Again, with my highlighting:
Healthcare providers are already required by law to report to VAERS
US Health and Human Services "strongly" encourages healthcare providers to report to VAERS "Any adverse event that occurs after the administration of a vaccine licensed in the United States, whether it is or is not clear that a vaccine caused the adverse event".
"Vaccine manufacturers are required to report to VAERS all adverse events that come to their attention."
If you're asking why members of the general public are not subjected to criminal prosecution if they fail to report an event that healthcare providers are required by law to report to VAERS, I'd guess that has to do with a widespread desire to avoid living in the sort of police state
Tippit is effectively advocating in the post quoted above.
Two things. First, I never suggested that the general public be criminalized for not reporting to VAERS, because it is healthcare providers who are not reporting to VAERS, citing cost, and lengthy paperwork and time requirements. We can reasonably assume that the general public are reporting their adverse events to healthcare providers since they have a direct interest in their own health, and that it's the providers who are failing to report.
Second, I think it's unreasonable for someone advocating forced vaccination and universal vaccine mandates to cry "police state" at the suggestion that
providers (not the general public) be forced to report adverse events. Since the only surveillance we have outside of some studies, two of which you cited, is the VAERS it seems to me that this is a pretty important public safety issue. While we appear to have a nascent police state, it certainly isn't because healthcare providers are not being punished for not reporting to VAERS.
What do you make of the Lazarus report:
Electronic Support for Public Health–Vaccine Adverse
Event Reporting System (ESP:VAERS)
For serious outcomes that were common enough to support statistical analysis, there were none at all that were sufficiently more common in the first 21 days following vaccination as compared to the subsequent 21 days as to indicate an association with 95% confidence, but there were 2 of the 23 adverse outcomes for which the study uncovered some weak evidence for an excess of cases during the first 21 days:
- venous thromboembolism (estimated excess of 7.5 cases per million)
- acute myocardial infarction (estimated excess of 1.2 cases per million)
So in other words, the study compared "serious outcomes" for two arbitrarily short 21 day time periods, found that the outcomes were no more common in the 2nd period than the 1st with 95% CI, and then used this to conclude a lack of causation? Is that right?
Comparing to the unvaccinated group, there was only one serious outcome that appeared to be correlated with vaccination: myocarditis/pericarditis, with 132 cases per million person-years following vaccination versus 83 cases per million person-years among the unvaccinated.
Yes. This probably has something to do with why Sweden banned the Moderna "vaccine". It produces the most spike protein of all, and we have evidence that the spike protein is harmful, thanks to Bubba linking the original Swedish study.
All of those numbers are for cases, not deaths, and the confidence intervals are wide for the less common adverse events (for which we know, because they were so uncommon, there cannot be many of those events caused by vaccination).
I don't understand this logic. It seems to me that the less common and more serious adverse events are more likely to have been caused by the vaccine, not less, and the more common and less serious events are more likely to be coincidental/correlated because they're more common in the general population. For instance, my cousin died of Thrombocytopenia, and was recently vaccinated. I don't know how many days after he was vaccinated that he died, but there was no indication from his family that they thought it was a result of the vaccine. Yet he was exceedingly healthy, and more or less dropped dead a short time after being vaccinated.
Getting back to
Tippit's two questions, using data from the paper discussed above and
from another paper examining anaphylaxis, with 193 million people vaccinated in the United States, it looks to me as though it might be reasonable to guess, as a ballpark figure, that something on the order of 15 thousand adverse events might possibly be attributable to COVID-19 vaccines, which would be something like 2-3% of all adverse events reported to VAERS in connection with COVID-19 vaccines. I therefore estimate that something like 97% or more
* of all adverse events reported to VAERS following a COVID-19 vaccination are unrelated to those vaccinations.
That's cases of adverse events, not deaths. The number of deaths reported to VAERS is something like 3% of all VAERS reports.
Not quite. There are 1,697,752 adverse events reported to VAERS for Covid-19:
If I generously use your 2% estimate, I get 33,955 adverse events that likely are, not "might possibly be" Covid-19 vaccine events. Why would you qualify the product with "might possibly be", when you should have qualified the factor that way? This is evidence of your strong bias.
Applying that factor to my personal estimate of 15000 events attributable to COVID-19 vaccines yields an estimate that perhaps as many as 500 deaths could conceivably have been related to COVID-19 vaccinations. I suspect that's an overestimate, and I hope it's grotesquely overestimated, but a handful of specific deaths have been traced to the vaccines, and it seems reasonable to suspect the number of deaths actually caused by the vaccines may be at least an order of magnitude greater than the number of deaths that have been specifically attributed to the vaccines.
I agree with your last claim in that paragraph, but I think your 2-3% estimated causation rate is patently ridiculous. I don't see how you can suggest with a straight face that 97-98% of VAERS reports are just coincidental. Lets assume that the vast majority of vaccinated people were reasonably healthy prior to being vaccinated, yet suddenly they reported an adverse event within days of being vaccinated. What's more likely, that the patient is a hypochondriac, or that there is a causal relationship?
I stand by my estimate that 80% of VAERS reports are likely caused by the vaccines. Thanks for answering the question.
*Moving on to Tippit's second question, concerning under-reporting of adverse events to VAERS: Only one of my calculations above is affected by such under-reporting. If under-reporting has occurred, at (say) the 0.3 reporting rate suggested by Tippit, then my estimate that at least 97% of the VAERS reports have nothing to do with COVID-19 vaccines becomes an estimate that at least 99% of the VAERS reports have nothing to do with COVID-19, and none of the other numbers change.
I don't understand how the reporting rate affects the degree to which the reports are correlated with, or caused by the vaccines. That should be independent. Also note that my 30% estimate is far more generous to you than the 1% indicated by the Lazarus report.
Thanks for answering the question.
Bottom line: Even a crude back-of-the-envelope estimate such as the above, based upon credible data, suggests that Tippit's estimates 181000 or 48208 vaccine-related deaths are off by at least two decimal orders of magnitude.
We will have to agree to disagree. I think your suggestion that only 2% of VAERS reports are vaccine-causative is specious. It sounds like you're making assumptions by projecting the results from the studies you linked to fit the narrative. As far as how many adverse events go unreported, who really knows. If it is anywhere near 1% reported, then we have a serious problem.