Homeopathic Cough Medicine

Good stuff

I am not trying to convince you of anything. I am trying to provide information in an understandable manner as to why objective experts do not consider homeopathy a valid therapy. And why they consider the evidence to date adequate to come to this conclusion.

Linda

Linda may I say I think you've done a great job in this thread.

For some background information on the apalling spread of the 'homeopathic' adjective, when my wife was pregnant last year we were at the group discussing worries about pregnancy (I forget what it's called) and the subject of breach births came up (pardon my spelling).

The midwife promptly told us that the hospital we were going to be at (the Whittington in London) had a Nurse who'd had great success turning babies in the womb with homeopathic remedies and homeopathic massages. My mind boggled but the pregant lady next to us had told us she was a naturopath so I didn't want to cause a scene.

Of course after the birth and with our baby having trouble gaining weight and having some digestive problems a different midwife advised us to go to a cranial osteopath. Because obviously manipulating a 3 month old babies flexible skull is going to do wonders for his stool consistancy.


I wonder if Rodney truely realises just how much this nonsensical twaddle is spreading and how much damage it may in the end cause?


Editted to add: I will now keep my distractions to a minimum, sorry.
 
Linda may I say I think you've done a great job in this thread.

For some background information on the apalling spread of the 'homeopathic' adjective, when my wife was pregnant last year we were at the group discussing worries about pregnancy (I forget what it's called) and the subject of breach births came up (pardon my spelling).

The midwife promptly told us that the hospital we were going to be at (the Whittington in London) had a Nurse who'd had great success turning babies in the womb with homeopathic remedies and homeopathic massages. My mind boggled but the pregant lady next to us had told us she was a naturopath so I didn't want to cause a scene.

Of course after the birth and with our baby having trouble gaining weight and having some digestive problems a different midwife advised us to go to a cranial osteopath. Because obviously manipulating a 3 month old babies flexible skull is going to do wonders for his stool consistancy.


I wonder if Rodney truely realises just how much this nonsensical twaddle is spreading and how much damage it may in the end cause?


Editted to add: I will now keep my distractions to a minimum, sorry.

The glaring question in all of this is, why don't governments enact laws to prevent shysters practicing their BS?

Seems to me that if you have a claim to the efficacy of your product, you must prove it scientifically to the satisfaction of all stakeholders. If you cannot do this, then your product is barred from sale in our society.

M.
 
Sorry, I have just found this and have not read all 400+ posts. I hope this is not redundant:

From the FDA consumer, homeopathy is not necessarily harmless-
http://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/096_home.html
Other problems include:
  • products promoted as homeopathic that contain nonhomeopathic active ingredients, such as vitamins or plants not listed in homeopathic references
The potential for trouble when one is unwittingly taking a drug is huge. The manufacturers sometimes add drugs in order to provide an effect; which they know is lacking in true homeopathic products.

Also, there is some discussion of homeopathic clinical trials (or, lack of them) here-
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2006/11/homeopaths_doubleblind_studies_of_homeop.php

Finally, quackery is not equal to a scam in my understanding of the term "scam." I live near an epicenter of woo- Northampton, MA (USA). I know people who are quacks; but who truly believe in their snake oil. I think "scam" implies that they know they are robbing you.

You can now return to your regularly scheduled thread, and whatever Linda has to say.

Joe
 
I support permitting any non-harmful product to be sold with a disclaimer on the product's label, if warranted, that the product has not been demonstrated to be effective.

So I can quote you as saying that homeopathy should always be labeled as ineffective and that herbal remedies should not be sold at all. I hope you won't mind being called a hypocrit next time you argue in favour of homeopathy.

The glaring question in all of this is, why don't governments enact laws to prevent shysters practicing their BS?

Seems to me that if you have a claim to the efficacy of your product, you must prove it scientifically to the satisfaction of all stakeholders. If you cannot do this, then your product is barred from sale in our society.

M.

In our case, both the royal family and the prime minister are both firm supporters of sCAM, and severely anti-science in general. The government doesn't enact laws against it because the current government is only interestd in pushing its own personal agenda and beliefs and has no interest in doing either what people want, or what is good for them.
 
Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha Ha

"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
"Show me a study where..."
etc etc etc etc

Followed by,
"Well I'VE never seen it for sale!"

Frakking hilarious.

The point, which you missed in spectacular fashion, is that Vicks Medinite is not, as far as I know, available as an over-the-counter medicine in the United States. I was therefore asking whether it is truly an OTC, as opposed to a prescription, medicine. The answer apparently is that, in the UK, it is somewhere in-between, being considered a controlled "Pharmacy Medicine."
 
Last edited:
So I can quote you as saying that homeopathy should always be labeled as ineffective and that herbal remedies should not be sold at all. I hope you won't mind being called a hypocrit next time you argue in favour of homeopathy.
I respectfully suggest that you, along with Indolent Wretch and most others here, try reading my posts more carefully.
 
We can calculate the positive-predictive value (the probability that a positive result is a true positive) using the model in this paper. Before we look at the trials, what level of positive-predictive value would you accept as reasonable support for your current position and what level would you consider so low that you would re-evaluate your current position on homeopathy?

Linda

Rodney,
I have finished my explanation and my calculations. Before I post them, I would like an answer to my question above - some sort of numerical indication of what you consider reasonable. (The combined positive-predictive value (PPV) of positive trials for the effect "conventional medicine" is essentially 100%, for comparison.)

"If the probability that the positive homeopathy trials are true-positives is _____ (1%, 33%, 99%, ???), my position on homeopathy is reasonable."

"If the probability that the positive homeopathy trials are true-positives is less than _____ (50%, 10%, 1%, ???), I will re-evaluate my current position on homeopathy."

Linda
 
Sorry, I have just found this and have not read all 400+ posts. I hope this is not redundant:

From the FDA consumer, homeopathy is not necessarily harmless-
http://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/096_home.html
The potential for trouble when one is unwittingly taking a drug is huge. The manufacturers sometimes add drugs in order to provide an effect; which they know is lacking in true homeopathic products.

Also, there is some discussion of homeopathic clinical trials (or, lack of them) here-
http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2006/11/homeopaths_doubleblind_studies_of_homeop.php

Finally, quackery is not equal to a scam in my understanding of the term "scam." I live near an epicenter of woo- Northampton, MA (USA). I know people who are quacks; but who truly believe in their snake oil. I think "scam" implies that they know they are robbing you.

You can now return to your regularly scheduled thread, and whatever Linda has to say.

Joe

Some good advice there, bud.

And I agree -- if the purveyor of BS believes in the BS, we should cut them a break -- NOT!

What are you thinking?

M.
 
So I can quote you as saying that homeopathy should always be labeled as ineffective and that herbal remedies should not be sold at all. I hope you won't mind being called a hypocrit next time you argue in favour of homeopathy.



In our case, both the royal family and the prime minister are both firm supporters of sCAM, and severely anti-science in general. The government doesn't enact laws against it because the current government is only interestd in pushing its own personal agenda and beliefs and has no interest in doing either what people want, or what is good for them.

Alas, it is largely so here, too :(

M.
 
And I agree -- if the purveyor of BS believes in the BS, we should cut them a break -- NOT!

What are you thinking?

M.
I was wondering if I should explain more fully. I think many purveyors of BS are idiots, not frauds. If they practice medicine without a license, I call them criminals. I don't "cut them a break." Your point is well-taken.

I never like arguing philosophy or semantics. However, I distinguish between a fool offering harmful advice and a grifter; but I have no tolerance for either. I think the fool should be educated, and the grifter should be punished. I think if one calls a true-believer a fake, one is on the way to losing the argument. You may feel differently.

I have vociferously opposed all forms of quackery for more than thirty years. The staff at my NPR station all think I am a crackpot because I complain when they do things like air a chiropractor(!?) warning against the hazards of vaccination. I do not support woo in any form.
 
I was wondering if I should explain more fully. I think many purveyors of BS are idiots, not frauds. If they practice medicine without a license, I call them criminals. I don't "cut them a break." Your point is well-taken.

I never like arguing philosophy or semantics. However, I distinguish between a fool offering harmful advice and a grifter; but I have no tolerance for either. I think the fool should be educated, and the grifter should be punished. I think if one calls a true-believer a fake, one is on the way to losing the argument. You may feel differently.

I have vociferously opposed all forms of quackery for more than thirty years. The staff at my NPR station all think I am a crackpot because I complain when they do things like air a chiropractor(!?) warning against the hazards of vaccination. I do not support woo in any form.


Welcome to the forum. In general, I agree 100% with you, except that I have found very few (read none ) "true believers") in my travels.

I've found when you dig deep enough, you'll likely find the true motive informing woo beliefs, and it ain't always what you expect. This goes to all woo beliefs, including religion.

Cheers,

M.
 
In our case, both the royal family and the prime minister are both firm supporters of sCAM, and severely anti-science in general. The government doesn't enact laws against it because the current government is only interestd in pushing its own personal agenda and beliefs and has no interest in doing either what people want, or what is good for them.
Once again, I hope this is not redundant, you can find a lot of good information here:
http://www.homeowatch.org

Most particularly, the status of homeopathy in the USA is due to a powerful Senator (Royal Copeland, a homeopath) when federal legislation regulating drugs was written 70 years ago:
http://www.homeowatch.org/history/reghx.html

Ignorant legislators, other officials, and royal figureheads bring us quackery. And many quacks are allowed to fly under the radar. My little town (pop. 8500, in the most rural part of the state) is home to two of the state's 35 "naturopaths." One advertizes that she is not licensed to practice, and her home office is at ... How did I come to be so blessed?
 
Rodney,
I have finished my explanation and my calculations. Before I post them, I would like an answer to my question above - some sort of numerical indication of what you consider reasonable. (The combined positive-predictive value (PPV) of positive trials for the effect "conventional medicine" is essentially 100%, for comparison.)

"If the probability that the positive homeopathy trials are true-positives is _____ (1%, 33%, 99%, ???), my position on homeopathy is reasonable."

"If the probability that the positive homeopathy trials are true-positives is less than _____ (50%, 10%, 1%, ???), I will re-evaluate my current position on homeopathy."

Linda
Assuming I agree with your methodology, 50% to both.
 
During this thread, we have mostly talked about the collective effect of the homeopathic studies - even though individual studies are testing individual treatments, the studies are united by the idea of homeopathy. If the studies are analyzed collectively (i.e. analyzed as though the thing being tested is "homeopathy" rather than "oscillococcimum, arnica, drosera rotundifolia, etc.") we see that the evidence for the idea of homeopathy has progressively become weaker until it has essentially disappeared.

Now you have shifted your attention to the studies of individual treatments. If the test of an individual homeopathic treatment is positive, that means that there is evidence of a true effect. And if there are numerous individual treatments that show evidence of a true effect, and the only idea that combines these effects into a unifying hypothesis is homeopathy, the positive individual trials suggest that there is evidence for homeopathy. Homeopathy serves as a way to explain an effect that otherwise would have no explanation.

Does that last paragraph serve as a reasonable summary of what you are thinking of?

Assuming that you mean an effect above placebo, yes.

Okay. That is a reasonable approach to this issue.

If the test of an individual homeopathic treatment is positive, that means that it is possible that there is a true effect. What we need to determine is how possible. We need to know the positive-predictive value (PPV) – “if this test is positive, what is the probability that it’s a true positive.” This is analogous to the question we ask of a diagnostic test. You are probably already aware that diagnostic tests are rarely 100% accurate – it is possible to have false-positives and false-negatives. So we typically ask questions like, “if the test comes back positive for HIV antibodies, what is the probability that this person has an HIV infection?” The answer varies greatly depending upon the sensitivity and specificity of the test, and the prevalence of the condition. We use 2 x 2 tables for analysis. http://gim.unmc.edu/dxtests/Default.htm

We can calculate what the PPV would be for an individual trial. And we can combine the results of all the trials to figure out what the overall probability is for a true positive. And since the only reasonable explanation we have for a true positive would be the hypothesis of homeopathy, this will translate into a measure of the probability that homeopathy has a true effect. This is a different approach than the metanalyses that have been done.

This model was developed as a way to calculate the PPV of a research study. If you want to know more, you can read the paper, but it is quite technical. I’m willing to try to explain it, but it’s not light reading. <g>

These are the assumptions that I will use from the metanalysis that you have been referring to. There is a legitimate case for further evaluation of the idea of homeopathy, there are 81 positive studies of which 15 are high-caliber (high power and low bias) and 66 are flawed (low power and high bias). However, I am willing to treat all of the studies as being of high caliber. We need these values for the formula – beta (1-power), u (bias) and R (a ratio of the number of true effects over the number of effects that could be postulated). R is very important. I am willing to consider that there may be true effects (the numerator isn’t zero). But the number of effects that may be postulated is not constrained by any proven theory or hypothesis. This means that R is very low. In the absence of pre-knowledge of true effects in a field that is constrained, an R of 0.001 is used. Since we are talking about an unconstrained field, we really should choose an R that is at least one degree of magnitude lower. However, for the sake of this exercise, I am willing to use the R of 0.001. I want to start out with assumptions that are heavily weighted in favour of homeopathy.

The formula that we use to find the probability of true relationships in the presence of bias is on the second page of the paper I referenced. Using the values listed above, the calculated PPV for a single study is 0.0015. That is, there is a 0.15% chance that the positive study represents a true positive. Combining these results for the 81 positive studies (these results are all independent), we have an 11% chance that there is a true effect.

And I was very generous in my assumptions. The numbers I used were not realistic. For example, even though the relatively high-quality studies were called “high-caliber”, none of them had a beta or u as low as 0.20. If I use more reasonable numbers – an average beta of 0.5, an average u of 0.5 and an R of 0.0001 (these numbers are still not the average, but at least fall within the range of possibility) – then the PPV of a single study is 0.00014 and the combined PPV is 0.011. That is, there is a 1.1% chance that there is a true effect.

And in order to anticipate your next question. This model can and is applied to conventional medical research. It turns out that for conventional clinical trials, the PPV is essentially the same as the p-value, so it is basically ignored.

So there it is. Using realistic, but generous parameters, the chance that the 81 positive trials you keep referring to represent a true positive is 1.1%

Linda
 
During this thread, we have mostly talked about the collective effect of the homeopathic studies - even though individual studies are testing individual treatments, the studies are united by the idea of homeopathy. If the studies are analyzed collectively (i.e. analyzed as though the thing being tested is "homeopathy" rather than "oscillococcimum, arnica, drosera rotundifolia, etc.") we see that the evidence for the idea of homeopathy has progressively become weaker until it has essentially disappeared.

Now you have shifted your attention to the studies of individual treatments. If the test of an individual homeopathic treatment is positive, that means that there is evidence of a true effect. And if there are numerous individual treatments that show evidence of a true effect, and the only idea that combines these effects into a unifying hypothesis is homeopathy, the positive individual trials suggest that there is evidence for homeopathy. Homeopathy serves as a way to explain an effect that otherwise would have no explanation.

Does that last paragraph serve as a reasonable summary of what you are thinking of?



Okay. That is a reasonable approach to this issue.

If the test of an individual homeopathic treatment is positive, that means that it is possible that there is a true effect. What we need to determine is how possible. We need to know the positive-predictive value (PPV) – “if this test is positive, what is the probability that it’s a true positive.” This is analogous to the question we ask of a diagnostic test. You are probably already aware that diagnostic tests are rarely 100% accurate – it is possible to have false-positives and false-negatives. So we typically ask questions like, “if the test comes back positive for HIV antibodies, what is the probability that this person has an HIV infection?” The answer varies greatly depending upon the sensitivity and specificity of the test, and the prevalence of the condition. We use 2 x 2 tables for analysis. http://gim.unmc.edu/dxtests/Default.htm

We can calculate what the PPV would be for an individual trial. And we can combine the results of all the trials to figure out what the overall probability is for a true positive. And since the only reasonable explanation we have for a true positive would be the hypothesis of homeopathy, this will translate into a measure of the probability that homeopathy has a true effect. This is a different approach than the metanalyses that have been done.

This model was developed as a way to calculate the PPV of a research study. If you want to know more, you can read the paper, but it is quite technical. I’m willing to try to explain it, but it’s not light reading. <g>

These are the assumptions that I will use from the metanalysis that you have been referring to. There is a legitimate case for further evaluation of the idea of homeopathy, there are 81 positive studies of which 15 are high-caliber (high power and low bias) and 66 are flawed (low power and high bias). However, I am willing to treat all of the studies as being of high caliber. We need these values for the formula – beta (1-power), u (bias) and R (a ratio of the number of true effects over the number of effects that could be postulated). R is very important. I am willing to consider that there may be true effects (the numerator isn’t zero). But the number of effects that may be postulated is not constrained by any proven theory or hypothesis. This means that R is very low. In the absence of pre-knowledge of true effects in a field that is constrained, an R of 0.001 is used. Since we are talking about an unconstrained field, we really should choose an R that is at least one degree of magnitude lower. However, for the sake of this exercise, I am willing to use the R of 0.001. I want to start out with assumptions that are heavily weighted in favour of homeopathy.

The formula that we use to find the probability of true relationships in the presence of bias is on the second page of the paper I referenced. Using the values listed above, the calculated PPV for a single study is 0.0015. That is, there is a 0.15% chance that the positive study represents a true positive. Combining these results for the 81 positive studies (these results are all independent), we have an 11% chance that there is a true effect.

And I was very generous in my assumptions. The numbers I used were not realistic. For example, even though the relatively high-quality studies were called “high-caliber”, none of them had a beta or u as low as 0.20. If I use more reasonable numbers – an average beta of 0.5, an average u of 0.5 and an R of 0.0001 (these numbers are still not the average, but at least fall within the range of possibility) – then the PPV of a single study is 0.00014 and the combined PPV is 0.011. That is, there is a 1.1% chance that there is a true effect.

And in order to anticipate your next question. This model can and is applied to conventional medical research. It turns out that for conventional clinical trials, the PPV is essentially the same as the p-value, so it is basically ignored.

So there it is. Using realistic, but generous parameters, the chance that the 81 positive trials you keep referring to represent a true positive is 1.1%

Linda
Okay, thanks for the calculation, Linda. However, as I'm having trouble understanding the model, let me ask you this: If all 107 of the homeopathic trials discussed in the 1991 British Medical Journal article had been positive, what overall percentage of a true positive would the model calculate?
 
Okay, thanks for the calculation, Linda. However, as I'm having trouble understanding the model, let me ask you this: If all 107 of the homeopathic trials discussed in the 1991 British Medical Journal article had been positive, what overall percentage of a true positive would the model calculate?

The model is difficult to understand, even for people who have some experience with 2 x 2 tables. However, it was published in a peer-reviewed setting and is considered a valid and important model.

What is important to understand is that these results do not depend upon the relative proportion of negative to positive studies. Negative studies do not influence the results. The effect of increasing the number of positive studies is the same as adding additional rolls of the dice - it gradually increases the probability of a particular result.

(The answers are 15% using the unrealistic numbers, 1.5% using the realistic numbers.)

Linda
 
Okay, thanks for the calculation, Linda. However, as I'm having trouble understanding the model, let me ask you this: If all 107 of the homeopathic trials discussed in the 1991 British Medical Journal article had been positive, what overall percentage of a true positive would the model calculate?
If I may help translate, I am fluent in woo-ese:

Faux quote "So you are saying that there is a chance, no matter how small, there is a chance." [Grabs, desperately, at straws.]

In plain English- faux quote "Don't bother me with facts, my mind is made up."
 
Oh, in case anyone was wondering...

It's okay to talk now. <g>

Linda
 
For some background information on the apalling spread of the 'homeopathic' adjective, when my wife was pregnant last year we were at the group discussing worries about pregnancy (I forget what it's called) and the subject of breach births came up (pardon my spelling).

The midwife promptly told us that the hospital we were going to be at (the Whittington in London) had a Nurse who'd had great success turning babies in the womb with homeopathic remedies and homeopathic massages. My mind boggled but the pregant lady next to us had told us she was a naturopath so I didn't want to cause a scene.

Of course after the birth and with our baby having trouble gaining weight and having some digestive problems a different midwife advised us to go to a cranial osteopath. Because obviously manipulating a 3 month old babies flexible skull is going to do wonders for his stool consistancy.

There is of course a very obvious reason why most homaopaths are nurses and midwifes, instead of doctors.

As the addendum to that old saying goes:
Q: What do you call the med student who graduated bottom of his class?
A: Doctor.

Q: What do you call de med student who dropped out or failed?
A: Homeopath.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom