Homeopathic Cough Medicine

None whatsoever. An request was made for an opinion regarding the applicability of the analysis Linda did regarding homeopathic studies. That was what I provided.



You are, of course, free to ignore anything and everything you choose. As is everyone else. However, responding to a post is essentially the opposite of ignoring it. :)

I was referring to the stats, not your "responding to a post."

Point being, most punters who are likely to buy into homeopathy are not interested in the niceties of statistical analysis, including Sir Rodney's.

M.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, Beth.

You're welcome. Gave me a night to dream about something besides multivariate equivalence testing. :)

I also am interested in whether you agree with Linda's contention made in post #484 that, in the model she is using: "The negative studies don't matter; there don't even have to be any."

The paper she's referenced doesn't deal with that aspect at all, so she's correct in that it doesn't matter in regards to the formula she's using. If and how such results ought to be included in the analysis is not something I feel competent to comment on at this point.
 
I thought I'd posted that yesterday, but it seems not. I probably hit the wrong button. I'll try to compose it again.

I'm not sure about Linda's assessment regarding homeopathic studies being categorized as "discovery-oriented exploratory research with massive testing" and setting R at 0.001. I'm not well acquainted with the literature on homeopathic studies, but the one homeopathic paper I've read was testing a specific substance for specific outcomes and thus it seems to me it would not fit into that category.

Finding a reasonable magnitude for R is the key issue. The typical controlled trial consists of testing one or a few homeopathic remedies in a clinical setting like "influenza" or "post-operative ileus". There is no established method by which the remedy or the condition is chosen for the testing. Rather, they are chosen based on the idea of homeopathy which has no supporting evidence as a valid method of choice.

If you are not familiar with homeopathy - it is based on an idea of "like cures like". A substance that causes certain symptoms when taken in pharmacologic doses, will cure those symptoms when taken in miniscule doses. A substance is "proven" by ingesting the substance and then meticulously recording all physical sensations the individual has for some period of time afterward (e.g. nausea and vomiting). Thereafter, if someone presents to a homeopathic practitioner with vomiting, they are given a very dilute preparation of the substance, to relieve their vomiting. The dilutions are made serially - the substance is put into solution in water and one part (e.g. one drop) of that is diluted with 100 parts of water ("C" potencies). Then one drop of that solution is diluted in 100 parts of water. This is repeated (commonly) 30 times. After 15 dilutions, the probability that the solution contains a single molecule of the original substance is effectively zero.

No part of this idea has ever been established. In fact, it contradicts all of our detailed knowledge about physiology, pharmacology, pathology and chemistry. And this is the critical part for determining R. Despite all the time and effort that has gone into developing homeopathy, the method of selection is no different from playing a game. The "rules" of the homeopathy game are arbitrary - there is nothing that prevents anyone from changing the rules. I could just as easily say that "like cures like" and choose a remedy that starts with the same letter of the alphabet as the symptom that I wish to treat.

Because the rules are arbitrary, there is no constraint on what substance could be chosen to treat what condition. It is no different from throwing a series of dice in order to make a choice. So, yes, you are testing one substance in one condition, but that combination has been (essentially randomly) chosen from among millions of possible combinations to test. And the totality of homeopathic clinical trials amounts to having chosen a few dozen combinations from among the millions, to test. That is why it is similar to exploratory research, which may test a few dozen combinations at one go.

[As an aside, in interpreting results of a situation with "massive testing", simultaneous confidence intervals should be used which keep the probability of a false positive from rising above alpha. I'm not sure how commonly simulataneous C.I.'s are used, but the author of the paper makes no adjustment for that situation in his analysis.]

That is one of the problems with homeopathic research. In many studies, multiple comparisons are made with no adjustments in alpha. If one of those comparisons is "statistically significant", it is concluded that the remedy is effective.

The use (or non-use) of commonly simultaneous C.I.'s would probably be covered under his "bias". But I agree, that it could benefit from further quantification.

And if you are not familiar with homeopathy research - the majority of trials are of poor-quality. A few dozen are of moderate to good quality. The better the quality the more likely they are to be negative. Metanalyses show that the demonstration of benefit can be accounted for by placebo-effect and bias, or by the use of active ingredients (i.e. non-dilute preparations acting by normal pharmacologic methods).

Since R respresents the ratio of "true relationships" to "no relationships", it can literally vary from 0 (no true relationships) to infinity (everything is related). Depending on your prior assessment of the ratio of true relationships to no relationships, the outcome can be just about anything. Unless you and Linda can agree upon a reasonable value for R, I don't think this analysis is useful to your discussion. On the other hand, discussing a reasonable value to set for R might be.

That's the issue. The analysis is useful to demonstrate that a reasonable value for R must be chosen. It cannot be assumed to be 1:1, which was what Rodney was assuming.

I am definitely open to other suggestions.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Why not a figure of zero? (Then the medical establishment can simply dispense with those annoying homeopathy trials. ;))

That's the first sensible thing you've come out with!

Spending money testing this pathetic system of sympathetic magic can no longer be justified. After 200 years of failure it's not as if there's going to be some sort of breakthough discovering that it really does work (for anything) after all.

It's one thing being skeptical and reserving judgement on ideas etc. until they have been thoroughly tested, but once something has been tested and failed, time and again (for example, 2 centuries) to prove its worth then we are completely justified in rejecting the idea.

So let's not beat around the bush any longer and go where the evidence leads us: Homeopathy does not work.

Homeopathy is a prime example of a delusion. It illustrates beautifully just how irrational thinking can get.
 
That's the issue. The analysis is useful to demonstrate that a reasonable value for R must be chosen. It cannot be assumed to be 1:1, which was what Rodney was assuming.

I am definitely open to other suggestions.

Linda
My suggestion is that you consider how Randi's organization tests applicants for the million dollar prize: It doesn't apply a pre-test probability to an applicant's claim and it could care less what the theory is behind that claim. Applying a pre-test probability in either that context or in the context of testing of homeopathic medicines is simply a way of putting a weight on the scale so that, even if the claim CAN be demonstrated beyond a reasonable doubt, it will judged to have failed because it does not meet the constraints of an artificial pre-test probability percentage.
 
I'm not sure about Linda's assessment regarding homeopathic studies being categorized as "discovery-oriented exploratory research with massive testing" and setting R at 0.001. I'm not well acquainted with the literature on homeopathic studies, but the one homeopathic paper I've read was testing a specific substance for specific outcomes and thus it seems to me it would not fit into that category. ...[bold added]
You must see more homeopathic "research." Most is pathetic and does not rise to the level of a primary-school science fair.
 
Last edited:
And if you are not familiar with homeopathy research - the majority of trials are of poor-quality. A few dozen are of moderate to good quality. The better the quality the more likely they are to be negative. Metanalyses show that the demonstration of benefit can be accounted for by placebo-effect and bias, or by the use of active ingredients (i.e. non-dilute preparations acting by normal pharmacologic methods).

Linda
Exactly!
 
My suggestion is that you consider how Randi's organization tests applicants for the million dollar prize ...
Translated: "Is there a straw I can still grasp? I mean, if they nail homeopaths- how long will it take before they get to chiropractors and acupuncturists?"
 
Finding a reasonable magnitude for R is the key issue. Because the rules are arbitrary, there is no constraint on what substance could be chosen to treat what condition. It is no different from throwing a series of dice in order to make a choice. So, yes, you are testing one substance in one condition, but that combination has been (essentially randomly) chosen from among millions of possible combinations to test. And the totality of homeopathic clinical trials amounts to having chosen a few dozen combinations from among the millions, to test. That is why it is similar to exploratory research, which may test a few dozen combinations at one go.

To be honest, even though the ideas behind homeopathy don't make much sense to me, they don't seem to be completely random and arbitrary either. It seems more like a 'hair of the dog that bit you' approach. Thus, I don't think they'd consider influenza to be cured by a dilute iodine solution just because they both start with the letter I. While the two theories might be equally (un)sound, it seems unfair to claim that millions of combinations are possible on that basis.

That's the issue. The analysis is useful to demonstrate that a reasonable value for R must be chosen. It cannot be assumed to be 1:1, which was what Rodney was assuming.

OTOH, if you accept their contention that water has 'memory', then it would seem that every possible combination would have a relationship, making the 'no relationships' denominator of R 0 or very very close to it. This would have the effect of making R extremely large.

Seems to me that depending on what premises you accept going in will completely determine what value you end up with. Not unusual, but not convincing to anyone who doesn't share your begining assessment.

Anyway, it's been an interesting respite to look at this analysis. Definitely food for thought. Thanks.
 
My suggestion is that you consider how Randi's organization tests applicants for the million dollar prize: It doesn't apply a pre-test probability to an applicant's claim and it could care less what the theory is behind that claim. Applying a pre-test probability in either that context or in the context of testing of homeopathic medicines is simply a way of putting a weight on the scale so that, even if the claim CAN be demonstrated beyond a reasonable doubt, it will judged to have failed because it does not meet the constraints of an artificial pre-test probability percentage.

You have completely missed the point.

Scientific methods and standards are not arbitrary. They represent the hard-won recognition that chance and cognitive bias (aka wishful thinking) conspire against us to give the illusion of pattern where none exists. We don't hold research to these standards in order to get into some Old Boys' Club. We hold it to these standards because we have discovered that if we don't, we are likely to be wrong. We have demonstrated over and over and over again, that if we aren't meticulously careful, we end up concluding stuff that just isn't true. So now, instead of kicking ourselves for wasting years/decades/centuries on backing the wrong horse, we actually try to do it right the first time. We hold conventional medicine to the standards presented in that model because we are tired of being wrong, not so we can exclude homeopathy and the rest of the sCAM from the game.

Quit moving the goalposts. The Million Dollar Challenge is not a scientific test. It is a test of gamesmanship. So which is it? Is homeopathy game-playing or science?

Linda
 
To be honest, even though the ideas behind homeopathy don't make much sense to me, they don't seem to be completely random and arbitrary either. It seems more like a 'hair of the dog that bit you' approach.

Even if this approach has a "name", if there is no pharmacologic, physiologic, pathologic or chemical mechanism that corresponds to it, how is it anything but arbitrary?

Thus, I don't think they'd consider influenza to be cured by a dilute iodine solution just because they both start with the letter I. While the two theories might be equally (un)sound, it seems unfair to claim that millions of combinations are possible on that basis.

How many combinations would you suggest?

OTOH, if you accept their contention that water has 'memory', then it would seem that every possible combination would have a relationship, making the 'no relationships' denominator of R 0 or very very close to it. This would have the effect of making R extremely large.

That ties in nicely with the one of the current math threads on the forum. :)

Seems to me that depending on what premises you accept going in will completely determine what value you end up with. Not unusual, but not convincing to anyone who doesn't share your begining assessment.

I agree. If I were trying to convince other scientists of the value of homeopathy, though, I don't think I could reasonably ask them to accept any premises except those that are consistent with our understanding of physics and chemistry.

Anyway, it's been an interesting respite to look at this analysis. Definitely food for thought. Thanks.

It's nice to talk to someone that understands the analysis.

Linda
 
Even if this approach has a "name", if there is no pharmacologic, physiologic, pathologic or chemical mechanism that corresponds to it, how is it anything but arbitrary?
Sorry, I just don't know enough about homeopathy to state with certainty one way or the other. I'm only saying that from my limited perspective, they have a rationale - albeit not a particularly rational rationale - thus, it isn't arbitrary.
How many combinations would you suggest?
Sorry, but I am clueless as to the answer to that question. Besides, it's not me you are trying to convince me that homeopathy doesn't work, so even if we agreed to the a reasonable number of combinations, it wouldn't serve to convince Rodney.
I agree. If I were trying to convince other scientists of the value of homeopathy, though, I don't think I could reasonably ask them to accept any premises except those that are consistent with our understanding of physics and chemistry.
That's reasonable, but not the reason you did the analysis. You're trying to convince Rodney, not other scientists.
It's nice to talk to someone that understands the analysis.

Yes, it is. Thanks.

Beth
 
Last edited:
To be honest, even though the ideas behind homeopathy don't make much sense to me, they don't seem to be completely random and arbitrary either.
You need to study chemistry and physics to see that they are random and arbitrary. Not against you, but those who argue for homeopathy:
Oliver Wendel Holmes:
Do you think I don't understand the hydrostatic paradox of controversy? If you had a bent tube, one arm of which was the size of a pipe-stem and the other big enough to hold the ocean, water would stand at the same height in one as in the other. Thus discussion equalizes fools and wise men in the same way, and the fools know it.
This is a problem with the public at large who are not versed in science- they think all statements are equally valid "opinions," and they can weigh those opinions and decide. That may be true with social questions, but science comes down to "opinions" that are so certain, that opposition is perverse.


OTOH, if you accept their contention that water has 'memory' ..
There is not a shred of reliable evidence that water has memory; and everything we do know contradicts that notion. So, accepting that notion is the path to uncritical thinking. Once again, it is not a matter of imagination- education is the path to follow.

Seems to me that depending on what premises you accept ...
Once again, premises matter with social/philosophical questions; not with questions about the physical processes of nature. You may may not accept the "premise" of gravity; but, you will die if you jump off a cliff. Disbelief about gravity loses in the event.

Homeopathy is entirely imaginary. Not philosophically possible.
 
Blah blah blah.
Altie Speak, in English: "I can't argue the facts; but, I can still make noise ..."

Rodney, what is your professional opinion of the Logan technique in chiropractic? Are you embarrassed by it?
 
Heavier-than-air flying machines are impossible.
- Lord Kelvin (1824-1907), ca. 1895, British mathematician and physicist
See http://www.lhup.edu/~DSIMANEK/neverwrk.htm

Lord Kelvin was wrong - which proves nothing about homeopathy. You're using the 'science has been wrong before' fallacy. ;)

Of course, Lord Kelvin wasn't basing his conclusion on 2 centuries' worth of failures as today's opponents of homeopathy are. Even if he was, heavier-than-air flight and homeopathy are not comparable anyway.

False analogy Rodney!!
 
Heavier-than-air flying machines are impossible.
- Lord Kelvin (1824-1907), ca. 1895, British mathematician and physicist
See http://www.lhup.edu/~DSIMANEK/neverwrk.htm

Two quotes down from yours:
I confess that in 1901 I said to my brother Orville that man would not fly for fifty years. Two years later we ourselves made flights. This demonstration of my impotence as a prophet gave me such a shock that ever since I have distrusted myself and avoided all predictions.
- Wilbur Wright (1867-1912) [In a speech to the Aero Club of France (Nov 5, 1908)]

It seems real scientists are willing to admit when they got it wrong.

The fools are the ones who keep asserting their idea is correct, even after science has advanced well beyond the point where their crazy brainchild loses any workable hypothesis.
Perhaps 200 years ago, homeopathy seemed like a reasonable idea, but today, we pretty much know that it can't possibly ever work. At least not the way it's supposed to. Research confirms this.
 
To be honest, even though the ideas behind homeopathy don't make much sense to me, they don't seem to be completely random and arbitrary either. It seems more like a 'hair of the dog that bit you' approach. Thus, I don't think they'd consider influenza to be cured by a dilute iodine solution just because they both start with the letter I. While the two theories might be equally (un)sound, it seems unfair to claim that millions of combinations are possible on that basis.
The actual choice of homoeopathic remedies is endless. Anything goes. We have homoeopathic dilutions of herbs, duck livers, mud, even pieces of the Berlin Wall! (used against a feeling of oppression). Moonlight has also been diluted into a homoeopathic remedy, and of course various radioactive matters. The procedure is as Linda described it: Take any substance you like, material or not, dilute it into a mother tincture (or expose a mother tincture to moonlight or whatever, it really does not matter), give a number of healthy test persons this mixture, and record anything that happens to them. If they are homoeopathic believers, they might have violent reactions, but mostly they just record common ailments, like a little headache, dizziness, lack of concentration and so on. The remedy when diluted through a special magical technique called succussion (which is just shaking), will then be suitable for healing those ailments in sick people. The more serial dilutions have taken place, the more potent is the remedy. At 12C (12 serial dilutions of 1:10) there is nothing left of the original mother tincture, but the homoeopaths happily continue to several thousands of C.

The standard homoeopathic technique is to administer one remedy after the other until the illness has been healed or the patient has died, whatever comes first. Because of this, homoeopaths are very much against tests that only involve a single remedy. They would claim there is no such thing as a homoeopathic cough remedy, because they treat the whole patient and not just the cough, and they would decide on an individual basis what remedy would be most suitable to start with.

It is also funny to note that to homoeopaths it is a sign of healing if the sickness gets worse. This is called aggravation, and is normal in homoeopathy. It is a win/win situation: If the patient gets better, homoeopathy works, and if the sickness gets aggravated, it also shows that homoeopathy works!
 
The actual choice of homoeopathic remedies is endless. Anything goes. We have homoeopathic dilutions of herbs, duck livers, mud, even pieces of the Berlin Wall! (used against a feeling of oppression). Moonlight has also been diluted into a homoeopathic remedy, and of course various radioactive matters. The procedure is as Linda described it: Take any substance you like, material or not, dilute it into a mother tincture (or expose a mother tincture to moonlight or whatever, it really does not matter), give a number of healthy test persons this mixture, and record anything that happens to them. If they are homoeopathic believers, they might have violent reactions, but mostly they just record common ailments, like a little headache, dizziness, lack of concentration and so on. The remedy when diluted through a special magical technique called succussion (which is just shaking), will then be suitable for healing those ailments in sick people. The more serial dilutions have taken place, the more potent is the remedy. At 12C (12 serial dilutions of 1:10) there is nothing left of the original mother tincture, but the homoeopaths happily continue to several thousands of C.

The standard homoeopathic technique is to administer one remedy after the other until the illness has been healed or the patient has died, whatever comes first. Because of this, homoeopaths are very much against tests that only involve a single remedy. They would claim there is no such thing as a homoeopathic cough remedy, because they treat the whole patient and not just the cough, and they would decide on an individual basis what remedy would be most suitable to start with.

It is also funny to note that to homoeopaths it is a sign of healing if the sickness gets worse. This is called aggravation, and is normal in homoeopathy. It is a win/win situation: If the patient gets better, homoeopathy works, and if the sickness gets aggravated, it also shows that homoeopathy works!

Quick error check (which I'm sure you know! ;)): "C" dilutions are 1:100. "X" dilutions are 1:10. And "M" dilutions are 1:1000.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom