Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Another one:
(This one is from America - Mayo clinic)

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/cold-remedies/ID00036

BillyJoe

Can you explicitly state what your point is, and how you think that the information you have provided so far makes your point? And since I think you are directing this at me, can you also specifically refer to what I have said that you think is wrong including some indication of what you find unhelpful or unconvincing about the research I have provided in support of my statements.

Linda
 
This particular excerpt you are dismissing is a summary of the recommended treatment by physicians from a major children's hospital who treat patients with these conditions. It is the recommendation they give to patients, and to Family Physicians treating these patients, on how to manage these conditions based on best available evidence.

I don't think their advice can be just ignored.

regards,
BillyJoe

I think the problem is that there is a difference between "evidence" and "recommendations". What originally arose in this thread was the statement that cough medicine has not been shown to be effective, which was incorrect, and I provided (on numerous occasions) links and references to original research looking at this (trying to be inclusive and including all studies, not just positive). And that's all I've really meant to address, although I seem to have given you the impression that I am dismissing the recommendations of expert groups.

When making recommendations, one takes into account more than just the evidence - the potential seriousness of the condition, the possibilities of abuse and toxicity, the vulnerability of the target population, ease of use, etc. So reasonable recommendations can and do differ from what is demonstrated by research.

I have not dismissed the recommendations of any group. I have simply tried to counteract inaccurate or misleading one line summaries with more complete information. I'm sorry if that's not clear. If there's confusion, I usually try to clarify it as soon as I notice it (including confusion on my part). But I don't always realize right away that someone thinks I am saying something that I didn't intend.

Linda
 
But some of your recent posts are a little self-serving sorry to say.

regards,
BillyJoe

Are you talking about posts where I just mention that a newspaper article is incorrect without really addressing it point by point?

I don't really know how to handle that situation. In the past, I have tried going through these things sentence by sentence. This makes for a very long and tedious response, although it can be worth it if the person reading my response is making a good-faith effort to understand. And maybe I just had bad luck, but the majority of the time (actually I can't remember a single exception <g>) it seems to be ineffective. The response I get back is either a repeat of the same misinformation or a reference to a different article with new and different misinformation. This stuff seems to grow exponentially. I remember on one occasion that within the space of two posts, I wrote a thousand word essay in order to counteract a single 8 word sentence. And even then, in spite of numerous references and detailed explanations, the person my essay was directed at was unconvinced.

Not doing this does come across as self-seving, or cryptic, or dismissive, though. I think I'm damned either way, but at least saying, "this is incorrect, here's a link to the original" is a lot less work. <g>

Linda
 
Linda,

After reading the whole thread, it seemed obvious to me that there are really only two people who are patiently trying to discus this thing in a reasonable manner. Yourself and Rodney. Yes, Rodney has been very patient considering the amount of attention he has been receiving. Of course he has a very unsceptical view of homoeopathy. However, he is willing to listen to alternative views and has conceded a few points along the way. This makes him a winner in my book, in the sense that he is getting something out of this thread, whereas other are just confirming their prejudices and learning nothing.

Rodney, it seems to me, is a practical sort of person as evidenced by his repeated question about which cough mixture he should use. It seems he is also correct in his impression from what he has read, that cough mixtures are a waste of time and money. And all the discussion about the proven biological effects of the components don't change the fact that, on the coalface, in practical everyday life, they are almost useless. Homoeopathic preparations are of course totally useless, and I am willing to bet Rodney is having a second think about that as well. No thanks to most of the posters on this thread, yourself excluded of course. But then you...

I don't want to labour the point about your self-serving responses, but I can't help but feel you are losing him by the sort of response you gave to his quite legitimate quotes about cough mixtures from the medical fraternity. Sure they where obtained via media reporters who so often screw these things up. But above I have given you a quote from physicians at the Royal Children's Hospital to both patients and to Family Physicians. This advice is based on best evidence.

I don't think your responses to those quotes or to the practical advice offered by that major public hospital do anything to advance your cause.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
Well, as long as you keep under four standard glasses... ;)

Perhaps I should start at page one and see....
Reading from where I came in, though, there seem to be a number of self-serving responses and a bit of congratulatory back-slapping which do not augur well for this thread. :(
But, perhaps I should read first....


I agree with your comment, although I'm not surprised that the tenor of the thread should turn less serious. I'm awaiting the recipes...

I trust that levity is still allowed?

M.
 
Rodney, it seems to me, is a practical sort of person as evidenced by his repeated question about which cough mixture he should use. It seems he is also correct in his impression from what he has read, that cough mixtures are a waste of time and money. And all the discussion about the proven biological effects of the components don't change the fact that, on the coalface, in practical everyday life, they are almost useless.

The research for the ingredients contained within various cough medicines is similar to what I summarized for dextromethorphan - animal studies and human studies using induced and other types of cough. And they are mostly positive and form the bulk of the information that leads to FDA approval for that indication. These studies do include specific formulations of cough medicines, not just single ingredient studies. And I think they correspond to your comment about "proven biological effects of the components". Then we have clinical studies where cough medicines are tested in various clinical scenarios, which I think corresponds to your statement about "practical everyday life", with more heterogeneous results.

What information you look for to guide your opinion depends upon the question you are asking. If you have a cough associated with a viral infection and you are having trouble sleeping at night, you are interested in a study that shows whether or not, if you actually take the medication at that time for that indication, you are likely to get more sleep. You are less interested in studies which look at the results in people that may or may not have taken the medication (clinical studies are analyzed as intention-to-treat - the outcomes in the treatment arms are analyzed as though everyone took the medication (or placebo) even though it is rare for everyone to use the medicine as directed and many times a large portion of the group does not use the medication at all (this does make it more likely to get negative results, but there are good reasons to do it this way)) since you know that you are actually going to take the medication in the recommended amounts. You are also less interested in studies where people took the medication for reasons other than your own. And you are less interested in studies where the outcome measured was not sleep or satisfaction, but something like cough sound volume.

On the other hand, if you are a group of experts charged with making public policy recommendations, you are more interested in studies that look at how people use the medication in the real world, taking into consideration that people will not take the medication or will not follow recommended dosing, or they will use it for conditions for which it is not recommended. Measures of change in discomfort, disease, disability or death are more important than changes in dissatisfaction. And potential harm from mis-use is a serious consideration.

Both you and the experts are probably concerned with cost and ease of use, but as an individual, you are better able to make that determination for yourself, and research or the opinions of others isn't really relevant.

Why we see a disconnect between what the research shows (lots of evidence that cough medicines are efficacious and effective) and what you think the various experts are saying is that you and Rodney have provided links to statements that deal with somewhat isolated situations (some quotes taken out of context give the false impression that they refer to all the evidence), and that the priorities of the expert groups are different from the priorities of an individual. For example, you refer to the CPG from the Royal Children's Hospital, but that is a statement about whether cough medicines treat cough, not whether they relieve cough, and clinical evidence for children should not automatically be extrapolated to adults (and vice versa). The issue about treating vs. relieving coughs has come up several times, and I agree that it is important to recognize that people can be confused. Expert groups tend to be very conservative when it comes to recommending treatment that addresses only dissatisfaction or mild discomfort. And that is really all that we are talking about addressing with OTC cough medicines.

We can look at the review published in the BMJ as an example, especially because I suspect many of the statements of opinion that you and Rodney have presented as evidence stem from that source. Please note that this review only covers acute cough due to URTI in adults.

This is a summary of the results:

Two trials of codeine showed no effect above placebo. One trial of DM showed effect above placebo and one did not. One trial of moguistiene showed effect above placebo. One trial of guaifenesin showed effect above placebo and one trial did not. One trial of a mucolytic showed effect above placebo. One trial of an antihistamine-decongestant combination showed effect above placebo and one did not. Three trials of mixed-preparations showed effect above placebo. Two trials of terfenadine (note this is a different type of antihistamine from those used in cough and cold medicines with a different mechanism of action) showed no effect above placebo.

The effect sizes varied. Keep in mind that the placebo effect in cough is large - around 1/4 to 1/3. So a small effect above placebo still represents a moderate difference, although we cannot tell how much of that is subjective.

I need to digress again to talk about Type I (false-positive) and Type II (false negative) error. Medical research is very conservative. The bar is set, by convention at 95% for a Type I error. We are trying to avoid coming to any hasty conclusions in the drive to make the best recommendations. This means that we will reject as "positive" effects that would only occur one time out of 19 by chance. This makes the chance that we come up with a false postive low and gives a measure of confidence in our results. But of course, this makes it easy for us to reject a lot of medications that may be effective (false negative). We measure Type II error by looking at the power of a study - what is the chance that we won't miss a true effect. If you look at medical research, especially less recent research, you rarely see power calculations. I think part of this is because power is more difficult to grasp intuitively and is more difficult to calculate as it may include values that have to be estimated (if done, it is usually done before the study is carried out in order to estimate the necessary sample size), and because accepting a false premise is considered a worse offense than rejecting a true premise. By convention, the usual level is chosen to be 80% for this kind of study, which leaves a one in five chance that you will miss a positive effect. However, that power level is rarely achieved. In particular, in the studies referenced for the review, the power of the studies was less than 50%, making it more likely than not that a clinically significant effect could be missed.

Ignoring what anyone else has to say about these results, there are several reasonable conclusions that could be drawn from this evidence depending upon how you wish to present the results.

There is reasonable evidence that the following cough medicines are effective in reducing cough symptoms in adults with acute URTI - dextromethorphan, moguistiene, guaifenesin, a mucolytic, an antihistamine-decongestant combination, and multi-ingredient cough medicines. There is weak evidence that the following cough medicines are ineffective in reducing cough symptoms in adults with acute URTI - codeine, terfenadine. The effect sizes vary in clinical significance from small to large.

There is conflicting evidence that the following medications are effective in reducing cough symptoms in adults with acute URTI - dextromethorphan, guaifenesin, anti-histamine-decongestant combinations. There is reasonable evidence for the effect of multi-ingredient cough medicines and a mucolytic. There is weak evidence that codeine and terfenadine are ineffective. The effect sizes vary in clinical significance from small to large.

There is no strong evidence that any of the tested cough medicines have a large, clinically significant effect on cough symptoms in adults with acute URTI.

There is weak to moderate evidence that some cough medicines have a large, clinically significant effect on cough symptoms in adults with URTI.

There is weak to moderate evidence that some cough medicines do not have a moderate to large clinically significant effect on cough symptoms in adults with URTI.

All the above conclusions are valid interpretations of the results presented (I could do more, but I hope you see my point). And what it really indicates is that one cannot make blanket statements about whether or not cough medicines are effective. They are effective for some purposes and not for others, depending upon which particular preparation you are considering. And the negative studies are not strong enough to prove they are ineffective by themselves. Unless you provide specific evidence of equal or greater quality that counteracts the positive evidence, the negative evidence serves to qualify the positive, rather than negate it.

Sure they where obtained via media reporters who so often screw these things up. But above I have given you a quote from physicians at the Royal Children's Hospital to both patients and to Family Physicians. This advice is based on best evidence.

The quotes you provided were unreferenced. There was no indication given as to what evidence was used for the advice. Given the source, it is reasonable to assume that good evidence was used. But since none of what they said contradicted the evidence that I provided, it doesn't really matter. It also doesn’t serve as a comprehensive survey since it only addressed isolated situations.

I don't think your responses to those quotes or to the practical advice offered by that major public hospital do anything to advance your cause.

regards,
BillyJoe

It wasn't intended to advance my cause. It was intended to point out that it did nothing to counteract my cause. The evidence on the effectiveness of cough medicine cannot be summarized in a single sentence and it is more incorrect to say that they are not effective than it is to say that they are effective. And taking into consideration the strength of the evidence, the size of effect, and that they provide symptom relief rather than disease modification, it is a matter of personal opinion whether they are worth the expense. But the buying patterns of consumers suggest that most consider it worth it (i.e. people are willing to spend a little money on relief of symptoms (not knowing how many are confused about the relief/treatment issue)).

Linda
 
Linda,

After reading the whole thread, it seemed obvious to me that there are really only two people who are patiently trying to discus this thing in a reasonable manner. Yourself and Rodney. Yes, Rodney has been very patient considering the amount of attention he has been receiving. Of course he has a very unsceptical view of homoeopathy. However, he is willing to listen to alternative views and has conceded a few points along the way. This makes him a winner in my book, in the sense that he is getting something out of this thread, whereas other are just confirming their prejudices and learning nothing.
Obviously, you are a very perceptive person, Billy Joe. ;) Seriously, though, l do think that learning something from a thread is the key.

Rodney, it seems to me, is a practical sort of person as evidenced by his repeated question about which cough mixture he should use. It seems he is also correct in his impression from what he has read, that cough mixtures are a waste of time and money. And all the discussion about the proven biological effects of the components don't change the fact that, on the coalface, in practical everyday life, they are almost useless. Homoeopathic preparations are of course totally useless, and I am willing to bet Rodney is having a second think about that as well. No thanks to most of the posters on this thread, yourself excluded of course. But then you...
I do think I'm a practical person, and it is nice, when you have a cough, cold, or sore throat, to have some idea what OTC medicine to take for it. Regarding homeopathy, I still don't see the hard evidence refuting it. I will grant you that it's hardly proven, but that's different than refuting it. And, as far as I know, no homeopathic cough medicine has ever been subjected to controlled testing.

I don't want to labour the point about your self-serving responses, but I can't help but feel you are losing him by the sort of response you gave to his quite legitimate quotes about cough mixtures from the medical fraternity. Sure they where obtained via media reporters who so often screw these things up. But above I have given you a quote from physicians at the Royal Children's Hospital to both patients and to Family Physicians. This advice is based on best evidence.

I don't think your responses to those quotes or to the practical advice offered by that major public hospital do anything to advance your cause.

regards,
BillyJoe
Linda has not lost me, but you're raising some valid points. I don't think either you or me has been cherry-picking the quotes -- it's just that most of them are negative toward OTC cough medicines.
 
But the buying patterns of consumers suggest that most consider it worth it (i.e. people are willing to spend a little money on relief of symptoms (not knowing how many are confused about the relief/treatment issue)).
Linda
You are a very articulate spokesperson for the manufacturers of OTC cough medicines, Linda. You don't have to answer this question if you would rather not, but do you work for one of them or an industry group representing them?
 
You are a very articulate spokesperson for the manufacturers of OTC cough medicines, Linda. You don't have to answer this question if you would rather not, but do you work for one of them or an industry group representing them?
This is called "poisoning the well", Rodney. Also, it is bordering on an ad hominem logical fallacy.

Perhaps you might rephrase your question a bit better?

Incidentally, whatever Linda has or has not said about OTC medications, whoever she works for or whatever she promotes (or does not), it still makes no bearing whatever on the efficacy or otherwise of homeopathic medicines. To imply so is a tu quoque logical fallacy.

Let's look at your stated position on that subject though:
Regarding homeopathy, I still don't see the hard evidence refuting it. I will grant you that it's hardly proven, but that's different than refuting it. And, as far as I know, no homeopathic cough medicine has ever been subjected to controlled testing.
To me, this as clear as is possible to say where you are coming from: You are saying that you believe any remedy (in this case, homeopathy) works unless proven otherwise. Is that not correct?

I think it should be clear to you by now, having had it demonstrated clearly with multiple real-life examples, that the position of science is precisely the opposite, being both pragmatically realistic and conservative: That any remedy does NOT work unless proven otherwise.

As can be seen from Linda's extensive responses, that is precisely the tack taken - the testing is to evaluate what positive results, if any, exist. And to report on them conservatively and truthfully.

The opposite, your position, would allow for any and all remedies, however fantastical, whimsical, or even downright dangerous, to be considered "valid" and "working"...until someone goes to the bother of testing the obvious, or someone gets hurt as a result. This is both logically and ethically wrong.

I take it you know the children's fable of the Emperor's New Clothes?
Many years ago there lived an emperor who was quite an average fairy tale ruler, with one exception: he cared much about his clothes. One day he heard from two swindlers named Guido and Luigi Farabutto that they could make the finest suit of clothes from the most beautiful cloth. This cloth, they said, also had the special capability that it was invisible to anyone who was either stupid or not fit for his position.

Being a bit nervous about whether he himself would be able to see the cloth, the emperor first sent two of his trusted men to see it. Of course, neither would admit that they could not see the cloth and so praised it. All the townspeople had also heard of the cloth and were interested to learn how stupid their neighbors were.

The emperor then allowed himself to be dressed in the clothes for a procession through town, never admitting that he was too unfit and stupid to see what he was wearing. For he was afraid that the other people would think that he was stupid.

Of course, all the townspeople wildly praised the magnificent clothes of the emperor, afraid to admit that they could not see them, until a small child said:

"But he has nothing on!"

This was whispered from person to person until everyone in the crowd was shouting that the emperor had nothing on. The emperor heard it and felt that they were correct, but held his head high and finished the procession.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Emperor's_New_Clothes

Well, homeopathy is the new clothes, the homeopaths are the theiving scoundrels, and the Emperor is...?
 
Last edited:
I do think I'm a practical person, and it is nice, when you have a cough, cold, or sore throat, to have some idea what OTC medicine to take for it. Regarding homeopathy, I still don't see the hard evidence refuting it. I will grant you that it's hardly proven, but that's different than refuting it.

I hope you see the problem with that particular approach. Nobody has refuted the idea that bloodletting cures disease. Nobody has refuted the idea that infectious diseases can be cured by using potentially toxic doses of heavy metals. Nobody has refuted the idea that boring a hole into the skull will cure epilepsy.

And the theory behind some of those proposed cures make more sense than homeopathy, which proposes that giving people a few drops of water will cure them of disease. It seems reasonable to suggest that hypotheses need to be tested and alternate explanations ruled out before anyone is obliged to take them seriously. Especially when the choice is between something unbelievable on its face and something that is plausible. And it turns out that once we started doing that, vast progress was made in the area of medicine.

And, as far as I know, no homeopathic cough medicine has ever been subjected to controlled testing.

I found this for sinusitis. You keep bringing up this point as though it is meangingful. Does that mean you consider homeopathic cold medicine a valid choice if there is either no information or if a single study shows effect? If so, why do you not extend the same criteria to conventional medicine?

Linda has not lost me, but you're raising some valid points. I don't think either you or me has been cherry-picking the quotes -- it's just that most of them are negative toward OTC cough medicines.

I hope that suggests something to you. Because the evidence for the efficacy of a single, minimally useful, non-homeopathic OTC cough medicine is stronger than the entire collection of evidence for the field of homeopathy. And that even with dozens of studies that build support for the use of a cough medicine, all it takes for physicians to start hedging their bets is one weakly negative study on effectiveness. That should give you an indication of the strength of evidence that we think is necessary before we consider effectiveness proven.

You seem convinced that OTC cough medicines have been shown to be ineffective. Since the evidence that homeopathy is ineffective is far more damning than the evidence for any non-homeopathic cough medicine, why don't you say the same about homeopathy?

Linda
 
You are a very articulate spokesperson for the manufacturers of OTC cough medicines, Linda. You don't have to answer this question if you would rather not, but do you work for one of them or an industry group representing them?

No. I avoid the pharmaceutical industry.

Linda
 
Linda,

First of all, thanks for the considered reply.

the CPG from the Royal Children's Hospital, but that is a statement about whether cough medicines treat cough, not whether they relieve cough, and clinical evidence for children should not automatically be extrapolated to adults (and vice versa).
It would seem a reasonable extrapolation, don't you think?

"Cough medicines are not useful in treating cough in children"
"There is no evidence that cough medicines, decongestants, antihistamines or antibiotics have a role in treatment."

Firstly, there is a specific statement that there is "no evidence" for a role of cough mixtures in treatment. So, I think your assumption (see below)that the advice was based on evidence is probably correct. ;)
Secondly, your distinction between treating and relieving doesn't seem to apply here. I agree thay can mean different things in certain contexts. But in this context I can't see a difference in meaning. Can you, really? They are clearly talking about treating symptoms, not treating the underlying cause. Their statements would otherwise make no sense to their target audience.

Two trials of codeine showed no effect above placebo. One trial of DM showed effect above placebo and one did not. One trial of moguistiene showed effect above placebo. One trial of guaifenesin showed effect above placebo and one trial did not. One trial of a mucolytic showed effect above placebo. One trial of an antihistamine-decongestant combination showed effect above placebo and one did not. Three trials of mixed-preparations showed effect above placebo.
Some support but not an ringing endorsement, IMO...a single positive trail (and the next trial might be positive or negative)....a couple of trials, one positive, the other negative....a few positive trials "showing effect above placebo" (unquantified)

Keep in mind that the placebo effect in cough is large - around 1/4 to 1/3. So a small effect above placebo still represents a moderate difference, although we cannot tell how much of that is subjective.
Seems to me that reduces the difference the cough mixture makes. It reminds me of the following story:
A couple of years ago, a family physician who used homoeopathic "treatments" with impressive effects, had it bought to his attention how ridiculous the idea of homoeopathy really was. He then realised that the effect he was acheiving was purely placebo - produced by the care and attention he was providing his patients. He therefore continued his care and attention and dispensed with the homoeopathy.

There is no strong evidence that any of the tested cough medicines have a large, clinically significant effect on cough symptoms in adults with acute URTI.

There is weak to moderate evidence that some cough medicines have a large, clinically significant effect on cough symptoms in adults with URTI.

There is weak to moderate evidence that some cough medicines do not have a moderate to large clinically significant effect on cough symptoms in adults with URTI.
If this is a correct summary of the clinical trials, I guess, on balance, there is likely to be some beneficial effect of cough mixtures on symptoms. I'm still not kicking up my heels with excitement though.

what it really indicates is that one cannot make blanket statements about whether or not cough medicines are effective. They are effective for some purposes and not for others, depending upon which particular preparation you are considering. And the negative studies are not strong enough to prove they are ineffective by themselves. Unless you provide specific evidence of equal or greater quality that counteracts the positive evidence, the negative evidence serves to qualify the positive, rather than negate it.
Fair enough, but I wonder why the RCH, presumably using the same evidence base, conclude otherwise.

Given the source, it is reasonable to assume that good evidence was used. But since none of what they said contradicted the evidence that I provided, it doesn't really matter. It also doesn’t serve as a comprehensive survey since it only addressed isolated situations.
Except that one of those statements include the phrase "there is no evidence for". And it addressed the situation of a mother or family physician faced with a child with a cough.

And taking into consideration the strength of the evidence, the size of effect, and that they provide symptom relief rather than disease modification, it is a matter of personal opinion whether they are worth the expense. But the buying patterns of consumers suggest that most consider it worth it
And, of course, you know that what consumer's do is always rational. ;)
They also demand antibiotics for viral infections because they know it helped last time.
What the RCH is saying to parents is: over and above looking after your child, the addition of cough mixtures play very little, if any, role.
So far, my own experience with my children would back up that advice. :)

regards,
BillyJoe


Anyway, I think we've derailed this thread enough.
I'm still keen to hear from Rodney about whether he has any further thoughts about homoeopathy.
 
Sorry To Derail Again.

Community Management of Lower Respiratory Tract Infection in Adults
A national clinical guideline

The above is a reference regarding use of cough mixtures in adults:
(It is from 2002 but agrees with the more recent RCH reference)


Here is the link
http://www.sign.ac.uk/pdf/sign59.pdf
(pages 15 and 20)


Here are the relevant excerpts:

PAGE 15:

"There are a number of experimental studies where the severity of pharmacologically induced cough is reduced by dextromethorphan and codeine (but these tend to be small studies of around 20 patients) and there is conflicting evidence for the therapeutic effect of dextromethorphan and codeine and pholcodeine in patients with chronic cough."

"Two studies have addressed the the efficacy of codeine in the treatment of cough associated with acute lower respiratory tract infection. Neither of these placebo controled studies showed a benefit from codeine."

"The place of cough suppressants in non-productive cough in lower respiratory tract infection remains unclear with the larger RCTs suggesting they are not of benefit. A recent meta-analysis concurs with this opinion."

"It is also generally accepted that expectorants and demulcents are ineffective"


PAGE 20:

From the information leaflet for patients:
"There is no good evidence that cough mixtures work."


But let's return to homoeopathy....
 
Thanks for the explanation, Linda. If I understand you correctly, the medical community now believes that the saline solution works to reduce pain either partly or entirely because it causes the production and release of opioids by the body. However, until the Benedetti study, was this the medical consensus, or was the consensus rather that the patient experienced less pain entirely because (s)he thought morphine -- and not a saline solution -- was being administered?

Think of it this way. If you get sick after eating something the first time it is likely to make you gag later times as well. This is also the placebo effect, your mind is very good at convincing your body to feel certain things, as anyone who has vomited from stress can attest to.
 
Absolutely. I have burned the midnight oil on countless evenings undertaking a statistical analysis of all studies of the efficacy of OTC cough medicines. I just want to make sure Linda has obtained the same results as me. ;)

Then you read the wikipedia and wedmd articles that is the only thing you referced here.
 
Seeing how ephedrine and pseudoephedrine are controlled substances (being an ingredient for meth) I bet you could even trace the origin of the pseudoephedrine in your cough medicine back to a specific manufacturer, and come to the conclusion that the specific batch of pseudoephedrine is exactly the same as that used in a number of commercial OTC products.

Basically, this is Rodney saying "Yes, you've shown that ice can cool a drink, and you've shown me scientific studies that back this assertion. Now show me a study that says that this particular ice that I've just made in my freezer last night will also cool my drink".

Ice is ice Rodney, pseudoephedrine is pseudoephedrine, sugar is sugar, butter is butter. In the end, they may taste a little different, but chemically, they're the same stuff.

You are wrong about butter, it can varry in percentage of butterfat and such, but as the others are chemicaly pure substances and not a composite substance like butter.
 
This is called "poisoning the well", Rodney. Also, it is bordering on an ad hominem logical fallacy.

Perhaps you might rephrase your question a bit better?

Incidentally, whatever Linda has or has not said about OTC medications, whoever she works for or whatever she promotes (or does not), it still makes no bearing whatever on the efficacy or otherwise of homeopathic medicines. To imply so is a tu quoque logical fallacy.
I never implied that. I was simply curious, and Linda has now been kind enough to respond.

Let's look at your stated position on that subject though:To me, this as clear as is possible to say where you are coming from: You are saying that you believe any remedy (in this case, homeopathy) works unless proven otherwise. Is that not correct?
Hardly. I simply don't think it's logical to rely on the August 2005 Lancet study as the final word on homeopathy. Prior to that, there was the 1991 British Medical Journal study that covered 107 controlled trials, of which 81 showed that homeopathic medicines were effective, 24 showed they were ineffective, and 2 were inconclusive.
 
Think of it this way. If you get sick after eating something the first time it is likely to make you gag later times as well. This is also the placebo effect, your mind is very good at convincing your body to feel certain things, as anyone who has vomited from stress can attest to.
But that's not what the Benedetti study found. Rather, it found that naloxone blocks the pain-relieving effect of saline solution, just as it blocks the pain-relieving effect of morphine.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom