporting one conclusion or another that isn't necessarily conclusive.

That zoonoses are common is one thing, that SARS came from a wet market does not implicate every wet market in China as a potential source without at least some shred of evidence.

You know that Kenny Rogers song, "You've got to know when to hold them"?

LiveScience, a year ago! : The coronavirus didn't really start at that Wuhan 'wet market'
Early reports blamed a market where live animals were sold, but evidence now shows they were wrong.

The first case of SARS-CoV-2 didn't emerge from a Wuhan wet market, according to experts at the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV). ...

"I haven't seen anything that makes me feel, as a researcher who studies zoonotic disease, that this market is a likely option," said Colin Carlson, a professor at Georgetown University who studies the spread of such zoonotic viruses, which transmit between animals and humans. Carlson does not work for the WIV. ...

Carlson said his colleagues in China have been careful and precise in their work, publishing data according to international regulations that any scientist anywhere in the world can examine, and that strongly supports the conclusion that the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market wasn't the source of the virus.
I think there is another citation here somewhere with the CCDC also confirming the seafood market was not the location of the spillover.

"... know when to fold them and when to walk away..."
 
Last edited:
We are so far past the seafood market, you really need to make an effort to understand the difference between no evidence except claiming it is possible and evidence supporting one conclusion or another that isn't necessarily conclusive.

That zoonoses are common is one thing, that SARS came from a wet market does not implicate every wet market in China as a potential source without at least some shred of evidence.

You know that Kenny Rogers song, "You've got to know when to hold them"?

LiveScience, a year ago! : The coronavirus didn't really start at that Wuhan 'wet market'I think there is another citation here somewhere with the CCDC also confirming the seafood market was not the location of the spillover.

"... know when to fold them and when to walk away..."

To repeat….

“So now you are going to show me how the first cases in Wuhan were connected to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. No doubt that evidence is right at your fingertips.”
 
Checking in to see if any actual evidence of a lab leak has surfaced.

*Nope*

See you in another couple of weeks...
 
Back to the GOP report, the items in need of repair were numerous and ongoing. These are from the Chinese sources themselves.

The GOP report
Page 18:
As discussed in our original report released last year, in 2018 U.S. State Department officials sent cables to Washington, D.C. highlighting concerns with safety issues at the WIV. The cables reported that scientists at the WIV noted “a serious shortage of appropriately trained technicians and investigators needed to safely operate this high-containment laboratory.” The cables also questioned the PRC’s commitment to prioritizing the important research for which the lab was designed. ...

Three months later, in September 2019, Yuan Zhiming, the Director of the BSL-4 lab at the WNBL and Shi’s superior, published an article in the Journal of Biosafety and Biosecurity ...

Page 19:
Entitled, “Current status and future challenges of high-level biosafety laboratories in China,” the article discusses at length the construction of the WNBL. Yuan identifies multiple key issues, including inadequate biosafety management systems, insufficient resources for efficient laboratory operation, and deficiency of professional capacity. With a surprising level of transparency, Yuan admits that the enforcement of pathogen, waste, and laboratory animal management regulations “needs to be strengthened.” Discussing the insufficient level of resources being provided by the PRC government, he stated:....

Interestingly, there appears to have been ongoing maintenance and repairs projects occurring at the WIV in 2019, before Yuan published his article raising these concerns. It is important to note that at the time of the hazardous waste treatment system renovation project, the WNBL had been operational for less than two years. Such a significant renovation so soon after the facility began operation appears unusual. Procurement announcements published on the PRC’s government procurement website provide evidence of ongoing work at what appears to be both WIV locations. ...

The references to maintenance at the BSL-3 and animal center at the WNBL, the procurement of an environmental air disinfection system, and renovations to the hazardous waste treatment system and central air conditioning system all raise questions about how well these systems were functioning in the months prior to the outbreak of COVID-19.

The point of that procurement document isn't that the virus leaked and they rushed out to fix the problem. The issue was work only started on repairs of the air filtration system in or after Aug 2019.
 
Checking in to see if any actual evidence of a lab leak has surfaced.

*Nope*

See you in another couple of weeks...

Again you seem to believe it is all or none, either there is proof or none of the supporting evidence matters.

The labs at the WIV had serious safety issues as reported by Shi's superior himself. One particular issue documented by Shi's superior was the problem with the air disinfection system. Work may or may not have started on the repairs but at a minimum it wasn't until in or after Aug 2019.

Dismiss that all you want but it is corroborated in the GOP report by supporting evidence.
 
Back to the GOP report,

Run away! As always, instead of supporting a claim, skip to another one. And as usual, a right-wing source is offered up as though it should be taken at face value (spoiler: don’t take ANYTHING by the GOP at face value!)

items in need of repair were numerous and ongoing. These are from the Chinese sources themselves.

The GOP report

Page 19:

The point of that procurement document isn't that the virus leaked and they rushed out to fix the problem. The issue was work only started on repairs of the air filtration system in or after Aug 2019.

We don’t even know that they were doing “repairs”.

You have a document confirming that Chinese specialists were concerned about lab safety in general (though not mentioning the WIV) but mix it together with some paraphrasing of some cables which may or may not have been directly relevant (quote the actual cables themselves please!)

As usual, you do the Gish Gallop and hope that everyone reading your cobbled together right-wing conspiracy theory joins all the dots the way that the conclusion that GOP is deliberately manipulating the evidence to support.
 
Forget the air system and just post the lab leak evidence found in the GOP report? Maybe it’s in the chapter titled EVIDENCE OF A LAB LEAK or the chapter titled EVIDENCE OF A LAB LEAK COVER-UP?
 
By the way, please also note the irony that you find it significant that we are talking about BSL-4 when it is convenient, and then get alarmed when something is at BSL-2 or BSL-3 when convenient, or that maybe a lab researcher got some ice fed by a bat in a cage when convenient and then back to BSL-4 again.

None of this is coherent. Like a 9/11 Truther you will accept the most obviously poor quality sources, the most obvious manipulations of sources, the most obvious cases of quote-mining and the most obviously partisan political hacks to jump to various mutually inconsistent conclusions as long as they have one thing in common: lab leak!
 
Oh for pity's sake, I didn't run away from anything. And you guys are missing/ignoring what I've posted. :rolleyes:

I shall wait for the next round of evidence.


By the way, what evidence has anyone posted here that supports the natural spillover origin?

So far it is mostly: it could have happened.

Double standard much?
 
Last edited:
Oh for pity's sake, I didn't run away from anything. And you guys are missing/ignoring what I've posted. :rolleyes:

“So now you are going to show me how the first cases in Wuhan were connected to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. No doubt that evidence is right at your fingertips.”

Apparently not. Yet this was enough evidence to rule out that it could have come from a market.

What's good for the goose should be good for the gander.
 
By the way, what evidence has anyone posted here that supports the natural spillover origin?

So far it is mostly: it could have happened.

Double standard much?

Checking in to see if any actual evidence of a natural spillover has surfaced.

Nope.

It doesn't work like that.

That viruses, particularly novel viruses, emerge from nature is the null hypothesis.

Now, if we are talking about someone working in a lab and getting smallpox, then obviously the null hypothesis is that it came from the lab.

It would require extraordinary evidence to show otherwise.

In this case, we are talking about a new virus. So, even it it leaked out of a lab, we need evidence that somehow it got into the lab, or was engineered there.

Well, SG got really angry when asked for evidence that it was engineered and claims that such theories are strawman arguments deliberately made up by devious virologists who want to throw people off the scent that this was a captured virus that somehow got out after gain-of-function experiments.

The problem is that none of the "evidence" adds up at all. We have no candidate virus (RaTG13 has sometimes been floated but then discarded; SG has made the claim that it came from the Monjiang mine, but then it makes no sense that another piece of evidence - the taken down database - would have had this virus up there the whole time).

Basically, if we have no evidence that such a virus was there to begin with, why do we have evidence that it leaked from a lab?

The possibility that it came from nature is one that is, clearly, going to be difficult to verify. This is true of almost every aspect of viruses and spillovers. It is apparently very difficult to find viruses in the wild. Maybe Capsid could come in here and confirm, because I am not a virologist and I am mostly going by what I read in Spillover by David Quanmen.

Besides, if the lab leak is true, then we have to also explain various other more difficult problems, such as why it is that most virologists seem to think it came from nature (SG will claim this is BS and point to, maybe Drastic, or Yuri Deigin etc... but they are not virologists - or perhaps to people like Richard Ebright, etc... but they are people who have had long running arguments about gain-of-function etc...).

It seems to me that most of what is presented as "evidence" for lab leak is extremely distorted. Sometimes because the people presenting it are just ignorant, and sometimes because they are willfully distorting it.

On the other hand, I don't see evidence for thinking that Zhengli Shi, Peter Daszak, Anthony Fauci, Kristian Andersen, Robert Garry, etc... are lying. Most of the time their apparent "inconsistencies" seem to be misunderstandings (again, sometimes accidental, and sometimes deliberate).

So on balance, I go with the null hypothesis and the opinion of the experts. That is what seems to me to be the most rational thing to do and most consistent with scientific skepticism.
 
Back to the GOP report...
Back to politics, not science, Skeptic Ginger. That is a report from politicians with their own agenda and ignoring that places like laboratories have ongoing maintenance and renovation.

You do not have to keep repeating that the cluster at the Huanan seafood market was not the first case. Chinese authorities have said since early last year [i.e. 2020] that the first confirmed victim was a Wuhan resident surnamed Chen who fell sick on Dec. 8, 2019, and had no connection to the Huanan seafood market, which was tied to many of the early infections.

COVID-19 lab leak theory
The COVID-19 lab leak theory proposes that SARS-CoV-2 (the virus that causes COVID-19) escaped from a lab in Wuhan, China, resulting in the COVID-19 pandemic.[1][2] The theory developed from the circumstantial evidence that the Wuhan Institute of Virology (WIV) is close in proximity to the pandemic's early outbreak in Hubei, China,[3] and suspicions about the secretiveness of the Chinese government's response to the pandemic.[4] Scientists from the WIV were known to have collected SARS-like coronaviruses, and the allegation that the institute performed undisclosed risky work on such viruses is central to some versions of the theory.[5][6] Some versions (particularly those alleging human intervention in the SARS-CoV-2 genome) are based on speculation, misinformation, or misrepresentations of scientific evidence.[7][8][9][10]
...
Scientists have largely remained skeptical of a lab leak origin, describing it as a remote possibility and citing a lack of supporting evidence. Most scientists agree that a natural origin is far more likely.[15] Some scientists, despite being concerned about the risks of politicization,[16][17] agree that the possibility of a lab leak should be examined as part of the ongoing investigations into the origin of COVID-19.[18][19]
My highlighting added.
 
Last edited:
“So now you are going to show me how the first cases in Wuhan were connected to the Wuhan Institute of Virology. No doubt that evidence is right at your fingertips.”

Apparently not. Yet this was enough evidence to rule out that it could have come from a market.

What's good for the goose should be good for the gander.

Straw man arguing much?
 
Last edited:
Back to politics, not science, Skeptic Ginger. That is a report from politicians with their own agenda and ignoring that places like laboratories have ongoing maintenance and renovation.
Jesus Christ, did I not say corroborating evidence was needed here?

Why yes, yes I did.

The report was from the head of the WIV over Shi. You want to argue with that? Is there evidence it is completely fabricated?

No, there isn't. Because that particular bit of evidence is in reports that were made before the pandemic started. And the GOP report is not the only citation here with that particular pre-pandemic evidence.

Handwaving things away is fine when one is discussing right wing opinion and unsupportable claims. But when corroborating evidence exists, it is not supportable to just hand-wave the evidence away.
You would think I shouldn't have to, I agree. And yet the assertion continues to be made in this thread that we should keep the seafood market on the table for .... reasons.


As for the assertion the spillover is generally supported by scientists, that is no longer true and in fact it has come out that Daszak did his best to slant the consensus. Scientists are recognizing that now. The majority has shifted to the two origin hypotheses are both on the table.

Even the head of the WHO has questioned the conclusions of the WHO investigation.
 
Last edited:
It doesn't work like that.

That viruses, particularly novel viruses, emerge from nature is the null hypothesis.

Now, if we are talking about someone working in a lab and getting smallpox, then obviously the null hypothesis is that it came from the lab.

It would require extraordinary evidence to show otherwise.

In this case, we are talking about a new virus. So, even it it leaked out of a lab, we need evidence that somehow it got into the lab, or was engineered there.

Well, SG got really angry when asked for evidence that it was engineered and claims that such theories are strawman arguments deliberately made up by devious virologists who want to throw people off the scent that this was a captured virus that somehow got out after gain-of-function experiments.

The problem is that none of the "evidence" adds up at all. We have no candidate virus (RaTG13 has sometimes been floated but then discarded; SG has made the claim that it came from the Monjiang mine, but then it makes no sense that another piece of evidence - the taken down database - would have had this virus up there the whole time).

Basically, if we have no evidence that such a virus was there to begin with, why do we have evidence that it leaked from a lab?

The possibility that it came from nature is one that is, clearly, going to be difficult to verify. This is true of almost every aspect of viruses and spillovers. It is apparently very difficult to find viruses in the wild. Maybe Capsid could come in here and confirm, because I am not a virologist and I am mostly going by what I read in Spillover by David Quanmen.

Besides, if the lab leak is true, then we have to also explain various other more difficult problems, such as why it is that most virologists seem to think it came from nature (SG will claim this is BS and point to, maybe Drastic, or Yuri Deigin etc... but they are not virologists - or perhaps to people like Richard Ebright, etc... but they are people who have had long running arguments about gain-of-function etc...).

It seems to me that most of what is presented as "evidence" for lab leak is extremely distorted. Sometimes because the people presenting it are just ignorant, and sometimes because they are willfully distorting it.

On the other hand, I don't see evidence for thinking that Zhengli Shi, Peter Daszak, Anthony Fauci, Kristian Andersen, Robert Garry, etc... are lying. Most of the time their apparent "inconsistencies" seem to be misunderstandings (again, sometimes accidental, and sometimes deliberate).

So on balance, I go with the null hypothesis and the opinion of the experts. That is what seems to me to be the most rational thing to do and most consistent with scientific skepticism.

I prefer to think of it as prior probability. A billion years worth of examples of zoonosis means the prior probability for zoonosis is 100%. If you want to move that needle you need positive evidence for something else.

That said there is real evidence that suggests it's not a lab leak.
- there is no catalogued proximal ancestor as you would expect if it were a lab leak
- The key feature that allows SARS-CoV-2 to infect humans (it's receptor binding domain) shows a clear evolutionary pattern in closely related corona viruses suggesting that it's a naturally evolving feature.
- bats and Pangolins sampled in Thailand showed the presence of SARS-CoV-2 reactive antibodies(meaning they had been infected with a close covid relative in the wild)
- environmental samples showed the presence of SARS-CoV-2 at and near where animals were kept in the Wuhan Fish Market, but not elsewhere.
- SARS-CoV-2 shows traits that are inconsistent with how a real researcher would engineer a virus.
- Key parts of the SARS-CoV-2 genome contain elements that were completely unknown prior to researching SARS-CoV-2. Unless the researchers had traveled backwards in time there is no way for them to design these.
- The earliest know cases ALL come from either the vicinity of the market or from people with direct contact with the market.
- None of the early case have any connection with the lab and are located 20Km away from the lab
- The highest concentration of early cases start showing up near the market and radiate outwards over time as you would expect for an outbreak that started in the market.
- Excess deaths follow the same pattern, showing a rise near the market then progressively radiating outwards over time.
- The concentration of cases and excess deaths radiated towards the lab, not away from it as you'd expect from a lab leak
- the existence of 2 SARS-CoV-2 lineages at the time the virus jumped to humans suggests animal origin. Multiple crossover events from a population of infected animals could explain the early existence of distinct lineages.
- If there were only a single crossover event it's 75% likely the virus dies out within a week or two. A population of infected animals would create multiple infections and raise the probability of a successful jump to humans dramatically.
 
Back to politics, not science, Skeptic Ginger. That is a report from politicians with their own agenda and ignoring that places like laboratories have ongoing maintenance and renovation.

You do not have to keep repeating that the cluster at the Huanan seafood market was not the first case. Chinese authorities have said since early last year [i.e. 2020] that the first confirmed victim was a Wuhan resident surnamed Chen who fell sick on Dec. 8, 2019, and had no connection to the Huanan seafood market, which was tied to many of the early infections.

A couple things to note
The estimated date for the first human infection is early Nov. Chen is NOT one of the earliest cases, in fact he was infected 4-6 weeks after the earliest cases

While Chen had no direct contact with the market or someone who had been to the market, he did live North of the Yangtze River relatively close to the market. The other confirmed case from that time period also lived close to the market and had visited it.

Chen had no connection to the virology lab, no contact with anyone with a connection to the lab and lived 20Km away from the lab
 
The majority has shifted to the two origin hypotheses are both on the table.

Even the head of the WHO has questioned the conclusions of the WHO investigation.[/B]

Neither of these things are true. The head of the WHO has expressed support for a planned follow-up investigation nothing more nothing less. This follow-up was planned even before the first team went to China, but was scuttled due to the political games being played in the US.

Most high profile papers that touch on the subject either directly or indirectly presume zoonosis. The ones that support a lab leak are almost inwardly relative nobodies who are not even working in their own specialty.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom