Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Actually, if I remember correctly, placebo effect only specifically covers taking a non-active medical product or procedure, and getting better anyway. As such, it's only one of the several phenomena that make it seem as though a person is being helped when no actual healing is taking place. Including misdiagnosis, and several biases by the patient themselves, the physician, subjective interpretations, touchy-feely stuff, etc...

I believe steenkh is correct. Generally the placebo effect refers to everything that influences the results that is not an actual physiological effect. The most important parts of the placebo effect are actually the things you mention, especially patient bias and subjective interpretations. In trials, a placebo will be an inactive medication which stimulates these biases without having any other effect, but it is just as much a placebo when these things happen unintentionally, hence the need for placebo controlled trials.

Edit : In fact, this is the whole problem. Many people think, as you do, that the placebo effect is just one specific thing, when it is actually a term that covers basically any bias. This is why some people claim homeopathy, for example, works above placebo because the practioner is more friendly, when in fact a friendly practioner is a placebo.
 
Last edited:
If you look at the studies on OTC cough medicines (both positive and negative), the majority are positive.
How many studies have been done and how many were positive?

By the conventional standard (p<0.05), you would only expect 5 percent to be positive due to chance.
Assuming that's true, homeopathy easily meets that standard.

The studies that are negative have a low power - that is, the chance of a Type 2 error (false negative) is high. If the medication was ineffective, high powered studies would also be negative.
Linda
Can you be more specific as to which studies you're talking about?
 
If you look at the studies on OTC cough medicines...the majority are positive.
OTC cough medicines contain three main ingredients:

An anti-histamine which might be useful if you have hayfever, but which does nothing for a cold.
A cough suppressant, which doesn't work, or an expectorant which is just as useful.
A decongestant which works but which causes rebound congestion.

In other words, they are about as effective as homoeopathetic remedies.

BJ
 
Last edited:
Rodney will not or cannot produce any evidence (I don't call what he has produced evidence) that homeopathy has a leg to stand on.

It really comes down to whether it is moral to charge people money for water that is claimed to have a "memory" of an active ingredient.

If that is moral, then so is my offer of sending you cures for whatever ails you via email -- and my email cures are cheaper, too!

Send me a description of your ailment, and I will concoct a "cure" tailored to that ailment. The first "treatment" is free; however, the necessary subsequent treatments will incur a small fee.

M.
 
How many studies have been done and how many were positive?

I will give you an illustrative example using Dextromethorphan.

Looking only at controlled studies for acute cough (RCT's where appropriate)....

There were 14 studies in animals and all were positive.
There were 5 studies in humans using induced cough and all were positive.
There were 5 studies in humans with acute upper respiratory tract infection and 3 were positive (one of the positive studies was a metanalysis of 6 other studies, but I'm only counting it as 1 instead of 6).

Assuming that's true, homeopathy easily meets that standard.

It doesn't. I'll explain why using two different approaches.

First I have to digress a bit to explain what p<0.05 means, because you have made a common mistake (I am not singling you out as I have seen this mistake from many people, including scientists) and since I see this oft-repeated, this is my chance to set the record straight. <grin>

Many people say that a study with a p<0.05 means that it is more than 95% likely that the treatment is effective. In reality, the 95% doesn't necessarily say anything about the possibility that the treatment is effective. Most drug trials consist of taking a group of people, dividing them into two groups, giving all the people in one group a drug and all the people in another group a comparable placebo, and then looking for any differences in (pre-specified) outcomes days/week/months/years later. Now, anytime you divide people into two groups, you are likely to find differences between them due to chance. The 95% confidence interval recognizes that by coming up with a way to say, "yes the differences may be due to chance, but it is so unlikely that you should consider that there is some other way in which the groups are different". All the p<0.05 says is that there is some other way in which the groups are different. It says nothing about what that difference may be. In a meticulously designed and executed RCT, the only way that the groups are different is that one group is receiving a drug and one group is receiving a placebo. It is only then that one can say that the possibility that the treatment is effective is greater than 95%. Any deviations from that ideal mean that we cannot be sure why the groups are different, so we need to look at all the plausible explanations.

Common reasons for groups to be different - selection (the population that is selected for study), sampling (the method of choosing people from the population for the study), non-randomization (the way that people are divided into two groups), non-pharmaceutical treatments (attention, comfort, coercion, etc.), variation in measurement of outcomes.

If any of those reasons are present, then for all we know, our p<0.05 reflects bias rather than treatment effect.

Now for my first approach. We can let the results of the studies stand as reported and agree that the majority show a positive result (the groups are different in some way). But let's look a bit more closely at the demonstrated positive results.

Many of the studies do not involve an untreated group, so the positive result says "if you start with people who are unwell, give them drops of water, and then ask them how they feel a day/week/month later, many of them will state they feel better". However, we already know that "if you start with people who are unwell and then ask them how they a day/week/month later, many of them will state they feel better". There's no way to differentiate between those that took in gallons of water during that time period from those that took in gallons of water plus a few more drops during that time period.

Many of the studies involve two groups that are treated differently - one group gets attention, the psychological advantage of being told they are receiving a treatment, and a few drops of water. The other group gets none of this. We already know that people that get attention, and who are told that they are receiving a treatment feel better, regardless of whether or not they also receive a few drops of water.

Some of the studies are partially placebo-controlled - one group gets attention and both groups get the psychological advantage of receiving a treatment. We already know that people that get attention feel better regardless of whether or not they also are told that they are receiving treatment.

A few of the studies are fully placebo-controlled - both groups get the complete therapeutic package of attention and treatment, so that the only difference between the two groups is the presence or absence of a few drops of water. In this case, p<0.05 could be reasonable assumed to represent the treatment effect.

So what it boils down to is that the bulk of homeopathic research that is "positive" demonstrates that the groups are different in ways that we already know will create group differences through well-established conventional methods. There are a handful of studies that suggest that the differences could be due to treatment effects. But considering that all positive results will get published and only some negative results will get published, this handful could easily represent the few studies that we expect to see as positive due to chance.

And that does not even take into account that improper use of multiple comparisons and the use of homeopathic preparations that are not dilute (i.e. they contain active pharmacologic ingredients) accounts for some of these results.

My second approach refers to something I mentioned in a previous post - playing with a weighted coin. It is possible to generate a normal distribution with a weighted coin - it simply changes the mean and variance. I mentioned before that the study design/execution of most of the homeopathic studies introduces a bias similar to playing with a weighted coin. It is possible to compare the distribution you would expect from a weighted coin (in this case "the placebo effect") with the distribution of homeopathic studies and conventional medicine studies. In this type of analysis, it turns out that the distribution of homeopathic studies is not distinguishable from the distribution of the placebo effect, whereas the distribution of the conventional medicine studies is.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...Retrieve&dopt=abstractplus&list_uids=16125589

So even though the homeopathic studies are "positive", they are not indistinguishable from a chance distribution taking the placebo effect into consideration.

Also, there is a strong correlation with "bias introduced during the design and execution of the study" and "magnitude of the result" in homeopathic studies which suggests that positive results are due to chance. If there was a true effect, there would not be a correlation between the two or it would be in the opposite direction (as you reduce the effects of noise)

Can you be more specific as to which studies you're talking about?

Power is affected by variance and the number of subjects. In studies where the variance is low and/or the number of subject is high (such as the animal and induced-cough studies I referenced above for Dextromethorphan), the power is high and none of the studies are negative. In studies where the variance is high, the power is low and some of the results are negative. That is, there is a correlation between the power and the results. That suggests that negative results are due to chance. If the medications were truly ineffective, then there would not be a correlation between the two.

Linda
 
OTC cough medicines contain three main ingredients:

An anti-histamine which might be useful if you have hayfever, but which does nothing for a cold.
A cough suppressant, which doesn't work, or an expectorant which is just as useful.
A decongestant which works but which causes rebound congestion.

In other words, they are about as effective as homoeopathetic remedies.

BJ

I am willing to make a serious effort to educate and discuss, but I expect people who choose to enter the discussion to at least have the courtesy to not pull stuff out of their a**.

:)

Linda
 
Last edited:
Snipped all that very educational stuff...

It falls on Rodney's and others' deaf ears, fls.

The essence of wooness is that anything goes until proven otherwise.

And the proof has to be prominent on Tweety and Sylvester's half hour, else the true believers won't see it.

Such smurfs don't use common sense because they never had any to begin with. They're a lost cause, so save your erudition and apply it where it might do some good.

M.
 
It falls on Rodney's and others' deaf ears, fls.

The essence of wooness is that anything goes until proven otherwise.

And the proof has to be prominent on Tweety and Sylvester's half hour, else the true believers won't see it.

Such smurfs don't use common sense because they never had any to begin with. They're a lost cause, so save your erudition and apply it where it might do some good.

M.

You're trying to save me?

Aw shucks. That's sweet. <grin>

Linda
 
I will give you an illustrative example using Dextromethorphan.

Looking only at controlled studies for acute cough (RCT's where appropriate)....

There were 14 studies in animals and all were positive.
There were 5 studies in humans using induced cough and all were positive.
There were 5 studies in humans with acute upper respiratory tract infection and 3 were positive (one of the positive studies was a metanalysis of 6 other studies, but I'm only counting it as 1 instead of 6).
Thanks for your continuing educational efforts, Linda. Still, I wonder why I keep finding articles like this one from only a month ago:

"Non-prescription cough syrups do little if anything to stop coughs, according to a study by the Northbrook, Ill.-based American College of Chest Physicians.

"The study suggests over-the-counter syrups contain medications in such low doses that they are ineffective, or contain a combination of active and inactive ingredients that are not proven to control cold-related coughs. The American Thoracic Society and the Canadian Thoracic Society are two other professional organizations that support ACCP's conclusion.

"One popular brand's combination of codeine and dextromethorphan has been approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), however the ACCP study authors suggest their doses are too small to produce the relief many cold sufferers seek.

"A spokesperson for Wyeth Consumer Healthcare, the company that makes Robitussin brand cough syrup, said its product 'wouldn't be a top brand if people didn't feel it was efficacious.'

"It could also be said that Robitussin wouldn't be a top brand if Wyeth didn't spend an estimated $17.2 million on product marketing and advertising in 2003, according to a survey of the 100 Top Advertisers compiled by Advertising Age magazine.

"Over-the-counter brands racked up an estimated $3.6 billion in sales during 2005. And, by one estimate, nearly 30 million people visited health-care professionals for treatment of coughs and related ailments."
See http://wcco.com/topstories/local_story_296160716.html
 
Linda,

I am willing to make a serious effort to educate and discuss, but I expect people who choose to enter the discussion to at least have the courtesy to not pull stuff out of their a**.
And I was going to congratulate you on your Language Award Nomination. :mad:

Anyway I'll read the thread when I get a chance (your nomination bought me here it was so good :)), but just issuing a word of caution to look in your back yard.

Cough mixtures are not really as useless as Homoeopathic but nearly.
I may be back depending on time
(You won't tale my word for it so you will obviously need lots of references :D )

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Non-prescription cough syrups do little if anything to stop coughs, according to a study by the Northbrook, Ill.-based American College of Chest Physicians.

Don't most 'cough syrups' do a lot more than just purport to stop coughing? I have a bottle of generic brand Nyquil upstairs, and IIRC from when I took some last night, it said it would stop coughing, but also relieve aches and pains and relieve nasal congestion and fever. Maybe some other stuff, too. I'd go grab the bottle and look, but I can't leave my toddler alone to go get it. Plus if she sees fun red coloured liquied then she'll want some.

So even if the 'cough' portion is ineffective, that doesn't mean the other stuff is. Or are people in this thread just focussed on the 'cough' aspect? After reading the last 7 pages over the last few hours I've kind of lost track of where this discussion started.
 
You're trying to save me?

Aw shucks. That's sweet. <grin>

Linda

I don't think you need saving, at least I hope you don't.

It's the Rodneys of this planet who need some sort of wake-up call, IMO.

Doubt that it would do much good, though.

M.
 
Thanks for your continuing educational efforts, Linda. Still, I wonder why I keep finding articles like this one from only a month ago:

I already told you why. Journalists always make mistakes when reporting on scientific research. If you choose to obtain your information from newspaper articles, then you will be misinformed.

ETA: I mis-remembered. I did write a post about my informal study of science reporting by journalists (all contained mistakes, half were major mistakes including many that made statements that were the opposite of what was found in the research), but apparently that was somewhere else.

There was no "study" by the ACCP, there was a panel that summarized a whole bunch of information on cough, which was published as a supplement to Chest.

http://www.chestjournal.org/content/vol129/1_suppl/#top
http://www.chestjournal.org/cgi/content/full/129/1_suppl/1S

The panel recommendations do not conclude what the journalist has written.

It is true that the dosage recommendations for Dextromethorphan, on the bottle, are for a dose that has been shown to be less effective than a higher dose. This means that physicians should recommend a higher dose. That is not uncommon, by the way. There are many OTC medications where the dosage recommendations are less than ideal as a trade-off for safety.

It is also true that cold medicines that include "cough" as the list of symptoms that they treat, will contain ingredients that have been demonstrated to be effective against coughs and ingedients that have not been demonstrated to be effective against coughs but have been demonstrated to be effective against other cold symptoms.

Codeine can not be purchased OTC in the US, so that particular cough medicine will not be OTC.

Linda
 
Last edited:
I don't think you need saving, at least I hope you don't.M.

I was sorta thinking of whether I need to be saved from myself.

I think I need to hit my favourite cold medicine. <grin>

Linda
 
I already told you why. Journalists always make mistakes when reporting on scientific research. If you choose to obtain your information from newspaper articles, then you will be misinformed.
Two sets of questions:

(1) Even if "[j]ournalists always make mistakes when reporting on scientific research", why is it that they seem to consistently come down against the efficacy of OTC cough medicines? Are they out to get manufacturers of those medicines? If so, why?

(2) How do you explain these quotes from MDs? --

"We found that there is little evidence for or against the effectiveness of over-the-counter cough medicines," says lead author Knut Schroeder, MD, researcher at University of Bristol, Englandger. See
http://www.webmd.com/content/article/18/1689_51929

"There is no clinical evidence that over-the-counter cough expectorants or suppressants actually relieve cough," said Dr Richard Irwin, panel chair of the American College of Chest Physicians which drew up the latest US guidelines.
See http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/li...ain.html?in_article_id=373758&in_page_id=1774

It is true that the dosage recommendations for Dextromethorphan, on the bottle, are for a dose that has been shown to be less effective than a higher dose. This means that physicians should recommend a higher dose. That is not uncommon, by the way. There are many OTC medications where the dosage recommendations are less than ideal as a trade-off for safety.
Yes, but the debate here is about the efficacy of OTC cough medicines. What you seem to be suggesting now is that it's not enough for someone who needs a cough suppressant to purchase an OTC medicine containing Dextromethorphan; rather, (s)he must visit a doctor to obtain a prescription for a cough medicine containing that ingredient.
 
Don't most 'cough syrups' do a lot more than just purport to stop coughing?

A lot of them are marketed for colds and cough. Some are cough only.

I have a bottle of generic brand Nyquil upstairs, and IIRC from when I took some last night, it said it would stop coughing, but also relieve aches and pains and relieve nasal congestion and fever. Maybe some other stuff, too. I'd go grab the bottle and look, but I can't leave my toddler alone to go get it. Plus if she sees fun red coloured liquied then she'll want some.

Unless of course you want her to have some. Then it'll end up on the front of her shirt. <g>

So even if the 'cough' portion is ineffective, that doesn't mean the other stuff is. Or are people in this thread just focussed on the 'cough' aspect? After reading the last 7 pages over the last few hours I've kind of lost track of where this discussion started.

It started with a homeopathic cough remedy. There was never any evidence submitted on its behalf, though. It's more useful to dissect stuff there is evidence for, I guess.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom